Canada -   

1
Montreal Canadiens coach Randy Cunneyworth talks to a referee from behind the bench during the second period of an NHL hockey game against the Boston Bruins in Boston Randy Cunneyworth speaks at a news conference in Montreal Saturday, December 17, 2011 after being named as interim head coach of the Montreal Canadiens Randy Cunneyworth listens to Montreal Canadiens' general manager Pierre Gauthier speak at a news conference in Montreal Saturday, December 17, 2011 naming him as interim head coach of the Montreal Canadiens. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes Randy Cunneyworth

Habs fans stew over coach who can't speak French

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Coach already makes enemies
The Montreal Canadiens are feeling the heat after tossing aside a French-speaking head coach for an Anglophone replacement who can't speak the language that the majority of Quebecers understand. Genevieve Beauchemin has more on pucks and politics.
CTV Montreal: Habs owner responds to critics
Geoff Molson released a statement Monday after some francophone groups and individuals expressed alarm that the team has hired an interim coach who cannot speak French. Maya Johnson reports.
CTV Montreal: Language debate continues
Does Montreal need a bilingual hockey coach? La Presse sports analyst Francois Gagnon shares his opinion.
National Affairs: New hire under fire
Randy Tieman a sports anchor with CTV News Montreal and Allen Mendelsohn a Habs blogger discuss why so many Quebecers are upset about the new coach and also whether Randy Cunneyworth will last.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (86) Facebook   

Montreal Canadiens coach Randy Cunneyworth talks to a referee from behind the bench during the second period of an NHL hockey game against the Boston Bruins in Boston Randy Cunneyworth speaks at a news conference in Montreal Saturday, December 17, 2011 after being named as interim head coach of the Montreal Canadiens Randy Cunneyworth listens to Montreal Canadiens' general manager Pierre Gauthier speak at a news conference in Montreal Saturday, December 17, 2011 naming him as interim head coach of the Montreal Canadiens. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes Randy Cunneyworth

Photos

Montreal Canadiens coach Randy Cunneyworth talks to a referee from behind the bench during the second period of an NHL hockey game against the Boston Bruins in Boston

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Dec. 19 2011 10:32 PM ET

The Montreal Canadiens are feeling the heat after tossing aside a French-speaking head coach for an anglophone replacement who can't speak the language that the majority of Quebecers understand.

Many fans had been calling for the firing of Jacques Martin, the veteran coach who was let go from his job Saturday.

But when it was announced that his English-speaking assistant, Randy Cunneyworth, would be taking over behind the bench, some fans still weren't placated.

Cunneyworth can't speak French and for some Habs fans, that is a big slap in the face.

"In Quebec, the Canadiens aren't just a hockey team," sports writer Philippe Cantin said in a column published in Montreal's La Presse.

"They are also an institution. And like all institutions, they have a responsibility to the community."

In other words, some fans think their head coach should be able to speak directly to them in French, just like any other politician or leader would.

Sports columnist Rejean Tremblay said Monday that the coach of the Montreal Canadiens appears on TV in Quebec more often than Prime Minister Stephen Harper or Premier Jean Charest.

For that reason, he argues that the top Habs coach simply has to speak French.

"Eighty per cent of that province is French and that means that you cannot communicate with those people," he told CTV Montreal in a telephone interview on Monday.

The 50-year-old Cunneyworth is the first unilingual English-speaking coach to lead the Habs since Bob Berry in the early 1980s.

The controversy spurred Canadiens' owner Geoff Molson to issue a statement Monday, explaining the decision to promote Cunneyworth to the team's top job.

In his letter to fans, Molson said that Cunneyworth was in the best position to take over the team because of his role as an assistant coach.

"The action was taken to remedy the situation without further delay," Molson said. "Randy Cunneyworth is a qualified and experienced coach who has earned the respect of the players and everyone within the organisation."

