Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
U.S. President Bush makes a statement on the economy in the Roosevelt Room of the White House in Washington on Friday, Jan. 18, 2008. (AP / Ron Edmonds)  A South Korean man walks past a stock board in Seoul on Friday, Jan. 18, 2008. (AP / Lee Jin-man) A pedestrian looks at an electric market board in Tokyo on Friday, Jan. 18, 2008. (AP / Katsumi Kasahara)

Bush seeks economic boost package worth $145B

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Tom Clark with the billion-dollar bailout
10p_bush
Mike Duffy Live: Economists discuss Bush's bailout
MDL18_one
CTV Newsnet: Bush speaks from the White House
JM18_bush
CTV Newsnet: BNN's Michael Hainsworth explains the economic impact of Bush's announcement
DM18_markets_chat
Mike Duffy Live: Avrim Lazar, from the Forest Products Associaton of Canada, on how the U.S. slowdown will affect Canadian industries
MDL18_two

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (36) Facebook   

Date: Fri. Jan. 18 2008 8:35 PM ET

U.S. President George Bush called for the immediate implementation of US$145 billion worth of tax rebates for individuals and businesses in order to kick start the country's ailing economy.

While Bush refrained from specific details, he said the package must represent at least one per cent of the country's gross domestic product.

"This growth package must be built on broad-based tax relief that will directly affect economic growth," he said Friday during a press conference, adding that the package should not include any tax increases.

Specifically, Bush said the package should bolster business investment and consumer spending and must include:

  • Tax incentives for American businesses, specifically small businesses;
  • "Direct and rapid" income tax relief for individuals.

"Americans can use this money as they see fit; to help meet their monthly bills, cover higher costs at the gas pump and pay for other basic necessities," Bush said of the temporary plan.

"I believe there is enough broad consensus that we could come up with a package that can be approved with bi-partisan support," Bush said, adding that passing the growth package was the country's most pressing economic priority.

The rebate plan was backed up Thursday by Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke who suggested the government needed to put money in the hands of Americans who would spend it quickly.

"Putting money into the hands of households and firms that would spend it in the near term" is a priority, he said, suggesting research shows poor people and the middle class are most likely to spend the rebate soon after receiving it.

But some economists say the Bush plan won't do much to help resolve economic problems over the long term.

"The U.S. economy has been hit right smack across the forehead by the back of a shovel in the form of the sub-prime crisis and the ballooning trade deficit which are destroying demand for U.S.-made goods and services," Peter Morici, a business professor at the University of Maryland, told CTV Newsnet's Mike Duffy Live.

"This is kind of like a big Band-Aid or an Aspirin. It will make the patient feel a little bit better, but it won't solve the problem."

Morici said the U.S. needs to tackle its banking system and large trade deficit, which keeps growing.

"Unless we fix our appetite for oil, our appetite for Chinese goods, we're going to have to keep people borrowing all the time to keep America working. It's a crazy model," he said.

U.S. economy's impact on Canada

Patricia Croft -- chief economist at Phillips, Hager and North -- says the U.S. economy is likely in a recession and that will have a major impact on Canada.

"The myth has been that the U.S. could go into recession and the rest of the world, particularly Canada, could party on." Croft said. "But I don't think that's the case. I think our two economies are inextricably linked and as a result -- with a bit of a lag -- I think Canada is going to feel the pain, as well."

But Croft told Mike Duffy Live that doesn't mean that Canada will necessarily fall into a recession.

"The U.S. is in a housing depression. Our housing prices are just cooling off and the Canadian consumer indeed is in far better shape. But, nonetheless, given the linkages on the trade side, I think at a minimum it means several quarters of sluggish growth for the Canadian economy lie ahead," Croft said.

The impact of a weak U.S. dollar has already had a negative impact on Canada's manufacturing industries -- such as the forestry sector -- which are dependent on exports to the U.S.

"It's been really bad and it's probably going to get worse when your major customer is heading towards a recession," said Avrim Lazar, head of the Forest Products Association of Canada.

"When the prices of your products are going up because the dollar has gone up, of course, you're in trouble. And it's not just forestry, it's all of manufacturing."

