Canada -   

1
Attawapiskat Reserve Former prime minister Paul Martin speaks to CTV News Channel on Oct. 11, 2011. Former Prime Minister Paul Martin

Paul Martin: Education at root of Attawapiskat troubles

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Attawapiskat forced to pay
Attawapiskat is being forced to pay the salary of the accountant appointed by the government to solve the financial crisis. That's more than $1,000 a day that won't be spent on housing. CTV's Daniele Hamamdjian has the details.
Power Play: Trouble for Attawapiskat
Pamela Palmater a representative for the centre of indigenous governance at Ryerson University and David Harper, the Grand Chief of MKO North discuss the unfortunate news of the Attawapiskat ordered to pay money to the government.
Power Play: Politics behind Attawapiskat order
Greg Rickford the Parliamentary secretary to Aboriginal Affairs minister and Charlie Angus a representative for the NDP discuss the politics behind the Attawapiskat's paying money to an Ottawa appointee.
CTV News Channel: Paul Martin, former PM
Former prime minister Paul Martin is calling on the Tories to strengthen its relationship with First Nations people. He says there has to be a better way of working with the Aboriginal leadership and areas like education must be properly funded.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (25) Facebook   

Attawapiskat Reserve Former prime minister Paul Martin speaks to CTV News Channel on Oct. 11, 2011. Former Prime Minister Paul Martin

Photos

Attawapiskat Reserve

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Dec. 8 2011 11:01 AM ET

The federal government's response to the crisis in Attawapiskat must begin with a renewed focus on education, says former prime minister Paul Martin.

Martin, who helped usher in the Kelowna Accord which sought to improve the plight of Aboriginals across Canada, said education is vastly underfunded on reserves, where it is the responsibility of the federal government.

Elsewhere in Canada the provinces and territories are in charge of education.

"20-40 per cent less money is spent on education in primary and high school on reserves, compared to what provinces spend in their jurisdiction," Martin told CTV News Channel.

"Most Canadians would not send their children to the kind of schools that Ottawa asks Aboriginals or First Nations to attend on a reserve."

The community of Attawapiskat rocketed into the headlines last month when leaders declared a state of emergency and images began to emerge of uninsulated plywood shacks, moldy housing and large families crammed into small houses.

The community's elementary school has been closed since 2000 with classes being held in portables.

Since the story first broke, the federal government has taken over management of the community, complaining that $90 million has been spent there in the last six years and the money doesn't seem to have been managed properly.

Martin said part of the problem is that the Conservatives turned their back on the Kelowna Accord, which was the result of 18 months of discussions between the federal government, the premiers and aboriginal leaders.

Many aboriginal leaders saw the agreement as a breakthrough for native people in Canada, placing a new focus on education, employment and living conditions for First Nations.

However, after Martin's government fell in 2006 and the Conservative minority government took office, the Kelowna Accord was never fully implemented.

Instead, Martin said, the Conservatives implemented a strategy of imposing decisions on Aboriginal communities, rather than working with them to find solutions.

"We've got to understand these are this country's first people. They were here long before we came, they had their existing traditions, their existing beliefs and the fact of the matter is they had their identity and they want to maintain that identity and that is perfectly natural."

Comments are now closed for this story

Rick in the Hat
said

Suggest, we establish a military training base along side of there place. Our engineeers can build or improve infrastructure. The tax money would be indirectly managed by Defence personnel and they would create a commerce by spending their dollars in the community and hiring local people. Win, Win, Win.


MARG MM
said

Well, Mr Martin if education is the answer, why didn't your Government offer up what you are proposing now during the 13 years that the Liberals had a majority. It is always easy to have the solution when you are no longer in power. Keep in mind that the Conservatives have only had a majority for 6 months, that's MONTHS not years. Anything could have been done up to that point by the Liberals/ NDP who are now blaming the Conservatives for something that has been going on for years. Go figure!!!!


JDF - Calgary
said

I voted conservative because: The Liberals never listen and the NDP will never understand.MONEY DOESN'T ALWAYS ANSWER THE PROBLEM. IT ONLY SERVES TO BANKRUPT THOSE WHO PAY.


