Canada -   

1

Are Ignatieff's family ties a help or a hindrance?

George Ignatieff, then-Canada's Ambassador to the United Nations, poses for a photo on July 11, 1966. Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff speaks with the media outside the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Wednesday, March 23, 2011. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) George Ignatieff, then-Canada's Ambassador to the United Nations, poses for a photo on July 11, 1966.
George Ignatieff, then-Canada's Ambassador to the United Nations, poses for a photo on July 11, 1966.

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (61) Facebook   

Selected Comment

When one's product is not good enough to stand on its own merits, one must resort to defaming the competition. Such is (and always be) the case with Mr. Harper and the manner in which he sells his party to Canadians.

It's what it is

Are Ignatieff's family ties a help or a hindrance?

talking about
Are Ignatieff's family ties a help or a hindrance?

Date: Saturday Mar. 26, 2011 10:07 AM ET

The ad campaigns have just begun, but already the Conservatives are painting Michael Ignatieff as out of touch with average Canadians.

Their previous ads -- with taglines like: "Just visiting," "Just in it for himself," and "Didn't come back for you" -- cast the Liberal leader as a gatecrasher who arrived too late to the politics party. This time, Ignatieff's own family background finds itself front and centre.

In fairness, it's the Liberals themselves who made Ignatieff's origins an issue.

In a video called "This is who I am" posted earlier this month on the Liberal website, Ignatieff talks about how his father George came to Canada on a boat in 1928 "with nothing," to give his children a chance at a better future," and "lived that immigrant dream, up the ladder one rung at a time."

The Tories immediately attacked that portrayal as disingenuous.

They shot back by posting a Web ad arguing that Ignatieff's father was hardly a typical hard-scrabble immigrant.

"The Ignatieff immigrant experience is one of significant wealth, first-rate educations and privilege. Very few Canadians can claim this 'immigrant experience," the ad intoned.

Ignatieff's father's family was indeed once part of the Russian aristocracy. Before the 1917 Bolshevik Revolution, his grandfather was the last czar's education minister and his grandmother, a princess.

After fleeing Russia, Ignatieff's father, George, lived on a British manor for a decade before coming to Canada. And once George arrived in Canada, he became a Rhodes scholar and later, a diplomat and ambassador to the UN.

Ignatieff was infuriated by the Tory ad, telling CTV's Question Period last weekend that Stephen Harper's party had distorted the facts and crossed the line of political decency.

"Their attack on me is a disgrace," Ignatieff said. "They've attacked my patriotism. They've attacked my commitment to the country. And now they're attacking my family...

"A Canadian is a Canadian is a Canadian. I am a proud Canadian. I won't take that from him or from anybody else."

One wonders whether the ads risk backfiring.

Many, including University of Windsor's Prof. Lloyd Brown-John, have said they smack of the ugly tone of "birthers", the U.S. conservatives who are trying to depict President Barack Obama as "un-American" because of questions about his birth.

Winnipeg political commentator Frances Russell wonders whether the Tories released the ads simply because they resent Ignatieff for being well-educated with an aristocratic pedigree.

But should it really be a shock for a politician to have come from wealth and good connections? Throughout time, and in many parts of the world still, "good" family ties are assets – and indeed, prerequisites – for entry into politics.

In the U.K., politicians have long sprung from the "upper classes." And while there's no literal aristocracy in the U.S., there is arguably a political aristocracy. America's electoral landscape is littered with candidates from wealthy families -- the Kennedys, the Rockefellers and the Bushes among them.

It's odd then that being born into privilege may become a political liability for Ignatieff.

Globe and Mail columnist and Question Period host Jane Taber remarked recently that the fierce rhetoric about whether Ignatieff is the product of "real" immigrants is a reflection of how highly prized the votes of immigrants are to each of the three main political parties.

The Liberal leader's video aimed to convince Canadian newcomers that Ignatieff understands their mindset, by right of his own immigrant history. The Conservatives, for their part, want new Canadians to see Ignatieff as "not one of them" – the son of an immigrant in name perhaps, but so unlike them.

