Entertainment -   

1

Cuts to Toronto's transit service, crossing guards proposed

Massive cuts to Toronto’s police and transit services, as well as public health programs and libraries, are recommended in the last of eight core service review reports released on July 21, 2011.
Massive cuts to Toronto’s police and transit services, as well as public health programs and libraries, are recommended in the last of eight core service review reports released on July 21, 2011.

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (26) Facebook   

Date: Thursday Jul. 21, 2011 8:55 PM ET

Massive cuts to Toronto's police and transit services, as well as public health programs and libraries, are recommended in the last of eight core service review reports released on Thursday.

Two weeks of reports recommending spending cuts to 150 city services came to an end on Thursday, with the release of the longest, and possibly most contentious, report to date.

The latest report targeted errant spending in Toronto's 105 arms-length agencies, and suggests selling off the Toronto Zoo, Exhibition Place and one or more city-owned theatres.

City council called for the massive full service review in April, asking a consulting firm to recommend ways to bring spending in line with the city budget. Toronto faces a $774-million shortfall in 2012.

Cuts suggested to TTC services

The report, conducted by KPMG LLP, suggested wide-spread service reductions to Toronto's transit system including abandoning its current service improvement strategy, eliminating overnight bus service and setting stricter criteria to use the Wheel-Trans program.

KPMG says city coffers would benefit from abandoning its current Ridership Growth Strategy. The changes would increase "acceptable" crowding levels, cut service frequency and could also eliminate Toronto's overnight bus services.

The report goes on to say the elimination of overnight buses would be "a major inconvenience to a relatively small number of customers" and suggests doubling fares on overnight buses as another option.

As well, it recommends the city consider further privatization of its Wheel-Trans service, while also making the service's criteria stricter to lower demand on the system.

Report targets police cuts

In a bid to save money spent by the Toronto Police Service, the audit recommends the city consider implementing a hiring freeze and offer incentives for early retirement in order to cut down on front-line workers.

The report does warn that reducing the number of uniformed officers could "adversely affect crime rates in the city."

Other suggestions for the police service include:

  • considering one-officer patrols instead of the current partnership model
  • reducing or eliminating the school crossing guard program
  • ending the need for police officers to be posted at construction sites
  • transferring parking and by-law enforcement to another department

Thursday's report further suggests closing some of the city's library branches and cutting hours at others, selling some of the city's off-street parking facilities as well as selling the Toronto Zoo, Exhibition Place and at least one of the city's theatres, specifically the Sony Centre for the Performing Arts.

KPMG also suggest eliminating a public health program that funds AIDS and drug prevention as well as student nutrition.

Previous recommendations from the core services review over the past two weeks have included:

  • eliminating city-run childcare
  • cutting farm and zoo attractions
  • sending more trash to landfills to cut down on costly recycling
  • further privatizing garbage collection
  • cutting down on how often streets are cleaned and snow is plowed
  • eliminating fluoridation of Toronto's water supply
  • eliminate funding for public art programs
  • cutting heritage grants available to historical buildings.

In another cost-cutting measure, Mayor Rob Ford has offered buyouts to 17,000 city employees.

Comments are now closed for this story

Ivan
said

My #1 suggestion - stop throwing away $$$ on useless consultants and their even more useless reports. For what KPMG charges, you could have hired 3-4 accounts to audit the citys finances.


Joe Spumolio
said

While the cuts sound drastic, you have to remember that the majority of Toronto's budget doesn't actually go to delivering services. Some 85% goes to paying employees. That's a staggering number that reflects the cost of decades of entrenched union entitlements. Are any city workers willing to take a pay cut to keep their jobs? Millions of public sector workers have lost their jobs and I bet most would have taken a pay cut to keep their employment. I certainly would have but wasn't given a choice. Rather than grumbling and complaining, why don't public sector unions get creative and offer up a savings package in order to save their jobs? No union has ever made such an offer in the history of public service in Canada. They could be pioneers, rather than always taking and taking and taking and taking.


Ethan Leduc
said

Wow, who knew we could balance the budget by cutting services and selling city property?Rob Ford is a visionary.


Bill from Whitby
said

What a bunch of whiners in the city of Toronto if you want to keep all of your services then take a property tax increase. Everyone outside of Toronto pays more in property taxes and gets less services......pay more taxes and stop whining. As far as the crossing guards go kids are not getting enough exercise dodging a few cars will help.


Tracey
said

Cutting transit services when transit ridership is at an all-time high is absolutely ridiculous! Rob Ford and Karen Stintz truly have no clue! Eliminating Blue Night buses will only hurt the poor even further. For those who work two jobs, how will they get to and from those jobs throughout the night? This is disgusting!


KMPG is bad thing....
said

KMPG is same auditor group that audited my workplace which is having difficulty going through because of bunch of good reasons but things are picking up. We are making profit then KMPG came in and guess what? We all got laid off within 2 weeks after that.....