Molson said the head coaching position will be re-evaluated at the end of the season. Finding a coach to help the team win will be the top priority, Molson said. However, language considerations will also factor into the decision.

"It is obvious that the ability for the head coach to express himself in both French and English will be a very important factor in the selection of the permanent head coach," he said.

Gilles Rheaume of La Ligue Quebecoise Contre La Francophonie Canadienne, which promotes French language and culture in Quebec, said "a good coach in Montreal is someone who speaks French."

In an interview with CTV Montreal, Rheaume called for a boycott against Molson products.

For his part, Cunneyworth said he hopes to learn French -- something that some Montreal players have done in the past.

And he does have supporters among the general public, who couldn't care less about his linguistic capabilities and more about his ability to get the Canadiens into the playoffs.

"J'ai un très bon feeling!" Sébastien Théberge, a Montreal-based communications professional, tweeted on the weekend after Cunneyworth was announced as the new Habs coach.

On Monday, Pierre Ferland, an executive with a human resources IT company, suggested on Twitter that "the only language fans really care about is WINNING."

With files from CTV Montreal and The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Old Ted
said

Most Quebecers understand English. I don't think there is going to be any problem with people understanding each other.


KC BC
said

It may be time for Quebecers to take their beloved Canadiens out of the NHL and begin an all French world league. Cities such as: Marseilles, Strasbourg, Nice, Paris, Lille, and Beaune would field some wonderful hockey teams for French Onlyviewers.


Linda in Vancouver
said

LOL!! This sounds a lot like an NDP policy in BC. A retiring MLA in their party has to be replaced by the best WOMAN for the job. But it is Quebec.And it is their team,and they have a right to hire the people they want.But if they extend this policy to players as well,I wonder how they will find enough top quality players to win anything. As a Habs fan in BC,I might have to look for another team to cheer for though.Not because of the language policy,but because cheering for a team that loses forever is a tough task for this sports fan.Rebuild years are no problem.But if a policy keeps the team losing,it's time to bail out of the fan base.


Kim in NB
said

Seriously? If the coach learns french will everyone just get over it? How about a few french learn english just as a show of good faith. HEY - learns all learn both languages we can just let it go. It's just a language regardless of which side you are on. I agree with others here - this is a non-issue.


Jason
said

I don't understand the big deal...I'm an English-speaking Habs fan and couldn't care less what language the coach speaks as long as the players understand...it's not like I'll be listening to the coach anyway.


Jagators63
said

why worry about language in Quebec ? get over it and move on , respect anyone's right to refuse to speak french in Quebec.


GC in Ont
said

In one of the posts below, someone has referred to the French as "Frogs"....how ignorant is that???


Take back Canada eh !!
said

Hey my fellow Canadians - aren't you fed up with this bigotry over language and political correctness? This was a great country - I want to take it back from these looney tunes who have tried to hijacked it and the best way is for all of us to get in their faces whenever they come up with this non-sense.


Jo
said

Aw damn. Do you go to a game to watch the players or talk to the coach?? Stop your whining!!


Not just ignorance
said

As a French Canadian, I somewhat understand the hate and ignorance of the posters here. After all, we may be like them if the Habs were perpetual losers like the Maple Leafs! and god knows what perpetual losing does to oneself....


IslandGuy
said

Just like international airline pilots, the official language of the NHL (and sports in North America in general) must be English. Regional sensitivities take a back seat to the larger interest. De son dommage.


Mike
said

Ok enough about having a coach that can speak only French or some French. If the coach is good for the team who cares what language they speak. I think Quebec needs to get a life and stop this 2nd language crap. I am forced to speak french in my job if I want to be promoted but the french don't have to speak english. Now is this fair, NO its not.


