Canada -   

1
Asian carp, silver carp, Great Lakes fish A Fisheries and Oceans Canada worker pulls a fish from the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal as they search for Asian carp in Lockport, Ill., Thursday, Dec. 3, 2009.  (AP / M. Spencer Green) Agencies concerned about the Great Lakes have recommended that a massive barrier be built to protect the lakes from an aggressive species of fish.

Barrier urged to protect Great Lakes from invasive fish

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Barriers for flying fish
David Ullrich of the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence Cities Initiative says while there are electric barriers stopping Asian carp, there is evidence they are getting beyond the barrier, so a permanent physical one is needed.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (19) Facebook   

Asian carp, silver carp, Great Lakes fish A Fisheries and Oceans Canada worker pulls a fish from the Chicago Sanitary and Ship Canal as they search for Asian carp in Lockport, Ill., Thursday, Dec. 3, 2009.  (AP / M. Spencer Green) Agencies concerned about the Great Lakes have recommended that a massive barrier be built to protect the lakes from an aggressive species of fish.

Photos

Asian carp, silver carp, Great Lakes fish

View Larger Image

Date: Tue. Jan. 31 2012 8:47 AM ET

Agencies concerned about the Great Lakes have recommended that a massive barrier be built to protect the lakes from an aggressive species of fish.

The Asian carp's voracious eating and breeding habits have environmentalists worried that the fish will overrun the Great Lakes and damage the ecologically fragile area.

In a bid to prevent a school of scaled invaders from entering, two organizations issued a report Tuesday calling for a large physical barrier to be placed between the lakes and the Mississippi River watersheds.

Tim Eder, executive director of the Great Lakes Commission, has called a barrier the "best long-term solution for preventing the movement of Asian carp and other aquatic invasive species."

The Commission, along with the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence Cities Initiative, has suggested three possible ways to close the gap between the lakes and the river.

  • A single down-river barrier between the two drainage basins

  • Barriers in five locations near Lake Michigan

  • A "mid-system" option that would come close to restoring a natural divide between the watersheds, broken more than a century ago

The report doesn't recommend a particular option but says the mid-system method is the least costly of the three multi-million dollar solutions.

There is already an electric barrier in place about 60 kilometres away from Lake Michigan, said David Ullrich of the Great Lakes and St. Lawrence Cities Initiative.

"Although that appears to be slowing down the fish, there is evidence that some may have gotten beyond the barrier," he told CTV's Canada AM on Tuesday.

Aquatic vegetation and creatures such as zebra mussels are also not deterred by the electric barrier, he added.

That's why Ullrich says additional measures are necessary, and soon.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has said that as many as 10 invasive species are poised to enter the Great Lakes from the Mississippi River.

Economic projections place the costs of the barriers between $100 and $150 million.

However, Ullrich said the total cost of the infrastructure project could range anywhere between $3 and $9 billion over a 50-year period. That includes flood control, water quality tests, transportation issues and more.

The Corps of Engineers are conducting their own study of how to close the divide between the two waterways but those findings aren't slated for release until late 2015.

"While we recognize and support the work being done by others to find solutions to the Asian carp threat, we need to appreciate fully the urgency of this matter," Ullrich said in a news release.

Preventing just one invasive species from entering the Great Lakes could save as much as $5 billion over 30 years, according to the report.

Comments are now closed for this story

DCI
said

I totally agree with Mike. This should be turned into a money making effort. It would create jobs in the area. These fish wil not be stopped by some wire fence. If needed, bring in other fish that can eat these carp. Let nature take care of itself....This problem has been known for a few years.Why have they waited so long to do something about it?


Gerald
said

@Pip..Calm down, just fishing.


BUBBLES
said

We have hungry people in Canada...And guy wants 3 billion for a project that will not work because we are to late to do anything about it.The fish are a problem..agreed. However the goverment is talk about rising the age to collect social security..GOOD GRIEF


Mike of Essex
said

Why not turn this into a profitable venture ?Find the best "choke" point where these fish are and create maybe a cannery on one side to make cat food and on the other side maybe a fertilizer plant for that rose garden you love and put people that need work on some nets to capture the invasive fish. Grant it a lot of other fish may be caught at the same time but the few, far outweigh the many that will hurt us in the long run.In short, don`t waste the millions of $ on a barrier that does not make money or save money, put people to work that can use the income.


