Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1

Martin to Harper: Stop studying issues, go to a reserve

Former Prime Minister Paul Martin smiles during a discussion on Indigenous governance in a new century at Ryerson University in Toronto on Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2011. (Frank Gunn / THE CANADIAN PRESS)
Former Prime Minister Paul Martin smiles during a discussion on Indigenous governance in a new century at Ryerson University in Toronto on Tuesday, Jan. 25, 2011. (Frank Gunn / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (75) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday Jan. 25, 2012 12:05 PM ET

OTTAWA — Paul Martin does nothing to mask his frustration on the other end of a telephone line.

The former prime minister and architect of the scuttled Kelowna Accord tried to find something to salvage in the historic talks between First Nations chiefs and Stephen Harper. Instead, what he saw was the federal government wasting more time and sending the chiefs home empty handed.

"The government has nothing concrete to say," Martin told The Canadian Press. "They wasted six years."

The joint statement between Harper and the chiefs released Tuesday committed to a task force on economic development and a working group on the structure of government financing of First Nations.

It also committed to reviewing a report on education, as well as processes to improve governance and the implementation of treaties.

But all that work has already been done many times over, Martin said.

"All of this preliminary work that they're now talking about doing has been done. It's there. It's on the record."

Martin, who is now 73, and aboriginal leaders negotiated a pact in 2005 that would have pumped $5-billion over five years into native health care, education, housing and clean water. The Kelowna Accord was shelved by Stephen Harper soon after his Conservative government defeated the Martin-led Liberals six years ago this week.

With no clear time lines or goals included for the processes they've set up, Martin says his successor is proving the Conservative government "has no sense of urgency."

At the very least, the government should have committed to ending discrimination in education funding for First Nations children, he added.

"How difficult is it for a government to say 'we're going to end discrimination'," Martin said.

The Prime Minister's Office was asked for reaction to Martin's remarks and declined to offer any comment.

First Nations have long complained that money spent on education per student is several thousand dollars less for on-reserve children than for children just a kilometre away off-reserve.

In court, the federal government has argued that it's not fair to compare provincial funding of off-reserve schools to federal funding of on-reserve schools.

Equal funding would likely cost the government billions. But money is no excuse for discrimination, Martin said.

"Are they going to eliminate the deficit on the backs of six-year-olds who can't read?" he said. "There is no doubt that you're not going to get economic development unless you have an education."

The federal government has a moral obligation to make sure each child is funded equally, he added.

"There is no moral argument stronger than condemning an act of discrimination against the most vulnerable in your society," he said.

Martin remains involved in First Nations affairs, heading up a foundation that invests in aboriginal education and entrepreneurship. He is flabbergasted by the emphasis Harper is putting on "building a relationship" with First Nations, saying the Conservatives have had six years to do that and "it's unbelievable" that they seem to be starting from the beginning only now.

"If you need to establish a relationship, go to a reserve and read to a six-year-old," Martin said. "Set up a literacy program."

Harper has made a point of doing things differently than Martin. Upon taking office six years ago, the Conservatives let the Kelowna Accord sink unfunded, and dismissed it as flimsy -- despite 18 months of negotiations with First Nations, Inuit, Metis and the provinces.

Harper has also stressed that he prefers an incremental approach that takes small, practical steps rather than the comprehensive approach favoured by his predecessor.

But Martin says the Kelowna Accord was not his idea. Rather, it was the collective idea of aboriginal groups who set their own agenda and brought it to him.

"The reason it's the best approach is because the government didn't dictate it."

Martin says Harper, by contrast, is imposing his own will and ways upon First Nations -- an approach the former prime minister insists won't produce results.

Still, Martin has nothing but praise for the Assembly of First Nations for entering into talks with the Harper government while pushing for fundamental changes.

They can't give up now, though, Martin added.

"Their next step is to hold the government accountable."

Harper needs to demonstrate his commitment in the upcoming budget, Martin said.

Sources suggest the budget may contain something for First Nations education, perhaps a pilot project. But as yet, there is no plan in place for how the government wants to handle education reform and the budget is fast approaching.