Earlier this month, the Harper government announced a $1 billion aid package to help communities and workers affected by a downturn in export-dependent industries. Lazar says Ottawa can help in the long term by making Canadian manufacturers -- specifically the forest industry -- more competitive to meet a growing global need for wood products.

"As we restructure and invest, we know that the market is going to be there. But we need the government to create a business climate that gets us ready. So that means -- not bail outs -- (but a) tax regime that makes us competitive," said Lazar.

Lazar said Ottawa could invest more in research and market development, and it could also make research tax credits refundable.

Meanwhile, Liberal Leader Stephane Dion issued a news release Friday outlining what a Liberal government would do to protect the Canadian economy.

Dion would create a $1 billion "Advanced Manufacturing Prosperity (AMP) Fund to support major investments in manufacturing and R&D facilities to help Canada's manufacturing sector thrive in the global economy," the release stated.

Markets rally, lose momentum

European and Asian markets maintained a steady climb back from Friday's early-morning plunge -- bolstered by news of Bush's growth-package announcement -- while North American markets lost momentum by the late morning.

Toronto's S&P/TSX composite index slid from a triple-digit advance to fall 29.43 points to 12,766.2 after plummeting 279 points Thursday.

Oil, copper, gold and other commodities were again to blame for the down turn. The TSX Venture Exchange dropped 8.94 points to 2,647.8. However, the loonie edged up 0.28 of a cent to 97.39 cents US.

Earlier in the day in London, the FTSE 100 Index rose almost 2 per cent to 6,016.40, led by the Rio Tinto Group mining company whose shares rose by 5.6 per cent.

Other European markets:

  • Frankfurt, Germany's blue chip DAX 30 index rose by 0.8 per cent to 7,474.21,
  • In Sweden, the Stockholm-based OMX increased 1.3 per cent to 316.97.
  • In Paris, the CAC-40 climbed 1.2 per cent to 5,219.22.

Tokyo's Nikkei 225 stock index -- the largest in the region -- rose 0.6 per cent to 13,861.29, which followed a drop of three per cent when the index opened Friday.

The main Hong Kong index also gained, rising 0.4 per cent to 25,210.87 after an initial loss of 3.7 per cent Friday morning.

Asian markets have sagged since the beginning of the year amid worries about the impact of the U.S. economic slowdown. A slump in the U.S. housing market and mounting credit crisis are responsible for much of the problem, which some are calling the first U.S. recession since 2001.

Comments are now closed for this story

Ex-American Drone
said

As an American living in Canada, I feel quite ashamed to say I am American. How could they not see this coming? Greed always bites you in the "end." The fact that the American economy is down the toilet because Americans don't have cash to blow on unnecessary things means the economy is in recession? This only goes to show that the American government wants to keep it's "drones" dumb and greedy in order to keep the the rich richer. I'm happy to call myself a SOCIALIST!





Trent
said

Danny in Winnipeg... In 2000, whether anyone wants to consider the election rigged or not, Al Gore received 48.4 percent of the vote compared to 47.9 percent for Bush. So no, at least half the country did NOT vote for Bush.


jerry G
said

Biggest corporate hand out ever. I think this does constitute unfair subsidies and I suggest it is illagal practice. Canada needs to take them to cleaners and insist that they have to also pay the Canadians, other wise this is an unfair business practice and we should go after them for.

Lets see what our leadership will put forth to this bailout. I am prodicting that our government will follow suit with something like it for our ailing auto industry!



Mike
said

Why do people insist on linking Bush and Harper? They have never been buddies, they have met only a couple of times and Harper's policies are much better than Bush's. I personally think the Conservative gov't alignes better with the Democratic party. I'm sure a lot of you don't agree, but that's the way I see it.


Jeanne
said

To: Canuck in Seattle:

I totally agree with you - Bush has NO idea of how to handle the economy, and obviously, neither do any of his administration. And, he should NEVER have become President, but he lied about the "ballots" and Gore was left out in the cold.

If Gore had gotten in as President, as he should have, we would be enjoying economic prosperity right now, instead of wondering if both the US and Canada are both going down for the count!!