The irony, noted a recent Globe editorial, is that Canada's current immigration system now prefers immigrants just like George Ignatieff: skilled, "business-class," and with means. Through Immigration Canada's skilled-worker program, points are awarded to potential immigrants for having university education and skilled work experience. So Ignatieff's father today would have been in plenty of good company.

But then, Canada likely doesn't like to think of itself as a country that prefers elite immigrants to desperate ones. That simply doesn't jibe with the image we have of ourselves.

We prefer to think of ourselves as a citizenship of salt-of-the-earth immigrants who pulled themselves up with our own bootstraps. We prefer the self-made -- both in our men and in our politicians.

It remains to be seen whether the Conservative attack ads will work as intended.

Ignatieff's popularity already remains desperately low. The most recent polling suggests that less than 15 per cent of Canadians think Ignatieff would make the best prime minister, compared to the 35 per cent of those who prefer Harper.

Over two years of Liberal Party leadership, it seems Ignatieff still struggles to connect with Canadians. Even after a summer bus tour of "practice" campaigning, it's not clear whether he has shaken his image of elitist aloofness.

And in politics -- Canadian politics especially -- one needs a man-of-the-people image in order to survive. As an article in The New York Times commented, Canada is a country "where politicians with even the vaguest hint of self-importance are more likely to be mocked… than revered."

Comments are now closed for this story

Leslie in Scarborough
said

The choice of "selected comments" would make you think the majority were in line with the theme of the piece. I had to go all the way to the bottom to find this one and only coherent quote that supports both her and Mr. Ignatieff's contention of how unfair his being called out on his less than truthful portrayal of his immigrant family history. ( I am an immigrant family member and a visible minority, so I don't think he should attempt to speak for me) I think the "Liberal" bias press is the last hope for the Liberal party. The Canadian 5th Estate has taken another blow for the party.


Gerry
said

It dosen't matter where he came from it matters what he does now. I think all minority governments should have to form a coalition in order to form a government and be forced to work together, also I think the prime minister should only be allowed to serve two terms.


UNDECIDED VOTER
said

Seems like the Conservatives are making much ado about "nothing"! The statement they dispute is "his father George came to Canada on a boat in 1928 "with nothing,". I talk to many immigrants who use this phrase when they say how they came with just the clothes on their backs. Afterwards you find out they did come with some money, which anyone with common sense would do.So are the Conservatives saying bringing money when you immigrate is not normal???That doesn't make sense at all, you'd be an idiot to come to Canada with no cash...


LDawg05
said

I think perhaps the point was missed; Iggy was trying to inform potential voters that his family came from a low start as immigrants to deflect from his past comments about being from Russian royalty; bottom line, he's not from the boat that most immigrants came in on; This is the point for better or worse...


Goodbye Iggy !!
said

1) Iggy is not a leader Canadians want - polls.2) Iggy stole his leadership - ask LPC members3) LPC demands a review after an election loss4) Vote Conservative of NDP gets rid of Iggy.5) Iggy needs to go (counting down 32 days)


Margaret
said

Good for Mr. Ignatieff's family! But what has this got to do with anything? An immigrant is an immigrant, is an immigrant. Mr. Ignatieff's ancestors survived tremendous social and political upheaval in Russia. So they went to Britain (uh? Why not? Wasn't Czar Nicholas a first cousin of Edward the VII of England? Maybe they had family connections in Britain?) before coming to Canada. Canada at that time didn't issue it's own citizenship papers. Mr. Ignatieff was born in Canada. That makes him as Canadian as me. Stop these personal attacks and get to the real issues at stake. The economy. Health Care. National Defense. Respect for our Representative Form of Democratic Government.


JUDY tired of this political crap
said

I for one don't care about where they came from what I am interested in is what honestly are any of the parties really going to do for us the Canadians who have build this land to what it is....every time the Liberals were in we went further into debt and they taxed us so high one could barely survive....and the NDP well, enough said and Bloc....I certainly do not want to become french in my Canadian country....so HARPER will definitely get my vote and I hope that most people who are true Canadians realize that what is has done is best for our country.