First Nations leaders are also desperate for more funding for housing, health care and child welfare services. The recent housing crisis in Attawapiskat, Ont., and on the Ontario side of James Bay, are examples of raging poverty and substandard housing conditions undercutting reserves in many areas, they say.

Some chiefs have threatened retaliation if Harper allows those conditions to persist.

But Martin believes First Nations communities won't let the summit's lack of concrete action get them down.

"I believe that in the First Nations right across the country, there is an enormous amount of hope, a huge amount of hope for their children," he said. "What they're looking for is for Canada and Canadians to respond to that. The Canadian people have to get behind them."

Comments are now closed for this story

Joan in Real World
said

Instead of fasly stating that Martin and the Liberals did nothing for the First Nations, read up on recent history. --- Under Martin, the Liberals instigated the Kelowna Accord, a series of agreements between the Feds, the provinces, the Territories and First Nations to improve employment, education and housing... First Nations applauded the accord. The Liberals were defeated and Harper scrapped the accord.... and replaced it with nothing.


saab
said

It is unfortunate that some 25% Canadians have voted Harper Conservatives in , and one wonder why would Harper respect First Nation, when he has no respect for rest of the Canadians. We all know that Harper has no respect for Canada e.g. contempt of Parliament issue was not "Liberal vs. Conservatives". Proroguing the House twice so that Harper and his cabinet dodge accountability. We seem to forget that the for all practical purposes the conservative were collapsed and the party was dead, however, Reformers borrowed the "Conservative" name. and remember one of the reformers was Harper who hated the guts of all conservatives. Reformers were also a dissident regional group similar to Bloc. Both of these regional parties were the result of incompetency of Mulroney Government


geebee
said

Mr. Martin was clearly embarrassed in the '05 election when the water conditions on the Kashechewan reserve in Northern Ontario became front page news. Clearly Mr. Martin had not visited that reserve or others! Mr. Martin had to send in DART to provide safe drinking water provided by a facility...funded by the Liberal government of the day! Mr. Martin....never mind the smug smile sir...when you point the finger, look where the other three are aimed!


John Lethbridge
said

Martin suggesting that the First Nations need to hold the government accountable...? I agree on the accountability problem, just never looked at it that way. Also, is Martin dumb enough to suggest Harper has not been on a reserve? Harper was even named Honourary Chief by the Blood Tribe last year, the second ever sitting prime minister to be named chief. He was also the PM that, on behalf of Parliament and Canadians, offered up unequivocal apology for the resident school fiasco. Martin has done not much more than commit a lot of $ to this problem, which history is demonstrating, was and is not the answer. I suppose that the Liberal model for this kind of event would be to end with a photo-up announcement of some staggering amount of money that was committed for some feel good cause, and Martin is frustrated that he didn't see that. Two things: Martin has failed on this file, and, he continues to believe in a Liberal money spending agenda and is doing 'nothing to mask his frustration' when Harper won't go along with that agenda. Martin was an alright Minister of Finance, but threw that away when he became a money blowing/vote buying and othewise mostly lousy PM.


Realist
said

I am a big believer in the expression "give a man a fish, and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he will eat everyday" Under this expression, PM Harper is doing the right thing. Native affairs ARE NOT a new issue. This has been in the commons for a very long time, and the so called solution in the past has simply been, give them more money. Obviously that hasn't worked as it is still a problem. I have lived on a reserve for 2 years and in the Native's defense, the homes were in pretty rough shape. HOWEVER, Every house had a brand new Ford F-150 in the driveway, A brand new Snowmobile, a satelite, and state of the art electronics inside the house. The government has been more than generous in its hand outs to the Natives, it is the squandring of those funds that creeates issues like what we have. Education is the key, and people need to realize that in order for a strong positive change to occur, It will take an absolute minimum of 2 generations. Steps are being made long term, and vision the end result is what we really need to look at.


AlbertaM
said

you make it sound like a Canadian individual or group doesn't have entitlement to anything unless they make their contributions to the country itself. the government itself is doing what it can i understand but still they should at least go to the communities not just reserves too to check on their status to see where they stand.


