Canada -   

1

Thousands of charity workers earning six-figure salaries

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (107) Facebook   

Date: Sunday Jul. 10, 2011 10:40 PM ET

OTTAWA — Goodwill means good wages for thousands of Canadian charity workers.

An analysis of tax filings by The Canadian Press has found salaries often run well into six figures -- raising questions about how money raised in the name of charity is being spent.

The Canada Revenue Agency keeps a database of all the country's registered charities, which now number around 85,000. Charities must disclose how much their 10 highest-paid workers take home.

There are around a million charity workers in Canada. The agency's database shows more than 6,000 of them earned above $120,000 last year. A few hundred made over $350,000.

Another 12,000 workers made between $80,000 and $120,000. And about 163,000 earned less than that.

It's likely the number of charity workers making six-figure salaries is actually greater since organizations must only disclose their Top 10 earners.

Charities defend the high pay by saying they have to pay top dollar for the brightest talent.

"If you really want those charities to have an impact and make a real difference, you're going to need to bring in the best people to work in that sector," said Marcel Lauziere of Imagine Canada, an advocacy group for Canadian charities.

"It's not only in government and in business. So you will have to pay salaries that are commensurate to that."

The definition of a charity is murky. Not every group that's registered as a charity builds schools in poor parts of the world or raises money to fight diseases.

Many are Canadian hospitals, school boards, universities and colleges. These groups tend to pay top dollar to attract the best talent, which perhaps explains many of the six-figure salaries.

Registered charities with at least 10 people earning $350,000 or more include the La Salle Manor retirement home in Scarborough, Ont., the Regina Qu'Appelle Regional Health Authority, the University of Saskatchewan and Toronto's Mount Sinai Hospital.

There are also many churches and religious or community groups. By registering as charities, these groups can issue tax receipts for donations.

Some spend millions of dollars on salaries.

The Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation paid its 156 full-time workers and 30 part-timers nearly $13 million last year, Canada Revenue Agency records show.

All of the foundation's top earners made more than $120,000 last year -- and three of them made between $200,000 and $249,999.

The foundation also spent about $23 million last year on charitable works, including research grants and scholarships.

Sandra Palmaro, head of the foundation's Ontario branch, said that's the going rate.

"From our perspective, that's basically what the market dictates as the acceptable salary range for employees at that level for our size of organization" she said.

The Sick Kids Foundation, which mainly raises money for the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto, paid its staff of 136 full- and part-time employees nearly $12 million last year.

The 10 highest-paid workers at the Sick Kids Foundation all made more than $160,000 -- and five of them made more than $200,000.

The group raised $51 million for the hospital last year, and spent another $1 million on other charitable programs.

Ted Garrard, head of the Sick Kids Foundation, said the group's board of directors sets the top salaries and reviews them every year.

"We are a large and complex organization," Garrard said.

"We want to make sure that we attract qualified people to oversee and manage our various programs."


Comments are now closed for this story

spaz
said
0 0

Looks to me that those "smarter and brighter" top exectives have followed the old saying "charity begins at home "....but in their case....their own homes !!!

I have donated regularly to the largest charity in Canada.....Revenue Canada.....fits all the criteria.....executives over paid and under worked......very small percentage of the money actually does anything usefull.....nobody cares


Cancer is big business
said
0 0

I stopped giving to the big name charities years ago. With all the trillions of dollars that have been donated to cancer research, heart research, kidney research...you name it, a cure ought to have been found decades ago. Most charities are, as this article points out, cash cows for administrators. What money i can afford to donate, I send overseas to Christian Charities. If all the money spent researching breast cancer has not yet resulted in a cure, then either there is no cure or they're not really looking for one. People in the third world need charity far more than doctors and rich execs in hospital alley.


Dave in Sarnia
said
0 0

My wife is a Haitian born Canadian. After the earthquack in Haiti last year the world donated about 5.5 Billion to various charities to help 're-build' the country.Very little of this money has ever made it to the people of Haiti, we know.Having said that, we know that the 'system' in Haiti is corrupt and to get anything done requires a kickback of sorts. What really gets my dander up is the fact that CEO's of these so-called charity organizations make huge salaries and do nothing but tie up the funds for years on end in order to sustain their own lifestyles. So much for the Haitian people that need everything that they can get.We send what we can, $200/month takes care of 18 of my wifes family members. Wonder what 5.5 Billion would do?!


Shirley
said
0 0

Seeing the excessive salaries these charities are paying makes you think twice about donating. Also, all the labels, etc that are sent out once you donate. I donate to help the cause, not receive something in return. I have stopped donating to charities that refuse to send out gifts.