Mike in Pembroke
said

I do not know how Iggy thinks the Conservatives are attacking his family. Iggys Liberals portrays his father as coming to Canada on a boat in 1928 "with nothing," to give his children a chance at a better future," and "lived that immigrant dream, up the ladder one rung at a time." This is a complete lie and is just a play for the immigrants vote. This just proves Iggy is nothing but a hypocrite. He tries to make scandals out of every thing the conservatives say but he has no problem out and out lying to the Canadian people. As for the Conservatives attacking his family, No what I see is the Conservatives pointing out the falsehoods that the Liberals are saying about Iggys family background that his family did not arrive in Canada with nothing but came from a privileged background. This is not an attack as it is pointing out that the Liberals and their leader can not be trusted to tell the truth either.


Guelph Observer
said

Who cares, but since Mr. Harper brought it up, where are his ancestors from, and what about Jack Layton's ancestors, and Duceppe and May - let's get 'em all out on the table. And none of that information will change my vote!. BTW, Mr. Harper, in case it matters to you, I won't vote for you simply based on the fact that you had no respect for parliament and therefore the Canadian people that put you in office. So goodbye.


Rae in the Okanagan
said

Here we go again. We have tweedle-dee, tweedle-dum, tweedle-dummer, el la tweedle-de-francois. Lots of choices. Personally I liked the conservative ads that showed Stephen Harper as a hard working politician way more than the back-stabbing ads from any of the parties.I too am a first generation Canadian from immigrant parents like many of us are, and though I don't openly claim relation to the russian or European aristocracy, I too am a person of influence. I don't flaunt it but rather work towards helping others to achieve a profitable future for themselves. Do I parade the discrepancies of others to make myself appear the better choice or do I go about and make myself as a better choice without hurting others in the process.


Doug
said

Whatever the true motives of the ad, I think its purpose is to show that the Liberal ad was distorted, that Iggy's father did not arrive with only $5 in his pocket, for example. Pointing out the false claims of the opponent's ad is not really negative campaigning, IMO.


sooozyann
said

If you read the article it doesn't say that conservatives are attacking immigrants or questioning birthrights. They are attacking the liberal party's false depiction of Ignateiff's background on the liberal website. Read the article.


SF Thomas
said

Ignatieff's ancestors went from being aristocrats and advisers to the Tsar to owning a dairy farm in England before coming to Canada. That doesn't exactly scream nobility to me.


Al
said

Liberal insiders know Iggy will not do well on May 2nd.It will force them into a leadership convention shortly thereafter


Vancouver Maria
said

This story is so typical of the Liberals. They all do it. They twist the truth to the point it becomes a lie. And they think Canadians are so stupid they will gobble up the big lie. The deal is if you are going to put something out there make sure it is the truth. People like the truth. Its the same with the Liberal led opposition kangaroo courts, they basically lied and on that lie the Liberals have pushed us into an election.


Jim in Ontario
said

Of course, it is alright to come from privilege, but the problem was Ignatieff misrepresented his father's wealth by saying they came to Canada with "nothing". This is Canada, no one is entitled to public office and the vetting of the assertions of a man trying to become our Prime Minister is part of the process.


T.Mekete
said

The Conservatives are copying the ways of the Right wing of the U.S.Rep.Party.They are trying to divide people.All this talk of 'Coalition' is fear mongering and Canadians are smart enough not to fall for it. What bothers me is reporters insisting on asking the Libral leader to answer a hypothetical quetion. He is running for Liberal win.He does not have to answer hypotheticals. Get off it and move on to relevant. Mr Harper is quite happy to receive NDP support when it suits him. When theydon't support him they are'Socialists' He does business with the BLOC too when it suits him. They become 'Separatist' when they oppose him. Give me a break.


KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

I find it funny that the election was called over the issue of "Contempt of Parliament" -- however out on the street everyone holds parliament in complete and utter contempt... Good thing that's not against the law yet or we could all be charged and convicted.


chuck
said

Claire, I agree with you, why make his family past an issue. So the big question is why did the Liberal Party do that. And why did the Liberal Party try to reinvent his families past, when a read of his own book makes that attempt a blatant lie? I think you should direct your anger to the real cause of this issue, the stupid actions by someone in the Liberal Party.


mikel
said

Iggy lied, plain an simple. Unfortunately Liberal voters like it when their party lies.....


matteo72
said

So Ignatieff lied about his heritage? Typical Liberal. He is sneaky and sly. He worked behind the scenes to oust Dion as party leader so he couls grab power, he worked behind the scenes to form a coalition with a seperatist party and a far left socialist - with himself as the coalition leader - because he wanted power. Now he worked behind the scenes to bring down a government that was working and forced an election that nobody wanted, just so he could try to grab power! If the Conservatives do not win a majority government this election, his next step will be to approach the GG and present a motion to form the next (coalition) government. Just so he can grab power. Ignatieff is power hungry and he claims the Conservatives are deceitful and lack integrity?? Thats the pot calling the kettle black my friends....


AW in GTA
said

I may not like Ignatieff, but his family background should be no one's business but his, except maybe as an interesting trivia. There's absolutely nothing wrong with coming from a distinguished lineage, just as there's nothing wrong with a humble one, as long as it doesn't figure into one's chance of success in life. Most Canadians are immigrants or their descendants anyway, so using this as an election issue is neither here nor there.


Scott
said

Harper embraces immigrants but not Iggy's family? Too successful? Well traveled, well educated and well respected outside this country. No, lets draw assumptions about him looking like a used car salesman based on trivial stereotypes. Is that not the same as making fun of Layton for his limp or Chretien for facial paralysis. Grow up, listen to the issues. Make up your mind. Vote intelligently. I don't know who I am voting for but it will take seriously good vision to get my vote, not a slippery handshake or an attack ad.


rick milley
said

if iggy doesnt like the ads he can go back to HIS america


Devin in Sask
said

Ignatieff''s the guy that decided to bring his family history into the far here. No one to blame but himself.


Stu
said

Harper is the only prime Minister that never achieved a law degree, oh & Joe Clark. Seems the cons are all a little short on the learnin. No wonder Harper acts like a child. Ignatieff will be 10000% better PM than Harper could ever dream of being.


Chad
said

He lied, plain and simple. The issue is not his family. The writer of this story is trying to spin the issue.If the Conservatives are the ones that think being elitist is bad, then why are Liberals trying to hide that fact that Ignatieff is one? The Liberals are the ones that are embarrassed of him.One other point. Why do Liberals try to paint the US as everything that is evil in the world and then have as a leader someone who spent more of his adult life in the US then Canada and referred to the US as his country?


Richard in New Brunswick
said

Mr. Ignatieff, if you wish to have a chance to win this election you must do the following. First, get the best writers who are expert in crafting political speeches that are sprinkled with humour, loaded with dramatic impact and that NEVER mention other parties or candidates. I repeat... NEVER respond to, reply, compare, attack, mention or in any other way acknowledge that there are any other candidates. Why use your time to advertise that they exist? Secondly, get an acting coach. Politics is theatre - not very good theatre, admittedly - but show business nevertheless. It's all about grabbing an audience in the first minute or two. To give a rousing stump speech is as different from delivering a lecture as lightning is from a lightning bug (thanks to Mark Twain for the analogy).

Claire - Toronto
said

What a crock! Now we are supposed to bring Michael Ignatieff's background into the picture? Oh, please. How about asking all the other contenders what their backgrounds are? This is going to be a tiresome election.


Prof. Pye Chartt
said

Make no mistake, the Liberal "strategy" was to appeal (pander) to immigrants in Canada by portraying Ignatieff as one of them, and just like them. However, Iggy's lineage and his father's immigration "experience" aren't genuinely relatable. The approach, and the attempt, has backfired. Wagging a finger at the Conservatives, who pointed out the political phoniness of the claim, is laughable. (Spare me the bogus and contrived "birther" take. It misses the central point entirely.) Ultimately, arguably, this disclosure underscores the countering Conservative assertion that Michael Ignatieff is par for the stereotypical Liberal course, an elitist (who spent a great deal of formative time outside Canada) with his very own political agenda.


