Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Canadian freelance journalist Amanda Lindhout sits with a child in Mogadishu, Somalia, in this undated handout photo. Released hostages Louis Guay, left, and Robert Fowler, center, talk with Malian Foreign Affairs Minister Moctar Ouane at a reception the day after their release, at the presidency in Bamako, Mali on Thursday, April 23, 2009. (AP / Harouna Traore) Canadian freelance journalist Amanda Lindhout is seen reporting from Baghdad, Iraq, in this undated image taken from video.

Public pushes to bring envoys home, not Lindhout

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Alan Bell, security analyst
It appears there has been some breakdown in the negotiations for the release of Amanda Lindhout and Nigel Brennan, who are being held by Somali kidnappers, or the situation would not have gone on so long or led to the unusual statement.
CTV News Channel: Michel Juneau-Katsuya, former CSIS officer, on the kidnapper demands
A new tape appears to contain the voice of Amanda Lindhout, and it seems the hostage-takers have grown tired and are trying to apply pressure on the family and government.
CTV News Channel: Ambroise Pierre, Reporters Without Borders, from Paris on the kidnapping
There are concerns after a woman claiming to be kidnapped Canadian journalist Amanda Lindhout said she was unwell and needed medicine, and given the journalist and a colleague have been held far longer than expected.
Canada AM: Daniel Smith, former colleague of Amanda Lindout, discusses the dangers of reporting
A former colleague of Amanda Lindout discusses the danger of reporting abroad after a woman claiming to be the kidnapped Canadian pleads with the Canadian government to help bring her home.
CTV National News: Janet Dirks with details of the disturbing phone call
A young woman, claiming to be kidnapped journalist Amanda Lindhout, called the CTV National News room on Wednesday, begging for the government to secure her release.
CTV News Channel: Lindhout's full statement to CTV
A woman who claims to be kidnapped Canadian freelance journalist Amanda Lindhout called the CTV National Newsroom late Wednesday afternoon and asked to read a statement. Some viewers may find the content of the audio tape disturbing.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | Print Facebook   

Date: Thu. Jun. 11 2009 5:23 PM ET

The public put significant pressure on the federal government to resolve the kidnapping of high-profile diplomats Robert Fowler and Louis Guay, while showing comparatively little support for missing freelance journalist Amanda Lindhout, documents obtained by CTV.ca reveal.

In the first seven weeks of Fowler and Guay's four-month-long captivity in Western Africa, Foreign Affairs and senior government officials received several dozen emails from members of the public, pressing for details about their case.

But in Lindhout's case, only one person bothered to send a letter to Foreign Affairs on her behalf, even after she had been held against her will in Somalia for more than 90 days.

Through the Access to Information Act, CTV.ca recently obtained copies of all of the emails, letters and faxes sent, or forwarded, to Foreign Affairs about Fowler and Guay, during the first seven weeks of their captivity.

Starting only two days after the pair of Canadians first disappeared in Niger, a flurry of messages were sent to government officials, including to high-level civil servants, diplomats, cabinet ministers and the Prime Minister's Office.

On Dec. 16, one letter writer told a sitting MP that he wished to "beseech quick and urgent action on the part of the Canadian federal government to locate and protect Louis Guay and Robert Fowler."

Two days later, an all-caps email which arrived in the inbox of Defence Minister Peter MacKay aptly summed up the tone of the incoming message from the public: "Please do all possible to free Bob Fowler and his team now. It is essential that Canada act now."

The same day, another email instructed MacKay to "devote the maximum possible efforts your office and our country can generate in pursuit of the safe return of these men and their driver."

The next day, an email was sent to MacKay, Foreign Affairs Minister Lawrence Cannon and the Prime Minister's Office, demanding that the two diplomats be returned to Canada "with all the energy that our country and government can generate."

And as time went on, the tone of the letters sent to Ottawa did not get any less urgent.

On Boxing Day last December, one letter writer sent a message intended for John McNee, Canada's ambassador to the United Nations, wanting to know "what is Canada doing at this point to find all three men (the diplomats and their driver) and what, in turn we can do to support your efforts in that sense?"

Less than two weeks later, another member of the public demanded to know what the government was doing about the kidnapping: "How about giving the press a statement on what you may or may not know concerning Fowler's disappearance? He is a prominent citizen and we have a right to know what attempts are being made for his return."

Some of the letters sent to the government regarding the Fowler and Guay kidnapping were deemed too sensitive to be released as four pages were blanked out in their entirety when sent to CTV.ca. The body of an email meant for Guay's family was similarly blocked.

Appeal for Lindhout

But the public pressure to bring home the diplomats appears to have been much higher than the resolve to free Lindhout, who was kidnapped for ransom in Somalia last August.

A separate Access to Information request for emails sent to Foreign Affairs about Lindhout, returned only one document that had been sent on her behalf during the first 90 days of her captivity.

"As you may know, Amanda Lindhout of Sylvan Lake, Alberta, is a freelance journalist and was abducted at gunpoint near Mogadishu, Somalia in August of this year. As of yet she has not been released," the writer said in the email to Foreign Affairs on Oct. 8, 2008.

"A fundamental responsibility of a sovereign state is to protect its citizens at home as well as abroad. I am asking what the Department has been doing to facilitate Amanda's release. I understand that for reasons of operational security, your response will be limited."

Nearly ten months after her abduction, Lindhout has still not been freed.

A woman claiming to be Lindhout called CTV's National newsroom on Wednesday afternoon, reading a statement to the person who answered the phone.

The woman pleaded with the Canadian government to get her home and said she was need in "immediate aid" for her survival.

Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Money

Canadians struggling to save money: RBC

More   48 Comments 48    3 Video(s) 3

Robert Pickton is interviewed by police in January 2000 in a video released to the media on Feb. 8, 2012.

Video shows Pickton 2 years before he was caught

More  2 Video(s) 2

Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital.

Crash survivors eligible for health care coverage

More   33 Comments 33    15 Video(s) 15