Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
Ahmad El Maati speaks on CTV's Canada AM, Monday, Oct. 20, 2008. Abdullah AlMalki speaks on Canada AM from CTV's studios in Ottawa, Monday, Oct. 20, 2008. Muayyed Nureddin speaks on CTV's Canada AM, Monday, Oct. 20, 2008.

Man at centre of Iacobucci inquiry feels 'betrayed'

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Torture victims discuss the report
Arab-Canadians Abdullah AlMalki, Ahmad El Maati and Muayyed Nureddin, who were all detained and tortured, discuss an inquiry report due Monday that investigates whether Canada turned a blind eye to the torture.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (12) Facebook   

Date: Mon. Oct. 20 2008 8:39 AM ET

One of the three men at the centre of an inquiry into whether Canadian officials were complicit in their detention overseas says Canada "betrayed" him and hopes the findings, which will be turned over to the government today, will allow him to rebuild his life.

Former Supreme Court Justice Frank Iacobucci has been conducting a review into the cases of Abdullah Almalki, Ahmad El Maati and Muayyed Nureddin.

El Maati says he was detained and tortured in Syria and Egypt, while Almalki and Nureddin claim they were held and tortured in Syria, on what the men say were false terrorist charges.

They accuse Canadian officials of passing on incorrect information about them to their interrogators.

In an interview Monday on CTV's Canada AM, Nureddin said he wants answers into the role Canadian officials played in his ordeal.

"I think Canada betrayed me as a citizen," Nureddin said. "Because once I travelled, I travelled hoping that if anything happened to me there is Canada behind me."

Iacobucci's review began nearly two years ago and has been mired in controversy. The three men, who claim they were detained and tortured based on false terrorism allegations against them, held a news conference a year ago and complained that the inquiry was shrouded in secrecy.

"Today I don't think I'll get any answers because the report is not going to be released today," Almalki said on Canada AM. "It's going to be handed over to the government and then the government does what they want, I guess, with it."

It is unclear when the report's findings will be made public.

The review began in the wake of the Maher Arar inquiry, which found the Ottawa engineer to have been detained and tortured in Syria without grounds.

Justice Dennis O'Connor, who led that inquiry, said the RCMP passed incorrect information about Arar to American officials, who first deported him to Syria from New York's JFK airport.

Almalki, an electronics engineer from Ottawa, was on his way to visit family when he was detained at Damascus Airport in May 2002. He was released in March 2004 after 22 months in jail.

El Maati, a Toronto truck driver, was travelling to Syria for his wedding when he was detained at Damascus Airport in November 2001. He was released in January 2004.

Nureddin, a geologist, was detained at the Iraq-Syria border in December 2003 on his way back to Canada after visiting family He was released in January 2004.

All three men say they were tortured and forced to sign documents they were not allowed to read.

The men said the ordeal has ruined their lives.

The engagements of both El Maati and Nureddin ended and all three men have suffered physical and psychological trauma, which they say was a result of their imprisonment and torture.

Almalki said three of his six children and his wife had to seek psychological help after his experience, which destroyed his company and his reputation.

"Because of the 22 months of severe torture I had to endure, I'll never be the same mentally or physically," Almalki said. "My professional life, my company and my reputation has been ruined."

Comments are now closed for this story

Llora
said

Wait a second... if your familiy lived elsewhere like these men, wouldn't you want to visit them, regardless of where that is? I know I sure would - especially since I know what it's like to have family far away.

Also, I don't think these men expected Canada's laws to apply in these countries -just that the Canadian government would support them and not betray them.

Finally, they are not grasping at straws. If you know anything about out legal system or government it's that EVERYTHING takes a long time. These men could very well have filed for an inquiry years ago and it's just now being talked about and dealt wiith.


Tony Bishop
said

Two of the three men whose overseas treatment is being reviewed do not claim they were "betrayed" by the Canadian government. To these men I would ask why did you come to Canada in the first place? Answer: because it is safer and more humane than your country of origin ... The next question is, "Why did you think you could return there to a country you knew was unsafe?" ....