Jackie a Liberal in Ontario
said

First thing to keep is that the liberals put Michaels family info out there on the website. This makes it fair game for the NDP and Concervitives to go after if it does not give an accurate picture. Michael has gone after the Harper Government and Mr. Harper himself on his integrity. Watching Michael over these past 12 months I find that Michaels integrity has been in question in my mind many times. As a Liberal myself I wish Michael would have spoken out about what he believes the Liberal Party could do to make Canada better and how he would help the Canadian people. I have not hear any of this from him. As much as it pains me to say this, come election day I will have to vote Concervitive this time.I feel the Liberals under Michaels leadership are doomed to failure.


Will
said

Oh, for crying out loud, will you lot please start thinking for yourselves! In what way has Harper shown any disrespect for democracy or contempt for Parliament? This is just a trumped up charge to force through Ignaetief’s non-confidence motion and try to create fear in Canadians. So let’s address the claims: 1) Oda- as minister all documents, no matter who creates them, in departments in her charge are HERs. She has the authority to approve, change, or cancel any of them. The public servants in a department work under the minister’s authority and it doesn’t matter what they decide/recommend/want, the final decision is the ministers. This is a non-issue. 2) estimates: numbers are NEVER attached to legislation when drafted and submitted to the house for consideration. When the house demanded them, they were provided but it takes time to put them together. Again a non-issue. 3) Contempt: a trumped up charge, seen by Canadians for what it is, nothing less than a way to bring down the lawful government for purely partisan purposes. Canadians will remember this, no matter how fickle the electorate may be, and punish the perpetrators at the poles.


Jay Lloyd
said

Though Iggy has said distasteful comments, arn't all Politicians guilty of doing things wrong at some point? Look at the bigger picture, Harper choose to brand Iggy an outsider immigrant- how odd! since He and Kenney pride themselves on multiculturalism!! so what Harper is saying then..is that any immigrants are not worthy of being Canadian nor of much else really..so Harper why allow immigrants in while you reject your own Canadians with Gender discrimination and rejection of citizenship based on it! Banging on about Iggys background is not the bigger picture Harper has closed parliament before and He will do what it takes to get what he wants..remember -you all have parents who will be elderly and short of being rich nothing Harper will do will help them! a few quid is not the same as decent Healthcare! You can convince Libs or NDP for that Harper wants jets and the economy is balanced now thanks Harper! Off you go!


Luke-Vernon,BC
said

I agree with Vicky. Just watch Ignatieff's facial expressions and gestures. He reminds me of what I don't want leading my country...a politician (a wealthy used-car salesman). At least with Harper, what I see is what I get. He is an economist, not a lawyer. His plans might not appeal to each one of us personally, but remember his job is to keep this corporation (Canada) afloat. I feel that he has been doing what needed to be done almost every step of the way throughout this global economic meltdown, and because of his strategies (and a little luck) Canada has come out very well. I reallly don't feel that Ignatieff ever has any ideas of his own, he just listens to what Harper announces and then puts on that smarmy grin and denounces it. Well if that is all that is needed to be a leader, you can go down to any pub around 11PM and find a room full of potential Liberal leaders, because after 6 pints, everyone is a smurking critic that can berate the PM's ideas.

KJ in Kingston Ontario
said

I think I would be more inclined to focus on Iggy's policies than his parents -- we can't really help who are parents were -- and if they were princesses and aristocrats -- it could be worse -- one look at him and you know he never worked in McDonalds but it is the idiot coalition plan the man has in mind for Canada that should be revealed in full... Spend spend spend - -tax tax tax -- borrow borrow borrow... The BQ, NDP and Liberals -- what a disaster that will be.