Bob,Calgary,Alberta
said

I really don't see how Paul Martin has any street cred on this file. When he was Prime Minister his answer to every problem was to throw money at it without any thought to accountability or management. I suspect that Martin's comments are primarily his ego talking. He was an abysmal failure as a Prime Minister and would not have helped aboriginals except for pouring money down the bottomless pit of First Nations demands. While Harper has not met with FN's previously there were a lot of other major problems he had to deal with in his time in office. At least now he is addressing the issue and,as is his way, he will take a measured,incremental approach to solutions. Harper is not a man of the grand gesture which differs from the approach of previous Liberal governments who generated a lot of publicity but solved very little.


Rob
said

Wow Paul, you and Jean really did a great job with reserves for the 15 years you were in power. As I recall reserves were prosperous, safe, stable, alcohol and drug abuse were unheard of. Its amazing how bad things have become in such a short time since the Conservatives have come to power. Really???? We all know the truth, reserves have always been bad, should never have been created, should be abolished, and the Liberals should stop crowing since all they did was cover things up with cash for many many many years. Remember Loubocon Lake??? Born with a tooth? Assumption, Alberta???? Hobema????? Where were you then Paul? huh... Where were ya???


Go Figure - Ontario
said

Why doesn't Paul Martin butt out - he still has nothing concrete to say, but then, does a fingerprint change??? Did he ever to anything concrete to help the native cause, except to talk about it???? Perhaps he can go and spend time on one of his ships with the income tax that he is not paying because of his Cayman Island monetary hideaway.


Courtenay
said

What did you do Mr. Martin when you were in office. The Liberals had an opportunity to make life better for the Aboriginal people for how many years? You don't have the moral authority to criticize what is now being done.


Tim
said

Paul Martin, just like you and I (everyone in fact), has the same right to freedom of expression. Yet some people strongly felt that they have more right than other by telling other they can't or shouldn't express their thoughts.


TrueNorth
said

When I want the advice of a failed Prime Minister, I'll ask Joe Clark.


stephen d. belding
said

to the canadian government: you have a responsability for accountability because your the voice for the people.. first: its time to do away with reserves...second: its time to treat everyone as equals ....thirdly: now - - how did the First Nations people get here before God?????? Please explain this so we all can understand where your all coming from on this issue. First Nation people who gave you the land and where did your people pay the land taxes too???? As far as the crown goes....... Please explain to all of us how the land became yours???? If these questions were answered they would solve a mountain of problems.. This seems like a joke to find out the right answer because no one and I mean no one has the BALLS to step up to the plate and settle this issue once and for all.......


Henry
said

We have seen the liberal solution for years, throw them more money to shut them up and change nothing!

Take a close look at his right hand to see what he really thinks.


franck commonsens
said

The biggest enemy of the First nation people is their own leadership. They are the one who gets the money handed by the Canadian government, waste it and keep them in that state of continual beggars instead of making them self sufficient.(last 90 millions is a great example)Clean up your own house by yourselves FIRST.


Dorothy
said

There are a lot of negative comments here about Paul Martin and 'what good did he ever do' kind of attitude. Well for one, when he was Finance Minister he established many of the banking regulations in Canada that prevented us from going into the same bank melt down that impacted the US in 2008. The Conservatives like to take credit for it, but Mr. Martin was instrumental setting our banking regulations. Also, I find it appalling that Stephen Harper has been Prime Minister for 6 years and is just getting around to meeting Assembly of Nations chiefs now. As stated in the article, the studies have been done. Our First Nations people don't need another 6 years wasted on studies. It is just a stalling tactic of Mr Harper so he really won't have to do anything towards a solution


Stewie
said

Harper's meeting was just a photo opt spinning wheels and doing nothing. Thank goodness for Paul's good management or our country would be in the same shape as the US. Thank you Paul for not letting Harper deregulate our banks. One thing we can guarantee is next election Harper will be kicked to the curb he was only voted in by 25% of eligible voters in the last elections. Canadians are embarrassed to have Harper as PM next election the 40% that didn't vote will be out to get rid of has been Harper we can't afford his tax & spend policies. Soon we'll be back to good liberal management.


FedUp
said

@First Nation(s) That's it, blame the government instead of taking charge and cleaning up internally. It's soooo easy to quickly blame others isn't it? To help you, you first have to help yourselves.