Don
said

I believe Hab fans should be able to converse in both languages with the teams coach..Even if the team has no French speaking players, its common courtesy when one lives in the Francophone enviromenti believe


Alfo
said

That small minded comment about boycotting all products of molson.....not very bright it is a company that has 100's of people working for them and the majority are French, as if we need more job cuts....you can always learn the language....hello people!


michael mcisaac
said

why should a coach have to speak a certain language just to please some people,what is important is that all the players,whether enlishor rusian,or swedis,or frenchcan under stand what he is trying to coachafter all the fans are not playing the game ,and after all winning is above all .


bikerborz
said

These so-called "Habs fans" need to get with the program. Why are the Canadiens (french spelling) called the Habs? Because, 'WAY back when, they used to be residents of Monteal... at least, of the Province of Quebec. That hasn't been true for decades. Now they have a (literally) international team. So what's with a non-French-speaking coach? This isn't 1950 anymore. Deal with it.


J.C.
said

I am not a big sports fan, however I do tire of this nonsense of having to speak french all the time. To me a job should go to the best qualified person regardless of which language they speak or what minority they belong to. As long as they speak one of the official languages of Canada then there should be no problem. That's why there are interpreters isn't it??


Coates
said

This is hilarious. Is it any wonder that French Canadians are a dying breed. They want another NHL team as well but they want the rest of Canada to foot the bill for the stadium. They want everything handed to them but don't want to do anything to get it. Once Bettman catches wind of this crap argument he surely won't want another team in that province. C'est la vie !!!


Den
said

This is 2011. It's time for Quebec to catch up to the rest of the world. I know some Quebecers love calling the language police everytime a person even thinks in English, but I have to say that bigotry works both ways. It is much bigotry when you discriminate against English people as it is if you discriminate against French people.


Victor in Vaughan
said

I agree with the Quebec sentiment about communication. Cunneyworth should understand and tell them he will try to learn French soon. French is an official language in Quebec, like or hate it. I know three languages and feel sorry for those that just know one, and complain about it. It's a big world outside and the driver's manual isn't only written in English.


Pip
said

Typical of those in Quebec and our Federal government who would rather have a Francophone regardless of ability than someone who speaks only English and is superior in ability. But then, not being a hockey fan - or a fan of government, come to that - what do I know?


Gisabun
said

Good luck in finding a coach who can speak French and can win and wants to coach in Montreal when the French media will hound you constantly.The blame this season is on Gauthier and not Martin. Martin was given the players and he was given players who can't score. Gauthier made no decent change this season except getting Cole but really didn't make sense in signing often injured Markov (who's laughing to the bank).


Robert B
said

C'est Les maudits francais encore, qui sont des plaiyards!!!


mirthful
said

You think that's bad, wait until they find out their players can't play hockey! *rimshot*


Gerald
said

@Jim-Surrey....Yours is the kind of comment I would expect coming from someone in Surrey.


Will
said

If wuebecers are unhappy, does anyone really care?


alain
said

Oh yeah..all you hypocrites who's comments for CTV French haters..however the day of the 1995 referendum, everybody "loved Quebec" and even flew to Quebec to support the "non" and who pleeded that the province be a part of Canada. WOW what an "about face". Quebec is better off souverain..oh that means NO QUEEN!!


spencer
said

Does the new coach have a drivers licence ?????Just think.....first time on the road and not an english sign in sight......or anywhere else in the province.....and the new coach is lost.....perhaps within sight of the Molson Centre.Is it just me, or is the gene pool in Quebec starting to look like it is shrinking ????


reidjr
said

Gord Most of the players don't speak french most of the media knows english this is a non issue.


Colin S
said

Typical, and a perfect example of why many people have a negative view of Quebec. They're worried about a french speaking coach, but not about a sub par product on the ice?


Nic
said

Typical French/Quebec attitude...not surprised.Ignorant!


WIN 14NOW
said

Habs fans..deal with it!Hockey is hockey, Cry Babies


Dave in que.
said

Nothing like the french english debate to bring out the pointed hats and white sheets.Any excuse to bash and bray like a biggoted jackass.


