Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Two people wearing earphones cross a street in New York, Thursday, Feb. 8, 2007. (AP / Peter Morgan) Ottawa police are warning residents to not display personal electronic devices Wednesday, Dec. 14, 2011.

Accidents involving headphone-wearing pedestrians on the rise

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Toronto: Music for ears can mean dangers on road
People who walk around the city wearing headphones and listening to music can tune out of the surrounding traffic. Dana Levenson reports.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (21) Facebook   

Two people wearing earphones cross a street in New York, Thursday, Feb. 8, 2007. (AP / Peter Morgan) Ottawa police are warning residents to not display personal electronic devices Wednesday, Dec. 14, 2011.

Photos

Two people wearing earphones cross a street in New York, Thursday, Feb. 8, 2007. (AP / Peter Morgan)

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Jan. 17 2012 8:55 AM ET

A new U.S. study looking at pedestrians who were killed or injured while wearing headphones finds that the incidents appear to be on the rise.

The study's lead author, Dr. Richard Lichenstein, says he began the research after hearing of a local teen who died while crossing railroad tracks. The teen was wearing headphones and didn't hear the oncoming train, even though it blasted its horn before hitting the boy.

"As a pediatric emergency physician and someone interested in safety and prevention, I saw this as an opportunity to -- at minimum -- alert parents of teens and young adults of the potential risk of wearing headphones where moving vehicles are present," Lichenstein said in a news release.

So Lichenstein, the director of pediatric emergency medicine at the University of Maryland Medical Center, gathered colleagues at the University of Maryland to search for reports of accidents involving people wearing headphones.

The team searched databases such as the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, as well as media reports in Google News Archives, looking for accidents between 2004 and 2011.

They found 116 reports of death or injury of pedestrians wearing headphones. Of them, 81 were fatal.

The majority of victims were male under the age of 30, and almost nine out of 10 cases were in urban areas.

A full 55 per cent of the accidents involved trains, and almost three in 10 cases mentioned that the trains or cars involved in the crashes blew their horns but were not heard.

The researchers found that during the seven-year study period, the number of such cases tripled – a finding that worries them and bears further study, they said, particularly since the use of cellphones and MP3 players is increasing.

"The risks posed in use of these devices by drivers are well documented, but little is known about the association between headphone use and pedestrian injury," write the researchers in the journal Injury Prevention.

The researchers say there are a few reasons why headphones with handheld devices might pose a safety risk to pedestrians.

The first is that the devices can cause "inattentional blindness," meaning multiple stimuli divide the user's attention. The distraction is intensified by sensory deprivation, as the sounds coming through the earphones mask the sound of the train or car horns.

The researchers note there were a number of limitations to their study -- primarily that it relied heavily on media reports. Media outlets likely over-publish fatal events but tend not to run stories on non-fatal accidents, the authors note.

As well, the authors weren't able to distinguish how many of the accidents involved suicidal intentions, substance abuse or mental illness – all of which might have played a role in some of the incidents.

Comments are now closed for this story

geebee
said

Stands to reason....place a device that plays amplified music over your ears, crank up the volume, then venture into an environ where ignoring said environ can result in grievous bodily harm...you are courting disaster!


screaminguitar
said

Don says: Yes and let a car driver hit one of these wire people chances are the driver will be charged. This problem also happens with people riding bikes and headsets. I had a guy on a bike ride right through a red light and if my wife had not yelled to warn me I would have hit him and YES he was wearing earphones _____So, your wife had to tell you to watch out for a pedestrian? In what you describe, it sounds like neither you or said pedestrian were paying attention. Its a good thing your wife was.That said, there are way too many people lost in their own thoughts, blackberries, iphones, cellphones, mp3s, conversations while driving or whatever not paying attention. The "weren't you paying attention to what I'm doing" attitude is everywhere.


kg1
said

to merv: new or old the earbuds/phones are not actually the problem, its the volume of the music/program people are listening to, simple solution though...turn down the volume. people standing 3 down from you in a line up do not necessarily want to hear your music selection


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Pedestrian techno-zombies. Their natural plight is our societal concern? There ought to be a law? (Don't think so. Let's move on.)


Dave from Toronto
said

Yup. I've seen it happen time and time again. Guys wearing headphones, earphones and talking on cellphones. They walk into other people, trip over things and seem to be immersed in their own little world.

I've seen sometone looking for an ATM walk by it three times while he was on the cellphone telling his girlfriend that he couldn't find the ATM???

It appears that male perception shuts down all other functions when it's listening or talking. Next, we will see accidents from being too preoccupied with chewing gum.


Sean
said

Just use a safer headphone option like Aftershokz which allow you to hear what's going on around you while still delivering your favorite tunes.


ocelot
said

There's a difference of listening to music but still being aware of things around you and listening to music and zoning out. When I listen to music while outside I always have it at a level I can still hear things happening around me. If anything I'm more aware of things around me because I make sure when I hear something that it's not something I have to deal with. I tend to make sure a crosswalks that if cars are coming that they'll slow down and stop (you never know when drivers aren't paying attention because they're listening to music in their car). There are times I want to be a bit more aware so I take off my headphones for awhile.I think it comes down to awareness, are you able to be aware of what is going on around you, with music playing in your ear? If you aren't able to be aware, you shouldn't be listening. When you are out in places with cars or bikes, you should be able to be aware of what is going on around you.