NL_Guy
said
0 0

Checking the CRA website it seems the Terry Fox Foundation has 9 of the 10 employees below 80k/year. I find the following comment disingenuous:
"If you really want those charities to have an impact and make a real difference, you're going to need to bring in the best people to work in
that sector," said Marcel Lauziere of Imagine Canada, an advocacy group for Canadian charities."
Marcel's charity Imagine Canada has 1 paid over $200K, 2 over $120K and 7 over $80
Of course he advocates HIGH salaries.
Appalling...


Salt and Vinegar
said
0 0

If they are defending these high salaries - then post their names and their salaries since there is no shame in what they do. Post their names, what is the problem.


workingpoor
said
0 0

When did raising money for Charity become such a BIG Business paying HUGE salaries ?I made the mistake once of giving to the Hospital my kids were born at.Now , I get calls monthly asking for more and they even asked to be put in our will to thank them.Does this take any amount of skill to guilt people and hound them to donate ?I give them NOTHING NOW ! I saw they actually gave less than 20% to the Hospital.........What a JOKE !


TOMO
said
0 0

It's sad, but it confirms what I've been thinking and feeling for years. I've watched the "incentives" that charities have been offering to get people to donate (ie. Heart & Stroke Lottery, Canadian Cancer Society Lottery, etc). The prizes are getting bigger, and the ticket costs have become outrageous ($100/ticket). Other events they use for fundraising are becoming more lavish and expensive also. It seems to me that if they can afford to give away so much (and pay their people so well); the money used to finance all of this (ie. the donations) isn't being properly spent. I"ve asked myself for years why they can offer such huge prizes, yet we still don't have a cure for cancer or heart disease. Apparently, it's because the donations are being used for pay people 6-figure-incomes and run lotteries with millions of $'s worth of prizes; instead of spending it on finding cures. I'm certain that if the money that's been actually raised over the years had been fully applied to it's intended purpose;


Evan
said
0 0

Are you aware of the concept of skill?Would you pay a skilled welder top dollar? I would hope so. If you're a large hospital, need fundraising in order to purchase equipment, wouldn't you pay for talent?Give your heads a shake. When someone is able to bring in millions a year in donations they deserve top dollar. And don't say "volunteers" can do that because they can't. I've done not-for-profit, and volunteers help on their schedule. Fundraising is a skill, and if a company - hospital, school board, etc... - wants to raise serious capital it needs to invest in talent.You might as well say that you're going to stop buying products from Canadian Tire because its CEO makes $6 million a year. "If he made less I wouldn't have to pay so much for a rubber hose. Off to Home Hardware I go..."


Prynce
said
0 0

You don't join or become an employee of a charity to get rich and sustain your lifestyle, You work for a charity because you love the work. If you want to get paid $350,000 to 1 million dollars then go work for a for profit company. People live off of 100,000 dollars a year or less just fine and comfortably.


sweets
said
0 0

I work for The Terry Fox Foundation - since the inquiry of the CCS last week we received many inquiries by the public across the country. I am PROUD to say that we do not receive these incredibly extravagant salaries. What we pay in wages and administrative costs Nationally is less than the amount certain "research" charities pay for 1 provinces (17 employees) salaries.My advice is to KNOW who you are giving your money to. Again, I am proud to say that we have a very high percentage of donated dollars going to research, programs, and fulfilling his dream.


robert
said
0 0

an old saying charity starts at home


Rick
said
0 0

I've worked, as a volunteer, within a charity that was 100% volunteers, and I say there is never enough direction in these.Too many people on the same level all want to be boss, and fight about everything. I would never give money to something that was not organized.

As for Sick Kids in Toronto raised of 50 million, paid the staff 12 million, do you think if they were not paid for their work, a bunch of volunteers would make 38 million plus. Yeah right!

If you don't want to donate then don't but unless you've been in the grind at one time of doing so, speak not of what you do not understand.


ArcticFem
said
0 0

Maybe rather then getting upset that people are making wages which allow them to live a comfortbale lifestyle... we should be getting upset that so many people in the world AREN'T. Why should we bring them down to the poverty line, when we could be bringing the poverty line up!I dont agree with the amount of dontations going towards administration costs, but i also dont agree that we should be paying these people minimum wage either.


Helene
said
0 0

Good for the media to disclose these facts.This whole charity giving has now developed into a highly lucrative industry having nothing to do with the initial mission of said organizations. Their payroll costs and funds spent on promotional activities are way out of line.It is now a "create your own job" scenario. Time for Revenue Canada to take a close look at this industry and rein them in.For me, time has come to STOP giving...and it will get worse with an aging population on fixed income.


Working for the Wrong Charity!
said
0 0

Well clearly I'm working for the WRONG charity!!!

