Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Ayat Manna appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Halifax, Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2010.

Muslim woman treated like 'terrorist' at U.S. customs

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Atlantic: Jacqueline Foster with the woman
While a Muslim woman hoping to travel to the U.S. waits to hear why she was denied entry, the head of an Islamic association is warning Muslims to prepare for problems at airports.
Canada AM: Ayat Manna, detained by U.S. customs
A woman who denied entry to the U.S. and held for four hours Monday in Halifax explains why she feels she was singled out by U.S. customs officials because of her head scarf.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (101) Facebook   

Ayat Manna appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Halifax, Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2010.

Photos

Ayat Manna appears on Canada AM from CTV studios in Halifax, Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Jan. 6 2010 9:34 AM ET

A Muslim woman who was held for questioning for more than four hours Monday at Halifax Stanfield International Airport is looking for answers.

Ayat Manna says she was made to feel like a terrorist while she was detained by U.S. border officials while trying to board a plane to Ohio to visit her husband.

She was eventually let go but was not allowed to board the flight entering the U.S.

Manna, who is originally from Jordan but has lived in Nova Scotia for the last 15 years, says she travels to the States often and has a valid Canadian passport. But on Monday, for reasons she still doesn't understand, a female U.S. border official picked her out of line and began questioning her.

"She asked me a couple of questions and I answered all of them: how long I'm staying in the States and why am I going there," the soft-spoken Manna recounted to Canada AM Wednesday from Halifax.

"After that, she took all my papers and passport and slammed it on the desk. She called security and she told them, 'Take her!' And I said, 'Why are you treating me that way? Why are you yelling? What did I do?' and she didn't say nothing."

Manna says she asked the border official whether she had singled her out because she was the only woman wearing a head scarf, but she received no answer. Instead, she was taken to a back room and questioned for four hours, including what she says were rude, personal inquiries.

When the border officials asked her questions she didn't understand and began to yell at her, Manna became confused and started to cry.

"It felt like I was a terrorist. That's exactly what it felt like," she says.

During the four hours of questioning, the officials asked for her bank account number and then called her bank to get all her financial information.

The officials took her photo and her fingerprints and eventually let her go, but Manna says she still doesn't understand why this happened to her.

"I asked them why, they just didn't answer... I'm still looking for answers why they did this," she says.

Manna says as she was being let go, she asked the officials what she would need to be able to enter the States.

"So they [said], 'You need to bring a bank statement, a doctor's note that you're not pregnant -- I don't know what that has to do with anything else -- and a note from your employer that you're coming back to work'," Manna says.

She says she was then escorted out of the airport.

"I stayed there until 9:30 p.m., and in the end, they called the RCMP on me for no reason and kicked me out," she says.

Manna says she went home and got all the information the U.S. officials had asked for and returned to the airport the next day, but they still refused to let her board a flight.

Canadian officials told Manna that the decision to refuse her entry was made by U.S. border officials, who have discretion about whom they allow into their country.

CTV News attempted to contact U.S. border officials for reaction to Manna's story but calls were not returned.

Comments are now closed for this story

Jim - North Saanich, BC
said

I suspect there were many reasons behind this incident, one being a display of conservative Muslim dress and the fact that all of the terrorist threats directed at the U.S., Canada and western European countries in the past decade have been from the more extreme factions of that persuasion.However, it can happen to anyone irrespective of their background. I'm a 70 years old, a still active business man who is a Canadian citizen today having lived here now for 43 years but am also a former US citizen. I surrendered my US citizenship inasmuch as I don't believe in dual nationality. I have no transgressions of the law save for two parking tickets in my life nor do any family members or business associates. I am clean-cut in appearance and married to a Canadian- born wife.I encountered virtually the same attitudes at the Vancouver Airport in April of last year, the issue being that I was a Canadian citizen but born in the US. I had even spent six years as an officer in the United States Air Force and was honorably discharged so I wasn't a draft dodger. I will never know what the reasons were for this and having chosen not to attempt another border crossing by air, I'm unlikely to ever know.Every Canadian will have to realize that this sort of thing can happen to any of us for whatever reason and whether it's outright stupidity by border personnel, namesakes deemed threats or simply random shows of muscle, it is the right of the United States to do so. My advice is that it can also happen to you for whatever reason so get used to a great deal more of it.


Ken, Toronto
said

Reading other poster's comments makes me angrier then the article itself. You choose to question the ladies motives more than to question the behaviour of the Border Patrol. While America needs to be on guard for any potential attacks, they need to also be accountable for their actions when dealing with people. All you people say 'it happens, deal with it' are sadly wrong to think this way. If you were pulled over by a police officer for no reason aside from maybe being a minority, you would question their motives as well. Passive aggressive rhetoric like that makes you seemed uninformed to the nature of the situation. I've flown almost 100,000 miles in the past 3 years and Border Patrol whether Canadian, American, British, etc always make you feel like you've done wrong and you believe I shouldn't question that? Honestly, its sad to see how many wingnuts there are on this board now. I'm going to be traveling to the US next month to visit my girlfriend and my only motive is going to visit the women I love and the women who loves me. I am going to assume that is all this women wanted to do and she was denied this opportunity because of overzealous guards. Lastly, all those with their Islamophobia, it should be known that the western races and their religions have historically been more terroristic than any other race of religion. Spreading god through force all over the world and yet you people seem to forget that and blame everything on Muslims. Shame on you. Take a look in the mirror and ask yourself why other races and religions hate the west and western religions.


Chris Eckel
said

It is disappointing to see how must comments support the profiling being done by U.S. agents. The comments make me see how easy it must have been to get the support of Canadians of the creation of Japanese internment camps to during the second world war. The individuals interned were of Japanese ancestory and many hadn't lived in Japan for years, but still they must have approved of Japanese actions. Many of the comments here support the profiling actions of the U.S. are at the top of the same slippery slope. I'd hope that we can do better than if she's Muslim, she must support or be a fanatic. I do agree though, the U.S. can do what they want, as it is there country, but I still don't support religious, country of origin or racial profiling.


