Entertainment -   

1

'Three Cups of Tea' shattered into a 'Million Little Pieces'?

'Three Cups of Tea' author Greg Mortenson. 'Three Cups of Tea' author Greg Mortenson.
'Three Cups of Tea' author Greg Mortenson.

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (18) Facebook   

Selected Comment

On balance, it seems that Mortenson's intentions are noble. Even if he is gaining personally, at least he is doing good work. By comparison, how many Wall Street brokers are building schools in poor countries?

Charles

'Three Cups of Tea' shattered into a 'Million Little Pieces'?

talking about
'Three Cups of Tea' shattered into a 'Million Little Pieces'?

Date: Tuesday Apr. 19, 2011 10:37 PM ET

Author Greg Mortenson spread an inspirational message about helping the poor in Pakistan and Afghanistan in his book, "Three Cups of Tea." Now Mortenson's book and the multi-million dollar organization he founded to help educate the poor have come under scrutiny following claims that parts of the book were fabricated.

In the 2006 bestseller, the former mountaineer recounted his travels to northern Pakistan in 1993, where he set out to climb K2 -- the world's second highest mountain.

Events lead Mortenson to a small village named Korphe, where the physically exhausted climber was cared for by locals. As a gesture of gratitude, Mortenson promised to build a school for the impoverished villagers. That promise led to the start of the Central Asia Institute, an organization which has raised funds to help build schools in the region.

But Mortenson's do-gooder image has taken a serious hit thanks to a segment aired on the CBS news show, "60 Minutes."

According to the "60 Minutes" investigation, enough allegations have surfaced to suggest that Mortenson may have fabricated the stories in his bestselling memoir.

The "60 Minutes" piece carried claims from mountaineer and writer Jon Krakauer, who said Mortensen had lied in his book.

According to Krakauer, Mortensen had not visited the remote village until 1994. Two porters who were with Krakauer corroborated his version of events.

A further claim that Mortenson was kidnapped by Taliban on a visit in July 1996 (also related in "Three Cups of Tea") was also said to be untrue.

More damning, still, were the allegations that Mortenson may have used Central Asia Institute as his own "private ATM."

Did Mortenson lie? Not so, says the author

On Monday, Mortenson issued a statement denying the allegations broadcast by CBS's 60 Minutes, claiming the program had not given a "fair, balanced or objective representation" of his work.

Mortenson also went on to say that some factual errors in the book likely stemmed from his lack of journalism experience and note-taking, and the collaborative effort behind writing the book, which he co-authored with "book writer" David Oliver Relin.

"When you re-create the scenes, you have my recollections, the different memories of those involved, you have his (Relin's) writing, and sometimes things come out different. In order to be convenient, there were some omissions. If we included everything I did from 1993 to 2003 it would take three books to write it. So there were some omissions and compressions," Mortenson said in a statement to Outside magazine.

In his defence, Mortenson complained about the manner in which "60 Minutes" first contacted him; by calling his wife, he said.

"Most professionals would call my office or publicist first and not my wife at home," Mortenson told Outside.

The fall-out has certainly sent ripples through the publishing world, rekindling memories of the scandal that arose in 2006 when author James Frey came under attack for fudging the facts in his bestseller, "A Million Little Pieces."

Viking, Mortenson's publisher, issued this statement: "Greg Mortenson's work as a humanitarian in Afghanistan and Pakistan has provided tens of thousands of children with an education. ‘60 Minutes' is a serious news organization and in the wake of their report, Viking plans to carefully review the materials with the author."

Comments are now closed for this story

nickmick
said
0 0

I have read both books and I can honestly say that Mortensons work is truly inspirational and astounding. That kind of dedication and compassion is rare in a complacent and brutal world. It offends me that 60 minutes would air this kind of garbage without looking into the whole truth. Mortenson himself has said that he is not an organised person when it comes to facts and time. He should be honored by his amazing work not discredited. It disgusts me that they would try and ruin his organization. Where would all those girls be right now if it wasn't for Greg Mortenson?


rachel_relin
said
0 0

Greg Mortenson's dramatic story of descending from his failed K2 climb to be rescued and nursed back to health in the village of Korphe, is recounted in a 2003 Parade Magazine article by journalist Kevin Fedarko. It appears that this was Greg Mortenson's version of the story long before meeting David Oliver Relin who he is now blaming for taking artistic license with his story.


