Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin Undated photo of French photographer Remi Ochlik as he was covering the Tunisian revolution, who died Wednesday Feb. 22, 2012 in Homs, Syria. (AP / Yoan Valat) Janis Mackey Frayer Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Journalists grieve for slain comrades in Syria

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Salute given to brave 'souls'
Amongst the escalating crisis in Syria, the final dispatch of a journalist is targeted and killed in the chaos. Middle East Bureau Chief Martin Seemungal on the salute given to the brave reporting on Syria and other combat zones.
CTV News Channel: The risks of bearing witness
Chris Waddell from the Carleton University School of Journalism says he believes the risks involved in reporting from the frontlines of conflict zones is worth it and that journalists who do it would say it's worth it as well.
National Affairs: Response to the crisis in Syria
The first commander of the UN Peacekeeping Forces in Sarajevo and a member of the Syrian National Council evaluate the international community's role as violence increases in Syria.
CTV News Channel: Deaths prompt international outcry
An associate professor at the University of Montreal, Samir Saul says there are very little options for action in Syria for western powers and that any action could trigger a regional war.
CTV News Channel: Robert Mahoney, journalist
A spokesperson for the Committee to Protect Journalists says Syria is extremely dangerous for journalists right now because the government is trying to seal the country, while pounding shells into civilian areas.
CTV News Channel: Erika Solomon in Beirut
A Reuters reporter says there are reports the journalists were killed after shelling began against the media centre they were in.
Canada AM: NBC's Richard Engel in Syria
An NBC News correspondent says the journalists were in one of the few areas that allowed for media access when it was destroyed, and explains how the condition of the other injured journalists remains unknown.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (20) Facebook   

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin Undated photo of French photographer Remi Ochlik as he was covering the Tunisian revolution, who died Wednesday Feb. 22, 2012 in Homs, Syria. (AP / Yoan Valat) Janis Mackey Frayer Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

Photos

Remi Ochlik and Marie Colvin

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Feb. 22 2012 10:19 PM ET

NEW DELHI — Shelling is a particularly brutal ingredient of war if you consider lethal explosives are fired to the sky without regard or need for an exact target with the sole intent of yielding enough damage to call it a "good strike."

Repeat or sustain that for hours, even days, or longer in the case of Homs, Syria, and you get a sense of the sort of treachery people endure when caught between warring and often unbalanced forces.

On this day, the shelling in Syria centred on a house that was a makeshift media centre where journalists were working and staying. From initial accounts they ran from the house and tried to escape but at least two were killed by either explosions or shrapnel.

Dead are Remi Ochlik, a French photographer in his late 20s, and Marie Colvin, an American reporter for The Sunday Times of Britain who was in her 50s. Others are injured but reports of who they are or the severity of their wounds or how they will be treated are murky at best.

I had met Marie Colvin a few times, mostly recently in Libya. As a journalist she was a legendary combination of authority and grace. To arrive at a place and see Marie Colvin seemed a sort of validation you were in the right place. She was a woman of incomparable bravery and fine humour when levity felt necessary.

If you are unfamiliar with her work with The Sunday Times, a Google search will return no shortage of stories about conflict and its consequences. She covered mostly Arab affairs but also reported from Chechnya, Gaza and Sri Lanka. She lost an eye there to shrapnel, but as one Twitter post recalled, "she recovered, wore an eye patch and returned to work."

In a statement, the editor of The Sunday Times, John Witheroe said, "Marie was an extraordinary figure in the life of The Sunday Times, driven by a passion to cover wars in the belief that what she did mattered."

Ochlik was born in 1983 and covered conflict in Haiti and the Arab uprisings. Last month he was awarded a first place finish at the World Press photo contest. The French government says it will demand an investigation.

Violence is intensifying in Syria. Yesterday Colvin did a video report for the BBC and CNN in which she described the situation facing Homs, the battered town where food and water are scarce (not to mention hope).

"I saw a baby killed today," she said, describing the bloodshed as absolutely sickening.

In a report she wrote, "The scale of human tragedy in the city is immense. The inhabitants are living in terror. Almost every family seems to have suffered the death or injury of a loved one."

Conflict has made for a costly year for journalism. Last week Anthony Shadid of The New York Times died of an asthma attack on assignment in Syria. A Syrian journalist was killed yesterday and a French television reporter died last month when a shell exploded near a group of journalists on a visit organized by the Syrian government.