The sooner BUSH is out of power, the sooner we will all breathe a huge sigh of relief, and start to rebuild the MESS he will have left.

Jay Palmer
said

I'm just wondering where all this money to bail people out is coming from. Won't the well run dry soon?


Ben
said

Nothing anyone does now is going to change a thing. They and us are headed for a major meltdown as I stated a long time 2 yrs ago. The so called terrorists need do nothing but let the goog ol' US of A spend itself into oblivion. We, the gov. and us have created a monstrosity of corporations that have gotten larger and larger chasing the buck to try and keep stock holders and themselves happy and have run themselves out of room to grow. Now everybody better tighten their belts because the biggest meltdown in history is about to descend on us. The morons that created this mess because of greed will try to put band-aids on the festering sore to no avail. We will have to start over by letting the crash happen in order to be able to start the greed cycle again.






Duane in Calgary
said

That's pretty edgy--give a bunch of people who are flat broke another $500 to put on their credit card balance and go and rack up more 18% debt. Sounds like Bush-o-nomics to me. Anyway, Canada should never fall below it's current 20% downpayment without insurance policy because sub-prime is a killer. Canada should also start subsidizing world shipping routes from our ports to stimulate business with more foreign countries because whoever is going to take over the good ole US of A after Bush is through with it will take years to fix what's broken. The war was supposed to be paying richly in new oil for US companies by now, but instead it's still costing trillions of dollars, and China sits on way too many US treasury bills for me to feel any sense of security with current conditions. Anybody have any ideas on here on how to re-invest RRSPs??


Iami Iamme
said

The fairest and most over due "TAX relief package" that BUSH GEORGE and or HARPER STEVE could ever offer...would be to put the IRS and CRA into a pretty container and put in on the next NASA flight outta here!
I sure wouldn't go out on a limb and state; this is what the middle class "POOR" has been waiting for...It's just another "smokescreen" handout to Corporate America from "The Good Ole Boy"


Danny in Winnipeg
said

Bush has not single-handedly destroyed the US. Keep in mind at least half the US voters elected him, TWICE. Despite the mess that has been created, anyone who has close ties with the US knows that there is ALOT of wealth down there that is not going to disapear as quickly as some like to suggest. Also, economies cannot continue to get richer indefinitely (refer to the unprecedented wealth of the Bush years), without some healthy and perhaps intentional correction every now and then. Lets see what happens when the Dems start to clean up some of the mess though.


Charles
said

There is an old saying that if the U.S.A. gets the sniffles Canada gets a cold. After reading many comments regarding the proposed "Bush Stimulus Package" I am amazed at the hatred of many Canadians towards the President of America. Recessions have appeared many times over the last 100 years. The U.S.A. and Canada will survive this downturn just as they have in previous years.


BL
said

So....where exactly is Bush getting this money from?

Add 145B to the US National Debt!

*Shakes head*


RICHIE
said

Don't listen to a MORTGAGE BROKER... they're just doing damage control. This is about a devalued US dollar because the American public, but more importantly, the American government is spending beyond its needs. YES this relates to war. YES this is linked to gold and oil. Bush can give as much borrowed money to Americans as he wants, but where do you think it's going to go??? Overseas, back to where the products are made. Stop believing economists and newspapers, they dont know the reality of this situation. Gas is rising not because of terrorism but because of a devalued US dollar... which is because of the Fed printing money to pay for its stupid endeavors.


JL
said

Get rid of the federal reserve and bring back the gold standard! Quit printing more money!!!


Dan I
said

Bush wants to boost the economy NOW !! Where the hell has he been for 7 years??? Someone should kick start him!! I think he's been having too many Bin Layden dreams....
I wonder if Bush really knows how much he has messed things up in this world besacuse of his own agenda; GREED


Canuck in Seattle
said

I am massively in debt. The gov't says the economy needs me, and is giving me a new credit card because my others are all maxed out.

Bush, the single stupidest thing about your dismal adminstration has been your handling of the economy. Canada has handled their debt intelligently. Bush is the worst thing that has ever happended to the US. He has hurt America 100 times as bad as Bin Laden ever has. But try telling that to someone here in the US?