Max in Vancouver
said

I understand that these Asian carp destroy the rest of the fish in the area they inhabit by means of the aggressive nature. So, when their food supply is depleted, what will they eat? If we left nature to its own resources, would these fish not destroy each other much like rabbits do when they overpopulate? Nature takes care of these things, why do humans need to interfere?


Shane
said

If there is evidence that the fish are in the lake already then it sounds like a case of too little too late to me.


Dixie from Alberta
said

Where did these fish come from??? Was this a case of someone dumping these fish that were imported from another part of the world?


Pip
said

And whose bright idea was it to bring Asian carp to North America in the first place? Find the original importers and get them paying some of the bill. The way these fish destroy the natural fauna and flora, they are no better than an oil spill, and oil companies have to pay to clean those up. The suggestions to import seals has merit, but then you have another invasive species; who will ensure the seals don't breed and take over, killing indigenous fish after the invasive ones are gone. Come to that, will seals even eat Asian carp?


JB in Ontario
said

Something must be done to save the Canadian Fishery in the Great Lakes.


Canadian Bob
said

Barriers will only slow down these fish, and once they have entered the Great Lakes waterway, they will be impossible to remove. Mankind has a history of trying to fix the problems he creates for himself "after the fact". Far too often public ignorance on invasive plants and animals destroys preventive action measures, and we end up with things like Purple Loosestrife, Zebra Mussles, and yes, the Asian Carp, which - barrier or not - WILL make their way into our Great Lakes. There's nothing stopping people from catching these fish, and letting them go on the wrong side of the barrier "just because" either. Like our environment, people aren't willing to pay attention to the warning signs until it's too late, and then it's a "beg for forgiveness" situation as opposed to an "act now while we can" scenario. Man will never learn with these types of situations, and our governments are more than willing to let future governments and generations pay the price for their mistakes. Don't bother with the barriers folks, they are a complete waste of money. Instead, put that money into some preventative measures for the next known invasion... oh... that would be man himself wouldn't it?


Steven Joseph
said

hay i think i know away to stop these fish from getting into our waters and rivers.here's what i think we should do?My late grandfather use to say back in the day how they use to kill fish with large rocks in the winter time.they would slam rocks in the ice and the cracking sound of the ice kill the fish the sound travels into there brain and kills or Paralysis them like that.if only we can mimic that kind of sound in the water? i thing we can.This could be the only way to stop them.


Gerald
said

Introduce more seals.


J.C.
said

They can look at the cost of building it as much as they like, but I would suggest they mainly look at the cost of not building the barrier!!! We do not need any more invasive fish in our systems.


Michael from Toronto
said

I watched the video and I've seen enough. This whole scheme looks more like a multi-billion $ boondoggle designed to line the pockets of contractors and corrupt officials building these useless structures. I tell you, it's not Mother Nature or human error that are our biggest threats, it's pure greed, stupidity and corruption.


Michael from Toronto
said

I don't think physical barriers work. They may slow down the invasion but there are too many ways that fish can get past barriers. They are better off to develop genetically engineered variants like genetically crippled fish where the males produce sterile sperm and the females produce eggs with genes that cause sterility. Farm a large quantity of such fish and repeatedly release them into areas where the carp spawn. This strategy affects not 1 but 2 generations of fish. Do this enough times and the species will die off.


Munro - Brampton
said

I really hope they do something about this. I remember Lake Erie used to have nice sandy beaches. Sure it was brown sand, but nice to lay in the sun on. In the early 90's the zebra mussel finally ruined the beaches. They are covered with broken shells that feel like glass. Very sad.


Samantha
said

That is one UGLY fish!


Stephen Schreinert
said

I live along the shore of Lake Huron by Goderich Ontario. I have slowly watched the decline in salmon stocks here where the natural salmon river run has almost disappeared. It is a matter of time before our Great Lkes will give up its natural fish stocks to these invasive spceices.


joe canada
said

These fish are a real problem. Hopefully they can figure something out before these waters are totally killed off of other species. Fishing tournaments and bounties may help a bit also? I know pet stores that used to sell snakeheads, and gwars and when they get dumped into water ways they will also kill everything. Some fish should never make it to stores to sell.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Anne-Catherine Powers, Shakti Ramsurrun, Gatineau, Quebec

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  2 Video(s) 2

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?