Jake
said

You have to respect the Quebec people's desire to save their language. In this case, the solution is simple: fire the English speaking coach. Hire a french speaking person to coach the team, even if he/she don't know anything about hockey. The language should outweigh winning!


Ron frrom Georgetwon
said

Quebec is a laughing stock around the world. A few years ago the coach of Englands soccer team could not speak English. They were looking for a coach not a political statement.


John
said

Talk about BS. There are 4 french speaking players on the team, 6 from US, 2 Czech, 3 Ont, 2 USSR, 2 Swiss, 1 BC, 1 Dane, 1 Sask, 1 Finn and 1 swede. I would bet anything the universal language in the dressing room is ENGLISH. As far as the idiot who complains about Chinese signs, at least we don't have language police


Hello.
said

Hockey is a sport, and is about achieving top form within that athletic arena. Quebec would have us believe that it's about mother tongue. Do they want the best choice for a coach, or someone with linquistic skills?


Johnny K
said

Habs fans are never happy. They had French coaches and fired them. The have english coaches and are mad because he doesn't speak French????. "Shoot Tabernac" is the same in both languages. They speak english 99% of the time on the ice anyway. Betteman, will make sure that Quebec City doesn't get another team with this kind of politics involved. I find it funny that even french hockey players don't want to sign with the Habs. and they speak the lingo?? Wonder why??? TOO MUCH POLITICS!!!


Thomas
said

I got the answer, go back to a unilingual, english official language country and stop these stupid french stuff now! I am sick of it.


Steven in Ottawa
said

Jacques Martin is an awesome coach. This is simply yet another example of very wealthy athletes who don't work hard enough to get the results expected of them. Cunneyworth has great leadership skills and is a former Ottawa Senators captain.


MikefromQuebec
said

The problem is that the team is made up of mostly players who don't speak any french. If your coach can't communicate with them, he's pretty much done. (Martin) An english coach should work out well here in Montreal where, contrary to popular belief, most of the people do speak English. Quite frankly, I think this is a made up crisis by the media to sell subscriptions. As long as the team benefits from the wisdom of the coach, it really doesn't matter what language he speaks does it?


Mike50
said

You must be joking right? Quebec is a PROVINCE, NOT a country. Yes it's pre-dominantly French, but for cying out loud, we're talking about sports. Not politics. If the guy can coach, win and bring honor back to the habs, montreal, quebec, then let him do is thing and the rest will follow.


Gord
said

I think a lot of people are a bit too fast to jump on the Montreal fans here. Have they considered how they would react if there local team hired a coach who did not speak English? Part of a coaches job is to communicate with the public. But I do think this is an issue for the hockey franchise to work out with its employees and fans so I'm not personally going to condemn the decision.


Calvin
said

Of course Habs fans in Quebec would prefer a loser who can speak French - that goes without saying. Francophone Quebecers can be such a small-minded parochial bunch. They are easily offended, deeply indignant and make themselves out to be fools by the enforcement of petty laws which even the lethargic UN has noted run contrary to human rights norms.


5th Generation Canadian
said

Heck, here in Toronto we'd welcome a coach who speaks only Klingon if he helped us to the Stanley Cup!!


DON
said

Who cares if he speaks FRENCH.This is CANADA and we are ENGLISH speaking people.


Sens/Habs Fan - Ottawa
said

If the coach of Montreal is interviewed by the Press at the end of a game..just make sure there is someone there to speak in french - what's the big deal..when Koivous was the Captain people were upset about him also (and he could speak French but was not a french Canadian) but neglected to say he gave a lot of money to a hospital there to buy special equipment. This is totally ignorant on the part of this province...it should be about the Sport not the language...


Hunky Dory
said

What a bunch of crybabies!! Poor Quebec's will do anything to play poor me! The Habs suck and always will. In English or French!!


Dixie from Alberta
said

They're not worried about winning? He can always learn to speak French but winning should be first. I think the French just like complaining about everything...they will never be satisfied.


