Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Produce section at the Hannaford supermarket. (AP / Larry Crowe) Mark Bittman, author of 'Food Matters' speaks to Canada AM.

Eat less meat, help save the planet, author says

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Mark Bittman, author of 'Food Matters'
While it may seem like a large task, helping people around the world can start at the dinner table with a environmentally conscious meal.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (47) Facebook   

Date: Thu. Jan. 29 2009 10:31 AM ET

Eating less meat is the solution to a slimmer physique and a happier planet, says the author of a new book that seeks to change the way we think about food.

Mark Bittman, the New York Times food writer and author of "Food Matters", says the industrial production of livestock is responsible for 18 per cent of the world's greenhouse gases.

By reducing the amount of meat we eat, he told CTV's Canada AM, we can have a direct and positive effect on the environment.

"In as big a way as switching to a Prius or using high-efficiency light bulbs or turning off the lights when you leave home or wearing a sweater in winter. It's another one of those small steps we can all take to have a positive impact on the environment," Bittman said.

He cited the clear-cutting of forests to make room for fields for cattle, the environmental impact of slaughterhouses, transportation costs and the sheer amount of methane gas emitted by cattle herds, as damaging to the planet.

On top of that, roughly 50 per cent of the corn and soy grown in the U.S. is used for animal feed, requiring incredible amounts of energy to produce and transport.

But Bittman isn't just a green geek, he's also a health nut, and says his book maps out a way to do both.

"It's so simple. It's really about changing the proportions of the food that we eat. And we North Americans eat a huge amount of meat, highly processed foods and relatively very, very little plants."

He said the average person gets between 80 and 90 per cent of their caloric intake from meat and processed food, and just 10 to 20 per cent from plants.  

In the U.S., he said, people get an average of 7 per cent of their daily calories from drinking pop. Cookies, doughnuts and cheeseburgers, not surprisingly, are also high on the list.

When the ratio of meat to plants is shifted by 10 to 20 per cent, the results are dramatic, he said.

Bittman cut his own meat intake by two-thirds, and reduced his intake of processed foods and dairy products and "tried to really gorge on plants", such as fruits, vegetables, whole grains and legumes.

"I lost 35 pounds, no kidding," Bittman said.

"My cholesterol went down, my blood sugar went down. I wasn't even trying to lose it, I wasn't paying attention. And a month after I started eating this way I'd lost 15 pounds and... then another month later I'd lost another 15 pounds and over the next year I lost a few more."

But Bittman is clear, he isn't trying to sell his book as a dieting guide or a "two weeks to 15 pounds weight loss kind of thing."

"It's really a different way of thinking about and handling and eating food and it's a lifelong thing."

Comments are now closed for this story

Guido
said

How about marijuana and the extreme negative impact that has on the planet?
The incredible amounts of energy required just for one grow-op, times that by thousands of them.
I guess changing a drug addicts mood is more important than global warming?
But don't eat meat!




EOE Jr. Manitoba
said

to MOOSEJAW...I'd just like to correct one small thing you said, actually the huge amounts of methane gas coming from the cows is NOT coming from their farts, but rather from their burps! Believe it...Anyways..they do produce massive amounts of methane, all which can be collected and made into renewables.


Elizabeth
said

I work in health care. Half of North Americans are obese and so are their children. We are seeing adult onset diabetes in children which has very serious long term consequences.

They are inactive because we adults drive them around to everything like little kings and princesses. Britain's top chef Jamie Oliver is concerned that obesity will increase even more because of the economic crisis. It's quite sad, you have the fattest people on the planet suffering from malnutrition because of their addiction to "easy grub". Bears become lazy when they get old and resort to "the town dump".

Our grandparents grew food without pesticides, ate lots of vegetables, and were active.

This is a good diet for the planet. Hopefully, people will get back to cooking whole foods again and having fresh fruits & vegetables as part of their diet.

