Canada -
News Sections
Think-tank report reveals U.S. myths about Canada
The Canadian Press
Date: Wednesday May. 11, 2011 7:16 AM ET
WASHINGTON The Canada-U.S. border will once again be under intense scrutiny in the United States as a congressional hearing aims to push for tighter security measures along the much-maligned boundary.
Sen. Charles Schumer, a New York Democrat, is holding a Senate hearing next week to prod federal officials for details about security initiatives along the border.
Schumer said Tuesday that top officials from the Department of Homeland Security, formed after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, will attend the hearing to discuss proposals that include employing military-grade radar along the border to crack down on drug smugglers.
News of Schumer's hearing before the subcommittee on immigration, refugees and border security came the same day that Canada's Fraser Institute released a report on U.S. congressional perceptions about Canada.
The study suggests American politicians view Canada as little else but a stable source of energy with a border security problem. There's also scant appetite for freer Canada-U.S. trade unless it involves cheaper prescription drugs.
According to congressional debates between 2001 and 2010, the report found that discussions about Canada primarily revolved around energy, including Alberta's oilsands. Most of those debates shone a positive light on America's neighbour to the north and there was little, if any, resistance to the oilsands.
But legislators were also deeply concerned about Canada having a porous border that was leaving the U.S. vulnerable to terrorists slipping across the boundary to wreak havoc. There were "persistent and repeated" allegations from lawmakers that Canada is lax on terrorism, including claims that some of the 9-11 hijackers entered the U.S. over the northern border.
The 9-11 myth is a diehard one in the U.S., with Frank McKenna, a former Canadian ambassador to the States, once calling it a "viral infection."
It's now become almost a rite of passage for Canada's envoy to the United States to remind Americans it's not true; Ambassador Gary Doer had to do it in October, when a Tea Party candidate repeated the myth publicly.
It's a message that doesn't seem to have reached many American legislators, the Fraser report suggests.
"When discussing border security, American politicians tend most often to speak of the Canadian and Mexican borders in roughly the same manner," the Fraser Institute's senior fellow Alexander Moens wrote. "Their concern about the threat of terrorists staging attacks from Canada remains high."
As for trade, Moens added: "Take cheaper drugs from Canada out of the picture, and the sentiment in Congress towards free trade turns negative."
At least one senator suggested Tuesday he was swimming against the tide in terms of the perceptions of some of his congressional colleagues.
"The closer you are to the border, the more you see and understand Canada's diverse importance to us," Vermont's Patrick Leahy, who's married to a French-Canadian, said when asked about the report's findings.
"In Vermont, we have the advantage of close proximity and many shared cultural and economic values. So much so that we good-naturedly refer to 'the giant to our north."'
Schumer's hearing takes place next Tuesday, a week after homeland security czar Janet Napolitano told a Senate homeland security committee that the Canadian government and the Obama administration are discussing how to set up radar and sensor feeds along the border as part of a future perimeter security deal.
Technology, she added, was the key to making the northern border more secure.
"We are adding more systems up there that can detect low-flying aircraft," Napolitano said.
The northern border has been on the hot seat in the U.S. since December, when the U.S. Government Accountability Office criticized security measures along the 6,400-kilometre boundary.
The report, largely dismissed by one White House source at the time, says that an "acceptable level of security" exists on less than one per cent of the border -- or about 51 kilometres.
It concluded that the United States did not "have the ability to detect illegal activity across most of the northern border."
As she did when it was first released, Napolitano took issue last week with the report, saying "some of the measures that are ongoing at the northern border ... I think are not captured."
In February, Prime Minister Stephen Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama announced a framework agreement on perimeter security. It focuses mostly on boosting information-sharing between the two countries and integrating border control.
User Tools
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Ron S
0
said
0
Having said the above; I do agree that more co-operation between both countries would be appropriate to ensure that no such tragedy can be repeated in either country. Perhaps we can kill the multi-billion Jet purchase that Harper supports and put some of this money into better border control since it seems to be a higher priority.
roger russell
0
said
0
Chris
0
said
0
Brent
0
said
0
Duke
0
said
0
Joseph, Halifax
0
said
0
Bill Lee
0
said
0
Bill Lee
0
said
0
Rod from Calgary
0
said
0
And if Canada were ever in need of military assistance, it would be our friends to the south that we'd expect to help us. And they unquestionably would.
Admittedly, the US has plenty of politicians and members of the media who are willing to attract attention to themselves using inflammatory info. But they DO NOT represent the views of the average American. The Americans I have met view Canadians as kind, wonderful people living in a spectacularly beautiful country. And they know the 9/11 bombers didn't enter through Canada. And they know we're not their main worry about illegal aliens or drug smuggling.
So don't be afraid to chastise the media or the politicians who rant. They earn their criticisms well. But don't paint the American people with the same brush.
Itellya
0
said
0
Christopher
0
said
0
Sam C
0
said
0
Pat Riot
0
said
0
Michael from the real world
0
said
0
Stacey
0
said
0
James
0
said
0
Julian
0
said
0
Have you ever heard some of these people try to discuss anything outside their home State?
The Comedy Channel could make a fortune running video clips!
The fact that most of them are allowed to continue representing one of the world's most powerful nations is a sad commentary in and of itself.
Matt
0
said
0
Gerald
0
said
0
k markham
0
said
0
Lonnie
0
said
0
A Proud American
0
said
0
Annie
0
said
0
Brent
0
said
0
Let's be good neighbours.
Would you rather live beside Iran, Syria, North Korea or one of the many corrupt Central and South American or African nations? I didn't think so.
Jane
0
said
0
What some people don’t understand is that when you point a finger at someone else there are three fingers pointing back at yourself! I have met some very wonderful people from the United States who have travelled, taken the time to get to know “North America”, and understand that both Canadians and Americans are good, hard working people with common concerns. Between the politicians who have their basic, righteous ideals and the media who continues to feed this hatred between our two countries, it is simply unbelievable. There has always been, and always will be, differences between our two countries and that’s what makes us unique. It seems that bad people are all over the world, so just target those people, not the entire nation.
Rob
0
said
0
Anne
0
said
0
Mr.Muse
0
said
0
Prof. Pye Chartt
0
said
0
Albertan working in Texas
0
said
0
Patchy patch
0
said
0
Mimi2005
0
said
0
dean
0
said
0
Chris
0
said
0
Concerned Citizen
0
said
0
Dave
0
said
0
Les In Ontario
0
said
0
George V.
0
said
0
Poohbear
0
said
0
Derek
0
said
0
stu
0
said
0
America=Ignorance
0
said
0
Frank Buchan
0
said
0