HMMMMMMMM KMPG has no clue but I think they just come in and recommend bunch of cut and changes that they could think of... KMPG bad.


Howie
said

No crossing guards? Dumb & DANGEROUS! How will young kids cross busy roads to get to school? It would be better to get out of the housing business! and many other subsidized ventures.


Roger Binny
said

Cutting Public Health Programs, what kind of review is this?- Health people, this is essential!


sulteck
said

Poor Toronto,,, how will you ever live without crossing guards. the solution is to teach your kids how to cross a road. The TTC should have to charge what it cost to run the service and not rely on grants and subsidies that already gets.

If you want all those services then pay for them or raise property taxes. the solution is simple. NO one needs a public art programs. poeple need a dry warm place to live and food and water to servive,,, anything more than that, than get a job and pay for it




Cambob in Toronto
said

Yes, eliminate the crossing guards. Drivers and pedestrians have to learn to use the road LEGALLY. Have you seen the j-walkers? Have you seen the people who speed up on yellow lights? THOSE are the ones who need to pay for thier stupid actions, not the entire community. Crossing guards are a luxury item. Gone. Frankly, I agree with all the KPMG proposals... because if the city goes bankrupt there will be NO SERVICES at all.


DON
said

All the cuts need to done and sooner the better.Whether we like it or not.We are strong we can take it.


russ
said

Buckle your seat belts TO, you are in for one hell of a ride. I bet you didn't see this coming when you decided that having a bleeding heart Liberal like Miller in office was too damaging for the city. Guess what, having someone like Ford is no better and now you will pay the price. Lets hope he doesn't close the cooling stations anytime soon.


D. Jackson
said

What would of been a good cut. Is to Cut the invoice the city is going to get from K M P G. They might have some clue in cutting corporation but the have no clue in how to run a city.


5th Generation Canadian
said

But where's the gravy, Mr. Ford? Where's the gravy? You wouldn't want your willfully blind "Nation" to start thinking that you were a liar with a hidden agenda all along, would you? Wouldn't be a stretch for those of us who saw through you during the election!


Aliza
said

Several of those recommendations (e.g. the public health ones, and some of the policing ones, and cutting child-care) will result in much higher costs down the road, and even deaths. Very foolish.

As for the privatization of parking facilities, the zoo, etc-- aren't those currently revenue neutral at worst, and revenue generators at best? Perhaps a better option would be to find ways for those to enhance Toronto's coffers and thus help pay for other programs!

If the report only identifies initiatives, but did not do a cost-benefit analysis (ie consider the consequences of cuts), then clearly the city wasted its money on that contract.


Len
said

Everyone wants to save money, everyone wants to save on taxes. I guess that's the problem - that everyone wants but no one wants to pay. That being said the Toronto voters elected the Fords and they are proposing to destroy the city. I'm glad I don't live there. What was once a great place will be decimated to slums and poverty. I hope my family members get out before it is too late.


andre
said

I wonder if the report addresses the fact that civil servants now make on average 20% more than the public sector. I also wonder whether it asks why there are now 40% more TTC employees when the ridership is the same it was 10 years ago.

Donatello
said

"The report does warn that reducing the number of uniformed officers could "adversely affect crime rates in the city.""

Ah I get it! Ford is a Conservative, so if he can increase the crime rates then Harper can justify multi-billion spending on prisons that we don't need...

No wait, never mind. He's going to do it anyway.


Born in Toronna
said

When I lived in Toronto, City Run Childcare was my lifeline to continuing to work after my daughter was born. I can't see how they're going to justify that.


SP
said

Has anyone noticed that these recommended cuts are for services that the public pays for. Funny how no recommendations for city council and their comfy desk chairs haven't been spoken of.
If Toronto is so broke where did they get the money to pay KPMG?






Michael
said

...and still no GRAVY! Throw the bum out.


Andrew
said

There is currently a need for a police officer at a construction site? How bizarre.

Keep the crossing guards.


craig
said

How come there are no recommendations to cut Mr Fords salary?


Mike
said

Yesterday the KPMG, during a city council meeting regarding funding cuts to city programs, admitted that their reports should only be considered along with public opinion. So speak your minds! We need crossing guards. Single police officers would be in danger, in my opinion, and that's not right. Some things need to be under city...how about cuts to taking taxis and free lunches on our bills.


Johnny Mac Intyre
said

K P M G...They Don't Have A Clue !


matlewy
said

Uh - no crossing guards? This has gone from foolish to dangerous.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Entertainment Stories

L.A. Galaxy's David Beckham leaves the pitch after a training session at the Rogers Centre in Toronto on Tuesday March 6, 2012, ahead of his team's CONCACAF quarter final first leg tie against Toronto FC tomorrow. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young

David Beckham likes to bite his baby daughter

More

Chris Brown accepts the award for best R and B album for 'F.A.M.E.' during the 54th annual Grammy Awards on Sunday, Feb. 12, 2012 in Los Angeles. (AP / Matt Sayles)

Singer Chris Brown selling his Hollywood apartment

More