Alysha Martenfeld
said

I go through this kind of crap all the time while traveling to the U.S. On one occasion I was crossing at Buffalo NY and it was late at night, all of the cars being pulled in for further inspection were carrying black families and people of eastern decent. While waiting for my papers to come back to me I witnessed the questioning of at least 50 people, the eastern people were asked a series of questions and the black people were physically searched, it was quite disgusting to say the least, watching 70 year old woman being patted down and emptying their pockets while many cars passed by outside carrying white passengers.


Melissa
said

To all of you that say that she should be speaking out against terrorism and not about what has happened to her I would just ask that you imagine for a minute that you are muslim. Everytime something happens, school shooting, bomb threat or hold up would you not hope and pray that the person responsible is not a muslim, because really the islamic extremists are doing more harm to the people who identify themselves as muslim than they are to those of us who are not. We as Westerners can play the victim card all we want but we are not the ONLY victims, and we are lucky because every time an extremist does something extreme we are not held accountable for it as if somehow we could have stopped it. These people who are orchestrating these 'terror plots' where not voted in by 'the people', and they are as much if not more of a threat to this women and every other islamic man and woman as they are to us as westerners. Why does she have to come out and say that what terrorists do is bad, that is a given. What is apparent by the posts here though is that the negative things we do to innocent muslims is wrong is not a givin and that is why she needs to speak out about it, so that you know that she is not a distant far away person that has nothing in common with you, she is your neighbor and a part of our community, someone we should be fighting for not against. In my opinion, the only way anything is going to change is if we get rid of this assumption that 'we' are entitled to something better than what 'they' are.


Patriotic Canadian!!!
said

For all the people that think this is racial profiling, I was picked out of a line of people(not my Lebanese husband) for extra checks. I am white and a woman. Not your typical terrorist! They stop whoever they want to stop and you should just stay calm and do your best. I never once tried to question the border official on why I was being stopped and searched! If you don't like the system, don't fly!


Russ
said

This is right on schedule for US Customs and Border Security. Let the Mass Hysteria begin where it always starts - with a paranoid Border Agent I would have been more surprised had an issue like this had not happened at some point. It gets me to thinking just how educated are the officials that decide who gets into the USA. For me personally, it is becoming more and more apparent that visiting the USA is less and less of a priority for me. I can spend my vacation dollars elsewhere. I don't need the hassle that come with travelling to the USA.Maybe that's what needs to happen. Less and less tourists to the USA. I'm wondering at what point in the future the US Dept of Tourism will be launching their "Visit the USA" marketing campaign due to the drastic fall in visitors AND they will be trying to figure out why the numbers have been falling.... It is absolutely amazing how the strongest country in the world seems to be in a a constant state of paralyzing fear on the Home front..


Matt
said

Twenty years ago I was held at U.S. customs in Vancouver on a trip to visit relatives in the U.S. . I was held for 3.5 hours and questioned, had my documents and luggage searched and even missed my flight. I complied and answered all questions as accurately as possible. Eventually I was allowed to get another flight to my destination. Did the media cover this story ? Ha Ha are you kidding.... Was I outraged ? No , because I know it is not my right to enter the U.S. as I am not a citizen of their country. The customs officials asked the right questions in her case and she obviously did not satisfy their concerns. Also, I am a white caucasian male and at that time was well dressed, well groomed and in good spirits.To this young woamn I say get over it....


Linda Cowan
said

Last year while traveling with with my cousin, her husband and their three children, we were taken aside by US customs. My cousin and her family are American citizens, I am a Canadian. We are white and middle aged, and not to sound arrogant but we are all decent looking people and well spoken. It doesn't always matter what your race is, or where you were born. We were detained for an hour and a half. This is what the terrorists have done to all decent people. I get tired of people always crying racism!


Rob
said

When our grandparents came to Canada they came here and excepted the way of life and fit in to society leaving some of thier traditions and grudges at home from where they came from. They tried to fit in and came here for a better way of life and they made it and survied and they did a great job. Thats part of the problem today some of them come here but are not willing to change. You can't have your cake and eat it to. They excpect us to change for them. Thats not the way it works.


Irritable Canadian
said

Oh well. Where's her outrage over what Muslims are doing worldwide when it comes to terrorism? Sorry lady. Tell your pals to quit flying planes into buildings and then maybe you won't get profiled.


Diane
said

While I don't think they handled the situation well, I agree that they have the right to refuse entry to anyone. Travelling to a foreign country is a privilege, not a right. Particularly since they may have had concerns she was trying to settle there illegally. We don't know the whole story.


Cam,Ontario
said

Stay away from the states unless you absolutely need to go.This is unacceptable to treat citizens of a neighbor who has bent over backwards to accommodate their irrational phobia since 9/11.They want to act like a-holes we should return the favor.Enough already!


LPattison
said

US Customs does not have to explain to Canadians why someone was denied entry. In fact, the situation may prompt investigation by our Customs officials when/if her husband returns from Ohio.Something in the pattern of their lives or some information not available to us triggered a denial.Just because we want to go to another country and have a passport does not guarantee that the officials of that country will allow us to pass.This is nothing new, though it feels new because of the security alerts.


Tom In T.O.
said

Why is this even a news story?? People get questioned at every airport in every country every day. Most don't call the media immediately afterwards crying racism.


Vancouver Girl
said

I have to agree with those who think she was denied entry b/c the US was concerned she was going to try and stay illegally. I'm a white female and on two occasions have been interrogated for more than an hour -- both times I came to the conclusion that's what they were concerned about. I think that's the difference, when I'm detained or pulled aside I'm annoyed but think the officers are doing their job. But if a darker skinned person is detained, then "OMG it's racial profiling"!!!!!