Studies have shown people who live in the suburbs are more obese and less active-drive everywhere. People in the city walk to the bus, and tend to walk to shops, hence getting exercise.


Deborah
said

This is not a new concept. Frances Moore Lappe wrote a book on it in the early 70's called "Diet for a Small Planet". I own a copy.
Montreal


Looking
said

And what was the carbon foot print of getting to your studio, researching for his book, transmitting the "story" on tv (the web, satellite, off air, cable), publication of the book, the paper a small number of people will use to print the "story," the electricity the people who reply? Get real. Quit wasting our time. Find a real story.


Lori
said

Nothing exceeds like excess!! We ask a vegetarian how they get enough protein but who asks a meateater if they are getting enough veg, grains and fruit. Are you??


Jill in Ontario
said

It's great to see more people get with the program and realize that a meat/dairy heavy "traditional" diet is not going to get you healthy! Talk to any nutritionist or naturopath and they will tell you the same thing. Supporting factory farming is awful for the planet, our health, and the animals. Going veg was the healthiest thing I ever did. That Atkins diet made a lot of people sick after it severely damaged their kidneys! And not everyone can afford a Prius or new energy efficient appliances, so going veg (or mostly veg) is the best and most affordable thing you can do for the environment.


Jason
said

Chicken Little says.
"Animals are carbon neutral, much like trees and pretty much anything in the circle of life."

Wow, your ignorance is astounding. Explain something. If we cut down trees to make arable land and then densely pack it full of animals that that land normally cannot support How exactly does carbon neutrality exist? Forests clean up C)2 but its been cut down to make room for even more carbon producing animals. Its called math and I sure hope you are not the one balancing your homes balance. Or are you one of those who helped the economic crisis on with a 40 year mortgage?

Before talking abot the complexities of climate change maybe you should actually understand the processes that are occurring. I question why CTV even allows comment sections on such stories as it tends to get full of nay sayers and complete morons who have no idea whats going on. You should be proud CTV for the damage you are doing with getting this pressing issue dealt with.


iphone--
said

I think he should spread his word to Texans. They eat alot of meat. Ever been to a restaurant down there? Limiting out caloric intake should also promote longevity too. Experiments have shown this in mice.


Jonathan W
said

"Maybe somebody can answer these: how much grain to bring cattle to processing size? How many people would that amount of grain feed, versus how many people would that amount of cattle feed?"

I can answer that - ideally NONE. Cattle are designed to eat grass. Grain is so hard for them to digest they are forced to medicate them with antibiotics. The only reason cattle are grain fed is for "marbling", i.e. to make them fatter. I am seriously amazed at the knee jerk reactions of those who feel threatened the moment anyone questions the wisdom of their dietary choices.


T
said

You've got to be kidding me. Now not eating meat is going to save the planet. What's next? The air we breathe? Ridiculous


Dan from Northern Ont.
said

I'll eat what I want, and enjoy my life for however short or long it is.

What's scarier? A heart attack at 50 or having to live from 70-100 wearing adult diapers?


I don't eat enough meat, I shall mend my ways.
said

What about the insects? The bugs? Does no one give a care about all the bugs?
Do you all have any idea how many inocent insects are killed in grocery store coolers? Thousands upon thousand of sweet little buggies lives destroyed every day so wontonly in order to grease the wheels of the heartless fruit and vegetable cartel and their inhumane machine!
Save the planet today! Don't eat lettuce or cabbage!
Do you know how many vitamins and minerals are leached out of the soil by those plants? The earth is being stripped of its nourishment by those cruel veggie farmers!
PS, people are fat and unhealthy because of cars, public transit, desk jobs, and a cleaning lady doing even that for ya. Have you noticed most cleaning ladies are nowhere near fat! Thats because they eat meat and do physical work!


DD
said

We are not cutting down forests to increase cattle herds. There is lots of room and unproductive land that can house cattle. What does he think happens if we all eat fruit and veggies? Where does the land come from this? People please look at the motives and look at what he is saying in a common sense way. More power to you if you think you want to eat a different way. Don't support your idea with crazy facts and theories about how the cattle are destroying our planet.