I have worked in the non-profit sector for 10 years - spending countless hours volunteering on top of my low salary positions. Sadly - Admin staff for most companies in the City of Calgary (where I work) make more than me, after dishing out thousands and thousands of dollars for a degree that qualifies me to be in the role I am. Now that I have a family, I am being forced to make a decision to stop doing what I love, helping people in need, to make more money so that we can afford to live in this City.

Please don't think that the salary figures listed in this story applies to all charities - a TRUE charity will have an Annual Report that will (or had better!) post the proportion of salaries paid versus the dollars spent on doing the actual charitable work. Get your hands on that and make a qualified decision before donating.




TC
said
0 0

Stop donating to those charity org that have high salary staffers. This will force them to show their skills are worthy of the salary salaries they think they deserve in running their programs.


Ed
said
0 0

'Save Your Bucks' it is ironic that you would target the Salvation Army as an organization that does not partake in these high salaries. I was an employee at the SA for about four years. You might be surprised to learn that Officers are given a house, vehicles, bills paid and a six figure salary on top of that. Of all the charitable organizations out there this is the one that I absolutely refuse to donate to in light of that.


Paradigm Shift Project
said
0 0

I found this article very saddening, as well as the majority of comments posted below. As the Executive Director of a registered Canadian charity, The Paradigm Shift Project, my work is all about showing how we can make our donations most effective. But in my mind, people should be paid for the important work they do, and charities do some of the most important work in the world. In fact, a sustainable future often hinges on this work. Our charity is currently run without paying one salary, but I really look forward to the day when I can pay my amazing staff the salaries they deserve- at least enough to support themselves and their families. It's my hope that the Canadian public keeps this article in perspective, and realizes that the charitable sector is by no means "rolling in it". This being said, unlike most corporations, charities have transparent financial records. If you want to know how much your favourite charity spends on what, you are entitled to that information, and you can make your decisions on who to support based on that information. It is my hope that you'd ask the same of the corporations you support!Sincerely,Rebecca SweetmanExecutive Director, The Paradigm Shift

Richard
said
0 0

As has already been noted, charities need professionals to make sure the millions of dollars Canadians donate are properly managed.
Some of you have said "get volunteers to do it." Well, get out there and volunteer! It has been getting harder and harder to get people to donate their time on a regular basis yet the work still has to be done, day in and day out. The only choice left to the organization it to hire someone.
Another thing missed is that it feels like every week there is a new law or regulation that volunteers or organizations must adhere to. This takes time for training and money to maintain.
I've worked the front lines and have seen the good work many charities do. I also have seen how much work it takes to get each volunteer out to the person who needs the help.
Check out the organization you want to donate to. If you like what you see,donate your TIME and your money. It does help. Get INVOLVED!


Alan
said
0 0

Maybe there needs to be more clarity in stating exactly how much goes to research or those in need versus administration. There could be a clear statement of this on the receipt even if it is a number from the previous year. In a nutshell I would like to know where my dollars are going.


Ron
said
0 0

Time for me to STOP giving to charities !!


LMG
said
0 0

These people aren't volunteering their time. They have bills and families, too. They are most likely still making less than they would if they were in a for-profit company in a similar position.


Perplexed
said
0 0

Think I will stick to helping Shriners Hospitals. The only ones that get the big bucks are the doctors that they hire.


Rich
said
0 0

Many years ago I wised up to these so called charities. As a result the only thing I give is blood. Hopefully Canadian Blood Services is not selling off blood for profit.


save your bucks
said
0 0

I refuse to donate to any of those charities. They don't do doodly-squat with the money except to live a fine life style. If the people who are taking home such enormous amounts of donated cash were serious about their "jobs" they would be living an average lifestyle like most other citizens. The only charity I will ever donate to is the Salvation Army. I can actually see the good they do for people who are having serious problems, not merely the drug and alcohol related ones, but counselling for troubles souls, meals for the hungry, you name it, they do it, and you don't see them drive in to work in a Cadillac Escalade!


Red Dikulus in ONT
said
0 0

This why the only charity I donate to is the local food bank, with food donations only. I also buy toys at christmas and donate them to one of the many volunteer run groups. Never money.


canUdigit
said
0 0

Outrage and rip off to the innocent Canadians! I can guarantee the next time someone ask for a charitable donation. My answer will be !!!!!


bradin780
said
0 0

I'm done with charities, I make 75,000 a year and figure i should do my part but after hearing I'm paying the wages of people that make more money than me disgusts me.My charity is now geared towards my family and extended family.Makes me sick to think I've lost aunts and uncles to cancer and I've helped to pay for somebody's cottage on the lake!


Anne webster
said
0 0

That's one reason I have stopped giving, my hours are cut, will they help me???