John Smith
said

Did all of you White Christians get together and have a meeting and decide to stand up to George Bush Junior when he decided to invade Iraq AGAIN to rape, kill, falsely imprison and displace millions of innocent Iraqis? Why not? You seem to think there's an underground secret way of communicating between 1.4 BILLION Muslims living in every single nation on earth. America is the biggest exporter or terrorism on earth and it's about time white "christians" stand up to the terrorists in their own community. Bunch of wingnuts.


paul
said

Absolutely disgusting is all I have to say about this American, who perhaps needs training in who to single out when someone is trying to enter that hell hole of a country. Perhaps if they knew how to do their jobs, the ones trying to inflict pain on them, would not get through. Disgusting Americans. Where is the Phelps family when you need them to make a point.


Amy
said

THE ONLY REASON THAT SHE GOT STOPPED WAS BECAUSE SHE IS MUSLIM. I have many Muslim friends and I see what they go through every day because of the plain fact that they are wearing a headscarf, which in my opinion is simply ridiculous. And Islam is NOT a radical religion, there are always bad eggs in the batch that ruin it for the rest. And the reason all this 'terrorism' is happening the western world is because we are stupid people that believe anything told to us through our extremely reliable media.Cheers.


Fishy stink to this story
said

The US boarder people owe nobody any answers as to why the pull sombody aside. Where does CTV get off thinking the public can "demand:" why they are pulled aside for further interrogation? If I were a border patrol I would be instantly alerted to a Muslim in line for good reasons and should I detain them that would be my choice and I owe no explanations. This young Muslim woman wants to try and create an issue which I gather is why the RCMP were needed to usher her out of the airport - it certainly wasnt because she was the model of social behaviour.


dc from Toronto
said

I listened to this interview this morning - the TV was in another room-- and couldn't help but notice her tone of voice - almost a beligerance to it. While I understand her frustration with this situation, if this same tone of voice came through in discussions with US officials at the airport, it certainly would not have helped her cause. As others have said, entry to the US is a priviledge not a right.


Melissa
said

I feel for her because there is no worse feeling in the world then being treated like your garbage and guilty of something when nothing can be further than the truth. Sure the US is paranoid right now, they go through their phases but at the end of the day asking this women for her banking info, a letter from her employer and a letter from her doctor is really ridculous. I myself have been profiled by the US before. I was crossing the border with a tour bus of 50 other people and asked to step off the bus and they kept me waiting and held up the bus for about an hour while they checked my previous travels. I was so embaressed when I got back on the bus that throughout my tour of NYC I kept thinking about it. To this day I'm scared to travel to the US because of how they treated me. This woman had it way worse than I did so thats why my sympathy goes out to her. Its easy to say they have to do what they have to do but when you're on the receiving end of this you can appreciate the fact that they're procedures for safety measures should not degrade someone and make them feel like a monster.


Who Knows?
said

Why do they live apart from each other? ...One in Ohio, and the other in Nova Scotia?This alone raises eyebrows.No explanation was given in the story. Perhaps there is a valid reason.On the other hand......Who knows?


ArmyDaughter
said

Should I feel bad for this woman? Sorry if Im not politicly correct, but I dont feel bad. Suck it up, and get over it!


Maria
said

My friend told me that he flew to the Carribean with a stopover in the US both ways. When he got back home, he realized he had forgotten to remove a box cutter from his carry-on back. 4 times he went through security checks including 2 times in the States, and 4 times it was missed. Would he have gotten in much trouble? Not likely. Blond, blue eyed, named Steve. So much for security checks though.


Citizen of Canada
said

I am a white male and just a few weeks ago on my way back from the USA i was pulled over, searched and asked questions. Guess what, it happens. If you have nothing to hide then who cares. It happens to many peeople, not only Muslims.


Cristina
said

A writer above commented "flying is not a human right". True, but being treated like a human being is. While the screen checkers have the right to turn people away, they must NOT abuse that power. Instead of acting like a firing squad such as in this case, how about concentrating on the basics required of them, and doing them well? The incident on Dec. 25 on Delta Airlines is a perfect example of not being able to perform those basic requirements.


James T Murphy
said

I stood in line and watched US security humiliate a white Canadian senior gentleman with a public partial strip search. I also watched 4 muslim young men pass through without issue.There's a big stink when it is a muslim and silence when it is not.


Steve
said

Once you present yourself to a Customs Officer, at a marked border crossing, Airport Terminal or Train Station. Your on US soil period. Border Guards are trained to spot little clues people give out during their questioning, Next time you go to the US, Try this and see what happens. When the guard asks you a question, pause before you answer, or don't look him or her in the eye when you reply to them. And see what happens next.The border guard probally picked up on something, and off she went for further questioning.And they have every right to refuse her entry to the USA, its their country....And for those of you who actually think racial profiling is not done in this day and age, look at ELAL Airlines THEY OPENLY ADMIT TO DOING THIS.. and they don't have 3 hour check in waits..


m@
said

To Mark in T.O.Your comments disturb me. Do you know how Nazi Germany started? Do some research and maybe you will come to understand that this sort if profiling is exactly what happend under Hitler's reich.


D. Ferguson
said

Canada Border Services and the young testosterone boys and girls they hire is still the worse in the world. They have been targetting young single women for a long time. I am a 57 year old Grandfather and do know we must get rid of Stephen Harper and Van Loan what they are doing to Canadians with expanding the young childish boys and girls on our border, while stripping away our freedoms is but a hint of what they will do to all of us, if ever elected with a majority! Please stop them!!


m@
said

Wow, that makes me so angry!The US is racial profiling now! What next????


todd
said

Who cares? Bring on profiling. It will save us all a lot of time when the border guards on both sides of the US and Canadian border start focusing on target groups. El Al does successfully. Auto scan everyone 100%. Any sovereign country has the right to refuse anyone entry.