Brian McElwain
said

Due to the current economic crisis, I would recommend that we could save a lot of money from removing our embassy presence and staff from various countries where we can't protect our Canadian citizens such as countries in the middle-east(eg; Maher Arar), Mexico (eg; Brenda Martin, Ienairos etc). Our Fedreral Gov't can't and will not try to help our imprisoned citizens in a timely fashion. And, our citizens should boycot any visits to these countries


Northerner
said

I want to show compassion but I'm having a difficult time. These men went to a country that may be hostile and/or not very democratic. They went for their own personal gain and/or pleasure. Now they say the one at fault for their situation is the Canadian governemnt. Why can't they take some responsibility for their actions? Why is it that everyone is at fault and everyone cries out that they are innocent victims? And pay me for my distress. Are they guilty of something that brought this terrible situation on them? We are all responsible for our actions and we must accept that not every country is like Canada.


Joe
said

I think they are grasping at straws. They have been back in Canada for more than a couple of years and should have said something when the Arar inquiry was going on. I see it as just looking for free Canadian tax money. It wont fly. For other people going to a foriegn state, do it at your own risk..


David Carroll
said

First: "These people" are really "our people". Canadians just like you and I. They may not be citizens yet, but that should not matter. The lesson is not that you should not travel, but rather: When one of our neighbors is betrayed by the same government we rely on to protect us, then we should fix that. Because if we don't they might come after you next.

Oh and Raj, the cases of all of these men were well known my the government, the press and the judicial system well before the Arar judgment. ...

Blake in Windsor
said

For those wishing to complain about the idea that travelling to a 3rd world country is a bad idea, please re-read the article. It's not about that. It's about whether Canadian government officials, when pressed by a 3rd world country, provided inaccurate or potentially even false information to said 3rd world country, whether because of incompetence or to determine if the people being held were associated to terrorists. That is the story and that is what must be addressed. And as for why now? Think for a minute - if you were on the receiving end and you thought the government might be responsible, do you think you'd put your family at risk if you were the only one stepping up to the plate? I'm sure everyone would love to say they would do it, but the hard cold brutal reality is that it is much easier to suffer silently than to take on a government behemoth.


Phil
said

Read the article folks, the Government is alleged to have given false information to Foreign officials that resulted in torture. In other words we broke our own laws.


Rob in Ontario
said

Travel at your own risk is probably the best sdvise you could give these people travelling to the middle east! Since when is it the Canadian governments fault that people travelling to these destinations get tortured? I certainly have no plans of travelling to the middle east because I know "It's not safe" It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure this out, and the Canadian taxpayers shouldn't be on the hook for decisions these men willfully made to travel there.


Socialism is killing us
said

Why do these people think Canadian laws apply in these third and fourth world countries? Why do they think Canadian laws apply anywhere except in Canada?


Heather
said

Don't visit 3rd world countries. The government will let you rot there if anything happens to you. That is the lesson I take away from this.


Raj
said

Ok, I see, these are the people who came forward and claimed to be tortured after Mehar Arar was awarded (rightfully) the compensation.

Something makes me wonder, where were they earlier? Why didn't they come forward right when it happened and try to get justice?

Why now?


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Versha Prakash talks to Canada AM about the Trillium Gift of Life Network donor record, Monday, May 28, 2012.

Ontario organ donor agency sets new 1-day record

More    Comments    1 Video(s) 1

Canada's Ryder Hesjedal holds the trophy after winning the 95th Giro d'Italia, Tour of Italy cycling race, in Milan, Italy, Sunday, May 27, 2012. (AP / Fabio Ferrari)

Hesjedal becomes first Canadian to win Giro d'Italia

More   23 Comments 23    8 Video(s) 8

Striking Canadian Pacific Rail workers picket outside the company's rail yard in Montreal, Wednesday, May 23, 2012. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Talks between CP, union stall; Raitt prepared to step in

More   43 Comments 43    3 Video(s) 3