More money
said

It is not more money "reserves" need. There are a lot of First Nations people, Metis, Inuit, who work for their food on their tables. This stereotype of looking for a hand out is so narrow minded. A man from another country figured that out on his own when he came to Canada that First Nations are just singled out.
I live in a city and I had visitors to come interview me about an "Aboriginal" program. My yard is clean and well kept, sad to say next door wasn't, and they were not First Nations people or Metis or Inuit. Guess which place they went to first?


Larry in winnipeg
said

This is not a situation that will be resolved by simply writing cheques. That is the easy, cowardly way to deal with it, but it only defers and further complicates the problem. I believe the answer lies in economic development. If you consider the tax advantages of operating business on reserves, the natural resources (forestry, minerals, fishing, water power,etc) available, the demand for services (transportation, construction, recreation, health care, education) in these areas and the unemployment, it takes a pretty unimaginative group (and I include first Nations leaders as well as past governments) to come up with just writing cheques as a solution. That solution just means you will solve all those issues again in another generation. lets get a national First Nations economic development plan going. Lets make sure the First nations children can look forward to everything the rest of Canada takes for granted - financial independence, home ownership, a safe environment, participation, good health care. They don't need the government to look after them - they need the government and their leadership to put together an intelligent plan to change conditions for good !


Brian Fr Langley
said

When he was thePM Martin did try to get some things done through the Kelowna conferences. Just another Politician who thinks the more dollars we throw at a problem the better the cure. Canadians need to realize our aboriginal issue are systemic and are deeply rooted in the racist white mans burden Indian act of generations ago. WHY are our aboriginal peoples the only folks in Canada who can not own their own homes on their ancestral (reserve) lands? They are wholly dependant on band Council's for housing. Not only an invitation for corruption, but we as a nation do not believe in collectivization for ourselves, so why do we perpetrate it on our aboriginals. Nothing will change (nor can it) until folks on 1st Nations can own title to their own homes and businesses. Title that is transferable and inheritable. NOT 99 year leases, FULL TITLE. All Band council's need to be responsible for is appropiate zoning.


CJ
said

Same old talk and blame you all should all be a shame of yourselves. There is no progress being made here. The First Nation wants change for their people and it"s about time the Canadian Government got going on this matter. Not Liberal, PC or NDP. For their future and Canada"s future their needs to be change. Long over due


Len
said

There are two sides to every story. To the Thunder Bay writer - maybe you feel that way about a party but that leader did have an accord, signed and sealed, and Harper cancelled it forthright. In that accord they were going to provide teachers, better living conditions, along with money to help them. This was mainly for western First Nation tribes. That was intended and agreed by both sides that these First Nation assemblies could not come back looking for more. To others, whether we feel that these people have been given too much money or whatever theytoo often live in conditions that we wouldn't care to live in. Much of this is due to poor education and educational opportunities. Therefore, to his credit, Martin is correct in saying that Harper should not just talk the talk but also 'walk the walk' and go to visit some of these reserves to see first hand what is happening. Harper is too insensitive to the issues before him.


FIRSTNATIONS
said

DCI just a thought we are the First Band across Canada to graduate a 4 year B.Ed. on reserve and start a on reserve a Masters program we have produced teachers however this so called government has not put any federal funding into the program. Your just like the government now putting bandaid solutions on real problems! Wake up your stuck in the past with your stupid comments about the elders and chiefs let me tell you they have way more wisdom then you will ever have. They still carry the words of our leaders that signed the treaties what do you have nothing just sit back and listen your opinion has nothing because they never agreed anything with you it was your government!


Alta Girl
said

If children just one kilometer are getting thousands more for funding, then drive or walk your child one kilometer and put them in that school. There are such things as car pools and school buses.The problem with having a beautiful school on the reserve is staffing it. Where are the educated natives? When you do get a teacher, it is an uphill battle to teach children who are not well rested or well fed when they come to school. Or worse, suffering from neglect or abuse. Their families often do not support the childs efforts at getting an education. It would be nice If people like Paul Martin paid their fair share of tax instead of collecting a bloated pension, but really, throwing good money after bad will not solve this problem. I think Stephen Harper is right, solve it incrementally and let people have time to adjust. I congratulate him for trying to find a solution when it has clearly eluded the Liberals entirely. If they have any suggestions, other than 'throw more money' it would be nice to hear them as this issue will take a lot of thought and co-operation to solve.