A Tibbs
said
0 0

@Jim McB: Many of those organizations are not charities. They may be non-profit organizations, but people do not get "tax breaks" because of their contributions to those organizations. Many people might not understand the difference, but you're right that NPO's are not subject to the same reporting requirements as charities. The only reason the government cares so much about charities (and collects so much information on their operation) is because of the tax deductions that donations to those organizations generate.


Cleo
said
0 0

Give only to the Salvation Army. A true non-denominational society that pays their average leader 15, 000.00 per annum. Yes they do get a free house to live in (in some cases), but they are always there in time of need.


Shelley Wilson
said
0 0

Thanks for enlightening us about these excessively high wages - both unethical and immoral. We can find a way to bypass these charity 'businesses' and give to new ones with more transparency and accountability as well as directly and personally to those for whom these charities say they are 'helping'.


Margaret
said
0 0

Why are you surprised a CEO of a charity gets so much money? Think CEO's of any company and our friendly politicians. They believe they are worth that much and we the lower class pay it. That is life. I'll bet the people that are no longer donating to charity are donating to themselves and expect all they can get out of life even if we don't think they deserve it.


JamesSK
said
0 0

I am member of a charity, and we survive on volunteer workers and only two paid employees -- not all charities are the same, so don't paint them all with the same brush.


Jim McB
said
0 0

An interesting analysis but focused only on the medical sector. It is time to report on GreenPeace, The Sieera Club, PETA and all those other pseudo charities that rip this country off for millions. It might not be so easy to find their data or maybe that is why they were omitted!


PBW
said
0 0

Given this information, every citizen in Canada who donates to charities should be demanding that our government insist that, in order to be considered a charity, an organization's total operating expenses - including salaries - should not exceed 15% of monies collected. A minimum of 80% should be spent on the purpose for which the money was collected, and that does not mean spending large amounts of cash on long TV ads.


Tom
said
0 0

can't belive some of you are just figuring this out(green peace good god)75% of all charity's are a scam billions and billions into cancer research and what do we have many many rich people


Jennifer
said
0 0

To lynnees - Before you jump to conclusions on the Canadian Cancer Society, please take a moment to do a little research than to trust media at face value. The Global Philanthropy website posted a great rebuttal that goes in to detail highlighting CCS as one of the most transparent charities in the country. The article is called "CBC report on Canadian Cancer Society -thoughts on transparency, media coverage, fundraising costs". Believe me, if you meet any CCS staff, they aren't there because of the money. They work long hours in an emotional environment and often make close to what someone would make working at Tim Hortons. They are there because they truly want to make a difference, not because they are going to get "rich" doing it.


Terry
said
0 0

Just goes to show you where peoples hearts "LIE"What a beautiful planet full of creeps.Too bad there isn't a real god ruling the planet because this would not be happening.The old saying.If somebody smiles too much and looks too happy.There is a demon lurking about.SO SAD.The Meek shall suffer at the hands of others is the way it will read in the final script.If you believe in Jesus.He did not ask for money just faith.I guess that has gone by the wayside.Money is what saves the needy.As long as you take out millions of dollars for the TOP people that know how to scam other people for their money.NICE.I feel so much better knowing they live compfortable until they get what they deserve.Nothing on a big stick.And to think I love this planet until the truth of it makes me sick all over.I just love the fact that the old saying is true.What goes around comes around.


Mark
said
0 0

I am part of a not-for-profit organization and just discovered that less than 40% of our capital is going directly to its intended cause, and even that is too low for me. Our board has become like a government. At a meeting today, I heard to comment "We have an income problem"....well no, we have a spending problem! Administration begets administration and now we are spending far too much energy and capital keeping the administration afloat. Steps are now being taken to burn the administration to the ground and start all over again, as administrators do not have the ability to control themselves or cut their own jobs. Simplicity, and finding people with a desire for a full heart and not a full bank account...............


Vancouver Maria
said
0 0

Charities are run from the top down now. And the top are receiving big salaries. Why would the top charity execs with big salaries want to reach out to retirees? Retirees with lots of professional and business experience? Retirees who would work for nothing but may ask questions, such as, why is so much money going to the top rather than to the people in need? We need big changes. We need them now. Lets get rid of entitlements.


Roger - Ottawa
said
0 0

I have stopped giving to charities about 10 years ago once I knew how much "admin" fees they scimmed off the top. United Way is the absolute worse of the bunch! SHAME!


Nothing new
said
0 0

That is why I don't donate to charities...


sm in montreal
said
0 0

From now on I will only donate directly to those people in need. I shall not contribute to any charity organization anymore. That means I will not be able to help those outside of my neighborhood. That this is happening makes me sick! Why do these people think it is OK to steal from those people in need? All of these people earn more than I do! And I work hard to do honest work to support my family. What happened to a honest day's job?