wpg420
said
0 0

I'm sick of this "Give the guy a break" nonsense. If he lied, even half as much as is reported by 60 minutes, he is an ass, pure and simple. Those of you that see this issue as little more than exaggerating are missing the bigger picture.


jhh
said
0 0

actions speak louder than words. I commend him for his work on the ground in Afghanistan.


a traveller
said
0 0

I wonder what experience Jon Krakauer has in the challenges faced in that part of the world trying to get anything done that might seem good in our western eyes and by our standards....or what sacrifice he has made of life and time to help anyone except himself and his own book royalties. Before I pass judgment on Mortenson, I'd like to see some exposure on Krakauer


URU
said
0 0

He is expressing his thoughts and that's what a writer does. Its freedom of express that shouldn't be under wraps.


Tahir Bukhari
said
0 0

Despite some fabrication of story in his book, we should really appreciate and applaud for all the good things this person has done. It is remarkable and noble to care about poor kids while the world has so many selfish and self-centered individuals. However, if there are allegation of charity funds being intentionally mismanaged and abused, that should be investigated.


LoriK
said
0 0

My understanding is that the 60 minutes story was based on or originated because of this article: "Three Cups of Deceit" by Jon Krakauer. It can be downloaded free until Apr 20. It appears to be scrupulously researched.Sadly it looks like the 60 minutes show is accurate. I feel sad about this - I've donated alot of $ and bought and given away more than 20 books.


baig
said
0 0

My biggest problem, other than misappropriation of funds, is that he was promoting his fiction book as required reading for military going to these regions. His exaggerated and fabricated accounts in the books were being promoted as a way to understand these cultures. For the sake of selling more books? Despicable.


BLM Ontario
said
0 0

I guess he should have spoken to 60 minutes when he had the chance - before the piece aired. There were lots of opportunities, not just one call to his wife. That was the time to address the issue.


Steve
said
0 0

Given the opportunity to give his side, Mr. Mortensen instead whined about the approach instead of addressing the questions. Never good!There's a stench here and it'sgetting fouler every day!


rachel_relin
said
0 0

Greg Mortenson's dramatic story of descending from his failed K2 climb to be rescued and nursed back to health in the village of Korphe, is recounted in a 2003 Parade Magazine article by journalist Kevin Fedarko. It appears that this was Greg Mortenson's version of the story long before meeting "book writer" David Oliver Relin.


Charles
said
0 0

On balance, it seems that Mortenson's intentions are noble. Even if he is gaining personally, at least he is doing good work. By comparison, how many Wall Street brokers are building schools in poor countries?


frank
said
0 0

He was also raking in big $$$ for those speaking engagements and did he contribute any of it to his charity? NO!!Now how do you know that? Sounds like you might not like a person who is making a living and helping people too.


Anne
said
0 0

The fact that both authors may have fabricated information in their books is a non-story. James Fey never claimed his book to be 100% autobiographical but Oprah crucified him none the less.If Mortensen stole money from the charity - that is despicable but if he fudged parts of his story lines, who really cares?


Sandy
said
0 0

Give the guy a break! Listen to him speak and take his lifetime of work into account. So what if the stories were compilations. He's done an amazing amount of good work and continues to do so.... living modestly and working tirelessly.


Jak
said
0 0

@roberta: And what about all the funds NOT going to building schools and being used for him to fly around to speaking engagements in private jets? He was also raking in big $$$ for those speaking engagements and did he contribute any of it to his charity? NO!!


ROBERTA HACK
said
0 0

I have every confidence that the results will show that 60 minutes jumped to conclusions and the information presented on the show was one-sided. My thoughts and faith are with Mr. Mortensen and his organization which helps so many children.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Entertainment Stories

L.A. Galaxy's David Beckham leaves the pitch after a training session at the Rogers Centre in Toronto on Tuesday March 6, 2012, ahead of his team's CONCACAF quarter final first leg tie against Toronto FC tomorrow. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young

David Beckham likes to bite his baby daughter

More

Chris Brown accepts the award for best R and B album for 'F.A.M.E.' during the 54th annual Grammy Awards on Sunday, Feb. 12, 2012 in Los Angeles. (AP / Matt Sayles)

Singer Chris Brown selling his Hollywood apartment

More