David
said

He is absolutely correct!

I went through the exact same experience (lost 30 lbs) when I moved to the west coast and adopted a diet similar to the one described. I still eat meat about once a week and actually enjoy it more because I dont have it every day.

To all the ignorant people who are afraid to open their minds and change their habits - He is not saying to stop eating meat! Grow up!
The amount of livestock we manage has an enormous impact on our resources not to mention crappy quality food due to the fact that the industries are profit based not nutrition based.

It will be survival of the fittest and those who adapt to our rapidly changing planet who have the last say.

Go ahead - have another steak!


G. Gravelle, Ottawa, Ontario
said

Where has Bittman been for the last 20 years??? I guess he's never heard of the Canadian/American Food Guidelines. He's basically saying to eat in accordance with that they say. Not exactly earth-shattering news.


Henry Wysmulek
said

Wow, he wrote a book, so he must be an expert!




Bob London
said

Turn off your power, grow food in your garden, hunt wildlife, milk your wife to make cheese you ecomentalists.


Charlie
said

It makes sense to me that eating less meat is good for the planet.

Maybe somebody can answer these: how much grain to bring cattle to processing size? How many people would that amount of grain feed, versus how many people would that amount of cattle feed?

I think the answers to those questions, and a little math, might help put things into context.


Moose Jaw, SK
said

Actually, Chicken Little, animals are not carbon neutral, especially cows. Cow herds produce a significant amount of methane gas. How you ask? Well, by passing gas out their backsides, that's how. Do your research before you make uninformed and factually incorrect statements like "Animals are carbon neutral, much like trees."


Dennis
said

Yet another benefit of being a vegetarian. 12 years and counting for both my wife and I.


Roger T
said

Is the author doing what he's preaching or just another way to claim his 15mins of fame?

Those who want others to give up luxuries and life style are usually the ones who do the most damage by not sacraficing themselves to what they preach.

It's like the Gov't telling consumers not to drive to save the enviroment but yet you see them in Limos with police cars lined up behind them.

Besides, when they say they do "how do we know they are doing exactly what they preach, unless they live on camera 7/24"?

Why should we sacrafice for the sake of some author telling us to.

Until than meat consumption it is.




Outdoors Woman
said

I eat meat, and like it, but I also eat meat that I harvest myself as a hunter. Deer, moose, ruffed grouse, along with fishing for my own fish. I know where my meat comes from, and it didn't need clear-cutting to produce it - just natural forest.


Jonathan W
said

You don't have to agree with Bittman on Global Warming to realize that eating little or no meat is far healthier. I note with amusement the predicatable defensive comments from those who blindly refuse to acknowledge the true costs of eating industrially produced meat. Take beef from the supermarket. This requires far more energy to produce than it yields, results in a huge amount of pollution - any idea of the environmental effect of manure lagoons produced by feedlots?, the animals are loaded with antibiotics because they are unable to properly digest grain and corn - they are designed to digest grass. If everyone ate less meat, we could produce enough of it using sustainable methods. Go to your local farmer's market and try some organically raised, grass fed beef and you will not want to go back. Better than Bittman on this topic though is Michael Pollan. The Omnivore's Dilemma provides a very thoughtful and well researched take on these issues.


bunny
said

Yes that will kill the cattle industry, not what we are trying to right now.I love a great t-bone steak, he can do as he wishes.


Omnivore in Toronto
said

Meat is the reason we evolved from tree climbing primates that were always being chased by predators to upright running and tool building primates that are the primary predator on this planet.
Without meat, we would not have the size of brian we have today.

If you want to reduce your meat intake to reduce your wight? that is a great idea, but seitch to fish and other less fatty meats. To do it for "global warming" or other environmental or animal loving reasons is just plain nuts (which, BTW, cannot come close to providing sufficient energy and protein per volume as meat does).


cmdh
said

I have absolutely got to stop reading comments on news stories, the vast majority of which are hair-trigger, knee-jerk reactions.

