Entertainment -   

1

Shatner to Carrie Fisher: Star Trek had 'prettier girls'

In this image from an online video, William Shatner discusses which is better: Star Wars or Star Trek? In this image from an online video, William Shatner discusses which is better: Star Wars or Star Trek?
In this image from an online video, William Shatner discusses which is better: Star Wars or Star Trek?

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (13) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Nov. 30, 2011 9:34 PM ET

William Shatner and Carrie Fisher have waded into that long-standing battle over which is better, Star Wars or Star Trek, posting videos to YouTube in which they argue over special effects and who would best fit into their old, revealing costumes.

Shatner fired the first shot back in September, when he dismissed Star Wars as "derivative" of Star Trek and criticized its special effects.

He also said the girls who appeared on Star Trek were "prettier than the girls on Star Wars."

"Princess Leia, as beautiful as she was and as wonderful an actress as she is, can't compare to the marvelous heroines we had on Star Trek," Shatner tells a female interviewer in the video.

Shatner did concede that given the chance, Captain Kirk would "absolutely" run off with Princess Leia.

But earlier this month, Fisher upped the ante in a video of her own in which she suggests the two films "aren't in the same league," and challenges Shatner to a "costume-off."

"I want to see him in his clingy outfit again," she says, alleging Shatner once borrowed her infamous metal bikini.

Fisher also praised her "space buns" for being "so much better than (Leonard) Nimoy's ears."

Near the end of her video, Fisher says Shatner auditioned for the role of Darth Vader but, despite being in full costume, "he couldn't do it."

"If you see Bill Shatner, call him Han Solo," she says.

After Fisher's video hit YouTube, Shatner filmed a retort in which admits he "grovelled" to Star Wars producers for the role that eventually went to "this big heavy-voiced guy," and joked that he would have played the villain in a squeaky, Mickey Mouse-type voice.

But Shatner wields his phaser once again, saying Star Wars had "the best special effects" but "forgot about story and character and plot development." He then turns his weapon on Fisher.

"I don't know if we're ready for you in a bikini," he says to the camera. "My costume was made of stretch material, so there wouldn't be any difficulty giving it a little push here and there for me to go into my original wardrobe. But you in a bikini, now, needs a little more than push and pull. It needs a lot of uplift. See ya Carrie."

Sci-fi fans everywhere are anxiously awaiting Fisher's response. Meanwhile, here are the videos:

Comments are now closed for this story

Earthwatcher
said

Ryan from Guelph, I don't know about that. The green alien chick was pretty hot in the old Star Trek series. meowr


Robert in Burnaby
said

I think all the straight men of geekdom had more the hots for Princess Leia than any Trek girl.Princess Leia vs Any Trek Girl: Leia wins.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

Star Trek wins by a parsec. Star Wars offered a one story line derivative of good vs. evil that makes the Adventures of Robin Hood look like Hamlet.


Pugfire
said

This story isn't Trek,,, it's dreck


Camwest
said

This is awesome... Shatner is a great guy and Carrie is incredible too. Both were influential in creating a movement that is close to a religion. Having them both talk brings them both down to earth and merges both worlds. Next we need Gene R and George L to get together. Thanks for the entertainment Bill, a truly great Canadian. Beam me up...


Chris
said

If Captain Kirk, Han Solo, and Luke Skywalker got into a fight... who would win? I'll tell you who... First Captain Kirk would proclaim he's the greatest and bravest, shoot the others, then go and have sex with a green chick. Secondly, Luke Skywalker would laugh, then proclaim that he would choke out the others with the force, slice the bodies with his light saber, then meditate. The winner would be Han Solo... he would say, "go ahead you two, do your worst because when this is all over, I'll have the multi-million dollar movie career and you two will be stuck doing stupid broadway shows and documentary narrations!!!"


peter in mb
said

@ rick are you serious? Darth Vader would use the force to chock Captain Kirk before Kirk could say beam me up Scotty. Or he would cut Kirk in half with his lightsaber.


Wade/Calgary
said

PLEASE PLEASE no videos of either of them in costume. Both Star Trek and Star Wars have their up's and down's. But video of them would kill them both.


marcel
said

of course captain kirk would win! this geek is waiting for a remake of fight club with shatner showing the right stuff!


Jason Daniel Baker, Toronto
said

The original Star Trek had more women than Star Wars (Which only had Fisher as far as I can recall).As to whether they were prettier the female guest stars (Diana Muldaur, Lee Meriwether, Julie Newmar et al) certainly were but hardly the regulars.If you rate sci fi TV by "pretty girls" the original Battlestar Galactica wins hands down.


Ryan, Guelph
said

This is the stuff that sci-fi nerd dreams are made of. Love it! (And Leia in a gold bikini beats every Star Trek girl, hands down!)


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Funny. (Two great talents barbing each other.) However, who cares? Both "Star Wars" and "Star Trek" are now the science-fiction elixirs for geeks and nerds who don't pay much attention to women. Damn it; give me Catwoman from "Batman." That's sexy. Never mind "pretty."


rick
said

Captain Kirk could easily take Darth Vader in a fight. He'd have Vader down in a flash, faster than Darth could say, "Luke I'm your father". and then Darth Vader would go insane by the complex questions the dear captain would ask!!!!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Showbiz news from CTVNews.ca

The cover of Fifty Shades of Grey  by best-selling author E L James

50 Shades

Why are so many women all tied up about what is between these covers?

biebs

Wanted man?

Watch: Justin Bieber wanted for questioning after alleged scuffle with photog.

Men in Black 3

Movie Reviews

'Men in Black 3' and 'Hysteria' hit theatres across Canada.

Red Carpet Wrap

Red Carpet Wrap

50 Pictures: Hollywood's hottest debut fun and funky fashion.

In Pictures: International starlets dazzle in extravagant, sparkly gowns at the festival.

Cannes Fashion

In Pictures: Starlets dazzle in extravagant, sparkly gowns at the festival.

Carrie Underwood

Carrie Underwood

Watch: Country superstar talks about music, marriage in exclusive interview.

Disco Diva

Donna Summer

In Pictures: Looking back at the life and legacy of Disco Queen Donna Summer.

Met Costume Gala

Met Costume Gala

50 Pictures: Stars debut jaw-dropping gowns at fashion's biggest night.

Today's Entertainment Stories

L.A. Galaxy's David Beckham leaves the pitch after a training session at the Rogers Centre in Toronto on Tuesday March 6, 2012, ahead of his team's CONCACAF quarter final first leg tie against Toronto FC tomorrow. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young

David Beckham likes to bite his baby daughter

More

Chris Brown accepts the award for best R and B album for 'F.A.M.E.' during the 54th annual Grammy Awards on Sunday, Feb. 12, 2012 in Los Angeles. (AP / Matt Sayles)

Singer Chris Brown selling his Hollywood apartment

More