Michel
said

To Sue: Do not forget Iggy lived in the states for many years, he supported the Iraq war and Torture just like the america really do... Even liberal do not find him canadian, he was hardly able to skate on the Rideau canal and one if is entourage did say it shows he's not Canadian... So who will get us turned into American's... Take you head out of ... and smell the cofee


Scott
said

Iggy's dad was a Rhodes Scholar - you can't buy that. Iggy is highly intelligent and very knowlegeable in economics, he actually seems to engage his MPs rather than run roughshod over them. Yup I say we have a real loser here! We need an arrogant farmboy to run the country.


Keith Fisher
said

The economy and health care do not appear to be issues with Ignatieff at this point. His main beef with Harper is integrity. Well, the matter of his heritage (on the Liberal website) portrays him as being something other than what he is. It is a misrepresentation of the facts. This leads to doubts about the integrity of Ignatieff himself. Something about the pot calling the kettle black? And regarding the feigned outrage that Count Ignatieff displayed on CTV, somebody should tell him that the Academy Awards were given out last month and by the time the next awards are presented, he should be but a distant unpleasant memory. Bring on the next Liberal messiah, be it Rae or Trudeau... with a cast like this, the Conservative Party has a bright future in Canada.


Will
said

Ignaetief’s family was irrelevant until he lied about his background. This brings the real issue up: who can be trusted. Ignaetief has painted a false picture of himself to the public, Harper and Layton have not. Ignaetief has NEVER contributed to this country throughout his lifetime; the same cannot be said for Harper or Layton who both have. Ignaetief constantly points to his education as making him superior to everyone else,(ever heard the old saying that you can lead a man to knowledge but you cannot make him THINK) not so for the other two main party leaders. Ignaetief was never elected to lead his party; do I really need to point out the difference? Ignaetief has always led a sheltered existence, hidden away from the real world in ivy covered halls, not so with the other two……Can anyone truly consider him a viable candidate for Member of Parliament, let alone as a potential Prime Minister?


Shannon
said

Mr. Ignatieff is the one who started trying to use his family ties to his own advantage. Then he's upset when someone calls him on it. I don't like attack ads regardless of which party they represent, but the truth is that the Ignatieff family did not exactly show up on a boat with the clothes on their back and a yen in their pocket.Maybe the Conservs. shouldn't have been nasty about Iggy's family, but Iggy shouldn't have (a) used his family for personal gain and (b) tried to "spin" the truth


Kathy (Don MIlls)
said

Ignatieff is an elitist, academic, socialist, snob. I don't trust the man, sorry. I'm good with Harper, he is steady with no unpleasant surprises. Iggy on the other hand stole the party leadership and I will remember that when I vote. Carbon taxes? NO THANKS to increased taxes.


Pat
said

Iggy is a Count...that's fine...his family had power and money...fine...but please don't try to fool Canadians by saying your parents were "poor Immigrants' with nothing. You are what you are, Count Iggy...just have the guts and honesty to admit what you are.


Vickie
said

My main problem with Ignetieff is that the Liberal party out of desperation put him in charge. Without even batting an eye, the Liberals decided that all Canadians, even former liberals should accept someone they have no real knowledge of. It was unfair and unresponsible. As a Canadian I feel I was let down by the Liberal party. I was not shown the choices, I was not privvy to their decision as there was no party campaign. At least had it been Frank McKenna, Justin Trudeau or another well known Canadian Liberal I would have had some inkling as to what this person was about. I truly do not trust Ignetieff. I personally believe he thinks he is the Liberal saviour but I as many others who have voted Liberal before will not again. Not until we have a strong trustworthy candidate. He is too wishy washy, does not come up with ideas until one is put in front of hime, he may be a very intelligent man but he is not for Canada. He is for himself. Watch his posturing, it is all about him. Watch his facial expressions, he is smug and mocking of our Parliment. One only has to listen to his voice, watch his movements and pay attention to his eyes then draw your own conclusions on his trustworthiness. I will not vote for the Liberals again until they have a person I feel comfortable enough with to say I want him/her to manage my country. No I am not a Conservative supporter, I am a Canadian who wants the best candidate out there. To be honest I think all three have too many bad points but for me right now, Harper is the best of the worst.