Anne
said

Of course education is key - and might spell the end of reservations because and educated individual would not wish to live like that. Incentive to not put money into schools hmm??? As for the rest - well, baloney - native kids get everything for free - including post secondary education that even covers daycare, transportation to/from school, books, rent, food etc etc etc. Quit trying to paint this community as dirt poor - as with the African countries, look to the Chiefs and Leaders, you'll find where the money went.


Brian Fr Langley
said

Mr. Martin's comments smack of "white mans burden" The sickenly racist ideology of hair pulling, guilt ridden, apologists for the imperialist policies of our Great, Great grandparents. The solution to this current unhappy situation, is to end the failed attempt to save these long lost cultures by collectivizing their heirs. Give our 1st Nations private property rights (on their reserves) like the rest of us. Until then prosperity for 1st Nations will be exceptionally difficult.


Marg
said

First: shame ,shame on the government for allowing natives "Canadians" i might add to have to live this way this long. if they were new to the country they would be treated to only the best accomadations available here in Canada and would have access and the money to only the best stores to buy food and clothing with the money the government gives out . it's always the children that suffer "WHY" show us the tax payers, " WHERE IS THE MONEY" that you gave and why are the children suffering? just asking


Seeking Wolf
said

uncle paul had his chance and blew it, as he did everything else. NO.


Ian Ottawa
said

Education is required but lets not forget that the average student on the Reserves are being torn between customs that in themselves will hold them back and also that they will be basically going from an age of unknowns to the space age and it will be difficult. The old ways shouldn't be forgotten but they are still old ways and we have to be supportive and sympathetic.


James, Ontario
said

A few people have posted something along these lines, I just want to say that I agree. Paul Martin had the power to fix this problem and many others for a very long long time. (Not only his time as PM but also as finance minister) Very few people in our history have had that much power for as long as he did. If anything he's responsible for these kinds of situations through his own negligence. They were simply not his priority; he's a great big hypocrite. Please take a bow, Mr. Martin and exit stage left.


rick
said

The real problem that no one will talk about is kids haveing kids having kids the results are disasterous and are only going to get worse. Then add to that most of these communities have absolutely no economic base. We something similiar on the east coast promoting people to stay in communities with no economic base has no logic to it at all. It only makes common sense that you need to move to where the economy is.


Windsor
said

$90,000,000.00 over 6 years devided by 2000 people living in the community works out to $7500.00 per person per year.How much infructure do you think you can buy for that much money?In Windsor Ontario we just spent $60,000,000.00 to up grade our sewer system and need another $30,000,000.00 to fix up 3 miles of old sewers. We are trying to build a new Aquidic centre at a cost of $65,000,000.00Lets get real people the costs of building in the Northern Ontario aera is much greater than what it costs to build the same in Southern Ontario.Every thing used to create a construction project must be flown in durring the summer or taken in over ice roads in the winter, the transportation costs alone are huge.It is about time that we the non native Canadian took responsibility to care for our origional native peoples, our fore fathers are the ones who are responsible for forcing the native peoples off their traditional lands on onto resverations, These resverations were the least desirable lands available.If you still think that there living conditions are OK then go there and stay for a week or longer and live as we have forced our Native Canadians to live.


Jim in Ottawa
said

"We've got to understand these are this country's first people. They were here long before we came, they had their existing traditions, their existing beliefs and the fact of the matter is they had their identity and they want to maintain that identity and that is perfectly natural." I think Mr Martin is the one in need of more education. I'm not sure what new insights he provided by making this babbling, meaningless statement--much like his own 25 months as PM, he said a lot of meaningless things that produced no measureable results. His inaction may partly explain some of the consequences that we're witnessing today in Attawapiskat.


Jazz
said

Proper education is a step in the right direction but only if the students and their parents will give it a try. I have seen so many First Nation's students make no effort in grade/high schools and completely drop off the map when they go off to university with their free education.