Remarkable
said

Yeah, Martin is right the PM should go to a reserve. But if and when he does go to a reserve, don't be like the Liberals where it was nothing more than a photo op and a bunch of empty promises, actually meet with the people (not the hierarchy of the bunch) and listen to their concerns. However on a national level just going to a reserve is not going to solve the problems, they are unique and sensative to each different region across this enormous, gigantic, beautiful country.


Mark
said

Mark to reserve chiefs and councils: Open up your books and show us where the government funds are going and being spent on!


Marisha
said

One comment after another is showing just how furious the average taxpayer is about this whole situation.

Why isn't the government holding hearings/meetings inviting the average taxpayer for their input? After all it is taxpayer's money that is being spent on this fiasco.

Meetings for taxpayer input aren't being held because because the government doesnt want to open that can of worms as well.

If this is a Canadian problem that is going to take more Canadian Tax dollars to fix, then EVERY Canadian should have input on a solution!!!!

Marisha




Wes Sask.
said

How hypocritical, the Liberals were in government for many years yet did very little.


jen
said

In my opinion the bands have received over the years way too much government funding with nothing much to show for it other than some of the chiefs and their relatives benefiting. It is time for the government to abolish the Indian Act as there are few real Indians left and tax payers money is being totally wasted. Harper would not benefit by visiting the reserves he should visit the homes of the chiefs and their relatives to see their lifestyle then everyone would know where all the government funding went to over the years. I for one as a taxpayer am sick and tired of hearing how they live in unsanitary conditions. This is the lifestyle they chose and if your reserve cannot be self-sufficient why are you still there. Move where there are jobs and go to work everyday like everyone else and that way you'll be self-sufficient. Life is what you make of it for yourself don't rely on your chiefs majority of them only think of themselves.


FIRSTNATION
said

I have question to "taxpayer unfortunately you weren't here from the beginning and the first on this land so what doesn;'t make sense is that you should keep your 2 cents and save instead of wasting your time venting out your poor uneducated thoughts!


Will
said

iam: like so many of the liberal faithfull, you fail to understand the difference between doing the right thing and doing what is right. Please learn the difference, it is profound.


Pay Canadian Tax Boy
said

Martin did nothing in his days but live off of Mulroneys GST


steve
said

Paul Martin is exactly right on this matter. The cons scuttled the kelowna accord and have the nerve to lie about it. Paul Martin is a financial genius and Harpo cannot even carry his Jockstrap.


Michael from Toronto
said

With all due respect to Mr. Martin, these issues with regards to the reserves are NOT high level issues to do with the PMO. Perennial problems with the reserves have to do with their own dysfunctional administration and corruption within the reserves, they insist on retaining sovereignty but then hold us responsible for their mistakes. For effective manager authority and responsible should both align but they don't with regard to the reserves. Federal authorities that should deal with such matters are at the ministry level. If the PMO gets involved it becomes political and the authorities of the ministries will get overridden and we get conflict between civil servants and the PMO. This is a matter for civil servants to deal with. The problems lie within the reserves.


Anne
said

Hold the government accountable?? Discrimination? How about accountability for excessive funds already received hmm? And, they get free education for college and university, EVERYTHING paid for, right down to daycare - the rest of us in Canada have to fend for ourselves. So don't throw discrimination around. And by the way, how is that the recent exposure of sexual abuse of girls and women across reserves has apparently been swept under the carpet??? Care to explain that? We all tiptoe around these Chiefs wringing our hands at things that happened 400 years ago and ignore the trajedy that is ongoing today?


Scott Ash
said

This is classless by Martin. Former president Bush does not criticize Obama stating : "Obama has enough critics and I'm not going to be one of them" so congrats Martin, you have less class than W. Bush


Austin W in Saskatoon
said

Good job CTV.. way to cover the important issues. Why would you give this pompous, old, blowhard any media coverage other than to remind Canadians of the brutal Liberal reign and incite anger? Or maybe that's what you wanted to do? That's being objective. I may as well start getting my news from TMZ...