Paul
said

Here, to appease the usual ignorant masses in Que. , I'll assist the new coach in his first locker room address..... " Nous ne jouerons pas de (H)Ockey ce printemps, les gars."


Lina
said

Dear Quebec: Please get over yourselves. Sincerely,~ Canada


Stanley Kapooniack in the Arctic
said

Hey Reese, if Canada is a bi-lingual country, why is that English signs are illegal, even when the company has an English name? It is about time that the Quebecois learned to be part of Canada and accept English speaking people and their right to speak that language.


Dave W, Lacombe, AB
said

If the Habs start winning under Cunneyworth, this'll be a non-issue. Just another example of how Quebec (or at least the people who think this is an issue) is not part of the real world! Right now, English is the language of North America; and if one wants to learn a second language, the more practical one is Chinese as that will likely be the language of the future!


Paul ~ Kitchener
said

Hey Quebec "This is CANADA" and Quebec is not yet its own country ~ although it things it is. Maybe the Quebecers could learn ENGLISH. Its the best man for the job, not the man who speaks FRENCH, but, can't do the job . The sport first, the language second.


Jim
said

I"m a Habs fan and I think this is ridiculous! It shouldn't matter if the coach can speak french or not.


Mar
said

Reece, do you know how many of the players are french? Many players probably don't even speak French, or if they do they certainly aren't fluent! The coach does not need to speak French to communicate with the players, otherwise all the players would have to be from Quebec because very few other players are fluent enough in French to be able to be coached in French. What is the big deal if he needs a translator to talk to the media? As long as he can coach, he is good to go.


David H in Ottawa
said

After following the Habs for now merely 30 some years, one starts to grow tired of the media that surrounds this team. Our interest should rest on how this team preforms, and not what language the coach speaks. Face it, if the team started a winning streak, would there still be as many cries?


Bob
said

You think that they would accept that French is a dying language. At the rate we are going we better all learn Chinese !


Pete
said

This is just too stupid for words. Does every player on the Habs team speak French Canadian?? I think not they were hired to play hockey not give speeches. Get over yourselves. The language the coach uses every team member will get the meaning trust me.


Hoppy
said

If you eliminate all English speaking coaches, the number of French speaking is very small. Do the fans want a lousy coach that speaks French or a good coach that speaks English? Can't have it both ways.


Jayme
said

ReeceNo matter how you cut it the best person should have the job if it comes down to he to be able to speak french well then the habs could be in serious trouble.


Paul from Pickering
said

There are mostly English-speaking Canadians coaching all over the world. If the citizens of those countries are happy to have unilingual coaches from Canada because of their skills, why shouldn't Quebecers be happy too? Naive? Who me?


rmsbl4
said

All this bellyaching over a team from QC that only have three YES 3 players from QC on it.Click on Montreal and see all the comments for this same story that are already posted there. There are 11 from Canada, 5 from U.S. and 11 players from Europe on their roster according to the NHL Network.


Mike
said

As with Ottawa and the government it's not about your qualifications to do a job, it's about your ability to communicate in both official languages on how you can't do the job.


Jack
said

It's a job that he was qualified to do. Quebecers have to understand that we have Charter Of Rights and not giving a job to someone because they don't speak french is discriminatory.


Lou
said

I am sure once les Canadians start winning the bebes fans will stop their whinning and not mention the french language.


firstMickey
said

Is he hired to teach a language or to help the team to win at hockey? I think it is the latter. Language is immaterial when it comes to winning a hockey game.


Dave T
said

Suck it up Quebec you wanna win or do you wanna keep loosing !! If his TEAM can understand him thats all that matters..Like Really


al
said

I don't know man...I am a French speaking canadian outside of Québec and if there was a referendum I would vote "OUI". however I am a huge MTL Canadiens fan and I would do anything to see some Habs in the top ten scoring race, 2 fifty goal scorers, a Norris trophy winner and I want my HABS win another stanley cup.