CMQ
said

The only education missing here is on how our funds are being misused. How come other networks are giving a breakdown of how monies are being spent and are doing so with a certified accountant going step by step through the process. Salaries and administrative costs ran 15-17 million dollars of the 34 that was given to the reserve just last year. Why so much for 1800 people. Some people are being paid well. Let's have some bare facts here CTV on what is really going on! Then we can provide some real help.


kg1
said

well said John


Steve T
said

So, just to be clear Mr. Martin, you want to provide money to First Nations with strings attached (ie - it must be spent on education). As much as I agree with this approach ($x must be spent on food; $y must be spent on housing; etc...), I thought this was heavily resisted by aboriginals, and many apologists for the gross mismanagement of funds already provided. You can't have it both ways.


MIkeW
said

So what are you saying Martin, drop more money which will vanish into a hole.You did the square root of zero when you were in power, thank God for a very short time only. Go back and crawl under your rock you were hiding uder


RJ in Halifax
said

When are politicians going to stop playing politics with this serious issue? Paul Martin is simply continuing this trend. If the Kelowna Accord was so important, why did Paul Martin, the Liberals, the NDP and the Bloc not force the Conservatives to enact and adhere to it? The Conservatives only got a majority in May, 2011. I find it hard to believe that this reserve was fully functional, adequately funded, p[roper schooling in place and running smoothly until May, 2011. It seems all non-Conservatives are blaming Stephen Harper for a mess that has taken years to build up, virtually all of which has occured when the Conservatives had NO MAJORITY to enforce any of their policies.


George V.
said

If Paul Martin knew the problems and knew the answers of Attawapiskat when he was Prime Minister up to 2006. Why did he not implement all his suggestions at that time as it would have avoided all the hardships they are encountering today. The best sea captains are always on shore. Hindsight is is always 20-20. Dithering Paul please go back to obscurity.


JT in Vancouver
said

The only education necessary here is for the REST of Canada. The time has come to cut off all the freebies that these people recieve. No more free money, education, housing, and its time to pay taxes. It's long past time to end all of this. These people are Canadians. That's it, time to act like it! Get a job and pay your own way in this world like the rest of us!


Gilbert in Ottawa
said

With all do respect Mr. martin,Please enjoy your retirement. Canada has moved forward since you retired, and things have changed.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Don't think so, Mr. Martin. (But, thanks.) The "Kelowna Accord" amounted to another misguided left-wing idea of throwing a fat pile of money at a problem in order to solve it ($5B over 10 years). It lacked focus and targeted expenditures, administrative monitoring and proper accounting, and failed to address the need (profoundly evident today) for systemic reform. Scrapping it demonstrated rational intelligence on the Conservatives' part. Having read the consolidated financial statements for Attawapiskat (online), it is obvious that the problem here still boils down to near-criminal mismanagement of money. Nobody in that First Nations community should be lacking shelter, any basic essentials, or a proper education. The "emergency" there can't be explained with the former Liberal PM's worthless coins of wisdom.


JB in Ontario
said

We need to smoke the peacepipe and remember these Aboriginals were here in this great land first. I agree, education should be equivalent to ordinary citizens of Canada. There should also be classes taught by natives who know Aboriginal culture and teach it in the classroom! This also provides employment on the reserve and those individuals who choose to further their education can feel free to come back to the reserve and continue with education or be leaders in the Band.When I was working on a native reserve in northern Manitoba for a year, most natives were very interested in hunting, fishing, trapping and playing hockey. It was a wonderful experience for myself. They need to be treated with respect and it will benefit all Canadians.


John
said

The hypocrisy is staggering. Paul Martin had 13 years as part of the leadership of this country and he did nothing. Now he blames the conservatives? We're all angry and upset about what's happening in this community, that's why we want to know where the hell that $90M went? This would be a good time for the politicians to shut up and actually do something.


Raj
said

I heard one chief on a BC Chanel that the Kelowna accord would not of helped, and that it would certainly not of helped this situation It was more taxpayers money, and this would still have happened.Talk is cheap Martin, perhaps have a word with the MP of that riding .he's NDP and the MPP is also NDP!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  1 Video(s) 1

Wind damage following a storm in Ottawa is shown on Friday, May 25, 2012. (Bob Antonietti / MyNews.CTV.ca)

Teen struck by lightning during Ottawa storm

More

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?