Jon in London ON
said

Ignatieff's family was aristocratic. He should never have tried to portray them otherwise. Sorry Michael - you made your bed. As for the of the ugly tone of "birthers", the U.S. conservatives who are trying to depict President Barack Obama as "un-American" because of questions about his birth, remember that this started with the DEMOCRATIC Hillary Clinton team during the nomination process.


Sue
said

I'm amazed how anyone can be so mean to a well educated, well behaved man like Micheal Ignatieff. It's obvious the conservatives are only in it for the power, they are turning Canada into the USA. Harper has given away our sovereignty & become a puppet of the USA. We need a well mannered well educated Canadian like Ignatieff to run our country. This senior can not vote for a government that is in contempt of parliament.


Frank in NS
said

Hmmmm, so the apple doesn't fall far from the tree. "Poor" immigrants that came through pier 21 in Halifax were immediately shipped off to the Canadian prairies to continue to develop that area and work their butts off to survive. They are the real hero's and not this man who likes to lie and deceive.


Dave - Ottawa Valley
said

There is nothing wrong with Iggy's birth etc. While he could perhaps call himself Prince Iggy, it would not be in keeping with the Canadian political scene.What he misses completely is that the fiberal ads portrait his family as a poor family coming to Canada and working themselves up to the position where his father was touted as a possible GG.Like PET, he comes from a higher economic and social strata than most Canadians. This does not disqualify him from his present position.The ads are down right mis-truths. He should come clean with his background, pull the ads, and stop whining about it being unfair. He started it for the party benefit. Can we support the libs? when they accuse the government of being unparlementary while they lie to Canadians? I think not.


Al in Orillia
said

Amazing how a strong Conservative leader is painted by the Liberals as a dictator, but a controlling Liberal Leader like Trudeau or Chretien, is just a strong leader. It's so hard to take anything Ignatieff and his gang says seriously.


spaz
said

Regardless of his roots Michael Ignatieff moves, talks and behaves with the Liberal pompus rights of a Russian Prince.After countless years in the US of A Prince Michael now comes back to what......lead us in the next revolution ?????If this is your game plan.......you came to the wrong province........you need to be leader of the BLOC


Dr. James Bradford
said

Michael Ignatieff's family ties are not the main concern. The critical issue is can Canadians trust what Michael Ignatieff says? Ignatieff was more than a little dishonest when made a TV ad and contradicted his own biography by downplaying his status as a Russian Count to paint himself as an average Joe. The truth is Michael Ignatieff is not an average Joe he is an academic elitist from Harvard. Ignatieff was dishonest and undemocratic when he accepted the Liberal leadership position handed to him by fellow Liberal insider elites instead of being elected by the party grassroots faithful. Michael Ignatieff talks democracy yet breaks the rules for himself and that is dishonest. Beyond that this entire hyperpartisan non confidence "show" in the House of Commons for the last 4 months was a deliberate plan etched out in the Liberal war room by the old party hacks to try and topple the elected Government and force an election just so Michael Ignatieff "could have a go" at trying to become PM. Wasting $300 million dollars on a false pretense is more of the same dishonesty. The Tory TV ad which says "its always about Michael" is correct. Canadians are beginning to see clearly through this Liberal "Culture of deceit" and will respond accordingly.


Cleo
said

His arrogance and aloofness knows no bounds! He is certainly not the person who should lead the Liberals. I'm afraid they are doomed! If Iggy loses this election(no doubt in my mind) waiting in the background is Justin Trudeau. I think the Liberals are grooming him for the next leader!


Ryan
said

No one cares about his history....the point is Iggy isn't being forthright about his families true story....don't try and play a card that you never held..Ignatieff has been a failed political experiment by the Liberal Party of Canada


Flea Market Creep
said

This article completely misses the point. It is not that Ignatieff comes from wealth. I do not believe that most reasonable people in this country resent wealth. The Tories' ad was solely to show that Ignatieff is a liar. In his own biography he discusses his origins. It is only recently that his family were 'poor immigrants'. In fact, he is technically a Count. And good for him. But he lied about it to try and score political points. If the hot topic is contempt for democracy, what do you call this? Lying to get elected... I'd say that's contempt for democracy.


