Canada -
News Sections
Border info-sharing plan triggers privacy concerns
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTVNews.ca Staff
Date: Tue. Nov. 29 2011 8:53 PM ET
Under a new joint Canada-U.S. border security plan both countries will be able to track the movement of cross-border travellers to crack down on citizenship fraud, illegal immigrants and war criminals living in North America.
But the new 32-point border plan, which will be signed by Prime Minister Stephen Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama next week, is also raising privacy concerns over the amount of information that will be shared.
CTV's Ottawa Bureau Chief Robert Fife said the new arrangement will mean a greatly increased level of information will be exchanged daily between the two countries.
"What is going to be new is that every time someone comes into Canada or leaves they will be marked coming in or going out so we'll know exactly where they are," Fife told CTV's Canada AM.
"It will be the same when you enter the United States. If you go to the United States and show your passport to the Americans it will show that you've entered, they will send that information back to Canada and the same when you've exited."
Part of the goal, Fife said, is to keep better tabs on people who obtain landed immigrant status in Canada but then return to their home country to live, while still collecting Canadian benefits such as health coverage.
The system will also help Ottawa track the roughly 40,000 illegal immigrants currently believed to be living in Canada, as well as potential terrorists and war criminals.
However, Privacy Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart is concerned about the amount of information that will be shared -- particularly since she hasn't been consulted on the project, Fife said.
Because thousands of people cross the Canada-U.S. border each day, vast volumes of information will potentially be sent back and forth between the two countries every day.
Fife said Stoddard has indicated she would want strict limits placed on the type of information that can be shared with U.S. customs and immigration officials.
Under the current proposal border officials would be able to send additional information about the subject if security concerns were raised.
"They'll be able to pass that additional info on to the U.S. and vice-versa and this is the grey area where the privacy commissioner wants to make sure there are strict controls over how this information is shared," Fife said.
Currently each country's border keeps a record of those who enter or leave, but that information isn't automatically shared.
In past public comments, Stoddart has made it clear that Canadian sovereignty and privacy rights must be protected.
"Rather than jumping into a newly defined relationship with both feet, we should only do so with both eyes wide open," Stoddart wrote on her blog recently.
The federal government insists there is little to worry about.
"When I go to the United States today, you have to provide your home, your birth date, your passport information, your travel information," said Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird. "Whenever we look at security, we keep in mind privacy concerns are tremendously important to Canadians, and that's something we feel very strongly about."
In exchange for more information about travelers crossing the border from Canada, Washington has responded to a chief Canadian gripe about cross-border traffic: gridlock.
Along with security, parts of the new border plan will focus on trade, including pre-screening stations set up on Canadian territory, meaning less congestion at the actual border crossing.
Under the terms of the new deal, the U.S. will move to cut down on traffic at border crossings and allow pre-screenings on certain low-risk cargo trucks. In an effort to speed the process, U.S. officials will only flag suspicious vehicles at the border rather than doing full inspections that hold up other passengers and cargo.
The 32-point plan also features more than just new border-crossing protocols.
In fact, both nations plan to streamline and harmonize regulations in the automotive and food sectors.
In particular, Ottawa has already quietly prepared regulations to adopt U.S. crash-testing standards for seat belts and built-in child booster seats.
User Tools
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
PBW
said
ouifyg
said
Janessa
said
Dennis L. Krahn
said
Lz in Edmonton
said
Jim - North Saanich, BC
said
AM
said
Dave in Edm
said
Check The Food
said
Free to Travel
said
Steve in Vancouver
said
Over Here
said
Cameron in Deux-Montagnes
said
Scott in Langley
said
Alice
said
true north
said
joe canada
said
If it gets the lefties going, it must be good
said
Kris M.
said
Big loss
said
Mar
said
L
said
mike
said
Chris from NB
said
MARG MM
said
Steve in Vancouver
said
Ivan
said
Luke
said
Karen
said
Judy
said
Mary-Anne TO
said
Luke
said
JD
said
Dan From Calgary
said
Dennis L. Krahn
said
Jim McB
said
There she goes
said
mike
said
David
said
Ivan
said
N. G.
said
Canadian
said
A Koster
said
Roland, London, ON
said
Tdawg
said
Peter Wright
said
Caro-lyn
said
Josie
said
Dennis L. Krahn
said
S Wallace
said
Gerry
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
dante
said
Niagara George
said
Robert B
said
Worse than I Imagined
said
Lz in Edmonton
said
joe canada
said
TootsieFF
said
Terry from Pickering
said
Just Saying - Ottawa
said
Pip
said
kjs
said
Mike in Ottawa
said
Dean in Abby
said
A Koster
said