Elizabeth, Ontario
said
0 0

Paying big salaries, in a charitable organization, doesn't guarantee the best people are holding those jobs. Far too much money is spent on administration in many charitable agencies and much of that is spent on salaries, benefits and expense accounts for paid staff members. It's disgraceful and the reason I am very selective about which charities receive my donations. There are some honorable charities that spend public funds as they should however I believe there are many more which don't.


akm
said
0 0

well its the old saying charity beings at home ???


Dave
said
0 0

Well, this puts an end to my donating. Shame, as I just gave $'s to my neice for the SDM walk for the cure. No more. Charity will now stay at home.


Darlene
said
0 0

This is the reason I refuse to give to the Red Cross or any other charity group.

They are dishonest and steal the money.

People give them their hard earned money to help the causes they are sending the money to, and what do they do with it? they give themselves huge wages.
It's time someone puts an end to this dishonesty and fast


Margo
said
0 0

I stopped giving to the large charities ages ago because of this. My hard earned money is needed in my pocket not theirs. These big wigs are disgusting people, speak about robbing the poor. I am also thoroughly disgusted with the high salaries hospital execs. are paid, for what.? yet the wards are running short staffed when many more nurses could be hired instead of these morons at the top fattening their wallets. Makes me sick. I for one do not donate to the cancer societies any more due to greed. This madness has to stop.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

@ Trasie: Do most competitively successful private-sector companies with, say, 135 full/part-time employees have, say, TEN (10) people proximate to the top drawing OVER $160K in salary, with FIVE (5) of those folks making OVER $200K in salary? Certainly not. Compensation-wise, most major charities are pretty top-heavy. (P.S. Don't righteously pat yourself and everybody else who works for a charity on the back too hard. In tandem with this specific issue, the amount of money donated to charities that gets absorbed by "administration" is a legitimate growing concern. By the way, people who principally collect and distribute cash and, along the way, scoop funds for themselves, aren't "holier" than those who make needed/wanted products and offer needed/wanted services. Kindly step down from your pedestal. Thanks.)


J in Calgary
said
0 0

For those who are contemplating to stop donating, just remember, every little bit helps. Someone has to run the place and sadly that costs money. I personally don't agree with it so I give my $$$ to a charity where they don't get paid for the volunteering... the Military Police Fund for Blind Children. Established in 1957, it is administered by the Canadian Forces Military Police nation wide. It benefits children/young adults with sight defects from birth to 21 years of age. Look at their website or contact the nearest base and ask for their representative.


Munro - Brampton
said
0 0

Give directly to the charity. Give to your food bank or the Children's Wish Foundation. I don't give anything to the United Way as at least 80% goes into their pockets.


JPC
said
0 0

I worked for the Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation and it is run like a business. It has to be. We dealt with MILLION of dollars and we had full time staff that worked Monday to Friday like anyone else in a similar job. There's marketing, accounting, managers, customer (donor) service representatives and the list goes on. Without that staff working full time charities like this would not exist. We had volunteers come in and help BUT you can't operate something so BIG on volunteer work alone, it's impossible. On a side note there were less employees than most similar offices and everyone did MORE work than a regular place of work.


Brian
said
0 0

Charity used to be neighbour to neighbour, church groups, religious orders etc. Now it is just big business. We donate to the Sally Ann the most efficient chartity and to the best work.


grizz
said
0 0

well, 12 million out of 51 million leaves a profit of 39 million. for an outfit the size of sick kids i guess you get what you pay for. i'm more against churches getting not-for-profit status.


BC in BC
said
0 0

They (major charities org) should be capped at 10% admin and salaries.


lynnees
said
0 0

This is going to put a top to our donations. I cannot justify giving money to a charilty then seeing 80% going to some fat cat. I've been thinking about this since the Cancer Society numbers were released the other day. We have always given to the Cancer Society but at that point decided we wouldn't be doing that anymore. Now all the rest? I will not throw my hard earned money away.There is no justification for this.


Lucy
said
0 0

I would bet that hundreds if not thousands of EQUALLY COMPETENT people would do THE SAME funraising work and achieve the same results, as those now being overpaid, for at least HALF THE PAY...if not lessThis whole subject should be investigated (I know, I don't like investigations either) because many many people are giving to charities when they can hardly look after themselves - because they/we hope to help others less fortunate ... I think I will now give money to some families I know are struggling, through no fault of their own... then I will know where my money goes!


J. C. Wallin
said
0 0

Sad reflection upon charital societies! Always figured something crooked was going on. Shameful!


