Toronto
16°C, Sunny with Clouds

 
1
The War Museum display panel, entitled 'An Enduring Controversy,' will be changed. Cliff Chadderton, chairman of the national council of veteran's associations, speaks with Canada AM from CTV studios in Ottawa on Wednesday, Aug. 29, 2007. 'We need to find a way to explain the information that's on this particular text panel in a manner that is respectful,' Mark O'Neill, the Canadian War Museum's vice-president of public affairs, told CTV News.

Museum dispute not attempt to change history: vet

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Cliff Chadderton, Council of Veterans
CAN29_war

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (10)Add Comments Facebook   

Date: Wed. Aug. 29 2007 9:21 AM ET

A group representing war veterans says it doesn't want to be accused of trying to rewrite history after the Canadian War Museum agreed to change the wording on a controversial Second World War display.

Following an 18-month fight, air-force vets will now be consulted on revisions to a small display panel -- part of a larger Second World War exhibit about Bomber Command -- which they claim paints them as war criminals.

"We don't want to be accused of changing history," Cliff Chadderton, chairman of the national council of veteran's associations, told CTV's Canada AM on Wednesday.

"As some historians have said, if we look at the panel as it is right now, it could be considered as one-sided, we want to remove it so that it is telling the whole story."

The panel currently reads:

"The value and morality of the strategic bomber offensive against Germany remains bitterly contested. Bomber Command's aim was to crush civilian morale and force Germany to surrender by destroying its cities and industrial installations. Although Bomber Command and American attacks left 600,000 Germans dead and more than five million homeless, the raids resulted in only small reductions in German war production until late in the war."

Accompanying photographs show dead German corpses in rubble-strewn streets.

After refusing to budge, the Canadian War Museum has done an about-face and agreed to rephrase the wording of the display after consulting with the veterans.

Christina Selin, the museum's communications manager, told CTV.ca the wording will be revised in the coming weeks and the final text should be completed by October.

"It will be written by the professional museological staff. Right now we're consulting with veterans' organizations, including the Legion and the Mayday Committee -- one of the initial groups that raised their concerns over the wording," said Selin.

Ongoing debate

Since January 2006, the museum has held meetings with veterans over the issue, but discussions reached an impasse and the museum said earlier this summer that it would stick with its current display.

A Senate subcommittee weighed in on the issue. After holding a series of hearings on the exhibit controversy in the spring, the committee in June urged the museum to find a way to rephrase the 60-word panel and put and end to the "unfortunate public dispute."

Museum officials maintained the display is only a small part of a much larger exhibit on the bombing campaign, and that the exhibit also pays tribute to the 10,000 Canadian airmen who died.

Chadderton said the bombing campaign was all part of the strategy to "bring Germany to her knees," and that the information needs to be balanced out.

"They say they will write it (the new display) but they will certainly consult with the veterans before they do," said Chadderton. "I think that consultation will be very productive and very revealing."

Museum historians and experts, meanwhile, have defended the existing text. Jack Granatstein, respected historian and former head of the war museum, has said museum displays shouldn't be dictated by aggrieved groups or political pressure.

The Royal Air Force (RAF) Bomber Command was formed in 1936. During the Second World War, it conducted devastating air raids on Germany and occupied Europe. The Royal Canadian Air Force made up the RAF's No. 6 Group, representing about one-sixth of Bomber Command's strength.

The bombing campaign lasted almost six years, and led to about two million tonnes of bombs dropped over Europe.

While Germany continued to produce weapons during the offensive, they still had to devote hundreds of thousands of troops to battle the planes. In the final days of the war, Allied bombers focused on cutting off the German fuel system.

The bombing destroyed several German cities. The writer Kurt Vonnegut was a U.S. prisoner of war in Germany who survived the bombing of Dresden in February 1945. His 1969 novel "Slaughterhouse Five" was based in part on that experience.

With a report by CTV parliamentary correspondent Graham Richardson in Ottawa and files from The Canadian Press

1

Add New Comment ( )

Zach
said
0 0

This is not about whether it was right or wrong to bomb Germany, the text simply illustrated that a) it remains bitterly contested and b) the gains were questionable. And folks, political interference works both ways. I have no doubt that the same individuals who want to promote an unambiguously celebratory history of the bombings would object to more emphasis being placed on Canada's shameful and racist internment policies during World War II.


DAP
said
0 0

With this bit of appeasement, I am certain that the War Museum has achieved peace in our time.


Devon K.
said
0 0

All I have to say is thank you to the people who fought for our veterans and their legacy. The museum was buying into this politically correct revisionist history and someone put a stop to it. Our soldiers are heros and they fought the most evil regime in history to put an end to it. The idea what this is controversial is offensive. The War Museum will have me as a supporter for the rest of my life.


Grant
said
0 0

This incident just became an integral part of the World War Two unit that I teach my grade twelve students.


Paul Ulrick
said
0 0

As a lifelong student of military history & visitor to the War Museum, I am pleased with this decision. I believe that it is time to remove this sharp stick, out of the eyes of our valiant Air Force vets. While over all I believe the whole display is fair. This particular display represents a bias of those who wish to detract from the tough decisions made in the heat of the all out war of survival our vets fought in WWII.


Gilles
said
0 0

Just because Germany started it, it doesn't mean that it's right.


Ron Martin
said
0 0

Because of this "special group" Duane has the right to state his opinion in public and do it in English not German. I support them consulting with the veterans. There will soon be a time they will be gone.


Lynda Rook
said
0 0

I was born in England in a place called Shirley near Coventry,and had family members living in Coventry,London, Birmingham, Liverpool,Plymouth Etc were all bombed before Germany in fact Hitler told the German people they will never bomb Germany, and when the bombing was done we were not sure we were going to win until the end,the first 6 yrs of my life I did not have enough to eat and I'm so glad all the Canadians came to help us or I my have ended up in a concentration camp under Nazi rule.


mark
said
0 0

First of all I am very proud of our allied airmen. They had a difficult job to do. Maybe people will only have to remember the bombing of Britain that brought this on the German people.Remember our people that were slaughtered on the beachs. Just a final note to remind people who started the war.


Duane Taylor
said
0 0

As someone who respects the academic integrity of museums this latest move to appease a special group has appalled me and I will no longer support the War Museum for any cause.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada AM Stories

Luka Rocco Magnotta, the subject of a Canada-wide search warrant, is shown during an audition for the reality TV show 'Cover Guy' in 2007.

Murder suspect auditioned for reality TV show

More   48 Comments 48    20 Video(s) 20

Gabriel Nadeau Dubois of the CLASSE, centre right, responds to reporters questions after negotiations came to a dead-end with Quebec's minister of education at the legislature in Quebec City on Thursday, May 31, 2012. (Jacques Boissinot / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Talks between Quebec gov't, students collapse

More  4 Video(s) 4

Many seniors live on meagre pensions that cover the costs of rent and food but leave them with little else for smaller expenses. (CTV News)

New charity aims to help Canadian seniors in need

More   9 Comments 9    1 Video(s) 1