Canada -   

1
Jose Ramon Acosta Quintero, aka 'El Ray', is presented to the press in Mazatlan, Mexico, Saturday, Jan. 28, 2012. (AP / Christiann Davis) Sheila Nabb and her husband Andrew are shown in a family handout photo. The family of Nabb, a Calgary woman who was severely beaten in Mexico, says she is out of a medically induced coma and is able to recognize her husband at her bedside. Sheila Nabb, 37, was found beaten and lying in a pool of blood in a hotel elevator in the popular Mazatlan tourist area in Mexico on Saturday, Jan 21, 2012. Sheila Nabb, 37, was found beaten and lying in a pool of blood in a hotel elevator in the popular Mazatlan tourist area in Mexico on Saturday, Jan 21, 2012. In this undated image Jose Ramon Acosta Quintero is seen.

Mexican man admits beating Nabb, says he was afraid

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: David Agren in Mexico
A journalist discusses how there is a lot of concern in Mexico on how the beating case will affect tourism in the country.
CTV National News: Mexico suspect admits attack
Mexican authorities publicly presented their suspect Saturday in the brutal beating of a Canadian tourist, along with a startling account of what happened. CTV's Los Angeles Bureau Chief Tom Walters reveals the stunning details.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (27) Facebook   

Jose Ramon Acosta Quintero, aka 'El Ray', is presented to the press in Mazatlan, Mexico, Saturday, Jan. 28, 2012. (AP / Christiann Davis) Sheila Nabb and her husband Andrew are shown in a family handout photo. The family of Nabb, a Calgary woman who was severely beaten in Mexico, says she is out of a medically induced coma and is able to recognize her husband at her bedside. Sheila Nabb, 37, was found beaten and lying in a pool of blood in a hotel elevator in the popular Mazatlan tourist area in Mexico on Saturday, Jan 21, 2012. Sheila Nabb, 37, was found beaten and lying in a pool of blood in a hotel elevator in the popular Mazatlan tourist area in Mexico on Saturday, Jan 21, 2012. In this undated image Jose Ramon Acosta Quintero is seen.

Photos

Jose Ramon Acosta Quintero, aka 'El Ray', is presented to the press in Mazatlan, Mexico, Saturday, Jan. 28, 2012. (AP / Christiann Davis)

View Larger Image

Date: Sun. Jan. 29 2012 11:35 AM ET

A 28-year-old Mexican man who confessed to beating and abandoning a Canadian tourist in a luxury resort elevator says he attacked the woman out of fear.

"It wasn't planned or anything like that. It just happened in the moment," José Ramón Acosta Quintero told reporters at a Saturday news conference.

Sheila Nabb, a 37-year-old office manager from Calgary, had been on vacation with her husband Andrew at the five-star Hotel Riu Emerald Bay in Mazatlan when she was found beaten and bloodied in a hotel elevator.

Police arrested Quintero in connection with the attack on Friday. The next day authorities paraded him before the media to tell his version of what happened to Nabb.

"I didn't try to abuse her, or I didn't … I didn't try to kill her or anything like … or rob her or anything. I was just afraid and I wanted to leave," said Quintero.

Prior to the assault, Quintero said he had been drinking with a Canadian friend and "doing a line of cocaine." He told reporters that he got into the elevator with the intention of riding to the top floor and gazing down at the lights of the resort city.

He says he encountered Nabb, who he said wasn't wearing any clothes, at the sixth floor. When Quintero tried to prevent her from leaving he said she screamed, and he panicked.

"I didn't try to abuse her, or I didn't … I didn't try to kill her or anything like … or rob her or anything. I was just afraid and I wanted to leave."

Quintero said he covered Nabb's mouth and asked her not to yell.

"But she continued yelling," he said. "She got more afraid when I covered her mouth. And then I hit her ... four or five times in the face with my fist. And then I left."

Police have said they identified Quintero from surveillance footage showing a man exiting the elevator in question.

Authorities also say they found blood on Quintero's sandals which matches the blood of the victim, reporter Ioan Grillo told CTV News Channel on Saturday.

Quintero maintains that he didn't kick Nabb at any point during the attack.