Denise
said

I am a white female and never had any problem crossing the border, until I adopted my children. Both of my children happen to non white and guess what the first two times I tried to cross the border with them, we were pulled over. Despite all of our documents being fine, our car was searched completely we were delayed for hours with small children and treated very rudely. Now we do not bother to go to the U.S. it is just not worth the hassle. Even when we drive to visit family in Ontario we now take a bit longer and drive through Canada. The best way to deal with the U.S. bullying is to talk with our cash. Do not go to the U.S. as the visitors from Canada, stop going there and spending money there, they will notice and maybe improve their attitudes a bit.


Niel
said

How would the security personal know her life history? Yes, the fact that she lived in Nova Scotia for 15 years makes her a "low risk" muslim. But security personally have to "profile" people so that the lnes through security aren't absurdly long. It's unforunate that Muslim people have to deal with this profile, but that is the way it is because of their extremist counterparts. It also sounds like she was being difficult to the security people by not cooperating and asking them questions as well. Security's job is to question people....if you make it difficult on them, they'll be even more difficult with you.


Lorraine
said

Better to be safe than sorry. I think the extra review of this traveller was appropriate, and if she has nothing to hide or be guilty of, we should all appreciate what needed to be done to ensure everything and everyone would be safe.


Merlin............Surrey
said

And the American border guards are asking....""Nova Scotia"" isnt that somewhere in Jordan ?


Chris
said

Nothing's wrong with PROFILING.It's the only way to live in peace. And if you don't like it. You have the choice to go back where you'r from.


D.F.
said

Jimmy from Burlington hit this right on the nose. This woman wasn't being questioned because she was suspected of being a terrorist. She was being questioned because they believed she was trying to enter and stay in the US illegally. How we've become a society of victims.


R NS
said

I feel for the innocent Muslims...but racial profiling does work in today's security world. If they can convince the radicals to be moderates...there would be no need..until then...bring on max profiling..Muslim, fighting age males, #1 target. It's best for everyone's safety.


GUNNAR
said

She went through this because 1) she is a member of an identifiable group which has a known history of creating terrorists. 2) Because TSA personnel have been given absolute authority with limited training, guidelines and oversight and 3) Because the United States has absolute authority over who enters their country or doesn't, and does not need to follow Canadian guidelines. 4) There may be a fourth reason which, because of 3) above, the US may not disclose.Muslims are certainly not the only people in the world who can have terrorists in their population. They are at present however one of the more likely ones to have them. This has to do with education, religious beliefs and political and cultural structures in numerous muslim countries, and has little to do with individuals. Why did it happen to her? Bad luck. She had the bad luck to be born or raised into a group of people who unfortunately are saddled with more than their fair share of crazies. Nobody said life was fair.


CrackerJackLee
said

i find it difficult to believe that someone who emigrates to Canada, and is accepted, could have such wanderlust... i'd be happy just to settle down in Canada... as a Canadian, myself, i hardly cross the border... what is the big attraction for immigrants across the border...? they all hate U.S.A., but then they emigrate to Canada - and guess what...? why, they're flying and driving across the border like fiends to be in America on a monthly basis... while they park their extended families in Canada's free school - free healthcare zone, they run off to the good ol' U.S.A every chance they get... has anyone ever thought that they're hoping to be stopped and interrogated...? then they can sue for giant court awards... this makes border personnel "gun shy"... it slowly weakens our defence against terrorists... maybe this is the idea...


sjjd
said

nothing she said happened to her is breathtakingly shocking to me. "they asked me how much i weigh" so what? tell them how much you weigh, they ask you how much you weigh when you renew your drivers licence and apply for a passport too. they didnt "pick" her out of the line, us border patrol while i agree is a little abrasive in their approach has a job to do, her name must have popped up on a watch list of some kind, and they picked her out because they were looking for her specifically, not because of her headscarf. the usa is a foreign country, we have no right to enter it, it is at the discretion of us authorities to grant or refuse entry. this lady has no clue what shes talking about. shes defensive, argumentative and out of touch with reality.


Irate in Ottawa
said

I am tired of hearing of US officials that, while conduting their duties to determine the eligibility of Canadians to enter the USA, seem oblivious to the idea that they are doing so WHILE STILL ON CANADIAN SOIL. While they have to power to permit or deny entry into the USA, they are NOT entitled to verbally assault or otherwise abuse travellers who present themselves at US Custom and Immigration pre-clearance stations in Canadian airports. Why is there no recourse for Canadians to file complaints against specific officials and have THEM removed from Canada for their innapropriate behaviour?


Anne M
said

Unfortuately, if you dress like a Muslim, you will be treated as such.Life is not fair, so accept it and go on


Chris from MB
said

Although this woman was clearly singled out, i think that she needs to understand that as a Canadians we are not free to visit any country we want. We have to be let in to foreign countries, and in this case the USA did not let her in. They have no need to justify to a foreign citizen why their sovereign nation is not letting her in.


Mike
said

I and many of my white Canadian born non-Muslim male and female friends have been held up in the airports and borders for questioning and have on occasion missed flights. This is not news, this is the current state of the world and air travel. You have no 'right' to enter the U.S. unless you are american. Deal with it lady. Once again the media is trying to invent stories.