The conflict in Libya also rendered a terrible toll on the ranks of those who commit themselves to "bearing witness." Yesterday the Committee to Protect Journalists released its annual survey of attacks on journalists. You can read the full report at their website.

Even before I met her I admired Marie Colvin for her fearlessness and brilliant storytelling. She cast a necessary light, so to speak, on the sort of darkness that is difficult for many of us to understand. In many cases, her stories allowed people and their plight to exist.

In 2010 she made a speech to London newspaper executives and said: "Craters. Burned houses. Mutilated bodies. Women weeping for children and husbands. Men for their wives, mothers, children.

"Our mission is to report these horrors of war with accuracy and without prejudice.

"We always have to ask ourselves whether the level of risk is worth the story. What is bravery, and what is bravado?

"Journalists covering combat shoulder great responsibilities and face difficult choices. Sometimes they pay the ultimate price."

Journalists who report conflict or turmoil comprise a strange community of people attracted by (or sent to) certain headlines. In difficult circumstance you see familiar faces. Often you work in close quarters and share drivers or information or cell phone chargers or Nescafe. You help, you compete, you protect, you argue, you worry.

And on days like this, you grieve.

Follow Janis Mackey Frayer on Twitter at @janisctv

Comments are now closed for this story

Spare Me - You are totally wrong
said

As someone coming from a country where civilians were massacred, You do not understand the value of journalists like Marie. With Governments controlling the state media, these journalists are the only link the poor people have with the rest of the world. The "public" you are referring to, a head count which may or may not include you, is not the reason these journalists are out there. Please don't insult their sacrifice.


stevo
said

Geoff, while I agree with your point that we need the media to report the deaths of innocent civilians you still miss my point. The media presents the deaths of their own differently than the deaths of non-journalists. It becomes a big deal because two journalists die in a war zone while the media does not cover the deaths of two non-journalists in the same way. This was not an accident, it was not a tragedy, it was not surprising. In war reporters die, so do soldiers, and civilians do as well. Don't single out reporters because it gives the impression that their lives are more important. Report the deaths of all equally or none at all.


R. E. Lee, Cold Lake, AB
said

I personally know a Lebanese-Canadian who has recently been in the Syrian -Lebanese border area. He knows what it is like to live in a country such as Syria. History is replete with dictatorships and tyrants; it could even happen here if we are not careful. Fore-warned is fore-armed, and journalists are the people who have chosen to warn us of those who would oppress us, anywhere. We are all human, and deserve to live, and raise our children, in freedom and peace.


peter in mb
said

I disagree with a few people here journalists the go into war zones armed only with a camera are as brave if not braver then the solders. These journalists are the ones who witness the war crimes and human rights violations committed by countries.


Geoff B
said

Stevo - What you wrote just doesn't make sense. No, we may not know the names of the innocent victims of conflicts, but often we wouldn't even know there were any innocent victims if it wasn't for the presence of journalists like Marie Colvin. These days, there are local inhabitants able to record violence on mobile phones etc & broadcast the output via Internet - but often these images & accompanying commentary is confused. Official, independent reporters are still our best source of accurate information.


Kelly
said

My condolences to the families of these journalists. BUT as has been said - they chose to be in the line of fire to document the war. I think we have enough documentation of war to last us till the end of time - watch the History channel for an hour. Has all that "documentation" changed anything? enlightened us? Made us more peaceful?As one comment said "they are the true celebrities/heroes" - yes. I think that is exactly what they are there for. Viewing people torn apart doesn't stop the warring. And the constant vision of this in the news? Why do we bombard our senses with this as though we need front row seats to the wars? Listen to the news and do what you can to help those that are suffering if you can. To simply view pictures/video in the name of "educating" ourselves seems senseless.


Spare Me
said

@ Big Picture @ Mike in Mississauga: I'm not asserting that journalism in these situations is some sort of waste of time, and that journalists themselves aren't to be praised (or highly rewarded) for their professional bravery. Foreign news reporting amid armed conflicts is important. However, I do not believe that to accomplish this "public" objective journalists need to be danger-chasing "cowboys/cowgirls" scurrying from vantage point to vantage point, fueled by competitive greed. Often, in fact, the micro coverage distorts or devalues the macro understanding of what is really at play. Personally, I don't need to be shocked, aroused, or titillated, but, I appreciate that it "sells" news. (With endless graphic depictions of violence and death in our news, Western society is actually getting rather numb to the dire struggles in many parts of the world.) Ultimately, I want to be informed with proper political context. Thanks.


Remarkable
said

My thoughts and prayers go out to the friends and families who have lost their loved ones. Thank you to the journalists who go out to get the stories in the world, where ever the stories maybe, who put down the horrors of war into words, who take the pictures to show us the ugliness of war so that we who know the truth, so that those who commit attrocities cannot shove it under the carpet. I thank these two journalists who were there in Syria showing the world as to what is truly going on. Thank you to all of them. God Bless.


KJS
said

It's sad to see the lack of sympathy shown by some of the people commenting here. These people have made sacrifices to tell the stories of those who otherwise have no platform. It's one thing to read about shelling in an area, and quite another to have a face, the name of a baby who has died,. and the account of those who are grieving in these areas of conflict. I see this as a sacrifice made by journalists who hope by documenting this suffering to raise concern and bring changes for the better.


Don
said

Very sad but why are you there anyways? Find a safer job and who cares what goes on outside our own place!


J.C.
said

Many journalists enter these areas of combat and upheaval to try to seek the truth of what is really going on, rather than take the word of Regimes only such as those in Syria. It takes courage to do this. Condolences to the families and loved ones of those who have lost their lives for these reasons.


stevo
said

Sad? Perhaps. But it also comes with the territory. It's a far greater tragedy when innocent civilians die in war as opposed to professional journalists who choose to risk their lives by putting themselves in a war zone to do their jobs. How many civilians died yesterday in war zones? Does the world know their names? Does the media really care about any of them? This is only a story because journalists feel a personal connection to it in the way they don't when non-journalists are killed.


MY
said

We may not be 'desperate' to know of the political wars and conflict in other countries, but regardless if people like "Spare Me" care or not, there is still a need for humanity and empathy in this world. The people in Syria are being killed without mercy. There are innocent children and babies being brutally killed and starved. The outcry for help and aid whether we care or not is there. They are human and these monstrosities will never come to end if the voices of those innocent victims are not heard. Thank you Marie and Remi. You believed in what you did and I feel you made more of an impact in this world than either I or Spare Me ever will.


Mike in Mississauga
said

@ spare me. Ignorance is bliss isn't it?I applaud these journalists for their bravery and integrity to sacrifice their safety so that the truth can be told over propaganda. The stories of people’s lives and their suffering must be told. My prayers go out to the friends and families of these journalists, and all who sacrifice their lives for the less fortunate in this world. You are the real celebrities and heroes of the world.


Big Picture
said

Spare me has it wrong. Without the efforts of these brave journalists in bringing the truth to light the world would not have a clear picture of the atrocities perpetrated in these conflicts. Marie Colvin, and Remi Ochlik were not reporting this conflict because they were coerced into being there because it was their job.They believed that by exposing the truth they could make a difference, Spare me, show them some respect!


Scott in TO
said

I do feel for the families BUT certainly not for people who willingly place themselves in harms way...all for the sake of the almighty dollar or to "tell their story to the outside world". Yes, they have every right to be there but be careful of what you wish for.


Robert B
said

If its not reported did it happen???????


David Murrell
said

My prayers go out to friends, colleagues, and relatives of the two slain journalists. Though my views differ markedly to the mainstream journalistic opinions of those covering conflicts in the Middle East, I have alsways had the utmost regard for those journalists in the line of fire. They are brave people indeed.I despise the Syrian government for indisicriminate shelling of civilian areas. Yet few activists in the West seem concerned about this.


Mark in Newmarket
said

Journalists are always on the frontline of any conflict so that the story maybe brought to us on the outside to know what is going on. Journalists volunteer to go into these conflicts to tell the story, to take the photo's, to show us the horror and the atrocities of war and hopefully to remove any glamour that maybe associated with war. We may not like all journalists, but there are those who do put it on the line to get the stories waiting to be told and they try and keep the truth in the light because in war the first casualty is usually the truth.


Spare Me
said

With all due respect, yet honesty, I do not believe that the public is so "desperate" to know the street-level details of armed conflicts in foreign countries that it encourages or endorses journalists risking their lives for a news report (accompanied by a photograph or video) that is likely to be completely forgotten with seconds/minutes of being consumed.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   5 Comments 5    1 Video(s) 1

Canada's Ryder Hesjedal holds the trophy after winning the 95th Giro d'Italia, Tour of Italy cycling race, in Milan, Italy, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (AP / Fabio Ferrari)

Hesjedal becomes first Canadian to win Giro d'Italia

More   23 Comments 23    8 Video(s) 8

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10