"I've seen the video and it does show that I put my foot back into the elevator but… it wasn't a kick," the slight young man told reporters, speaking in both fluent English and Spanish.

In his version of events, Quintero said he was trying to push Nabb's hand back into the elevator to allow the doors to close so that he could leave.

Freelance reporter David Agren, who attended the news conference, said police are struggling to identify a clear motive in Nabb's assault.

Quintero, however, told the media that the beating was driven by pure panic. Speaking in a neon orange construction vest, he stammered while trying to tell reporters that he didn't intend to harm Nabb.

Nabb's family has said that every bone in her face was broken after the attack.

She was flown back to Calgary on Friday via a private air ambulance and was taken to hospital where doctors put her into a medically induced coma.

Her jaw had to be wired shut before facial reconstructive surgery. It isn't clear whether Nabb had that surgery in Mexico.

Back in the resort town of Mazatlan, hundreds of kilometres away from the woman he says he attacked, Quintero waits to appear before a judge to face charges of attempted murder.

Comments are now closed for this story

GB in SK
said

Interesting. When Canadians are arrested and held in Mexico we talk of the questionable Mexican legal system but we are ok with a "suspect" being put in front of cameras & microphones to tell the media what happened when a Canadian is attacked.


dante
said

My prayers go out to Shelia Nabb and family. I am not going to condemn Mexico nor it's people. Assaults and attempted Murders like this are happening all over. Anyone heard of the horrific Shafia trial. Quintero deserves a fair trial just like the Shafia family where he can display just like them, that he is guilty just like them. Thank the Lord time there is a living witness/victim.


Jack
said

Richard, more Canadians have been hurt in Surrey because there are more Canadians in Surrey! How many Canadians do you think were in Mazatlan that night? Do the math man! Mexico is a dangerous, lawless land of drugs and corrupt police. Many of you are too cheap to travel elsewhere so you try to justify your choice to fuel the corruption by going to Mexico. You wouldn't catch me dead there, or maybe you would!


AhoIza
said

Did anyone see a pic of this guy's hands?


JS
said

I don't believe for one second that Sheila Nabb was naked in that elevator. The Mexican police are trying to make her look bad. I also don't think that the man they are showing on TV with no lawyer to represent him, is the man who did it. To produce the kind if injuries that poor woman had it would take more than 5 or 6 punches in the face. This whole scene has one purpse only: to save Mexian tourism and show that the Mexican police are doing their jobs.


Gman
said

This guy can hit better than a UFC fighter! He better get in the cages and make some money to pay all the medical bills! Better yet maybe the Mexican government can anti up some money to pay the bills. Take all that money and give it to Shiela! I know what happened to her can never be undone, but I see people are raising money for her and I think the dude and the Mexican government can compensate her! The reporters have this whole story messed up and the public does not know all the facts!!!!!!! This is the first time I heard she was naked! Was she sleep walking? Did the husband hire this guy? How was the marriage? Was this a trip to patch up a breaking marriage? All questions we as the public don't know, so I don't understand why we come to conclusions! Reporters and the public!why did they not interview the husband for media coverage? I can't understand why they interviewed the uncle that wasn't even there. Does your uncle know most of the things you do? I know mine don't! How about interviewing the mother or the brother or sister or other hotel guests or workers and guards? Why did the Mexican authorities always want to point a finger back at another tourist? I like Mexico, but hate the corruptness of the authorities and the police! People should realize that they need to be street smart no matter where they go! This happens in all countries and especially third world ones! It happens even more frequently in our home turf than what more people want to admit! I will still go to Mexico , but I will stay clear of the drug trafficking ares! God bless you Shiela, have a speedy recovery.


Marie
said

(Continued from previous post) To put things in perspective, the murder rate in the Yucatan state of Mexico is 2 per 100,000. That’s about the same as Fond du Lac, Wisconsin or Evansville, Indiana. Mexico City’s is 8 per 100,000. Despite being one of the most populated cities on the planet, that’s on par with Albuquerque, NM. I don’t know about you, but I’ve never felt scared in Albuquerque…The number of Canadians killed in Mexico has increased in recent years, from three in 2009 to six in 2011.