B Friesen
said
0 0

You can find out how your charity spends money by reading their tax filings. All returns from charities are displayed online and you can find out how much they are spending on salaries in proportion to income generated as well as see salary ranges. I cannot post the link here, but go to the CRA website, click "Charities and Giving", click "Charity Listings", enter your charity and read their return.Give generously to charities, but give intelligently.


Kevin
said
0 0

once you add in university boards, health region boards, etc. I can see high paying management jobs on those. Very large charities such as united way or salvation army need experienced management oversight. The question I have is how does La Salle retirement residence in Scarborough have so many $300k salaried employees?


anyoldjoe
said
0 0

I agree with the earlier comment about NGOs. I volunteered with CUSO/VSO in India where we lived in squalid conditions with a stipend we had to top up with our own money to survive, while the country staff enjoyed above-average wages (by India standards) and were located in a posh embassy filled neighbourhood across the street from that of the Sultanate of Brunei.


JM
said
0 0

I tried applying to work with charities. However, I found that they have the same attitude as any corporate employers. Their needs are so specific and they are not interested in passion to help others. Charity is the new business. When speaking with these charities, I was shocked and disappointed to see so little empathy for the causes and so much focus on bottom line. I have stopped trying to work in the non-profit sector as I think it's all hypocritical and just businesses disguised under "charities".


WatchDawg
said
0 0

On average less than 0.25 cents on every dollar spent goes to supporting the actual charity the rest is all administrative costs. We for one pick and choose are charitable donations each year. The first question we ask is what is the percentage of your administration costs? If they can't answer or the ratio is out of whack they don't get a donation.


Big A Again
said
0 0

When you give to a charity, ask for the financial statement which indicates how much of each dollar goes to the bottom line or to the actual charity. I think you will be surprised.


jim
said
0 0

money not getting to those that need it, so thats why i don't give to charities.


Big A
said
0 0

This goes from your big charity exec at United Way down to the local guy who does the 2.00 chocolate bars. anyone who does this takes 20% off the top. Have you ever wondered why there is never enough money in the little cardboard box? Monitor it like I did and you too will ask him to take the box with him and not come back.Or the United way guy who has a better travelling expense account than most sales repsGood Grief -


Steve in Edmonton
said
0 0

After seeing the piece about the Canadian Cancer Society and the ballooning of "administrative costs" from 20 % of their annual budget to over 40% over the past decade I can guarantee they and many other similar charities will never see another donation from my household. Scandalous is the only word I can use to describe it! Unacceptable...utterly unacceptable!


Paul Misener
said
0 0

I work for a non profit charitable organization I'm a front line worker what this article doesn't tell you is who in these organizations are getting these top dollars maybe the question should be why are the front line workers not getting paid better honestly why are some of these individuals getting these high pays for their lip service and signing papers there is something wrong in our country regarding this and would love to hear from others and their opinions.


Unicef = Greed
said
0 0

One that many people like to give to and is one of the worst, if not the absolute worse is... Unicef!


URU
said
0 0

I guess its time society look after their own pockets and stop giving to those charities that pay their employees who think they are entitle to it. This is why I never donate becuase of these kinds of findings.


Scooter
said
0 0

So, where are all the newly retired people with some extra time on their hands? They could be doing these jobs for the "right" reasons and feel very fulfilled by doing so.


Steve in Vancouver
said
0 0

Our generous western world is getting way out of whack. Where is a Mother Teresa when you need her. People working for charities and making fat salaries are causing another concern. Yesterday a university researcher comes out with a report that the top people running non profits are mostly Caucasian. He suggests that its time these high paying non profit jobs be given over to non Caucasians. lm not arguing against that idea. But isn't it about helping the less fortunate and not about how much you get paid for helping and who should be getting a fat salary.


Rick M.
said
0 0

I think this article begs a critical question, what is the true purpose of charitable organizations? Furthermore, what is the true purpose of their advertising, and campaigns? Is it to meet their payroll, then distribute the balance of monies raised to administrative costs, then give what is left over to the beneficiaries? I disagree that charitable organizations have to hire top dogs to gain an advantage in the charity market place. There are many experienced and talented volunteers who can do the same job if not better. I think it is time to revamp CRA charitable status, make them more transparent, lower and cap top dog salaries and wages, and administrative costs so hard earned donations go to the people who REALLY need the funds. Alternatively, the greater amount of donations should go to the REAL people in need, and a lesser amount should go to administrative costs, then top dog salaries/wages. It is time Canada to question and take to task the purpose and integrity of charitable organizations, make them more transparent and accountable, and make top dogs make less money and do more volunteer time.


Steve
said
0 0

Those liberal types like to give a hand to those that need it. Good on them.


Ed2
said
0 0

If I can get my hands on that information, you can bet I will cancel my monthly donations to them and never give to them again. Those are greed sucking wages and I want to be no part of it.Anyone know where can we check to see if the charity we are donating to is paying the fat cats top wages?


