Canada -   

1

Think-tank report reveals U.S. myths about Canada

The Ambassador Bridge at the Windsor-Detroit international crossing is pictured from Windsor, Ontario, Friday, November, 26, 2010. (Brent Foster / THE CANADIAN PRESS) U.S. Sen. Charles Schumer, D-NY, left, is joined by U.S. Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-NY, left, U.S. Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood, second left, and U.S. Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-NJ, at an announcement in New York's Pennsylvania Station, Monday, May 9, 2011. (AP / Richard Drew)
The Ambassador Bridge at the Windsor-Detroit international crossing is pictured from Windsor, Ontario, Friday, November, 26, 2010. (Brent Foster / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (43) Facebook   

Date: Wednesday May. 11, 2011 7:16 AM ET

WASHINGTON — The Canada-U.S. border will once again be under intense scrutiny in the United States as a congressional hearing aims to push for tighter security measures along the much-maligned boundary.

Sen. Charles Schumer, a New York Democrat, is holding a Senate hearing next week to prod federal officials for details about security initiatives along the border.

Schumer said Tuesday that top officials from the Department of Homeland Security, formed after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, will attend the hearing to discuss proposals that include employing military-grade radar along the border to crack down on drug smugglers.

News of Schumer's hearing before the subcommittee on immigration, refugees and border security came the same day that Canada's Fraser Institute released a report on U.S. congressional perceptions about Canada.

The study suggests American politicians view Canada as little else but a stable source of energy with a border security problem. There's also scant appetite for freer Canada-U.S. trade unless it involves cheaper prescription drugs.

According to congressional debates between 2001 and 2010, the report found that discussions about Canada primarily revolved around energy, including Alberta's oilsands. Most of those debates shone a positive light on America's neighbour to the north and there was little, if any, resistance to the oilsands.

But legislators were also deeply concerned about Canada having a porous border that was leaving the U.S. vulnerable to terrorists slipping across the boundary to wreak havoc. There were "persistent and repeated" allegations from lawmakers that Canada is lax on terrorism, including claims that some of the 9-11 hijackers entered the U.S. over the northern border.

The 9-11 myth is a diehard one in the U.S., with Frank McKenna, a former Canadian ambassador to the States, once calling it a "viral infection."

It's now become almost a rite of passage for Canada's envoy to the United States to remind Americans it's not true; Ambassador Gary Doer had to do it in October, when a Tea Party candidate repeated the myth publicly.

It's a message that doesn't seem to have reached many American legislators, the Fraser report suggests.

"When discussing border security, American politicians tend most often to speak of the Canadian and Mexican borders in roughly the same manner," the Fraser Institute's senior fellow Alexander Moens wrote. "Their concern about the threat of terrorists staging attacks from Canada remains high."

As for trade, Moens added: "Take cheaper drugs from Canada out of the picture, and the sentiment in Congress towards free trade turns negative."

At least one senator suggested Tuesday he was swimming against the tide in terms of the perceptions of some of his congressional colleagues.

"The closer you are to the border, the more you see and understand Canada's diverse importance to us," Vermont's Patrick Leahy, who's married to a French-Canadian, said when asked about the report's findings.

"In Vermont, we have the advantage of close proximity and many shared cultural and economic values. So much so that we good-naturedly refer to 'the giant to our north."'

Schumer's hearing takes place next Tuesday, a week after homeland security czar Janet Napolitano told a Senate homeland security committee that the Canadian government and the Obama administration are discussing how to set up radar and sensor feeds along the border as part of a future perimeter security deal.

Technology, she added, was the key to making the northern border more secure.

"We are adding more systems up there that can detect low-flying aircraft," Napolitano said.

The northern border has been on the hot seat in the U.S. since December, when the U.S. Government Accountability Office criticized security measures along the 6,400-kilometre boundary.

The report, largely dismissed by one White House source at the time, says that an "acceptable level of security" exists on less than one per cent of the border -- or about 51 kilometres.

It concluded that the United States did not "have the ability to detect illegal activity across most of the northern border."

As she did when it was first released, Napolitano took issue last week with the report, saying "some of the measures that are ongoing at the northern border ... I think are not captured."

In February, Prime Minister Stephen Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama announced a framework agreement on perimeter security. It focuses mostly on boosting information-sharing between the two countries and integrating border control.