Marie
said

One needs to look in his own backyard. The medias are experts in exaggeration. Regardless of this specific situation or others please take a look at statistics before making unfounded comments about other countries. Take a look at those statistics from the Calgary police for 2011 for the city of Calgary alone:Assault:Level 3 - Aggravated 6 Level 2 - Weapon/Bodily Harm 83 Level 1 - Common Assault 321Assault Police Officer 10 Discharge Firearm with Intent 3 Other Assaults 2 Total Assault 425 Misc Person Crimes 29 TOTAL PERSON CRIMES 592Travel Safety in perspective: There’s been a lot of news coverage about violence in Mexico, very little of it bothering to note that Mexico is a huge country with thirty-some states and that a) almost all of that violence is narco-related and b) you can count the number of tourists affected on one hand. Officially, 111 U.S. citizens were killed in Mexico last year, a third in just two cities. Almost all of them were involved in illicit vocations, usually the trafficking of guns, drugs, or people across the border. This is 111 out of close to 8 million visitors, with nearly 1 million of those being part- or full-time residents choosing Mexico over the U.S. or Canada. You know who else had 111 murders in one year recently? Boston. And Las Vegas. And Orlando. Are any tourists scared of going to those places? Meanwhile, almost 1,000 U.S. citizens died in Puerto Rico. Nobody running the news desks cares about Puerto Rico or has an incentive to make people scared of Puerto Ricans (by nature, they can’t be “illegal immigrants”), so this isn’t widely reported. (Continued in another post)


terrytoogood
said

Sorry folks this story stinks...i cant imagine the naked angle and that part of it. i cant imagine a more sinister action by a human on another incapacitated human. But to parade the accused without due process and with out legal council and the story lines jumping from premeditated to i dunno is another reason i would not use the mexihole for anything but a stop over to some where safe and not some third world palace in the sand..i worked the princess cruise lines and found the dry dock in newport news virginia to be the most dangerous and knee shaking area i ever was in my life. Try the hotels in Port Angelos where the boats dock and see how far you could walk down the street before you became a victim. believe me there are worst places in your home town. The difference is most people know it and avoid it. So when on vacation we seem to put the radar away and shelve our comman sense and gleefully parade around with some superman like impunity and behave like we are safe.....very sad


Renate
said

100 % a patsy, I think they need a fall guy so tourist feel they caught the guy and tourists are coming to Mexico. I wish Canadian police actually would review this case. It stinks all the way to Canada.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

Bad enough to be almost beaten to death without being morally slandered in the press. Likely it is a bad idea to ride around naked in any elevator -- or use the drive-thru lane here in Canada. If the naked part is true -- and I WOULD BE VERY SKEPTICAL OF HIS WORDS. This guy is obviously unstable and dangerous to say the least. .


shannon
said

@ theolenbasset . when you are a tourist on vacation ,anything can happen. having been in cancun a few times i know tourist party all hours of the night. i know i found myself in some pretty weird places the morning after.i did not even remember how i got there. the thing is i would never party like that back in canada. but what happins on vacation should stay on vacation. to bad it did not in this case.


Mark O
said

Another alcohol fueled crime, I don't understand why they need to add & doing a line of cocaine, the buzz from a line of coke would have the effects of drinking a coffee. The only time coke is usually a factor is when someone is drinking heavily and they're using lots of coke to stay awake. My guess is it was the booze that was the cause of his irrational behavior.


harlo
said

there is lots of drugs in mexico. most of it is exported state side and weapons are imported from the states. it is not hard to get across the between the states and mexico. having said that i go to mexico often, but i stay away from the drug areas.i never had a problem. you can get mugged anywhere in the world. it is not a good idea to find yourself naked in an elevator in the middle of the night either..