Some Dude
said

Has anyone here ever gone though airport security and thought, "well these people seem like highly trained, intelligent professionals?" It's more like college co-op students or people who appear to be on a prison work release program. This story seems to be the result of WHO is working there, not the reality of threat.


rach USA
said

I can not believe the gaul of this woman to go on TV and complain about her ill treatment by US border guards. Instead of complaining to everyone else maybe she should take this issue up with your her local Imam about how to improve the perceptions of Muslims worldwide. Honestly, I pretty sure that border guards are sick of random questioning and searches when the terrorist acts that have been perpetrated against the US are anything but random. Instead of pulling aside my 65 yo grandmother, why shouldn't they pull aside a member of that ethnic/religious group and question them about their motives. Racial profiling for traffic violations-NO! Racial profiling for potential terrorism plots- Oh Hell Yes!!


Andrew in Alberta
said

It's their country and they have the absolute right to decide who get's in and who doesn't. If you don't like their rules, then don't go to the U.S. When you think of it, the U.S. is the HOME of Americans....if I don't want someone in my HOME, that being my house, then they don't get in.....period, and I wouldn't care who yelled, complained or felt they were discriminated against. I don't blame the American's at all. As someone who works in law enforcement, I can tell you, profiling works, be it racial or otherwise. The Americans have the RIGHT to secure their HOME from anyone they feel MIGHT be a possible threat!


Some Dude
said

Mark in TO said "Why is it we only hear outrage from the muslim community when they are the victims?" >> Anytime radical Muslims are behind a terror event, local Muslim community leaders in the US and Canada are out front condemning the action. It's not, as you characterise it, only when they are victims.


WestofTheRockies
said

Yes let's all be indignant! Except this woman wears a head scarf this would not be a story. Her "husband" lives in the US, but she lives in Nova Scotia and we are outraged she was turned away? Sounds reasonable to me, this situation raises a lot of valid questions. I've been turned away for much less and I'm a W.A.S.P. male born in Canada. They can turn you away for any reason, real or perceived, it's their right , it's their country. To Jackie Barrett, before you huff & puff all your righteous advise you should know U.S. Customs wherever, is under our laws, a little tiny piece of U.S. territory. Once you go to U.S. customs anywhere you have of your own accord subjected yourselve to judgement under their rules. What happened to this woman happens to dozens of people every day in every airport in both U.S. & Canadian customs. Oh and pay close attention to the location of most US & Canadian custom houses at the borber in relation to the actual boundry, next time you attempt to cross.


Marion
said

I feel for Manna, but I'm a caucasian female and I too have had to provide copious amounts of paperwork to cross into the US. I of course had a passport but I also needed a copy of the invitation to the conference, a copy of my pay stub AND a letter from my employer that I'm returning to Canada! The first time was 11 years ago and is still being demanded today!


Em
said

If Muslims do not want to be treated like potential terrorists, then they need to collectively stand up to the Muslim extremists and band together with the Western world in this fight against terrorism. I am not noticing any effort on their part.


erin
said

Border guards have this ability to make you feel like a criminal even when you aren't . I've crossed over a few times and been pulled aside because I'm a Canadian married to an American. Also the fact that I'm a nurse raises flags as well for some reason.


Robert Brise
said

Outrage B. Kelly Truer words could not be spoken. Also, if this had happened in Jordan I wonder how much publicity she would have wanted or been allowed to garner? Without feeling the wrath of her religious compatriots?


Andre Setton
said

Brian Kelly is right on the money.What happened to Manna is regrettable but it is the logical conclusion after so many years of passive acceptance or even encouragement of terrorism by the Muslim Community everywhere. Why are extremist Imams tolerated in mosques? Why are some people dancing on the street and passing out candies after a successful terrorist bombing? Why are recognized terrorist movements such as Hamas and Hezbollah elected and re-elected?All of these facts point to Muslims in general being at best passive towards the terrorists among them, at worst agreeing with the killing of Westerners.Until violent elements of the Community are thrown out and brought to the authorities, security forces have no choice but to always assume the worst. Manna simply is a victim of her own community's lack of commitment to everyone's safety and freedom.


Doug @ BC
said

Well said "Mark in TO".I am glad the big smoke in Ontario has not dried up all the brain power back there.Sadly,the one thing missing from this fight against terrorism is outrage from the Muslim community.The Sikh community here has a history of defending "their own" even when it is clear their own have broken the law.I get the impression amny Muslims,especially men,do not see themselves as our equals.They consider themselves our superiors. This woman is an innocent victim in a war we have to fight.It may not be fair,but it is the way it will be for a very long time.It is no different than our efforts to ban all guns in Canada because of a few drug crazed criminals insist on breaking the law. America has the right to decide who gets into their country.They do the cheks here for two reasons.One is to help speed things up.But more importantly,if a Canadian is going to be turned back,in most cases he/she would rather find that our here,not when they arrive at a US airport. To the bleeding hearts and perpetual whiners on the political left,you are reaping the benefits of your hippy mentality.Canada is seen as soft on crime,soft on secutity,and soft on defense.As long as other nations do not trust our efforts to fight terrorism,or to take part in the global war on terrorism,we,the people,can expect our ability to travel to be severely curtailed.And,guess what,no one else on the planet gives a fat rats behind about Trudeau's twisted version of our Charter Rights.And there is not one thing Canada can do to change that. You want freedom?? Stand up and defend your country.As brave as they are,the people in our military can't do it all for you. PRO PATRIA


Woman from the Peg
said

Maybe they had a reason to detain her? Maybe her husband is on a terrorist watch list, or maybe not. We do not know the circumstances. But I think they handled it appropriately. The border guards make a judgement call and that is their position. Take it or leave it. I'd much rather be safe than sorry. This world is messed up and the more ridiculous threats of terrorism that happen, the more we are going to see this sort of thing. Deal with it, play by the rules and everything will be fine.


composmentis
said

With all the illegal immigration going on, is it not reasonable of the US border to be suspicious of a woman going to visit her husband living in the US? It is their country and they get to decide who can come. Get over it lady. If you think your scarf is the problem, then remove it or else don't go to the US. They US is under no obligation to you.