Comments are now closed for this story

Ron S
said
0 0

I must agree with Sam C ; it is up to the U.S. to ensure who enters their country. Even if some of the 9/11 terrorists entered from Canada; why and how did the get past U.S. immigration so easily ? Furthermore, did they not get flying lessons in the U.S. under some very unusual circumstances ? The U.S. and perhaps Canada to some degree were greatly suprised and unprepared for 9/11 but we still have no direct control over who enters the U.S. do we ?

Having said the above; I do agree that more co-operation between both countries would be appropriate to ensure that no such tragedy can be repeated in either country. Perhaps we can kill the multi-billion Jet purchase that Harper supports and put some of this money into better border control since it seems to be a higher priority.


roger russell
said
0 0

American can't and or doesn't want to believe the 9/11 attacks didn't originate from Canada because that would mean America the all mighty isn't so all mighty at all. The birther movement, the tea party, Donald Trump, Sarah Palin, Anne Colter, Tucker Carlson, the average American may be ok, but their leaders and commentators are idiots! Build a wall along the 49th parallel I say. Hell Ill even give one Saturday a month free to help build it. We can still trade but other than that, their nut jobs can stay on their side. We have enough of our own nut jobs.America! Wow! I don't say that in a good way!


Chris
said
0 0

I used to spend a lot of time and money south of the border. I don't anymore. Not because of the every-day americans that I used to meet. I like them just fine. What has kept me out of the US is their boarder security and customs. We used to take pride in sharing the world's longest undefended border. Now their borader guards treat everyone as if they're planning to blow something up. These days, my money is spent elsewhere. I guess they don't need it.


Brent
said
0 0

Christopher: Point Pelee is actually on the same latitude as northern California, not Los Angeles.


Duke
said
0 0

It's your border, US. Stay in your own cage. Stop trying to drag Canada into your dirty cage. Canada wants to deal with the world, not cower in a cage with psychopathic freaks.


Joseph, Halifax
said
0 0

Rod from Calgary wrote "And if Canada were ever in need of military assistance, it would be our friends to the south that we'd expect to help us."The irony of this statement is that there are really only 2 reasons for American millitary assistance here - a major disaster similar in scale to Haiti or a hostile force invading our country our country. And, of course,, because of distance and other considerations the likeliest country to do that is.... You guessed it. :-)


Bill Lee
said
0 0

Christopher, Point Pelee is equal in latitude to the northern border of California, not Los Angeles which is much farther south.


Bill Lee
said
0 0

US, if so worried about its border . . . should seal its border. As for the "American people," they are not the problem. The people controlling the "American people" are the problem.


Rod from Calgary
said
0 0

Here we go again with our American-bashing. You people should be ashamed of yourselves. The vast majority of Americans I have gotten to know (and I own a winter home there, so I've met LOTS of them) are wonderful, peace-loving people who will unconditionally help a person in need.

And if Canada were ever in need of military assistance, it would be our friends to the south that we'd expect to help us. And they unquestionably would.

Admittedly, the US has plenty of politicians and members of the media who are willing to attract attention to themselves using inflammatory info. But they DO NOT represent the views of the average American. The Americans I have met view Canadians as kind, wonderful people living in a spectacularly beautiful country. And they know the 9/11 bombers didn't enter through Canada. And they know we're not their main worry about illegal aliens or drug smuggling.

So don't be afraid to chastise the media or the politicians who rant. They earn their criticisms well. But don't paint the American people with the same brush.


Itellya
said
0 0

I would be happy to see the US put more rules, regulations and security around Canadians heading to the US. I also think they should put more money into surveillance etc on the border line. Once they get it all in place....10 years later they will be begging us to visit, participate and support the US and their not so well thought out initiatives such as this one


Christopher
said
0 0

Several people mentioned that Americans are ignorant on their knowledge of Canada in many ways. When I was in grade 9, 30 some years ago, a student and his family moved here from Arizona. He made the comment that he thought we lived in Igloo's and traveled by dog-sled 365 days a year. My entire class gave him a lesson on what Canada is really like. It should be noted that, Point Pelee Ontario is the southern most place in Canada, equal in latitude to Los Angeles.


Sam C
said
0 0

Even if the 9-11 terrorists had entered the US from Canada, border guards don't inspect people LEAVING a country; the US Border Services inspects people ENTERING the US. (If I sneak into a hockey game, is it the fault of the staff at the restaurant I just left, or the staff at the arena I entered?)