Trasie
said
0 0

Based on these figures, then , 80% of those who work for charities make less than $100,000 a year. But that's not nearly as sensational of a headline, is it? Nor would a look at the top 10 salaries for corporations and how they compare to those in the charitable sector. At least I know I'm making a real difference in people's lives and not just getting them to buy more things they don't need, want or use.


Redneckvic1
said
0 0

So just how much money really get's to the people that were it's intended target market? Has anyone ever figured out how much money has been raised by all charities or fundraisers in Canada and how much was actually given to the said cause?


Alyx Crawford
said
0 0

@NoMore... yes, many of the front-line workers are volunteers -- canvassing for donations, selling raffle tickets, etc. But there have to be some paid staff that are accountable for the MILLIONS raised and distributed. I'm not saying that $350,000 isn't questionable, but staff working for a charity do the same job as similar staff in the business world, and should expect a decent wage.


Lawrence Brooks
said
0 0

The goverment has said the same thing for years, so they are just the same as politicians. So with these big wages has a cure been found for cancer, MS and the list goes on. Now we have a new class of scumbags is Canada great or what?


David Fraser Nanoose Bay BC
said
0 0

It does make you wonder how much of our donations actually make it the people needing help. Salaries are one thing, but how much of the money or goods get to where they are intended. I have seen reports of food stuffs ending up on Black Markets. It is unfortunate that the people who really need help are probably not getting it.


Sam C
said
0 0

Perhaps one simply needs to look carefully at a "charity" before deciding whether or not to give to it. But keep in mind, working FOR a charity doesn't mean one has to live in poverty, or work for minimum wage (well, same thing, really) -- there's no reason why the average person who works for a charity shouldn't earn a reasonable wage.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

I don't think that most people have a problem with those "AT" the top of charities making big bucks. The issue has to do with the number of individuals "NEAR" the top of charities making big bucks. For example, at the Sick Kids Foundation, 10 people pull down over $160K, with the top five of them making more than $200K. With just 136 employees, including part-timers, this seems rather excessive. The shareholders of a publicly-traded company of that size in the private sector likely wouldn't be content with that overall upper draw. How lovely it is for many major charities to be insulated and have a "Board of Directors" that just wink and smile.


Former charity worker
said
0 0

I agree with CharityWorkerInBC. It isn't until almost half way that the story indicates "charities" include school boards, hospitals and universities. Actual charities like Goodwill and United Way, etc. do NOT pay high salaries to the average worker. What is more helpful is to look at how much a charity devotes to program versus administration costs. The average admin costs are around 20 per cent and these numbers are always audited.


Fish
said
0 0

Recent brest cancer walk in Calgary had all the 'walkers' arriving in cars causing a traffic jam and lots of smog .... wonder how much the organizer of this event is paid. Why not everyone walk to the shopping center to meet and catch the bus home ... oops ... probably have to pay more to hire a better organizer!!


peter in mb
said
0 0

Somehow this does not surprise me in the least. It’s the same thing as union leaders holding there annual convention in exotic locations like Hawaii, guess where that money comes from. I understand that it’s a full time job for the people who run the charity but making that much money is a bit much. I wonder if they give money to their charity.


Dave
said
0 0

I figured that out a lot when I was serving in Cambodia... many of the NGOs had people living like royalty and very little help going towards those that needed it. Lots of overhead in Canada for charities, this is a great example as to why very little of donations goes to where donors visualize it going.


retiti
said
0 0

find charities that are 100% volunteer run, and have no paid people 'working' for them. you dont have to look far to find those!


Fire
said
0 0

This is just one of the reasons why I do NOT donate to charities! Even before I read this article, it seemed clear to me that the funds are NOT necessarily going towards what generous donors think! I see these home lotteries, and wonder how much it costs to run them! I see the people that have to PAY to run in the races / climb stairs etc -- and if they can't come up with the $$ they can't participate (ridiculous!). Now I see the exorbitant salaries these charities are paying their staff -- its ridiculous!!


Rolf in Regina
said
0 0

Yes there are some very large charities in Canada but there are many that are small and a do a great deal of work on shoe string budgets and work in the a local communities with many volunteers that do not get paid at all. Which do great work i have to add. I pray that we do become too quick to judge on the bases of this article.


BC
said
0 0

A former acquaintance (I use that term lightly) I knew a while back was a borderline idiot and was making 70k/yr in the IT division of Green Peace even though she'd never taken a computer course. This was pretty much the norm, and I suspect 90% of their budget would be spent on administration and personnel rather than saving the planet. She also indicated GP was a money machine making millions with their huge call center(s). People would hand over money no questions asked.


