News Sections
Family defends husband of woman beaten in Mexico
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTVNews.ca Staff
Date: Thu. Jan. 26 2012 9:02 PM ET
The brother of a 37-year-old Canadian woman who was badly beaten at a five-star resort last week in Mexico is defending the victim's husband, saying a statement by Mexican officials could be misinterpreted to suggest wrongdoing on his part.
In an email statement, Paul Giles described Sheila and Andrew Nabb as a "loving couple" and said Andrew is "innocent of any form of abuse."
"Andrew was initially questioned by authorities immediately after this tragic event and was soon after released when it became apparent that he was innocent of any form of abuse," Giles said in the email.
"Anyone who has ever met Andrew will immediately disregard any and all accusations against him. They are the most loving couple that I know, and anyone that knows them would agree."
Giles said he felt pressured to release the statement after Mexican authorities issued a statement in Spanish that could be translated to say "domestic violence" when they meant "internal violence."
The press release from the Sinaloa state government was referring to the violent incident being internal to Mexico.
Mexican police still don't have a suspect even though they have a surveillance video of the attack.
The video shows Nabb, who remains in a Mexican hospital after suffering multiple facial fractures, being beaten in a hotel elevator by someone who appears to be another guest in his mid-20s.
Tom Walters told CTV's Canada AM in a telephone report Thursday that the video shows the attacker "striking and stomping" Nabb in the elevator.
No one is in custody and police have yet to identify the man in the video, although they said the suspect isn't dressed like a hotel staff member or a local resident, meaning he may be another tourist.
Police have taken statements from nine people in the case, including a guest with bruises on his hand and injuries to his chin.
Nabb, raised in Nova Scotia but a resident of Calgary, had been vacationing with family members at the five-star resort hotel in Mazatlan at the time of the attack.
Officials said that if the man in the video returns home to his country of origin, they are confident he can be brought back through extradition treaties if necessary.
Her husband, Andrew Nabb, was interviewed by police but ruled out as a suspect, Walters said, indicating evidence shows he was sleeping in his room when the attack occurred.
Andrew Nabb also watched the video and couldn't identify the attacker, he said.
Police are waiting for Sheila Nabb's condition to improve to get a statement. She came out of a medically induced coma earlier this week but she's still too weak to talk, Walters said.
Nabb was set to undergo surgery on her facial fractures this week, but her doctors have postponed the procedure because of the illness.
The setback became apparent when doctors were preparing to remove a breathing tube in her neck, Nabb's family said.
Once awake, she recognized her husband and appeared lucid. She was also able to respond to questions, brother Paul Giles said in a statement.
Walters also said the media in Mazatlan seem to be more concerned about the "black eye" Mazatlan is receiving over the attack rather than the incident itself, calling it a "big fuss."
"The one thing that really has struck us here over the last couple of days that we've been in Mazatlan is how quiet it is for January," Walters said.
"This is not a place where the tourism business is doing particularly well at the moment," he said, adding local "authorities" seem to be more worried about the impact on the region's reputation.
An Ontario man from Fergus told CTV News Wednesday he will never return to Mexico after being brutally beaten outside a restaurant near the same resort a year ago.
Scott Giddy was also the victim of a scam at a local medical clinic he was first taken to by a taxi driver where he spent 45 minutes, and was then forced pay a $4,700 bill on a credit card before being permitted to leave.
He and his wife, Sarah Giddy, said when he was finally taken to a hospital the family was harassed by the facility's money collectors to pay a $45,000 medical bill or that Scott's treatment would end.
With files from CTVNews.ca's John Size
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
If 5000 jobs can be so vital to the nation's economy, they should get what they ask for in bargaining. Simple.
bob.
Raitt urges MPs to support 'expedited' back-to-work bill
Canada AM is a production of CTV News, and is Canada’s most-watched morning news program.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Ashley
said
I can understand people not wanting to make prejudicial assumptions and many of these comments here are ignorant at best and blatently racist at worst. That's disappointing to see. But I also don't think people should be dismissive of the fact that there have been too many Canadians killed or injured during their travels to Mexico.
Mother of 12
said
At least a dozen Canadians have been killed or injured in Mexico since 2000.
During the same time period in Cuba not one Canadian has been killed or injured.
Hawaii is somewhere in between.
patfromazatlan
said
So, I fell very safe in Mazatlan and will return many more times before I retire and live in Mazatlan. Just a matter of time before the Whole story emerges and the perpetrator is caught, convicted and jailed.
Ken
said
The video of the attack shows a man dressed as a tourist. Meaning non-Mexican.
needagrownupnopun
said
sad day
said
Frequent Mexican Visitor
said
1. It is not uncommon for police to investigate crimes prior to declaring who is guilty - in Canada and in Mexico
2. Would it be possible guests in an all-inclusive may have over-consumed alcohol and problems arose?
3. Based upon limited amount of facts available - numerous commenters have jumped to massive conclusions.
4. Are any commenters joining a media rush? Seems so.
daveyboy
said
Ivan
said
Peter
said
Joanne
said
Bob J.
said
Sam
said
Similarly spent the last 7 vacations in Cuba but since Fidel faded the police state has developed cracks. Economic hardships have spread with massive government resort layoffs in 2010 and there is more angry envy against tourists. The population has less fear of the Police which translates into more tourist crime and resorts are no longer safe zones. As much as I like the Cuban people, I can’t expose my family to escalating risk in Cuba and will not return. Florida & Negril Jamaica feels much better these days.
Ricardoc
said
Violence and opportunists is everywhere, but also is the ignorance as like I see with some of these comments.
Live life don't run scared. See you all in Mexico!!!
abby
said
Gloria Fiset
said
Phil
said
My question is, who would want to vacaction in a place like that? Also, who wants to support a country with systemic corruption and lawlessness?
My wife and I have travelled all over the world, but we have no interest in Mexico as it is today.
HighCommandGAFE
said
Shaun
said
Lori
said
JohninMaz
said
Susan Fairbairn
said
Alberta Mike
said
As for Sue's comment regarding Albertans, it was totally uncalled for and she should remember Alberta attracts people from all over the country. She should get out from the "rock" she calls home.
HeDidIt
said
Steve-O
said
TomPatty
said
This is what they're doing too. Look at the couple who was murdered a few years back - while attending their daughter's wedding. What ever happened with that????
I will never ever go to Mexico ever again. Canadians should boycot this country. Geeze, keep your money and go to Califorina or better yet, Hawaii.
raymonda ottawa
said
Dave in Calgary
said
I hope this young lady makes a fuul recovery. I hope her family (and husband) find the strength to get through this. I hope justice is done, and the real truth comes out, but I won't hold my breath on the last item!
Falcon
said
In my opinion the way things are in Mexico with all these reports of attacks, that nobody should travel there.
Chris
said
What was she doing ALONE, at that time on night in a strange country? Stupid ppl put themselves in stupid positions and get themselves into trouble! Women walkin the streets of Canada that late never get hurt do they?
Can't be ignorant and foolish in life.. There are places MUCH worse than Mexico.. Please stay home because I have more space and get better deals down there.
Ken
said
Devil's Advocate
said
Corry Todd
said
Ryan in AB
said
J.C.
said
Proud to be an Albertan
said
SueH
said
travelln_joe
said
wow
said
timbuck2
said
**Mandy**
said
Travelling Gal
said
peter in mb
said
sing4joy
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
TJR
said
Jenn Wake
said
URU
said
URU
said
Rick in Quebec
said
bradin780
said
Francine
said
CalgaryBrad
said
Highground
said
Ms. ME and ME and I
said
Jack Taxi
said
Greysky
said
Shoeman1975
said
Annie
said
Ken
said
BLM
said
Mr. ME and ME and I
said
Bob
said
Veronica
said
Kurt
said
TheOtherLowellInBC
said
William
said
Austin W in Saskatoon
said
Ken
said
Lindsay
said
Anne
said
Deb
said
Alexis in Victoria
said
Resident
said
Highground
said
bradin780
said
gil
said
SueH
said
Conservative Mike
said
Austin W in Saskatoon
said
Pat
said
DSK
said
Goldens
said
Ian Ottawa
said
dan
said
Sue
said