Pat Riot
said
0 0

sadly the truth is the border is indefensible and really cannot be secured. Its one of the longest borders in the world and drug dealers, gun runners and other lovely people cross every day with illegal intentions. All the anti-american and anti-canadian rhetoric doesnt solve the issue and in fact is the issue and until we grow up and stop finger pointing this problem will only get worse


Michael from the real world
said
0 0

Fact is that we need them, and they need us. Americans ARE going to secure their perimeters, and we should work to make ours contiguous with theirs. By this I mean that we should work together to have a common OUTER perimeter. This would mean some adjustment on behalf of BOTH nations. Luckily, we have a government in place who knows the importance of this, and are meeting with the Americans to secure our common futures. Juvenile and facile anti-American comments do nothing to help Canada advance our interests.


Stacey
said
0 0

@dean Is that why a substantial amount of US oil comes from Canada? Is that why a large portion of US building lumber comes from Canada? Is that why the US comes to Canada when they need certain medical procedures done? Finally, is that why the US and the vast majority of the world comes to Canada when they need isotopes for medical research? Yeah, Canada's useless.


James
said
0 0

I have been asked more questions and basically drilled by US custom officials in Calgary & Vancouver International Airports then I was walking across the boarder from Tijuana to San Diego.. I agree, we should be doing more trade with emerging markets and getting away from American Business. They have proven to be unstable and greedy.


Julian
said
0 0

The U.S. Congress is full of ignorant blowhards who know less about the real world than the majority of people they represent.
Have you ever heard some of these people try to discuss anything outside their home State?
The Comedy Channel could make a fortune running video clips!

The fact that most of them are allowed to continue representing one of the world's most powerful nations is a sad commentary in and of itself.


Matt
said
0 0

Hey, I love the United States and the good people down there. But it's time Canada wakes up and realizes, the US now needs us (Oil Sands, Water, Soft lumber) more than we need them. Canada should really focus our efforts on working with the new and real power of the world. China!


Gerald
said
0 0

Let's not sweat it....we'll just hide in our igloo bunkers till the drones pass over and they'll just think we've left.


k markham
said
0 0

I am not surprised. Canada as a image problem and that is not being helped by our federal government. We have a Prime Minister who is as dull as burned out light bulb so Americans have no political symbol in Canada to gain a positive perspective of Canada. Its not a Con/Lib thing its leadership. Mulroney and Chretien were good ambassadors for Canada but sadly Harper gets a F in that value. The NDP is also going to hurt our image to the Americans. We have to do better to improve our image south of the border, $billions of trade depend on it, sadly we will have to wait until either the Conservatives have a new leader, or we have a Liberal government and the NDP fluke is put back in the tin. We are a great country, we just have to make others aware of that. We also have to realize that Americans are not worldly like us, the majority of Americans have never left the USA so we have to expect a degree of ignorance.


Lonnie
said
0 0

@ Mimi2005. I had heard that Tim McVeigh flew to Canada for a vacation was admitted to our country and then returned to the US by land crossing. So you see, they were right....terrorists are coming from Canada. Americans are only alienating themselves. USA is soon to be the biggest prison in the world! Is that so bad?


A Proud American
said
0 0

The United States of America is the best country in the world ! We are the most economically, technologically, politically and technologically advanced in the world with fierce and strong security policies. That is why we are the victims of terrorist attacks and any other international threats. Why. Because we are very proud and we don`t care about what the rest of world thinks of us, especially Canada. Who cares about we think about what Canada thinks of us. At least we are one unified solid country. Canada on the other hand is not united. It is divided ( East vs West). English Canada vs French Quebec. Terrorists wouldn`t need to attack Canada because Canadians are constantly attacking and destroying themselves everyday. And yet Canadians look to the Americans for guidance on how to repair their own country. So what if we`ve made mistakes. At least we acknowledge them. This is America ! Don`t Copy us, Canada ! Grow up and step up to the plate and do something about it !