John Lethbridge
said

ha ha, no sympathy from Lethbridge


Jim-Surrey
said

Seems the frogs have forgotten that their jargon is the "second" language in Canada and not needed to speak to anyone...................


mike
said

Please Please get a coach that speaks french and you will stay losers for years.What you dont realize is that you have a small group to pick from which gives you very little choice.If he is good for the job you should be happy that you team wins. Once again politics gets into sports where it doesn't belong.But if you habs fans and are content with a second rate coach then fill your hats.Ottawa is happy with our coach.


Sissy
said

Seriously who cares! If he is a good coach and can get the team to win,what difference does it make.The french language is on it;s way out!!!


ajay
said

get over it! so what if he doesnt speak french! you're not too bothered with having a team that cant play hockey!


Happy ex-Quebecer
said

Maybe the Hababies in Quebec would prefer a loser who can speak french rather than a winner who doesn't? There is a "B" word for that kind of thinking but I wont say it lest we upset the "politically (in)correct" crowd who might get their "feelings" offended. Insane this leftie world we have made.


Original Canadien
said

As a bilingual Habs fan, I want the best coach available for the team, not just one that speaks French. I disagree with the peopel who are making this an issue. The only requisite I'd apply to anglophone coaches is to take French lessons, which everyone in the hockey world know, is a requirement for the team albeit unofficial.


S in Vancouver
said

Seems to me it's more valuable to promote the assistant coach to head coach since he already knows how the team works. Probably easier to ask one man to learn French than to bring in an outside hire and disrupt the strategies and team dynamics of a multimillion dollar sports franchise...


Kathy
said

The Habs fans need to get over themselves. Either they want a new coach or they don't but really what difference does it make if the coach speaks french or not. I'm sure that the majority of the players don't speak french so do you think that they care?


MN
said

What a joke!


Reece
said

Before any of you go on this anti-French rant, how do you feel when you are driving around in Vancouver looking for a restraunt only to be confronted with pre-dominated Chinese characters? And when you some how catch the small English words you enter the restraunt only to have a waitress who cant speak the native language? The French Canadians are the ones who have it right - it certainly is not us. Preserve the friggin language. This isnt a Russian, Chinese, or Spanish speaking country no matter how multi-cultural we are. Being multicultural suddenly means that you dont have to speak either official languages? Since when? When this coach applied for the job didnt he realize he had to communicate with players, the public in FRENCH? What a tool!


JoeMcS
said

Randy is an excellent coach and motivator. That's what the team needs. Had you fired the right person (Gauthier) you would not be seeking anyone for the coaching position. Who is left that is French to coach the team? Hartley?.... good luck Habs, Randy will do you good.....


Peter
said

What language the coach speaks should not even be an issue. Can he coach? OK - good.


RK
said

Substitute English for French, and Toronto for Montreal and this article would sound pretty ignorant and discriminatory. Oh wait, it already is. Why we allow the xenophobic francophone ideology to exist in our politically correct modern era is beyond me. Join the 21st century – and by the way, someone can always learn a new language, although ignorance is much harder to cure.


Lori
said

Hey Habs......you're making the Leafs look good!


Matt in NB
said

This article makes me smile. It's so symbolic of Quebec. They're just never happy with what they have.


Jason
said

Quebec, please don't turn this into another linguistic debate. Your political leaders barely speak english yet aspire to lead our country as Prime Minister one day. There's irony in your argument. Not to mention the fact that when you do speak, every other word is in english anyway. Case in point, Sebastien Theberge's quote in this article of "J'ai un tres bon feeling". And, he's a communications professional to boot! It's about having the right person for the job, regardless of language spoken. Not everything in life needs to be french.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  2 Video(s) 2

Wind damage following a storm in Ottawa is shown on Friday, May 25, 2012. (Bob Antonietti / MyNews.CTV.ca)

Teen struck by lightning during Ottawa storm

More

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?