Ralph Malph
said

It's funny but whenever Canada implements economic aid packages to it's business sectors we are accused by the Yanks of unfair subsidization under NAFTA..Cry havoc and let slip the dogs of war:)


ian
said

When people will sell out their own economy by purchasing cheap products from another country, simply because they can save a few bucks in the short term, there will be a fallout. So I wonder how the comment writers here feel about all those who rush from Canada to the U.S. to buy a car because they can buy a cheaper product.


Nick J Boragina
said

Q: How can we make the US economy?
A: I know, lets increase the already record-breaking deficit!
Q: Isn’t that a ridiculous idea?
A: Uh...


Nick, Montreal Quebec
said

Hmmmm i wonder who's fault this is Mr.Bush ;) Congratulations you brought the US Economy from a 10 trillion dollar surplus over the next 10 years when Clinton left office to a 10 trillion dollar deficit in the span of 7 years, oh how the mighty have fallen. It's a shame that us Canadians have to feel the wrath of poor economic policies by our neighbours to the South


Bob Smith
said

China is very pleased with this latest announcement...

Orders for $145 Billion worth of plastic crap will need to be filled PRONTO!!!

Bush has singlehandedly destroyed the US.


Roger T
said

I think Americans need more than just a tax rebate. It's not much of a rescue aid package given the fact consumers are not spending. If they are already worried about the economy and job cuts, what makes Bush think consumers will rush out and spend because of a tax rebate rtaher than saving $$$ for a uncertain future!

Maybe, instead of spending tax payers $$ in unless wars pump it back into the economy and pay of debts.

Don't be fooled by this aid package which will put consumers even more in debt.


GW
said

david: The US government is controlled by the huge corporations who make better profit by outsourcing American jobs. The Corps control the government through a well financed, efficient and effective lobbying system directed squarely at government representatives the people vote into power.

I personally can’t see an easy way to clean this up, perhaps legislation outlawing lobbying of government officials?



Doug
said

This really validates the opinions of those who have been pushing for both Canada,and it's citizens to reduce debt at all levels.
It's a lot easier to weather these inevitable economic storms if you are not hampered by massive debt.Either personal or government debt.At least being debt free allows more resources to be available for hard times.
Let's face facts as opposed to "spin".If either Bush or Harper could do anything about the pending recession,I expect they would.
Smart people used the good economy we've just been through to build up savings and pay down debt.Others spent like drunken sailors and plied up debt.You don't have to be a rocket scientist to see who is going to be better positioned to weather this storm.
Canada was right to pay down debt and lower taxes.Though I do have concerns we did not do enough of either,it surely is better than increasing debt and raising taxes.
Lets just hope this slowdown doesn't reverse ALL the gains we have struggled for.


Linda
said

I'm sure rich people will just find this to be another opportunity to buy something low,which can later be sold high.But the broker who says the problem is sub-prime mortagages hits the nail on the head.But knowing how,and why will do little to alleviate the problem.
"Made in China" is also a big problem.Not only in the USA.It's a bit sad when we can cut down forests in B.C.,ship the logs to China,then buy back finished wood products manufactured there.
"Steve I.C." also makes a good point.But in fact,as the US economy goes,so goes the rest of the world.Not only Canada catches cold.But I hope those who agree that we need to expand our foreign markets are willing to find ways to help make our products competetive enough to be sold elsewhere.

J-F (Ottawa)
said

The relevance of the world's economy will be nil until the new President is elected.


Nanook
said

My friend in Montana has a step-son who, at 19, was basically a high school dropout bum. HE applied for a mortgage! I don't think he got it, but it was pretty close. In Canada, a 19 year old, with poor job prospects, wouldn't even be let into the door of a loans department. (He did get a loan for a new Dodge truck, but lost that about 6 months later.) Scary stuff went on in the good old USA. Oh yea, wanna buy a cheap house? Kalispell Montana was being bought out by rich Californians ten years ago. Not anymore.


