Entertainment -   

1
Jennifer Argo, an associate professor at the School of Business at the University of Alberta, speaks with Canada AM from CTV studios in Edmonton on Monday, Nov. 26, 2007.

Men are magnets for fictional chick flicks: study

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Jennifer Argo, University of Alberta
am26_chickflicks

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (26)Add Comments Facebook   

Date: Mon. Nov. 26 2007 12:55 PM ET

A new study finds that chick flicks can be man magnets if they follow a few simple storytelling rules.

Jennifer Argo, an associate professor at the School of Business at the University of Alberta and one of the authors of the study, said she found that men are much more likely to enjoy 'chick flicks,' if they know they're watching a fictional story.

Women, on the other hand, generally have a higher level of empathy than men and tend to enjoy a story more when they know it is based on fact.

Fact or Fiction: An Investigation of Empathy Differences in Response to Emotional Melodramatic Entertainment, will be published in 2008, but the results have just been released.

Researchers asked undergraduates to read several stories and fill out a survey on how they felt about the material.

The researchers were attempting to determine the factors under which a male was most likely to enjoy a melodramatic story -- typically a sad tale where a protagonist or a main character tries to overcome a major obstacle, resulting in a struggle and sad emotions.

"We were interested in, well, is there ever a time when guys might actually enjoy this," Argo said. While many men would respond with a resounding "no," that may not necessarily be the case.

The research found that men who were told in advance that they were about to read a make-believe story, had a much higher chance of enjoying it than those who thought it was based on reality.

That may be because men are conditioned to dislike 'mushy' tear-jerkers or sad stories. When a story is make-believe, however, men can escape reality, detach themselves from cultural gender-role expectations, and simply enjoy the show.

Women who manage to convince their husbands, boyfriends or male friends to go to a chick flick with them, should try to convince them the story is fictional, if they want them to enjoy it, Argo said.

"We wouldn't say that the men are going to go out and, you know, start picking all the emotional movies all of a sudden, just because they're told it's fiction," Argo said.

But if they're told in advance that they show they are about to watch is fiction, their chances of enjoying it will increase dramatically, she said.

Unfortunately for men, Argo said, her research has not yet determined how men can turn the tables, and convince women that the next Jean Claude Van Damme action flick is worth their time and effort.

"We haven't found the answer yet," she said. "I think it would take quite a bit more research."

1

Add New Comment ( )

daffy
said
0 0

"MM
Oh, I can see it happening already...men getting all defensive and having to reassert their masculinity. "A chick flick? Me? Never!"

I think Jennifer Argo and her colleagues may have indeed struck a collective nerve."

Yeah. Sure. I'm just stinging, lady.


daffy
said
0 0

Yeah, like we want women to join us when we watch an action move.


Just say no
said
0 0

TO: AF

... and no male butt(s).


Sean Q
said
0 0

I hope the net effect of this research is that we'll finally be rid of a those stupid and meaningless "inspired by actual events!" (O RLY?) tag-lines. My doc thinks I may be suffering from a repetitive eye-rolling injury and has ordered me to stay off the "juice" during the upcoming holiday film season; it's not the films themselves, it's the previews before the films that usually get me.


hjo
said
0 0

Just wondering, did the researchers get paid for that type off boring research? Any way i don't care. I maybe see one movie a year and I threw out the TV when I divorced from a 32 year marriage.






Corey from Medicine Hat
said
0 0

Interestingly, my girlfriend has no interest in watching an action/war flick with me, unless she knows it's based on a true story! Needless to say, we watch a lot of "true stories" together. As far as going to the theatre to watch a "chick flick," I'd rather get a vasectomy.


Collage Student/Youth Care Worker
said
0 0

It's good to see that in this day and age of social problems, government corruption, and the high cost of living, that some people can do pointless work with money that could go towards so much more. A cure for HIV? NEVER, lets just develop a film that can incorporate both sexes likes. DISGUSTING!