Felix
said

to SAMC u cant blame the manufacturer of the device there is something called VOLUME CONTROL therefore you cant blame the maker of the listening device. too often these ding dongs like to play their slim shady gangster wannabe rap for the world to hear as if anyone else visibly appreciates it...NOTu also have aside from those who play their music loudly u have ppl who wear their hats so low they cant see anything


Merv
said

New headphones/ear buds are amazingly loud, and great at sound insulation. That's the problem.


joe canada
said

I don't think it is the headphones alone. There are many deaf people getting along just fine. It is people just zoning out and not paying attention to their surroundings. This is called Darwinism.


Jaid in Toronto
said

If you're going to multitask, do it right.


Sam C
said

L Neil... I don't believe it is as simple as people wearing headphones "ignoring" those around them. Young people listening to their music, at rather high volumes, and staring at their devices (mp3, iPod, etc) aren't necessarily deliberately ignoring others. They are simply tuned-into that activity, and really do not hear what's going on around them. It is dangerous, and part of the blame lays with the manufacturers who make devices that do play as loudly as they do. Having said that, there is no reason to crank the volume as high as most do.


Gundula Baehre
said

There is an attitude in north America that pedestrians can do no wrong and that they always have the right of way while crossing the street etc. Unless pedestrians are made to shoulder some personal responsibility, that when they are out and about, they have to be as vigilant as the cars, other pedestrians etc., not much will change. But perhaps, one way to get the ball rolling would be to negate the "pedestrians always have the right of way" attitude and laws if said pedestrians are wearing headphones, listening to ipods etc. (another way would be to consider walking and talking, walking and texting, walking and listening to music the same as driving and texting etc., but that will likely never happen and probably should not happen either, as it would be a bit too much of a restriction of personal freedoms).


CYL
said

I see it all the time not just crossing the streets but on the public transit, everywhere. They get on the bus with ear phones and talking on their cell about nothing important, then realize they are on the wrong bus. The announcement tell the next stop but they don't hear it, but when time for them to come off and the bus doesn't stop they get mad at the driver. I see them crossing streets even on red without looking. If these people have their ears plugged all the time, then suffer the consequences. The ears are for listening, being aware of your surrounding at all times is a no brainer.


Chris
said

All I do when crossing the street for example is simply take out one or both earphones and look left and right, making sure I get to the other sidewalk safely. Or better off don't even bother listening to your music while you are out in the public.


Iris Mary Shestowsky
said

I so agree about technology making people more antisocial. Last week on Montreal's metro I saw two young teenage girls obviously friends, instead of yaking their heads off like teens do and having fun, they sat beside each other plugged in and zoned out. What about good old fashion dating, no go on line and pick a spouse.


Don
said

Yes and let a car driver hit one of these wire people chances are the driver will be charged. This problem also happens with people riding bikes and headsets. I had a guy on a bike ride right through a red light and if my wife had not yelled to warn me I would have hit him and YES he was wearing earphones.


Deighv
said

Interesting stats but one important statistics was left out. The article states that from 2004 to 2011 the accident rate "tripled". Thats easy to understand considering the number of people actually owning portable devices requiring headphones has FAR more than tripled in the same period, especially those owning MP3 players. Without a proper breakdown of the numbers one could say that deaths occuring to pedistrians using portable entertainment devices and wearing headphones have remained about the same or even lower than in 2004. I can't understand why this 7 year study didn't take the market-explosion of portable media devices during that same period into account. Using Their logic one could also say that between 1900 and 2001 the number of automobile accidents has increased dramatically. BTW, thats a fact and I didn't need a doctorate or 6 figure income to come to that conclusion :)


Ryan, Guelph
said

A first step... not surprising findings. I see people do stupid things when they're plugged in all the time. Hopefully they can do some solid research and people realize just how zoned out they really are, to the point of getting themselves killed.


L Neil
said

"Auditory masking of outside stimuli.".....love how this person makes " wearing earphones" sound so sophisticated and scientific....headphones ignoring life around you = pain/death....easy as that......


David H in Ottawa
said

Technology was supposed to make man smarter; we've become antisocial, lazy and perhaps even less intelligent. Put down the blackberries/iphones and talk to your neighbour, be it across the table or street.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Subscribe!

MedNews Express newsletter

CTV MedNews Express

Sign up for our weekly medical newsletter, delivered for free to your inbox.

CTV.ca Blogs

Dr. Marla Shapiro

Health Blog

Check out what our guest medical experts and CTV health reporters are writing about.

Twitter

Avis Favaro Twitter

Follow us on Twitter

Follow CTV medical specialist Avis Favaro on Twitter.

Facebook

Like us on Facebook!

Like us on Facebook

Stay connected to the latest health news while you're on Facebook with CTV MedNews

Today's Canada AM Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More   5 Comments 5    1 Video(s) 1

Canada's Ryder Hesjedal holds the trophy after winning the 95th Giro d'Italia, Tour of Italy cycling race, in Milan, Italy, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (AP / Fabio Ferrari)

Hesjedal becomes first Canadian to win Giro d'Italia

More   23 Comments 23    8 Video(s) 8

Labour Minister Lisa Raitt speaks in the House of Commons in Ottawa on Monday, May 28, 2012. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Federal government orders end to CP Rail strike

More   51 Comments 51    10 Video(s) 10