Stop the clones
said

It is easy for China to rise quickly. They clone everything. Stealing technology from our software vendors. Using substandard material an pawning it off as acceptable, abusing their human resources. Stop purchasing Made in China. It may seem like a deal in the short term. Sure a couple of things bought at the big mart shop, you save a couple of pennies, but in the long term you will lose your employer to China. Stand up fight for our rights and higher standard of living. Your money will do the talking. Look at The Bay all their Canadian Olympic team clothing is made in China, Roots Canada made in China. Look at labels and think, refuse to purchase and tell retailers why you will not buy from them. A simple email goes a long way.


Sonny
said

It would be prudent of Canadian business' to try to buy Canadian OR Locally.

Diversify away from the U$ given the ship is sinking into recession, although they will try to throw good money to keep consumers spending OR in debt.

Since there are high mortgages and oil prices. The strategy would be to by fuel efficient cars from Japan.

With high rent OR mortgages people will likely buy the cheap goods from the dollar store OR sprawl mart...


Michele
said

I thought Bush said "all the fundamentals were good" with the American economy.

The worst isn't over, MORTGAGE BROKER, in regards to the subprime mess. As Paulson
himself stated, the problem will be significantly bigger in 2008 because 2006 mortgages had lower...standards. Industry people want us to believe 'the worst is over', though.




John
said

David, I am not convinced by your comments.With world's largest foreign reserves of 1.5 trillion and biggest market, it is important for Canadian business to crack Chinese market.
I would also rather believe the article about China by Newsweek magazine, published on Jan. 2008. It states "China's rise as the newest Superpower is no longer a forecast but a reality. In two decades China has experienced the same degree of industrialization,urbanization and social transformation as Europe did in two centuries. China has expanded personal liberty, it is not perfect but very significant"


Gold is real money not paper
said

If the Americans had been more strict on their mortgages instead of fanning the flames of greed the entire world markets would not be doing this yo yo dance. Analyst say the worst is behind us but then the US has to face the inept way they have handled their paper money. I expect to see a increasing demand for gold and gold stocks as the USD is devalued due to the Feds printing press.


Allan Eizinas
said

This is another example of a self fulfilling prophecy. Bush says that the USA is taking a hit so Harper says we are going to take a hit, the media says that we are going to take a hit so people sell because they don’t want to take a hit thereby taking a hit.

Perhaps in time when George Bush takes a hike and Harper takes a hike then the Market prices will hike up.

Don’t tell anybody but - if you buy low and sell high then you will still make a good profit.



Alex Sz
said

Digging a deeper hole in terms of debt is a pretty stupid idea. How about limiting the amount one can borrow from your house ATM instead? In Canada, we start at 75%, then make owners pay more when they go above that. Oh, and regulations and penalties for appraisers who over inflate house prices? Sounds like common sense, but instead, lets help people spend more. What a joke.


steve I. C.
said

We've but all our eggs in one basket. We need to stop relying on our number one trading partner, start doing business with a diversity of trading partners from the rest of the world as well as focusing on Canadians supporting Canadians. We need to go back to the land and invest in agriculture and push for growth in green energy.


MORTGAGE BROKER
said

Sub-Prime Mortgages are the problem.
People who should not get mortgages with nothing down got 2/28 mortgages, cheaper than rent for two yrs then the payment jumps and they cannot afford it leading to massive forclosure. The worst is over. It had very little to do with a war.
But the Mortgage brokers made an average of $10,000. a loan. here in Canda high ration mortgages of more than 75% need to be insured. In the states the subprime was nothing down and no insurance but the worst is over people who could not pay have been foreclosed on.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Canada AM Stories

Jun Lin, the Concordia University student who was murder and dismemberment in Montreal, is seen in this undated handout photo.

Police ID murder victim, say suspect has fled to Europe

More   31 Comments 31    14 Video(s) 14

The SpaceX Dragon capsule is seen just after the capsule is released from the Canadarm2 on Thursday, May 31, 2012. (NASA)

SpaceX capsule returns, splashes down in Pacific

More   2 Comments 2    1 Video(s) 1

A Canadian Pacific Railway employee walks along the track at a marshalling yard in Calgary, Wednesday, May 16, 2012. (Jeff McIntosh / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

CP Rail service returning to normal, officials say

More   2 Comments 2