AK
said

She wasn't treated like a terrorist at US customs. Terrorists get treated like everybody else who have no problems getting through security , how else do you think they keep boarding US bound flights?She was treated like a criminal. Big difference.


janfromnorthvan
said

Power tripping at border crossings happens all the time to people who look a bit different from the norm. My son has experienced it at the BC US border in the past. It is a fact of life and in the tenseness and fear heightened by propoganda in the US there is a great tendancy to take out frustrations on the innocent. Remember the internment camps anyone?


Wendy
said

Wasn't it the US that started terrorism with there policies? Didn't the invasion of Iraq & Afghanistan make these people even more angry. The source of terror is almost invisible now, because of US policies. Most terrorist will probably be home grown in the US. I think George Bush was the worst terrorist the world has seen in many years. I'm 50 yr old white Canadian, born & raised in Canada. I have always disliked the US always will & have no interest in traveling to the US. In my opinion the US created the terrorists & will continue to create terrorism until they change their ways.


mean old cat
said

Typical behaviour of American security personel. I guess most people should just strike the US of any destinations. I'm going to, just to protest such incidents of treatment of individuals such as this. Sue the RCMP and the US Customs for false imprisonment!I wonder how it will be before the American Tourism Industry is begging for bail-outs?


Sk. Traveller
said

I forgot one interesting point: Targetting skin color and possible nationality. Having worked in Security for a number of years; I know 1st. hand Security guards are underpaid.In different airports; I have noticed that a lot of Security personnel are a large mix of ethnic backgrounds and all do their jobs well. Should we target these security people also; in case they "might " allow a relative from a targeted country in?Harper signed an agreement with Bush; to allow American troops to enter Canada in case of a "Terrorist attack" in Canada. Instead of protecting Canadians; he is busy handing over the keys to our country and allowing them to do as they please.


Mike In BC
said

I can understand the US being stricter at the border especially with Muslims....BUT I have often ran into border guards that are rude and go far beyond what is necessary to check me out. I have been locked in a room and asked to remove my pants as well as many other infringements.I guess being a 68 year old white anglo-saxon male who is a veteran (with veteran plates on my vehicles) who has served for Canada with US forces makes me fit their profile!


Mirco Walther, Thunder Bay
said

While the US CBP official who detained this woman was probably overzealous, I'm thinking that the most simple solution to this woman's problem would be to forgo wearing a head scarf in the future.The easiest, cheapest and most effective way to provide air traffic security is to profile (and there is nothing wrong with profiling). If you dress a certain way you shouldn't be surprised if you receive some special attention.


John in SK
said

What a crock. Everything that happens is recorded by the CBP -- both audio and video. They are not security guards, they are Law Enforcement Officers.I flew to the US on January 1. I was flagged at passport control -- along with about half a dozen others -- and sent for additional screening. After about three and a half hours, which included a hearing in front of a CBP officer, I was deemed inadmissible, and given the reasons why in writing. I was also told that because I had been honest with them and co-operated I was being granted a one-time exception and was allowed to continue my trip to the USA -- and given one extra day in case of delays or problems of any kind.The officers at CBP did their job exactly as any Canadian would expect our own officers to do so. I treated them with the respect they deserved, knowing I was a visitor to THEIR country.What it all comes down to is that being a Canadian citizen gives me rights in Canada -- nowhere else. It may extend certain privileges, but privilieges are not rights. If you want guaranteed right of entry into the US, become a citizen there. Simple as that.As for being treated as a terrorist, watching the interview with the Ms. Manna, listening to her remarks, and watching her body language, facial expressions and eye movements suggest she is not telling the whole story. It would be interesting to see the footage of her behaviour in comparison to that of the CPB Officers before making judgments or fault.


Zero tolerance for a violent religion
said

If westerners suddenly began bombing Islamic states, mosques killing thousands like they have done here etc... how much accommodation do you think we would be given entering their Islamic countries. Don't think too long because we would get the same treatment and much worse. We must do what we need to do to secure our borders and if that makes muslims uncomfortable - too bad because their Islamic 'brothers' behaviour is killing our people. if they dont lke it then they had better put the word out to stop the violence.... but that will never happen.


Joel - Edm
said

Ignorance certainly isn't going to win the war on terrorism. Most of the posters on this story sound like they have absolutely no understanding of the rest of the world outside of Canada other than what the read and see on the internet and TV. I'm a fith generation Atheist Canadian, and I'm all about treating criminals like criminals, but it sounds like the US border official had no reason to treat this woman the way she did. Just a hint for most people that have never travelled to the Middle East, much less the rest of the world. Jordan is a peaceful, safe and friendly country - probably much more so than Canada. Not everyone in Jordan is Muslim. Not all Arabic people are Muslim and not all Muslim people are Arabic. Many women in the Middle East wear head scarves weather they are Muslim, Christian or Jewish. And if you were to ask someone from the Muslim faith, 99.9999% of them would respond that people that use terrorism to make a statement is un-Islamic, hence these people are not truely Muslim.


Eastern Eagle
said

The fact that this woman was not arrested means that she is not a terrorist! Then if she is not a terrorist why was she mistreated and denied entry? It is a very dangerous thing to give agencies in any country the right to abuse their powers and make serious decisions without being forced to explain the reason for these decisions! The question now is whether the Canadian government would stay silent on unjustified treatment of an innocent citizen or will they for once show some guts with our American neighbors? Based on the history of Mr. Harper in defending non white Canadians abroad, I am not that optimistic!


james T.
said

This incident is regrettable, but in a post 9-11 world it is understandable. Sometimes national security outweighs political correctness.