Deborah Le Blanc, Montreal Quebec
said

Whole thing seems strange to me. It's very unusual for security to let any Mexican's on the property of a hotel, let alone allow them to drink with the tourists. Please don't bash Mexico, I've been there many times and had never had something happen to me. According to statistics, the U.S.A. had twice as many assaults as Mexico last year, with Florida being a very dangerous place to visit. The most important thing is: USE YOUR COMMON SENSE.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

One Theory: She sleepwalked her way, naked, into the elevator. (Her husband says he found the door of their hotel room open in the morning.) She encountered the accused (an intoxicated jackass of lesser character), who started chatting her up, obnoxiously hoping to get somewhere. Nabb, now awake, startled, and, naturally, intensely afraid, began freaking out and yelling. He panicked, knowing what was at stake (he wasn't supposed to be in the hotel, and has run afoul of the law before -- once accused of rape, from what I've heard -- and, charged with cocaine, he began beating her in a panic to shut her up. Like all such types when caught, his account of what happened has been "modified" (softened) in his own defense.


Karen
said

We just returned from Mexico a week ago. We stayed in the Riveria Mayan and felt 100 % safe the entire time... but we were guarded more so than at home. While we are away in a foreign country, we do not attempt silly stupid things that we would not do at home. I would not walk down a street at 3 a.m at home, so why would I do so in a different place. I do not believe this confession as well. Almost seems like this poor guy is talking the fall, but I also question why the victim was in an elevator, naked and alone at 2:30 in the morning. She did not deserve for this to happen but why did she put herself in a vulnerable situation in the first place.


Richard
said

Tim Douglass said: Hundreds of sun-seeking Canucks have been killed, badly beaten or robbed at gunpoint... ummm about 5 have been killed, some involved in some questionable activities... and far fewer than the number of Canadians recently killed in the Vancouver/Surrey area. I am in Merida Mexico right now and I feel quite safe walking around downtown in this beautiful colonial city.


joe canada
said

Grab some guy and MAKE him do a confession and keep those silly Canadian tourists coming and spending money. That is what I get out of this any way. It is time our government makes an official warning telling Canadians DO NOT GO TO MEXICO! Iraq would be safer.


Suspicious Sue
said

I have an awful feeling about this. Has anyone else ever seen a suspect paraded out to a press conference to confess his guilt? I wonder how much the Mexican tourism industry paid this guy to "confess". I'm relieved that Ms. Nabb is now safely back home in Canada.


edCP
said

Whether she was naked or clothed - no one has the right to beat a person to a pulp for that reason. If she was naked and under the influence why not help her cover up to protect her from savages such as this attacker.


Marco Yazner
said

Is this a joke? The guy confesses in front of the media with no lawyer? I doubt very much he is responsible for what happened. The Mexican government just needed to "show" us tourists that their country is safe and that the police take these assaults seriously. I'm sure in a few days he will be let go with a few pesos in his pocket for the trouble. Do Mexican's think we are stupid??


Paul ~ Kitchener
said

Thank God for seeing her back home & may His mercy sustain & guide her through a long recovery. It will be some time before the court can hear the full story. In the mean time let this perpritator sit in prison until "Full Justice" can be attained. Mexico is not known for "Full Justice", but, lets pray it comes close at least.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

And the whole story will continue to make no sense until the obvious missing piece of the puzzle is added.


Stephen - ottawa
said

This confession smells. So he hit her 5 or 6 times and left?? Can you see how weedy/skinny he looks? Unless he has the power of Brock Lesnar in his fist there is no way that skinny guy can break every bone in her face with 5 or 6 punches. Also, did anyone notice how the confession was lacking anything about kicking yet the initial reports all said that the security video showed someone repeately kicking something off camera? No kicks in his confession...


theolebasset
said

I just don't get it that the woman entered the elevator completely naked according to the police. Why??


Tom Douglas, Oakville, Ontario
said

While I have nothing but sympathy for the victim, I cannot understand why Canadians keep flocking to Mexico. Hundreds of sun-seeking Canucks have been killed, badly beaten or robbed at gunpoint in that country yet people keep going there. Go figure!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Two prominent Cardiologists in Montreal are disciplinary hearings before the Quebec College of Physicians over allegations they took money from a patient in exchange for future medical services.

Mtl. cardiologists under investigation for payments

More  1 Video(s) 1

Graham James is seen exiting the courthouse in Winnipeg, Wednesday, Feb. 22. 2012.

Graham James apologizes to victims, hockey community

More  3 Video(s) 3