Why would someone feel threatened by a story like this? No one is going to take your meat away or even villify you for eating it. All Bittman is saying is that "hey, if you cut back a little on meat and eat more fruits and vegetables you'll likely be healthier and there are some environmental benefits as well". Read the story, spend a few moments thinking about what he’s saying, then take it or leave it (of course, which is likely what 99% of the people who read the story actually do). The story doesn’t help by calling him a “green geek” and “health nut”, of which he’s neither, but that’s typical of fluff journalism like this.

I won’t even delve into the environmental arguments for eating less meat (yes, I do eat meat) apart from saying that they are valid. Unfortunately, I think some of the “counterpoints” that have been raised so far demonstrate the lack of scientific understanding by the general public which is exacerbated by the deliberate spread of misinformation.



Hungry Steve in Montreal
said

Having grown up on a beef farm (Angus, the best) I whole heartedly won't buy into this. I bet this dude will do a book tour and fly all around North America to promote it all the while producing more carbon as he goes.


DWR
said

From the way I see it the only happy creature will be the cows, pigs, chickens etc etc. So go back to smoking what ever plant life your smoking and leave us meat eaters alone.



Proud Vegetarian
said

I have been a proud healthy ovo-lacto vegetarian for twenty years and have raised two strappingly healthy vegetarian boys who gobble up their tofu and ask for seconds. They have both tried meat and think it tastes weird and can't imagine why anyone likes it.
I've heard all the usual rhetoric from die hard meat eaters who can't part with their favourite comfort food. But I always get the last laugh when it comes to comparing grocery bills. We eat for about $300.00 a month less than other families who eat flesh. So ha!


Wilf
said

I need to talk to Mr Bittman. I was born and raised in South America where meat is the main Meal and the majority of people die from high cholesterol, Heart problems related to meat. I love steaks and just eat my meals in moderation, maintain my weight, have energy and sleep good, thanks to cutting down on Meat! God bless you, Mr. Bittman!!


Martin.NS
said

For every piece of meat you don't eat, I'm going to eat 3!


EOE Jr. Manitoba
said

I disagree completely, including about the slimmer physique. I am an active ringette player and had a weight issue because I didn't eat enough meat. I started consumming more lean meats and I dropped 42 lbs in 6 months, so take that fat cat! Saving our planet..pffff...you just have to use anaerobic digestion for all the cattle and hog farms to reduce methane gas and produce renewable electricity.


Kojak
said

I'm having three double cheeseburgers for lunch. Then I'm going to wash it down with coffee and a cigarette for dessert. My 95th birthday is tomorrow. Hooray!


Steve the Pundit
said

When I read this I nearly dropped my triple-pattied, bacon-slathered artery-buster!

Seriously, is EVERYTHING we do now a threat to the planet? Breathing? Sleeping? Watching reality television? OK, that one's just a threat to our IQ's...


Don from Ottawa
said

Yet another sales pitch linked to global warming. I can't wait until this cult-like hysteria takes its place in the history books alongside disco and Y2K.

Having said that, smaller portions of meat aren't a bad idea for many folks. Take the money you save on quantity and invest in quality - better cuts with fancier preparation - and enjoy the improved taste as well as your improved health. Works for me.


Jen in Ottawa
said

I was really glad to see this this morning. To many of us are unaware of the impacts that what we eat has on the environment and on our own bodies. Thanks CTV for showing this great article!


Raj
said

Watch the documentary JungleBurger and see what mass meat production did to the Costa Rican rain forests.

Animal fat is what causes bad cholesterol, for some it's not a bad idea to cut back and of course, reducing processed foods is a great idea for everyone but you can't deny the way most foods, meat and vegetables are industrially produced with little or no regard for the environment and our health has to change.