Annie
said
0 0

What Americans seem to have a misconception about is how the world feels about them. They are a very proud country and those that have not travelled outside of their beautiful borders, fail to grasp that much of the world hates them. I spent a good numbers of years travelling the world when I was younger. When struggling with language in foreign countries I was often greeted with irritation by the locals who, on plenty of occasion, scowled and muttered "Americans". When I corrected them to know I was Canadian the change in their demeanor was instant. It is true that we need the US more than they need us. My prediction is one day, they will alienate themselves from the entire world and our continued alliance will save them from themselves. The time will come that Canada will be the shining star on the world stage and not because we elected ourselves to the position, as Americans have done.


Brent
said
0 0

The US is the greatest democracy, protector and champion of human rights, promoter and provider of resources to the less fortunate around the world and Canada's best friend. We best not get the elephant to the south too upset.

Let's be good neighbours.

Would you rather live beside Iran, Syria, North Korea or one of the many corrupt Central and South American or African nations? I didn't think so.


Jane
said
0 0

I was pleased to read that Prime Minister Stephen Harper and U.S. President Barack Obama announced a framework agreement on perimeter security and that it focuses mostly on boosting information-sharing between the two countries and integrating border control. Now this makes perfect sense!

What some people don’t understand is that when you point a finger at someone else there are three fingers pointing back at yourself! I have met some very wonderful people from the United States who have travelled, taken the time to get to know “North America”, and understand that both Canadians and Americans are good, hard working people with common concerns. Between the politicians who have their basic, righteous ideals and the media who continues to feed this hatred between our two countries, it is simply unbelievable. There has always been, and always will be, differences between our two countries and that’s what makes us unique. It seems that bad people are all over the world, so just target those people, not the entire nation.



Rob
said
0 0

Let them build a wall for all I care, they're becoming less and less relevent anyway... Far more important relationships to consider in the world at this point...In all likelihood their dollar will collapse soon enough and we'd probably be best to distance ourselves from whats left of their economy by then anyway.


Anne
said
0 0

If ever that proverb that goes something like "take the log out of your own eye before looking at the sliver in someone else's" applies, it does to the good old US of A.


Mr.Muse
said
0 0

Pananioa is in bloom, the PR transmissions will resume...


Prof. Pye Chartt
said
0 0

This story has little, if any, substantive news content. As is clear from the comments posted thus far, it simply serves as a forum for "little" Canadians with their ingrained inferiority complex to build up their sense of nationalistic pride by putting down America. A "proud Canadian" seems to be inadvertently self-defined as someone who hates the U.S. the most, and can slag their southern neighbor with the greatest ease. Pathetic. I'm not sure when Canadians lost their class and became so petty and insecure. (Perhaps it was during the mouthy Chretien era.) Sad. And you folks wonder why, increasingly, Americans have little use for us. Trust me, many are aware of the false-superior "attitude"...and you know how they love France. Snap your fingers, and erase all the America-based business and subsidiary employment in Canada, and the resulting economic landscape would give most of you a heart attack. ...Reality check.


Albertan working in Texas
said
0 0

We can't blame the American PEOPLE for their train of thought. Has anyone watched CNBC lately? How about Fox News, CNN or Headline News. These are their major sources of information for the US, even if we consider them comedy networks. If the American Government wants to increase boarder protection, fine. It's not my decision, it's theirs. If any one is looking at the shape of the world right now, should we be concentrating on the US opinion of Canada, or should we be opening new doors to China, India and Russia, emerging markets that we can easily ship to from the west coast?


Patchy patch
said
0 0

First of all, none of the terrorists from 9/11 crossed over from Canada, hence the myth idea. Second, there is the issue of Canadians smuggling drugs into the US. However, the US like to try (and sometimes succeed) in smuggling guns up here. Clearly it's not nearly as bad as the problems at the US/Mexico border, but they do exist and need to be managed before it gets out of control.


Mimi2005
said
0 0

Where was Tim McVeigh from....oh yeah, the U.S. And he blew up a building killing dozens of children and adults. I think the Americans should look in their own back yard before they rant about their security issues with Canada.


dean
said
0 0

Well with all the anti- American rhetoric coming from Canada it isn't a wonder that the US wants to tighten border security. It seems Canadians feel free to deride the US, but when the Americans have a valid concern about Canada, it's taken as a huge insult and the name-calling begins. Some neighbors we are. Always remember that we need the US far more than they need canada.


Chris
said
0 0

I know how they can protect themselves. All they need to do is seal themselves inside a steel dome. No terrorists will get in and we won't have to put up with their world-wide meddling. Win-Win for everyone.