Lincoln Ho
said
0 0

If they include the University of Saskatchewan, and a regional health authority as a charity, then this article is truly misleading, leading me to believe that the writer of this article is simply an broke person angry that he/she hasn't made it, and wants to take others down as well.


Laurie
said
0 0

Churches do a huge benefit to people in the work of charity in the community. They deserve their tax break to continue to do the work. I can see the sinister leanings toward the stripping the Chrisitan churhes now of their charitable status.You take away their tax status, you hurt your community, that's the bottom line.


lala
said
0 0

Makes you think twice about giving to your favorite charity.


CYL
said
0 0

That's why I stop giving to 'charities' a few years ago. Maybe I should start my own charity instead.These charities are bleeding the hard earned cash of those who are so easily fooled.


john vezina
said
0 0

what else is new i,m a carpenter in alberta working my ass of in snow & mud for $30k a year what can they possibly be doing to earn that kind of money let me know where i can sign up for that job.thanks.


overit...
said
0 0

if money is the root of all evil, then why does the church and "certain" charity people need so much of it?


Larry Q Piblic
said
0 0

I am not going to donate to any of the bibillions of dollarsg charities any longer. Like cancer all that money and no real progress in the last thirty years except for administration costs!!


Mark, Vancouver
said
0 0

This is just the tip of the iceberg. From a local (Vancouver) point of view, this is what i call the "poverty industry" and the best example is the many agencies and charities that are here for the Downtown East Side. (DES) The whole situation should be reviewed and taxpayer dollars should not continue to flow at the rates that they do today. I am waiting for a politician to stand up and say "enough is enough" and stop throwing good money after bad. I understand the need for housing etc. but it does not mean it has to be in the middle of downtown. It is only there because all these high paid "charity" workers want it close to them they won't have to move elsewhere to take care of these people and their problems. The people who need the funds are not getting them - the money is going to pay a bunch of fat cats.


NoMoreAVolunteer
said
0 0

Paying for bright talent????Obviously a highly paid worker saying that.Everyone knows charities exist by Volunteers,millions and millions of volunteers just as corporations exist ONLY because of theirsales staff. These are the front line workerswho do all the hard work. Many volunteers work with passion for the cause as their only remuneration. But most of the highly paid leeches at the top are only there for the money; they don't love the cause even enough to work at reduced wages.


Mac
said
0 0

Dean, you should learn how to think. If you believe that it is only the people in charities and religion who are greedy, than you really need to start being honest. Your comments really just show your ignorance and biases.


Geraldine
said
0 0

I will to March of Dimes, War Amps, Salvation Army and some animal welfare. That's it.


CharityWorkerInBC
said
0 0

This story is very misleading. The Canadian Press has done a great diservice to charities by not balancing the report. I have worked for charities for 3 decades. Yes, some peolple make 6 figure salaries however MOST do not. It also takes, in many cases, years of devotion to get to a high level of salary. Many charities have no health and benefit plans, they do not have retirement plans, and workers commit to very long hours - certainly not 9 to 5. This report also does not show how the salaries correspond to the work of a charity. If a group is raising $75 million annually, just as in business, you need a very high level of skill and talent to ensure that amount is raised. The report also does not indicate if the salaries fall within a 10-20% administration cost. Few organizations are expected to work on such a low admin fee yet charities are held to the highest standards which are very often impossible to meet.This report needs to be balanced. It would be interesting to study reporter salaries and benefits and see how many of them make good wages, have benefit plans, have a healthy retirement fund.


The Other Lowell in BC
said
0 0

I am not sure I buy the argument that you can only attract dedicated and competent people to work for a charity by paying them big $$'s. Doesn't that go against the philosophy of working for a charity. There are plenty of folks who feel it is their life's calling to give back to the world. That would be in the true spirit of what a charity would stand for. The key words are giving back. If someone needs a three figured salary to be enticed to work for one, I would question whether he is in fact the right person for the job.


DCG
said
0 0

What is the use of donating when more than half goes to pay to administer it.


Dean in Abby
said
0 0

Charity and religion have more to do with getting rich than they do with helping people. If this wasn't true, not nearly as many people would do it.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

A Canadian Pacific Railway employee walks along the side of a locomotive in a marshalling yard in Calgary, Wednesday, May 16, 2012. (Jeff McIntosh / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Talks between CP, union stall; Raitt prepared to step in

More   38 Comments 38    2 Video(s) 2

Victoria Shachtay, 23, died in an explosion on Friday, Nov. 25, in an Innisfail townhouse.

Man charged in parcel blast that killed Alta. mother

More  2 Video(s) 2

Nova  Scotia, body, Hillside Road, Marion Bridge

Police identify humans remains found in hockey bag

More  1 Video(s) 1

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges