Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital. A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family. A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family. Ontario Provincial Police and emergency crews investigate a multiple fatal motor vehicle accident near Hampstead, Ontario, Monday, Feb. 6, 2012. Police say 11 people died in the crash. (Dave Chidley / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family.

Crash survivors eligible for health care coverage

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: More details on horrific crash
Concerns are being raised over the safety of 15 passenger vans, following the horrific van crash near Stratford, Ont. And as Seamus O'Regan reports, Ontario is looking at taking these types of vans off the road altogether.
CTV Southwestern Ontario: More on crash victims' futures
More information is being released on the company that employed the migrant workers and whether the survivors could be deported. Joel Bowey and Nicole Lampa report.
CTV Toronto: Group claims survivors may be deported
The Industrial Accident Victims Group of Ontario is saying that three Peruvian nationals who survived Monday's terrible accident in Hampstead could be deported once they recover. Austin Delaney reports.
CTV News Channel: Will the workers be deported?
Maryth Yachnin, a staff lawyer with the Industrial Accident Victims Group of Ontario, says migrant workers are often deported shortly after they've been injured, which then forces them to lose their workman's compensation benefits.
CTV National News: Fatal mistake costs 11 lives
Police have confirmed the cause of a horrific crash that killed 11 people on a country road near Stratford, Ont. A passenger van drove straight through a stop sign, into the path of a tractor trailer. Seamus O'Regan reports.
CTV Southwestern Ontario: Crash investigation continues
OPP say a horrific crash that killed 11 people in Hampstead is believed to have been caused by driver error. Art Baumunk has the details.
CTV Southwestern Ontario: Mourning the men lost
Sadness and loss is being felt both locally in Ontario and a world away in Peru, where the families of those lost in the car crash are mourning. Correspondents have more on the tributes.
CTV Southwestern Ontario: Crash memorial set up
Those trying to understand the loss and wishing to pay their respects have turned the site of the crash in Ontario, that killed 11 people, into a makeshift memorial. Nicole Lampa has more.
CTV Toronto: Driver of migrant workers made deadly error
A horrific crash that left 11 people dead was caused by a driver who ran through a stop sign and failed to yield to traffic, OPP said Wednesday. Tamara Cherry and Paul Bliss report.
CTV News Channel: OPP on the investigation
The OPP say there are a lot more questions than there are answers and they are working diligently to bring some understanding and closure to a heartbreaking event. They also say the crash was preventable.
CTV News Channel: WSIB to cover crash expenses
Stan Raper, national director of the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, reacts the the WSIB's decision to cover the medical and travel costs of the crash in Hampstead, Ont.
CTV News Channel: German Gutierrez, activist
A community activist says many migrant workers live in isolation, work long hours and have no contact with the community.
CTV News Channel: John Vennavally-Rao in London
Authorities are putting the blame on the driver for failing to stop at a stop sign and not yielding to oncoming traffic.
CTV News Channel: Seamus O'Regan in Hampstead
A CTV National News correspondent says friends and family of the victims grieved at the crash site, showing the victims had a support system in Canada. He also explains it is still unknown whether the remains will be flown back to Peru for burial.
CTV News Channel: OPP on the crash, survivors
Members of the OPP say they are contacting the victims' next of kin, and say the survivors of the horrific crash are alive and in hospital.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (33) Facebook   

Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital. A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family. A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family. Ontario Provincial Police and emergency crews investigate a multiple fatal motor vehicle accident near Hampstead, Ontario, Monday, Feb. 6, 2012. Police say 11 people died in the crash. (Dave Chidley / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A number of the victims of a crash in Hampstead, Ont., pictured here, are believed to be members of the same extended family.

Photos

Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital.

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Feb. 9 2012 9:53 PM ET

Three migrant workers injured in a horrific crash this week will be eligible for health care coverage from the Workers Safety and Insurance Board, a representative of the group said Thursday.

WSIB spokesperson Christine Arnott told CTVNews.ca the agency, which governs coverage for injured workers in Ontario, was putting together a plan for the men, the only survivors in the 14-person crash in southern Ontario on Monday. She said she would be releasing more details later in the day.

At least one of the crash survivors is improving. Juan Ariza, 35, was initially taken to a Stratford hospital in critical condition, but is now listed in fair condition at the London Health Sciences Centre. Javier Abelardo Alba-Medina, 38, is also at the London hospital in fair condition.

The family of Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, who was airlifted from the crash site to Hamilton General Hospital in critical condition, has asked the hospital not to release further updates to the public.

Earlier this week, the WSIB told the Ontario Federation of Labour that families of the 10 deceased migrant workers would also be eligible for compensation.

But despite the WSIB's assurances, a group of legal aid lawyers is warning that the survivors may not end up with the treatment they deserve. The Industrial Accident Victims Group of Ontario says that if recent trends continue, the men are likely to be deported and lose access to workers' compensation.

"We're very pleased to hear that families of the men who died will receive compensation, but at the same time, we have to ask what's going to happen to the men who survived," Maryth Yachnin, a lawyer with the group, told CTV News Channel Thursday.

"In our experience, what happens to migrant workers is shortly after (they get injured), they are deported to their home country," and lose any rights to compensation benefits, she said.

"Frankly, we think it's absurd," Yachnin said, adding that many migrant workers don't report their injuries out of fear of deportation.

"We see this very often. Farm work and work that migrant labourers do for us, to put food on our tables as Canadians, is some of the most dangerous work in this country," she said.

The victims' group says the Workplace Safety and Insurance Board often avoids payments by insisting the claimant can find another job in the province. But for migrant workers, whose visas are short-term and tied to their employer, that is rarely the case.

"I wish the board would set a precedent for migrant workers in Canada based on this horrific accident," Yachnin said.

Crash shakes rural community

The workers, a group of Peruvian men, died Monday when a flatbed truck and a 2007 GMC Savanna passenger van collided shortly before 5 p.m. northeast of Stratford, Ont.

Driver David Armando Blancas-Hernandez, who was among the 11 people killed, did not brake at a stop sign and failed to yield to traffic with the right of way, OPP Insp. Scott Lawson said on Wednesday. "It was this action that caused the collision."

Ten of the 13 men who were in the van died, as did the 38-year-old truck driver.

The van required a Class F licence because it had more than 10 seats. Police said Wednesday that Blancas-Hernandez only had a G-class licence, which could limit auto insurance payments made to the victims.

The workers had been working at a poultry farm vaccinating chickens near the crash site.

St. Joseph's Catholic Church in Stratford, Ont., will host a non-denominational prayer service for the crash victims on Friday at 7 p.m. The local diocese says the service will host victims of the crash and their families, and will pay tribute to the emergency workers who responded to the scene.

Meanwhile, Fulton's employers have set up a CIBC trust fund to provide financial assistance to his family. Members of the public interested in donating can go to any branch of the bank and reference the Fulton Family Trust (transit and account numbers 07612/52-04313).

--With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Dave in Alberta
said

I wish the fed.gov and the provinces especially the one I live in wakes up and put a stop to international drivers licenses. I do not have a problem with tourists renting or borrowing a car to drive around but when you start allowing visitors/workers coming in and driving vehicles with air brakes, vehicles with large capacity of seating such as this weh/mini bus van which its licensed as to drive without any training. You have a drivers program in each province and if one wishes to drive these vehicles they must have the correct one to do so yet not when it comes to international drivers licenses where the province has no idea what training you have. This driver would not even have to follow the hours of service to operate a commercial vehicle. Now we have to cover their hospital bills. Sure hope the province goes after this chicken company but they have a loop hole and thats all because of the international drivers license.


Imported worker
said

Harper government and cons have their share of responsibility for these events. They facilitate what I call human smuggling / illegal immigration and contraversial labour exploitation. No one is talking about the sponsor / employer of these workers nor about their immigration / visa status. How these guys were hired, smuggled in Canada? Were they legally entitled to work in Canada? Their healthcare expenses should be covered if they were legally entitled to work in Canada and if not the smuggler and employer should pay for the expenses. Cons and their supporters view in regard to these practices is despicable and nauseating.


Cambob in Toronto
said

Canadian citizens have rights. Visitors must obey the laws while they are here. I have enormous sympathy for the individual suffering of these poor people, but there must be limits. If they don't have to obey the law, then why should I obey the law? (by paying taxes)


Jester
said

No Nathan, the solution is to raise the pay for these workers to the minimum wage, to give all Canadians and non Canadians the chance to work for a fair living. Change the laws to classify these factory farms from agricultral to industeral, allow farm workers to be treated like workers in other sectors . Stop demanding cheep food, buy less but of better quality.


Margot
said

Did I miss the part in the news that stated who owned the passenger vehicle and allowed the man to drive without an F licence. Shouldn't the owner of the vehicle accept some of the responsibility for not checking the correct requirements>


BigT
said

The problem G, is that, from what i have gathered so far, they were travelling in a company van, that wasn't meant to carry passangers, it was meant for livestock, that is what i got from reading a couple of other posts.


Kevin
said

but being covered for something that happened physically off the job site, during the commute home and after their working hours?? Hmm.....Is this under WSIB coverage???--- G ---It's covered under "Make the Employer Pay them all the Benifits regular Canadians get , or suddenly there will be no jobs anywhere for regular canadians":) Should make them pay the same wages a regular canadian gets too , if you ask me.


JackBlack
said

I am extremely upset by this situation. I am Canadian like everyone else, and think that these people should be taken care of, but has anyone asked the Peruvian gov't to step in or to fly the deceased home at their expense? Why do we, as Canadians, have to foot the bill for this tragic accident? Thousands of Canadians every year are injured on their way to/from work and WSIB doesn't pay for their care. In fact if you have ever had to file a WSIB claim, then you know that it's like pulling teeth to get the benefits you're entitled to, so why did they jump to the rescue here? We need to learn to take care of our own, like the family of the innocent truck driver.


Kevin
said

I don't understand the problem. Heal them up , at our expense, and if the job vanishes (because the place blew up etc) that's just like a natural disaster, send them home. I'm not saying the Employer should get away with anything , if he's running an unsafe environment , he should be fined, shut down , even thrown in jail if it's really bad. But when the jobs over, the jobs over. These people weren't accepted as immigrants , and getting injured shouldn't be used as a back door to circumvent the process.


G
said

I was thinking the same thing as Joe Shmoe...Although it is a terrible tragedy, I do understand it would be one thing if it happened on the job site/during working hours...but being covered for something that happened physically off the job site, during the commute home and after their working hours?? Hmm.....Is this under WSIB coverage???


Nathan
said

@Alexandria You are right. But we should be making sure that our own citizens are first in line for employment. It is easy to see that cheaper labor is more prospective to employers. So the simple solution to this situation is to abolish the minimum wage so our own citizens get opportunities to work. As opposed to being undercut by people who are not even citizens.


Sam
said

This is the least the Province can do, after all they were here working under conditions that Canadians wont do. Those on the public dole should be made go to these work places instead of sitting at home waiting for their cheques. This is absurd. I hope the government remembers the Canadian truck driver who was also killed through no fault of his. The owner of the van who had a driver with a "G" license should also be dealt with. I am sure working conditions for some migrant workers are far from acceptable. Laws need to change for them.


Stu
said

Virginia These jobs are so low paying that Canadians can not afford to do this type of work.


Jester
said

Roby D, the problem is, his visa is only for farm labor at a specific farm, working anywhere else would be illegal.These workers are paid less than minimum wage, where I live, greenhouse jobs are advertized all the time, but they don't hire Canadians, its just for show, they would have to pay Canadians minimum wage. Greenhouse owners make millions off the backs of cheep labor, so you can buy cheep tomatoes. In the end this accident is all of our collective fault by our demanding that producers produce the low price goods that we demand. Next time you shop for low cost chicken and eggs think of the cost these workers paid.


Michelle - Ontario
said

I am truly saddened by this tragedy. loved ones lost. But I am extremely saddened that there is sooo much information on these immagrants, yet NOTHING of the truck driver that also lost his life. This person was not even licensed to drive this vehicle, and 14 people paid the price for that. I am worried that WSIB paying these workers is just openeing a HUGE can of worms. This was NOT an accident, as there is NO such thing. This collision was PREVENTABLE. And this did NOT even happen at the workplace. How is this work related? So if I get in an accident on my way to work, are they going to pay my health care also? I highly doubt it. Shouldn't their employer be responsible, as he was the one that let an unlicensed driver drive this vehicle? Isn't that what the employer has insurance for? I believe the Employer should have to pay ALL the surviving families...INCLUDING the truck driver!!!


Lynn
said

There seems to be a lot of people upset/confused and making comments about the type of work that the migrant workers do, that Canadians are too snobbish to do them and the migrant workers are cheap labour. First of all, for many workers coming to Canada and being paid minimum wage is a God send compared to the wages they would make in their home Countries- it's why they do it. No one is taking advantage of them- they come here on their own accord to provide a better life for themselves and their families. And then to say that Canadians are too snobbish or lazy to do this type of work makes me roll my eyes- coming from a family of farmers I have witnessed first hand Canadians doing this work. Farm work is tough, back breaking labour. To insult and generalize Canadians because you wouldn't do the work yourself is laughable. The hiring of migrant workers benefits everyone involved- it improves their lifestyle- compared to the country they came from, the money they send home puts food on their families tables, and the financial savings here keeps the costs of our own food lower. If these people didn't greatly benefit from this they would not leave their countries and families behind. Perhaps those concerned that we are using slave labour should focus their energies on the use of child labour which we Canadians directly fund on a daily basis.


Chris Kasulke
said

I have to agree with Tracey. Why has so very little been said about the driver of the 6 wheel truck? All we've been told is his name and age and that he was celebrating his 11th wedding anniversary the day of the crash. Does he have children? Will his widow receive adequate insurance for the loss of his income (never mind the loss of her life partner)? Regardless of the fact that 10 people died in 1 vehicle, why does that get more attention than the single person that died in the other vehicle, minding his own business, returning home from a day's work to celebrate with his wife? As for the other poster who said that because the migrant worker made the mistake their should not be any compensation....the driver is dead, his passengers had nothing to do with his poor driving decision....why should they be excluded from compensation because of his carelessness? Certainly, these poor men (some of them on their first day of work in Canada) and their families deserve the same consideration legally as the Canadian driver.


firstMickey
said

Virginia, Canadians who are on welfare can sit home and do nothing and get paid for it. They are not too proud for a handout, but too proud or lazy to do the kind of work the migrants were doing. I hope the workers who were injured will get good medical care and get well. The asses who want to send them home ASAP don't have a heart.