Concerned Citizen
said
0 0

If the Americans accept that the perpetrators lived within, then they have to take action, which no politician wants to. All that the politicians want is cheap publicity.


Dave
said
0 0

Once again some Americans need to get their heads out of their butts, as Derek has pointed out it is AMERICANS at the border crossing going in not Canadians. So to all those blaming Canada you have again proved your intelligence


Les In Ontario
said
0 0

Last I checked it wasn't just Canada that was responsible for policing the border between Canada and the US. So, why are we getting all the blame for not having the border under better control? HELLO!!! IF, and I put a big emphasis on IF, the men responsible for the 9/11 attacks did enter the US through Canada, then wasn't it the US customs officials that let them through?? Again, can't blame us entirely for that one either. I think that if the US wants to play the BLAME GAME they need to turn around and take a look in the mirror before they go accusing other countries of being lax in security, especially their neighbour to the north who provides them with water, energy, cheap prescription drugs, and oil. Don't bite the hand that feeds you now!!


George V.
said
0 0

Canadians give a huge boost to the U.S.A. economy, especially within the 200 km. range from our mutual boundry. Trade in this these areas are in the range of billions of dollars annually. This trade is to our mutual benefit. Why would anyone want to tinker, upset or change something that is so important to our economic well being. Here in Ontario when visiting cities like Rochester, Buffalo, Cleveland and the areas in between you can see the depressed state of the American economy , They sure can use the Canadian dollars to create jobs,and to sell product, With Canadians going in droves to cross border shop, not only for the small items, also the big ticket items like cars, boats, motor homes, house trailers, real estate etc.etc., if crossing our borders becomes to cumbersome and difficult people will stay home. Along the St.Lawerence, the great lakes and other waterways, everyone in the marinas used to go across with their boats and buy back our Canadian gas on the American side, plus other supplies, this practice has now been severely curtailed since 9-11. Safety and security is good, but don't upset the apple cart.


Poohbear
said
0 0

Thank God my parents choose Canada over the US when they immigrated from England. Proud to be Canadian!


Derek
said
0 0

Re: border crossing..........when you leave Canada and go to the US (south) you go through and talk to Americans at the American border crossings........and when you leave the US and go to Canada (north) you go through and talk to Canadians at the Canadian border crossings..........so please explain how is it Canada's issue for letting undesirables into the US? Just wondering.............


stu
said
0 0

I am against "IGNORANT THINKING", as most U.S. congressional members can't seem to get away from. The U.S. is not the place they once represented themselves to be, and I have made it a personal promise to never cross the border into their ignorant society again. (it's been 10 years) I would be in favor of boosting our Canadian security with a WALL along the entire border, and mounting 50Cal. machine guns to shoot the people trying to flee as the bottom falls out of the U.S. economy. All they want is our oil and cheap drugs to fuel their needs of getting to the doctor by driving and having him give them good drugs. Have you noticed that EVERYBODY in U.S.A. is sick with something?


America=Ignorance
said
0 0

God love em, I've dealt with dozens of Americans in my lifetime. A few were enlightened but the overwhelming majority were as dumb as a fence post. They believe whatever makes them feel good about themselves. If bashing their neighbours makes them feel good about themselves, then that is what they do even if they perpetuate an outright lie. I do not understand why Americans can not own up to the fact the 9/11 hijackers lived, worked and trained in America.


Frank Buchan
said
0 0

The US politicians want a country surrounded on all accessible sides by a giant wall of sorts, with a one way flow of information, resources, etc. One has to wonder if the people of the USA, which is a great country with some extraordinarily weak leaders, have observed yet that as their borders tighten their economy and standard of living is collapsing lockstep with that furious charge to isolate themselves from the world. Maybe someday they'll suss out that the best interests of the power brokers supposedly serving them isn't their own.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

A Canadian Pacific Railway employee walks along the side of a locomotive in a marshalling yard in Calgary, Wednesday, May 16, 2012. (Jeff McIntosh / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Talks between CP, union stall; Raitt prepared to step in

More   38 Comments 38    2 Video(s) 2

Nova  Scotia, body, Hillside Road, Marion Bridge

Police identify humans remains found in hockey bag

More  1 Video(s) 1

Most Talked about Stories

It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.

Harvey

Parents must learn to stop meddling, author urges