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Typical Liberal rhetoric, sour grapes, and partisan political grandstanding. Shawn Atleo, National Chief of the Assembly of First Nations, has publicly hailed the summit as a success. The icing on the cake here is Mr. Martin indicating that the farcical "Kelowna Accord" wasn't his idea; rather, it expressed the wishes of our First Nations people. Bingo. And therein rests one of the fundamental problems with it: a handout of more money to please and appease, thus, not solving the structural governmental issues that perpetuate the inherent dysfunctional nature of the relationship. Thanks, Mr. Dithers. (P.S. Perhaps one day you'll explain to us why Attawapiskat never got its school during your Liberal tenure, especially as PM.)


MAE in Ontario
said

Talk is cheap mr. Martin. In all the years that you and your cronies were in power you did nothing. I am sick of the media dragging this guy up for his opinion. No one cares what Paul Martin thinks. Did any one of you hot shot reporters think this guy would praise the Conservatives.


roy
said

or just dump more millions of dollars at the problem like the Liberals, Mr. Martin you ran your ship let Mr. Harper run his.


ian
said

i would have to ask mr martin why his liberal party who had a majority for so long never solved the problems, these problems on the reserves didnt just happen over night on harpers watch, martins solution was to dump more taxpayer money on to reserves, this guy is one of the biggest hypocrites around in my mind


James, Ontario
said

Paul Martin has used up his respect. This wind back flaps his yap again and sticks his nose into political issues in which he has no business. Again I remind you all, this is a problem that Paul Martin left behind.


mchief@hotmail.com
said

well its a slow process but yeah Harper government is doing its way rather then take a deeper approach into the issue instead of visiting the reserves and see first hand whats it like. i think the government is just checking on the situation rather then stepping in and look. they set up meetings outside of the reserves in the city too. its like sort of dusting off the issue and putting it back on the shelf to sit.


M.Thunder Bay
said

Canada to Martin: Shut Up! You and your party are has-beens.


DCI
said

Paul martin says that the Canadian people must get behind this matter. No. The first nations people must get behind themselves...Get teachers on the reserves. The elders and chiefs haveto get off their asses and get moving. Stop blaming everyoner else for their problems. The first nations have millions of dollars. Start taking care of your own people. And stop living in luxury, when your children and people on the reserves are going without. Stop all the handouts from the government and our taxes. The first nations must now start to be accountable for themselves. They have had years to clean up this mess. And did nothing. Now is the right time. If young people want to leave the reserve, then the elders and chiefs should make sure they are taken care of.They have a lot of work to do. But it can be done.


Dave
said

I would like to know what Martin did when he was PM, it is always easy to sit on the sidelines and mouth off.


Mike in ON
said

Can someone please suggest to me why Paul Martin's opinions should matter? It's pretty obvious how bad the state of affairs is within the Liberal party when they keep having to dig up their retired fossils just to bash the government. You had your day, Paul. Seems to me that you didn't accomplish anything particularly notable yourself.


jrayj
said

Wow, who in their right mind would listen to this guy, the liberals will say just about anything to discredit Harper, and what Martin dose not know is the natives them self's are their own worst enemy, they have one and only one mind set and that is free money and they do not want to have to do anything for it. We do not need to re= write the Indian act, we need to scrap it, it simply dose not work in today's world and never will.


middleroad
said

I have to agree with Paul Martin on this one!


Ernie Hushard
said

Messrs Martin and Chretian remind me of what Douglas MacArthur once said " old soldiers nevr die they just fade away". Perhaps it's time Martin did just that.. We gave the natives self governmentand a pile of tax dollars and they have clearly demonstrated that they have no idea of how to integrate both elements. They also refuse to accept any assistance in this respect. Time this laissez faire approach to our natives ceased unless they are prepared to work within our system and realize that they do not own this Canada of ours


Katie
said

Sub standard housing, raging poverty, lack of educational opportunities and minimal health care are obviously present in Canada's Aboriginal communities. We, as Canadian citizens, need to wake up and realize that we need look no further than our own borders to find people in dire need of assistance. While it is right for us to assist other countries and peoples in need, we should be helping those in similar situations right here in Canada. If, as it seems, all the background work has been done why is the Harper government dragging their heels.? I just realized I may have answered my own question. It is the Harper Government not the Conservative Government. It is driven by Mr. Harper's wishes and right now the Aboriginal people do not hold a prominent place on his personal agenda.


Anthony
said

It is extremely hypocritical for former PM Martin to criticize the Conservative gov.'t when his Liberals have ruled Canada for over 85% of the time since Confederation; they've had more than enough time to get a handle on native poverty and education; until the First Nations accept full and audited accountability for how they spend the approx. $10 Billion dollars they receive on an annual basis from the Feds, we the majority of Canadians say Bravo to our PM Harper for staying the course, and implementing incremental change through pilot projects that have worked wonders in improving the lives of natives in communities across Canada, since 2006; as for Mr. Martin, I would invite you sir to pay your full share of taxes by registering your Canada Steamship Lines in Canada rather than the Caribbean; the add'l monies could be used to improve the educational lives of our Native people.


Ian Ottawa
said

Hey aren't you the guy who used to be a Prime Minister? Yeah, you belonged to that Party that did nothing for Canadians except steal money, ( I'm pretty sure you were the Finance Minister that said he knew nothing about syphoned funds.) Isn't your old Party broke even after the inside trading that was swept under the table? Wow it seems like only yesterday you and your Party were doing nothing for the Indians. Or anyone else for that matter. The Pot shouldn't be calling the Kettle Black. Hey Paul, when is your Party voting in a leader? Afraid choosing one now would show that you don't have any?


Sober
said

Didn't he his time to do something about the situation? I am sure things did not start going the wrong way on Harper's watch.


Mike in Pembroke
said

Topical Liberal solution, take money from the reserve or CPP or IE to balance the books. When I was growing up that was called robbing Peter to pay Paul. Do not touch the reserve and find a way out of this problem with out robbing money that is put away for other things. Please Mr. Harper do not listen to Martin and steal from the Canadian youths future like the Liberals did.


Tom out west
said

And this explains perfectly why the Liberals are on the decline. The native bands in this country can pony up and show us accountability for what they get first. With Martin as PM the typical Liberal response is to shovel more money at them no questions asked. Time to ask question first before shooting money out the window. 400 chiefs and 1 PM is face time???


Trish
said

I Too am very disappointed in this Summit outcome. I am embarrassed that our current PM does not act to ensure that all Canadians have the same rights to the basics of education, safe clean water, proper housing and quality of life. There were too many delays in getting to this date and then nothing was accomplished. This should have been treated as the emergency that it is by our PM. Much change is needed as outlined by the First Nations, and Sheila Fraser. This Summit should have taken place on a Native Reserve, or at least there should have been visits, prior to, by the PM.


Gumpy
said

Isn't this amazing. One of the most ineffective prime ministers in our history and yet everything he says to the media is gospel. Of course he can agree with everything First Nations need and want, he has nothing to lose. But let's give him a headline because as far as the media is concerned their bias against the Conservatives is getting more and more blatant. What use to be an amazing news source is showing a greater and greater loss of integrity. I miss what CTV was and could be. Please, go back to unbiased reporting, report the actual facts and leave the propaganda out. We have enough issues without you building more.


GRK from Oakville, ON
said

Martin was a sorry excuse for a PM. He and his party have nothing to offer Canada. He should keep quite, and let our elected PM do his job, instead of trying to offer up any advice.


Seeking Wolf
said

Oh be quiet Martin, you have nothing to contribute now, as you had nothing to contribute as PM. Your term as PM and in finance was marked with inaction in everything, stealing from public funds to make yourself look good to the party faithfull, and a typical liberal arrogance that disgusts. Just go away.


d
said

whatever Paul!! you had the chance to help when in office and you didn't!!!


Jeremy
said

AMEN, if Harper would come off his throne for a second and go see the problem for himself. My god, even the minister of Aboriginal Affairs won't go up there. What is wrong with these guys especially the minister, are they afraid to lead, or do they just not now how to without bullying, or intimidating people.


URU
said

Mr Martin is well informed and educated not like Harper. The money and time spent on studying will cost more than it will fix the problems. Go there directly and fix the problems instead of hiring outside people to study what they don't know about the real needs for the First Nation People! If a Priminister needs to be told on how to do their job than we're in big S......!