John From Saskatoon
said

I am sure this woman may be alright but how many women have their been that have been suicide bombers? I would rather have American Customs and Immigration Officials turn someone back if they didn't feel comfortable than here Later on in the day that a plane was blown up or someone tried to re-enact the Xmas day episode. Also did you ever think how you would be treated if you were a Caucasian trying to go Into a Muslim country especially if something like the Xmas day episode had just happened. I imagine it would be the same thing.


Alex (Toronto)
said

The US has no business harassing innocent Canadians. This bureaucratic abuse is bad for tourism and trade, which kills jobs in both countries for no good reason. There is no security danger at the Canadian border and no law enforcement or security operation that can't be performed in-country. "Unalienable" rights aren't magically suspended at the border, no matter how that enforcement might find it convenient not to have to do their jobs correctly. If the US doesn't want to give citizenship to children of travellers, it can change its immigration law instead of needlessly stressing pregnant women. The cost in lost jobs due to so-called border security greatly outweighs any possible advantage the US gets from paranoia.


Mark
said

Sounds to me like this was a concern over someone immigrating illegally, though she was likely not, and not a terrorist fear. Did she have a return ticket or was she planning to visit for an undefined period? One way ticket is a quick flag at the border.I have been bounced at the border twice over concerns about immigration and I blame myself for saying the wrong thing and not having the right documents.


Jennifer Warren
said

I completely support increased security and due diligence by all border guards (US and Canadian), especially at airports. There is no need for innocent people to die in the name of political correctness. If most terrorists are muslim, then it only makes sense for border guards to subject them all to increased due diligence. If caucasian christians start bombing and hijacking airplanes and joining the jihad in record numbers... then border guards will start questioning them more often. Border guards are SUPPOSED to guard their borders! We have no idea (from this story) why they chose to detain Ayat Manna, but I'm sure they do... and it is their country.


The Truth Hurts!
said

To Tim: It is very easy to make a stupid statement and paint 1.3 billion Muslims with the same brush. The vast majoirity of Muslims have denounced this recent attempt but you are not allowed to hear their voices! Actually, the father of that terrorist did what many would not do; he reported his radical son to the Americans who, I claim, ON PURPOSE allowed him to board the plane with explosives. I claim also that the terrorist attempt on Christmas eve is a part of a hidden power struggle between president Obama who wants to restore civil liberties to the US and the monsterous right wing security agencies who are fighting any attempt to limit their infinite powers/resources after 9/11. I really feel worried on where the West is heading under the systematic fear mongering and abuse of power like the one this lady came under!


Phototrain
said

This type of US border patrol terrism should not be allowed. If she was being refused entry because of terrorism concerns she should have been arrested. That's why violent terrrorists are so successful. While this racist US border guard was breaking Canadian law with her 'official American' discrimination, no doubt real terrrorists will watch and learn from this. I like the American president, but hey, guess what Obama, your border patrol is going out of their way to disconnect the dots. Barak, committing racist crimes is not the way to go.


Diane, Woodbridge
said

These are truly sad days we are in!!! Let's just come to terms with the fact that there will be a whole heck of a lot of "profiling" happening from now until the end of time. There will be no end to this, period.


Paul in SJ
said

While I can not comment on whether or not this person should be allowed to the enter the USA (being a Canadian I have ZERO influence on who they let into their country), I cannot help but think that as offended as she was for being treated like a terrorist, as a traveller I feel comforted by the fact that they are airing on the side of caution....Better 1 person inconvienced than a plane hijacked or blown up.


Andrew SK
said

Profiling is wrong, and those that support it are wrong. It worries me when citizens are willing to allow or support this type of security. What will be next security camps, and racial ghettos?


Linda
said

There have been a number of threats to the US. They have every right to search whoever they deem questionable. Including a canadian citizen. Many terrorists have come from countries other than their origin. We need more security at the airports on both US and Canadian sides. I have no qualms about being search or held for a period of time. I am sure other passengers would rather feel safe even if it means hurting someones feelings.


adam, Montreal
said

I donno, her storey seems pretty rough. But its a heightened alert day of age. Im sure since the media reported this on her side shell be allowed to go. However, i think its important that they are prudent on who gets in or not, and its not just muslims who get a hard time, it can be anyone really. One time when i went for a conference, the border guy asked me to explain my thesis to him in ways he could understand, and I needed proof of why i was going for the conference and even that i was coming back, I was a white male. Like i said I donno, seems like something is missing here, but its unfortunate she wasnt able to see her husband even after she supplied what they asked for.


Lynnie
said

Brian - you hit the nail on the head. Why indeed do we have U.S. Officials in our airport. It's interesting that most American citizens think they have a right to travel anywhere without being harrassed. I personally know of a fellow who tried to cross our border, with a carload of his belongings (intending to move here) - telling the border officials that he was just visiting his girlfriend. They turned him back and he was "outraged".


Rob in North Bay
said

It would be interesting to hear the US Customs and Border Patrol's side of this story. Muslims (of course) are not the only targets of rightfully paranoid US policy. A colleague who was a 20-year member of the Cdn Forces and has the unfortunate name of Murphy was detained in Toronto by the Americans for four hours.


Ryan
said

All of you who thought this treatment was acceptable should go and look at yourself in the mirrors. I bet you won't like what you see......What's next detentions camps?


MM
said

I am a single, white female who travels extensively and often alone. In the past 30 years I have been pulled aside on 7 different occasions while entering the US and interogated. The longest I was held was just over 3 hours while they checked out the information I had given.This isn't anything new.


Chuck
said

I really do not blame the US for being a little shy on who is coming into their country. Canada thank the Lord has not had a terrorist attack on Canadian soil, so we seem to think others over-react.