Uwe Warkholdt, Elliot Lake, Northern Ontario
said
0 0

I don't know who they talked to for their survey but I am a straight male who enjoys a good old fashioned western.

"Nuf said"


Gregory S.
said
0 0

I enjoy real life stories, such as Hotel Rwanda, Aviator, Shake Hands with the Devil, etc. But, the pethetic mush with no real rhyme or reason but to cry over spilled milk type of stories -- that is the kind of garbage girls can enjoy if they really want and choose to see...


Sean (just say "no" to Fabio)
said
0 0

I'd like to see the raw data on this one. Does the term "...more men would like..." apply to a small amount of an already small test group? For example if 1 out of 15 like it better, this would mean a 7% increase but really it’s just one individual that was already on the fence in the first place. Machismo aside, some of these gender differences "studies" tend to leave out the obvious common sense flaws in favour of quotable candy one liners. No doubt Cosmopolitan, Chatelaine and the like have already begun their "How to Make Your Man Watch a Chick Flick" articles. All of them starting of by proclaiming "A recent study found..."


AF
said
0 0

I'll watch a 'chick flick' when there's at least one person getting shot and one car explosion.

XD


Don
said
0 0

Since most movie offerings are mindless dreck, I will have to conclude those taking part in the survey were equally stunned. Shouldn't that skew the results? By revealing the results publicly there will be an increase in domestic disputes that source from "which movie to see" arguments. I am sure the resultant squabbles will be more entertaining than the movies in question.


DW
said
0 0

Well if the movie is good who cares. Chick flick or any other, if the movie is good it is good.


Student
said
0 0

What a thrilling study. It's good to know that tuition dollars and grant money are going to such crucial social issues.


Niki
said
0 0

Personally, as a woman, I like chick flicks, action, sci-fi and all sorts of movies. I must agree that there are those women who like to watch a movie because it's based on real people and places. But, then there are other women, like myself, who have a fondness for movies not based on facts, but rather fiction. I guess when it all comes down to it, it all depends on the girl.


MM
said
0 0

Oh, I can see it happening already...men getting all defensive and having to reassert their masculinity. "A chick flick? Me? Never!"

I think Jennifer Argo and her colleagues may have indeed struck a collective nerve.


Don
said
0 0

Let me guess where this study was taking place? they were interviewed coming out of movie with their date in hand. If I am like other guys of course I am going to say I love chick flicks when I have a girl to impress, for that matter I like long walks on the beach and snuggling up on a cold day with a good book. Hahaha.


Mike
said
0 0

Guys!!!
Get with it! It is not about what you are watching, but who you are watching it with!


Albert
said
0 0

Is the reverse true, then? If we told her that a Chuck Norris flick was a true story, would she be more prone to watch? Hmmmm.


FreakAlert
said
0 0

One emasculating step at a time...


Steve in Nepean
said
0 0

Ha ha ha ha ha ha!

As if any guy could care less!

Bring on a chick flick, bring on the snores.


Denise
said
0 0

My thoughts exactly!


Angela Chapeski
said
0 0

Come to think of it, I think this might actually be true! At least in my house :)


RedNeck
said
0 0

Uh, I think Jeff Foxworthy already figured this out. All men really want is a beer and to watch somethin naked.


rm
said
0 0

The closest I've come to a chick flick is "Brian's Song"


Gord
said
0 0

Whatever!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest
Movie Moments

Movie Moments

Twenty-five scenes that get guys 'choked up.' Because of course, men don't cry.

Today's Entertainment Stories

Justin Bieber tweets about suffering a concussion in Paris, Friday, June 1, 2012.

Bieber laughs off fall, concussion worries in Paris

More  1 Video(s) 1

Matthew Fox talks to Associated Press during the launch of the new play 'In a Forest, Dark and Deep' at the Vaudeville theatre in London, Monday, Nov. 22, 2010. (AP / Sang Tan)

Ohio bus driver drops lawsuit against Matthew Fox

More