David
said

Mr Martin, keep your opinions to yourself. You had your chance in office. lets stop throwing good money after bad.


David
said

"Are they going to eliminate the deficit on the backs of six-year-olds who can't read?" -Wake up, even if they could read natives dont pay taxes. Cut all funding to the natives now!


George V.
said

Why didn't Paul Martin Mr. Dithers implement the Kelowna Accord when he was in power. This is typical Liberal rhetoric just like the Kyoto Accord they have all the ideas, no implementation, We can make the snowballs, you will have to fire them. It is easy to be an arm-chair quarterback sitting along the sideline, every unsucessfull play you would have done differently, taking credit as in my idea for all the sucessfull ones. How many days did he spend in indian reservations, he was too busy funneling his money off shore, and registering his ships in other foreign countries. Paul your a has-been, people pay little attention to what you have to say now. Your ideas and suggestions should have been made when you had the chance. The parade has passed you by.


john in Edmonton
said

Paul Who? Oh, right...the former PM who did so much to advance the cause of Aboriginal Rights and improve the situation on the Reserves. Hello, Pot? This is kettle...Hey Paul - you're irrelevant. And retired. Shouldn't you be playing shuffleboard somewhere?


haorbed
said

I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Right Honourable Paul Martin. However I disagree with his compassionate statement. The problem does not lie in insufficient funding but rather in lack of accountability and responsibility on the part of the First Nations. In Canada most recently there were 22 Chiefs who used Federal funding to pay themselves salaries in excess of what the Prime Minister is paid. In addition there are 116 Chiefs who pay themselves more then what a Provincial Minister earns. In Attawapiskat alone there are 18 Councillors for a settlement of 2000 people. Buildings are erected, homes are built and then are neglected and abused. What the news did not show in Attawapiskat was that there is a full service hospital, a school, a huge Northern Store, a brand new indoor arena with a recently purchased Zamboni, an Inn, an abandoned Healing Lodge which has now been renovated, a water treatment plant, street lights, and airstrip and small airport building and the list goes on. Yes while it is true that food cost more factor in what your cost of living would be if you had no rent to pay? What if every year the Fed's gave YOU 9000.00 per person in your family? You could throw billions into the system and nothing would change because attitude and self entitlements would remain the same. So what is happening? You have an appointed by election council and Chief. They are responsible for millions in funding yet have no training in management or self governance though I believe that was attempted. Teaching someone what is the right thing to do doesn't mean they will do it. and that is irregardless of culture, seriously look at your own non Native town council.


Frances P
said

The only way out off poverty is education. Parents must be involved with their children's education the teachers are already overwhelmed with a classroom of over 30 students per classroom. I am not a teacher but I know that is what is happening in the schools in most off the reserves. The foundation off a well rounded individual begins at home.


Frank Buchan
said

Why is it the media plays to so many former useless politicians? Regardless of political stripe, this has-been's only actual claim to fame is downloading on provinces and robbing the EI fund, amongst other transparent attempts to appear to have done something. During his tenure in government, exactly what was done for the First Nations people? Nothing. So where does he qualify to comment beyond the words, "See my smug grin? I can say whatever I like now, since I did nothing, made the problem worse, and can bash from the sidelines without fear of pension being affected."Note: I'm not even supporting the current government's continued inaction here, just observing we don't need commentary from failures like Paul Martin.


Ottawa Jack
said

Why is a telephone call with Martin making HeadLine news? Nothing but criticizm of a Conservatiov government would be expected from a former Liberal FM.


Stella in Toronto
said

Martin needs to shut his mouth,


SadbutTrue
said

Seriously Chiefs, have you not learned anything over the past 200 years? I'm sorry to say, it's never going to change.


JPC near Regina
said

Paul, please shut up and go away...you did nothing for aboriginal people...


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   5 Comments 5    1 Video(s) 1

Canada's Ryder Hesjedal holds the trophy after winning the 95th Giro d'Italia, Tour of Italy cycling race, in Milan, Italy, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (AP / Fabio Ferrari)

Hesjedal becomes first Canadian to win Giro d'Italia

More   23 Comments 23    8 Video(s) 8

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10