Chris in Ajax
said

Why would we expect anything different from the Americans? I think that we should get ready to hear even more stories like this in the future. When the Americans have suspended basic human rights(Patriot Act et al) for their own population why would we think that they would treat foreigners with anything even resembling respect? They have spent almost two decades bombing muslims around the world daily(Iraq since Desert Storm). It is my firm belief that this dehumanizing of an entire segment of society will only exacerbate the problem by radicalizing more and more good people. How could it not? Put yourself in their shoes.... Could you watch your family suffer through war with your relatives killed or tortured and not become angry? Why is the USA the only country with the "right " to commit terrorist acts and claim that they are moral?


Jackie Barrett
said

I think Manna might have been a victim of racial and religious discrimination in American hands.If I was Manna, I think she should file a "False Imprisionment" and discrimination suit against United States customs because even though the incident involves American authorities, it happened on Canadian soil, meaning out laws apply, not there's.Halifax International Airport Authority, CATSA, and RCMP might face false imprisonment suits.Besides, since when is it against the law to be pregnant.Even though she is Jordanian, keep in mind that since she is a Canadian citizen, she should be given the same rights and privileges like all Canadians.Earth to Obama, earth to USA, Islamic women who are Canadian citizens have rights too whether they like it or not.No wonder why Americans are the world's most hated people, its due to actions from over-zealous people like the American Authorities.Thumbs down USA.


Joey
said

Remember and I hate to say this, once you start this sort of screening, it must stay consistent. This is nothing about the Charter of Civil Right being violated. It happened on 9/11, it almost happened in Detroit. The terrorists are testing or in military language "Conducting a Recce" They walk amongs us in society. They look and study for clues. Look what happened in the Parliament Bldg's when Peace Activists climbed the building. They are watching this. It's called Lessons learned. We all have a responsibility to report anything suspicious however 75%, people don't get involved because their names might appear in the news, can't be bothered etc. Terrorism shook the foundation of North America and it's here to stay Get use to this type of security at airports and especially going to US. They get hit the hardest, Wait, CANADA MAY BE NEXT!!!


NSSherlock
said

She has a husband in the USA, travels there often, they want proof of her finances, employment, and proof she's not pregnant. Sounds to me like they're simply worried she may try to stay illegally, or give birth to a child that will automatically become a citizen she can use to sponsor her into the USA! This is a common event at the border, and certainly not a headline issue!


Lynnie
said

Sure, they fall down on the important facts - like the CIA having been warned about the Christmas attempted bombing. No one followed up on that very explicit report. But now they are going to harrass a Canadian woman who is simply trying to visit her husband - all because she is Muslim. I'm sorry, but it really does make one not want to go the States ever again.


Jimmy from Burlington
said

She was refused as she's considered a risk to stay illegally. Think about it. She has a husband in the US why? They asked for bank statement. Which would be proof of a job and income on this side of the border. They asked to prove she was not pregnant....this is common if they think you might be....if you have a birth in the US your child is a citizen by birth. Plus we are only getting her side of the story. As another commentor stated, US customs can deny you entry for any reason they want. Traveling to another country is not a right.


Zappacostta
said

Perhaps she would feel more comfortable if she were to move back to Jordon.Having a Canadian passport allows her no right to enter the United States. The only people with a right to enter the US are US citizens. Everyone else is allowed entry at the discression of the US Border Patrol.


Mike in Calgary
said

The simple fact of the matter is that the United States can - and will - permit or deny entry to any person they see fit. Given the current situation in the US with the terrorist threats (and the Russian experience with the "black widow" female jihadists) it is not surprising in the least that they are looking hard at women - they are the next logical weapon of the terrorists. Also, this woman seems to be travelling back and forth between Canada and the US for personal reasons. That is likely going to raise a few flags.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Here we go...the "news stories" founded upon political correctness have already started. Grab a beverage, sit down, and make yourself comfortable, folks; because this farcical "show" is just starting. While it is critical that our security officials at borders and at airports conduct themselves professionally, it is GUARANTEED that certain people are going to be "offended" henceforth. Too bad. The greater good, for the time being, dictates that some upstanding Muslim people are going to be considered POTENTIAL terrorists. Our governmental intelligence is not properly and sufficiently in gear as of yet, and we're only now equipping ourselves with the requisite physical-search systems. So, things are going to be a little rocky for while. Buck-up, suck it up, wipe your phony tears, and ignore the whining and crying from those leftist politicos who'll want you to believe that the "feelings" (and supposed "rights") of certain temporarily selected/identified people trump our collective NEED to exist in a secure, and free, society. Ladies and gentlemen; our apologies in advance.


Norm Shanahan
said

It's their country and if they don't want or have stricter regulations it's up to them.(USA)

Brian N
said

Why do we allow US officials to do this on Canadian territory? Why do we give them a place in our airports to screen before they leave for the USA? We don't have screening in New York or Boston or anywhere else. Let them screen them when they arrive in the US. I am sure a lawyer will pick up her case and I hope she gets soe financial satusfaction from it.


stubblejumper
said

I crossed the border many times as a truck driver. You must remember that the US border people have full authority to let you in to the USA or turn you around. Period. If for some reason you make them feel uneasy, guess what? you're going back. For the record I'm a caucasian male.


ADM Saskatchewan
said

Why did this woman have to go throught this? No explanation from the US government. I could maybe understand a little if she was coming from Jordan but she has lived in Canada for years. US customs needs to stop power tripping and use better judgement on who they detain.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Jun Lin, the Concordia University student who was murder and dismemberment in Montreal, is seen in this undated handout photo.

Police ID murder victim, say suspect has fled to Europe

More   21 Comments 21    10 Video(s) 10

The SpaceX Dragon capsule is seen just after the capsule is released from the Canadarm2 on Thursday, May 31, 2012. (NASA)

SpaceX capsule returns, splashes down in Pacific

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A Canadian Pacific Railway employee walks along the track at a marshalling yard in Calgary, Wednesday, May 16, 2012. (Jeff McIntosh / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

CP Rail service returning to normal, officials say

More    Comments