Karen
said

I have a few questions . Did the pay taxes? Why is WSIB paying for there health care when in fact most Canadians cant get coverage. Does this make my prieums go up? IS sanyone helping the tow truck drivers family? If i get injuired on the way home from work is wsib going to cover my expenses?


Taxpayer
said

if there are people on UI or well fare and CAN work, they should be doing this work. And not just getting free money. And why should we have to pay for their hospital bills, and they take up room for Canadians that are sick and could be in there.


rita
said

I feel for these people and their families, but many people are involved in crashes on their way to and from work and I never heard once that they are covered under WSIB. Unless they are delivery people???????


Roby-D
said

Joe Schmoe,The van was owned and operated by the company the workers were employed by, that is why it is a workplace injury.


JSB
said

That is great WSIB & part of the Gov't is paying the costs for these workers. Either hospital bills or sending them back to their country for Burial.
I have to ask this question as I have yet to see it anywhere.
Are the also paying the expenses for the truck driver that lost his life due to this acciden?
He also had a family and was heading home to celebrate his 11th Wedding anniversary.

With that said may they all RIP.


WSV
said

I'm glad to hear that the Peruvians will be getting WSIB to fund their treatment (which is paid for by employer contributions), I would hate for Ontario taxpayers to be picking up the tab when we already pay a health premium and face worsening health care services.Wait a second, if employers are paying for WSIB, that means that they will inevitably pass on the costs to customers with higher prices. Customers then pay higher HST based on a higher subtotal for goods and services. So in essence, with the law of increasing taxation, taxpaying consumers are on the hook for this bill. I love the blatantly inaccurate spin to deflect from the true reality of how these bills are being paid.Where is the Peruvian government in this situation, and why are they not ponying up something towards these expenses?


Alexandria
said

Virginia Migrant workers work for next to nothing at hard physical labour. Most Canadians would not do this kind of work for the wages paid. Probably minimum wage.


Christine Fraser
said

I will donate $100 to these families. We are a rich country and these people were just trying to make a living. This should never have happened. Canada is a good country and this co. was making money off the backs of these immigrant workers. Cheap labor. Cheap cheap.


Jill
said

They're here because Canadians do not want to participate in certain types of work, including farm work. It is extremely difficult to find employees to do manual labour as evidenced by my friend's perennial farm where she was forced to hire non Canadians to keep her business open.


Roby-D
said

Virginia, the migrant workers are doing the jobs the rest of us Canadians are too snobby to accept, regardless of how long they've been out of work. Migrant workers often come to the communities near wear I live, and do back-breaking work, usually out-of-doors, for long hours, for minimal pay - most of which is sent home to their families abroad.I agree, if there's work, why are so many people still unemployed?


Joe Schmoe
said

My (heartless) question is: Since when is having an accident when driving home from work considered a workplace accident.


Tracey
said

I have to get this off my chest. I am SO SICK of all the attention on the migrant workers who were to BLAME for this tragedy and hardly a word or issue of financial help or thoughts for that truck driver and his family (maybe Canadian and not as important????? ). What is up with all of these news companies? I am refraining from putting more thoughts into this email as I am so angered at the ignorance. The truck driver did not make the crossing illegally and yet he is dead due to money hungry farmers overfilling transport vehicles to save a buck.Ticked in JarvisTracey


Roby-D
said

I'm confused as to the problem with the Jamaican foreign worker. I work with WSIB claims in my job, and it is normal for workers to be sent back to work as part of their rehabilitation, and unforatunately they are not always able to return to the same job they used to do. The idea is to get them back to work, and a part of society again, earning a wage instead of just collecting a disability fund. If he is unhappy with the job opportunities available to him in Canada, then he always has the choice to return home to Jamaica.


dan
said

good. they should be treated the same as every worker in canada. they are doing much needed work in canada


Virginia, Montreal
said

As tragic as the accident is, there is an underlying question that has not been addressed yet (to my knowldge): Why are migrant workers working in Canada? Why don't Canadians have their jobs? Do we actually have to import workers when the Canadian unemployment rate is as high as it is?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   5 Comments 5    1 Video(s) 1

Canada's Ryder Hesjedal holds the trophy after winning the 95th Giro d'Italia, Tour of Italy cycling race, in Milan, Italy, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (AP / Fabio Ferrari)

Hesjedal becomes first Canadian to win Giro d'Italia

More   23 Comments 23    8 Video(s) 8

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10