Old Ted
said

It doesn't sound like Ignatief's immigrant parents were hardly the impoverished sould portrayed. Besides, people who lived fifty years ago hardly matter in this election. When it comes to a choice of an educated man or one with common sense, I'll take the man with the common sense every time. Since coming back on the scene again in Canada, I haven't heard of one good idea from Ignatief regarding the direction that Canada should be going in. It's time for him to step aside and allow someone else a chance at leading the Liberal party. Besides, Mr. Harper seems to be doing a relatively good job especially considering the economic mess the world is in.


Big A
said

Forgot oneFurthermore igg has brought down parliament for reasons that are very similar to the tactics of the previous liberals of Chretien. Was there ever a leader that was more dictatorial than Jean? Trudeau maybe.The public needs to have a better memory.


W
said

The issue isn't that he came from a more privillaged family; its about how he attempted to portray his background. Mr. Iggnatief did not come from humble beginings and he is not the typical first generation Canadian.


Big A
said

This man is a complete waste of taxpayer's money. He complained that Harper wasn't giving enough to get Canadians out of a huge recession so he got together with the coalition and threatened to bring an election if Harper did not give huge amounts to the auto sector. Now he complains that tthe deficit is too high!!Canadians want less crime but igg wants to reward criminals with less jail time and more "lets try to get them straight" We now have repeat sex pshycos rampant in our society with more rights than the victimsHarper has tried to make an elected senate only to be refused by the likes of igg who had a liberal majority in the senate. No bills were being passed under this system so Harper had to bring in new senators to get the bills passed. now igg complains that he is patronizing Igg and the boys still can't figure out where all the guns are coming from so they look at serial numbers in the gun shops. They weren't sold Igg !!!! They are smuggle while you turn a blind eye and blame the farmer or the hunterThe igg is out of touch


vince in trenton
said

For 5 years all I have heard is how bad PM Harper is and how he is going to ruin this country....5 years later still going strong....I wonder just how bad off we are going to be in 5 years from now???It is alright for everyone else in the political game to run Harper and anyone else who isn't painted red into the ground ......but when you lie and are called out on it it is attacking the other person, but only if you are blue.....If and only if the Liberals can show me what they will do for me and Canada will I listen to them, but quit telling me all you will do to make Canada better is get rid of PM Harper......


It's what it is
said

When one's product is not good enough to stand on its own merits, one must resort to defaming the competition. Such is (and always be) the case with Mr. Harper and the manner in which he sells his party to Canadians.


Habeous Corpus @ Whitby
said

So Iggy comes across being aloof and privileged at time, maybe he's shy? Harpy comes across like Napoleon, acting like a dictator with His MP's, could be He has trust issues? What are their policies & platforms, that's what we really need to know...


left or right, Cornwall
said

"No mothers man!"


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Election 2011

CTV Election Central

Election Cental

Click here for latest news, blogs, polls, issues and more.

Election Results

Election Results

Extensive election results. Click here to find out who won in your riding.

Campaign Blog

Campaign Blog

Latest reports, photos and videos straight from the campaign trail.

Election 2011 at CTV News

Election 2011 at CTV News

In Pictures: CTV News team prepares for Monday's election special

Poll Tracker - Final

Poll Tracker

Follow the dots on our nightly poll, plus analysis by Nik Nanos.

the party, promo

The Party

How hard can it be to create a political party? Watch the episodes.

Leader Profiles

Leader Profiles

What's their strategy, and how have things changed since the last election?

CTV's Question Period

CTV's Question Period

Politicians under the gun. Newsmakers on the hotseat.

Power Play

Power Play

Don Martin with a fresh look at politics, politicians and plays.

Today's Canada Stories

Double lung transplant recipient Helene Campbell appears on 'Ellen,' on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Campbell celebrates recovery with 'Ellen' appearance

More   15 Comments 15    10 Video(s) 10

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  1 Video(s) 1

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada has confirmed that a small plane has  crashed near Cochrane, Ont. on Friday, May 25, 2012.

2 dead in northern Ontario plane crash

More

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?