Again, check out JungleBurger and you'll see what i'm talking about it. If you can find it online, McDonalds spent hundreds of millions trying to buy up and keep this film from getting around.

It's expensive and not easy for most but people should buy meat and agri-products locally if they can.


dc in bc
said

Bittman, of course, is right. National Geographic did an article a year or two ago which showed how people in Sardinia, Okinawa, and Loma Linda, California live longer than others, and much of the credit was given to eating a vegetarian diet.

Many of us don't like the thought of eating a vegetarian diet, but the list of things that gives meat its flavour is not a very pretty list.

In addition, since productivity is one of the things that we in the developed world seem to admire, the transfer of food value from plant based food into meat is one of the least efficient things that you can imagine. In order to give us a little meat for cheeseburgers most of what cattle eat during their lifetimes goes for body heat. I f I remember right, I believe the ratio of what we waste in food value in producing meat is about 90 % wasted. How smart is that?

Besides all that, if eating meat is all about taste, vegetarian meat substitutes are very tastey as well. They are just not in style.

In view of the above I wish I could tell you I had a vegeburger yesterday, but l can't. I had a burger at a fast food place.



Trent
said

There is plenty of room of this planet for God's creatures; Right next to the baked potato, which happens to be smoothered in butter, sour cream, green onions and bacon bits. Yummmmm, I think I'm firing up the BBQ tonight!





John K
said

I've personally cut back on meat and eat more veggies, but it's because of my own personal health (cholesterol control) reasons, not because of these environmentalists.


Edb
said

Funny, a high protien (meat) low carb diet sheds more pounds then any other diet proven so far. Why not insist on less factory farming and more independent local farming. Sorry, I forgot, Dalton's nanny state police have been harassing and legislating local food producers out of the equation.


Mandosa in Sarnia, Ontario
said

Hey Mark Bittman. I like meat, and that's just the way it is. So deal with it.




Gerald from Belleville
said

Brilliant.

Nothing we didn't (shouldn't) know already, but never-the-less refreshing to hear it said again.

We are omnivores (sorry hardcore vegans, it's true!) and meat is part of our diet. BUT, it doesn't have to be the main part of the diet. Eat mainly fruit and vegetables, and then add a little bit of meat and dairy products and voila! Healthy human being.

This solution offers the best of both worlds. Focusing our diets on fruit and vegetables decreases the need for large cattle, which is environmentally disastrous, and is good for our healths. PLUS, we still get to eat that tasty tasty meat!

I'm just glad for once someone advocates eating less meat rather than no meat.

Oh, and a reality check. Except for a very tiny amount of people with hormonal imbalances or taking necessary medication, most people are fat because they're a)lazy and b) eat too much. Get off your lazy bums and eat right and you too can slim down to a healthy weight!

Cut down on your patties fatties!


Chicken Little in Revelstoke BC
said

Animals are carbon neutral, much like trees and pretty much anything in the circle of life. I agree with him that less meat may be healthier for us, but to save the planet?? Come on now.

Will anyone not use global warming to shamelessly promote themselves or their agenda?


David in Toronto
said

I'll think of this nut when I'm eating a nice steak at dinner time and thinking about the veal chops I'll be having the next day. If some people give up meat for this dumb reason, I'll be more than happy to pick up the slack.


Darcy
said

If you want to talk about clearcutting and using arable land, how about stopping smoking and drinking coffee as well?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Red stains are seen on a bed in Luka Rocco Magnotta's Montreal apartment, which is the scene of a murder investigation, on Thursday, May 31, 2012.

Montreal police confirm murder victim's identity

More   1 Comments 1    7 Video(s) 7

The SpaceX Dragon capsule is seen just after the capsule is released from the Canadarm2 on Thursday, May 31, 2012. (NASA)

SpaceX capsule returns, splashes down in Pacific

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

quebec tuition protest classe

Talks between Quebec gov't, students collapse

More  3 Video(s) 3