Canada -   

1
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff points at a luncheon speech at the Quebec chamber of commerce Monday, March 14, 2011 in Quebec City. (Jacques Boissinot / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff waves before a luncheon speech at the Quebec chamber of commerce, in Quebec City Monday, March 14, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS / Jacques Boissinot) Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff speaks to the media in Quebec City, Monday, March 14, 2011.

Liberals would fund Quebec arena, Ignatieff says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Robert Fife on the election
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff promises to help attract an NHL hockey team back to Quebec City if elected. Meanwhile, the Tories are making pitches of their own to gain votes in a possible federal election.
Power Play: Derek Fildebrandt, CTF
The national research director with Canadian Taxpayer Federation gives his reaction to Michael Ignatieff's promise to help build professional hockey arenas if elected.
CTV Atlantic: Steve Murphy speaks with Bob Rae
Liberal foreign affairs critic Bob Rae shares his thoughts on Japan, Libya, and a possible spring election with CTV's Steve Murphy.
CTV News Channel: Robert Fife on election buzz
Fife says government ads are intended to drive voters to the Conservative party, and Liberals are promising funding for sports arenas in Quebec. Meanwhile, polls suggest the Tories are in the lead.
CTV National News: Richard Madan on the budget
If you're among Canadians betting against a federal election, growing advice from Ottawa says don't risk your money. Several developments over the weekend are adding to mounting speculation that we are indeed heading for a spring vote.
CTV's Question Period: NDP leader Jack Layton
As an election looms, Layton says he does not want to support the Conservative government; he does want to 'get things done' and implement practical programs.
CTV's Question Period: Minister Stockwell Day
The Treasury Board president says after 25 years, he and his wife decided it was the right time for him to leave public office, saying 'it's not retirement, it's re-alignment.'

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (69) Facebook   

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff points at a luncheon speech at the Quebec chamber of commerce Monday, March 14, 2011 in Quebec City. (Jacques Boissinot / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff waves before a luncheon speech at the Quebec chamber of commerce, in Quebec City Monday, March 14, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS / Jacques Boissinot) Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff speaks to the media in Quebec City, Monday, March 14, 2011.

Photos

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff points at a luncheon speech at the Quebec chamber of commerce Monday, March 14, 2011 in Quebec City. (Jacques Boissinot / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Mar. 14 2011 9:51 PM ET

With a spring election possibly on the horizon, Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff announced his party would help fund a hockey arena in Quebec City if elected.

Ignatieff made the announcement in Quebec City, where the Conservative government waffled on helping build a new professional hockey arena, before ultimately deciding not to invest federal taxpayer dollars.

"There will be an alternative to the Conservatives who are saying no and the NDP that can't do anything, the Bloc (Québécois) that can't deliver anything, and the Liberal party that can deliver the goods on the arena question," Ignatieff said.

"Mr. Harper . . . said no to the arena. And I say yes, so there's a clear distinction there."

Ignatieff said he supports funding for a new arena, if it's a multifunctional public space. But he said he has yet to see a business plan for the proposed $400-million arena.

"If you have a public space that can serve the cultural and economic interests of a whole region, then it seems to me that's the kind of thing a federal government can participate in," he said.

"That's why we think the Colisée is a good idea for Quebec and we would take the same view for other cities across the country."

Ignatieff's opponents were quick to attack his pledge.

"He wants to subsidize professional sports teams that are owned by billionaires who hire millionaires. It's just outrageous," Conservative MP and Government House Leader John Baird said.

"There's no question Michael Ignatieff is pandering for votes in the Quebec City region," added NDP MP Thomas Mulcair.

Quebec City Mayor Regis Labeaume had asked for $180 million for a new hockey arena from Ottawa, which would be built in hopes of luring the return of an NHL team.

After the Conservatives eventually declined to fund the arena, Labeaume went on local radio saying the party had committed "political suicide".

The majority of the Tories 11 seats in the province are around Quebec City.

Derek Fildebrandt, the national research director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, said funding sports arenas is a waste of money, particularly because of the federal deficit. "They've deemed that millionaire sports players and billionaire sports owners are in dire need of corporate welfare," he said on CTV's Power Play of the Liberal policy.

"When no party has any real plan to get our spending under control and balance the budget, for the Liberal leader to come up with an announcement like this is entirely irresponsible."

Comments are now closed for this story

Catwoman 38
said

What a bunch of hypocrits on here. When the Tories offer to spend billions on prisons, etc. You now give an opposition leader crap for not even spending 250 million on an arena that people in Quebec want for their regions prosperity.Not to mention, the Quebec City mayor even spoke up and said he needed federal funding.So good play on Ignatieff. He is doing this for the people in the region , and not for his rich friends, like Harper would do.Is it the liberals fault Harper only cares for his own supporters in his own party? No it is not. It is Harper.Face it, Harper is not a leader


B in Ottawa
said

Professional sports arenas should not be the focus of the federal government. Arenas should be build as a private sector investment. If Quebec wants a new arena, they should do what every other province in this country would do: find a private investor who can raise money and build the arena. Not lobby Ottawa to build it for them. Quebec already gets special treatment from Ottawa as an incentive to stay in Canada. It is interesting to note that the Liberal Party complains about the Conservatives spending 1 million of their own money in an election campaign when they would have us waste 400 million taxpayer dollars on something that is the responsibility of the private sector, and another 300 or 400 million taxpayer dollars on a needless and opportunistic election that only Michael Ignatieff wants. Canadians want to see action on the economy and jobs. They don't want their federal government in the business of building sports facilities. The Conservatives continue to get things done for Canada.


CEF
said

Just another reason not to vote for the Liberals. Why should the rest of Canada have to pay for an arena in Quebec - they dont even want to be part of the country. Raising taxes to pay for this would be waste of taxpayers money. Think of the more important things that the money could be used for. This is just another vote buying scheme by the liberals and their coalition government wanna bes.


Kelly Hamilton
said

The Liberal party once again shows us why they do not deserve our respect nor support. It is the height of disrespect and irresponsibility for this so called leader to suggest this course of action. I am insulted just learning of this to think he can wave this proposal under voters noses and they would bite. The arrogance !!!


Jaid in Toronto
said

Tired of leaders trying to buy my vote, earn it.


Brad
said

So does that meen that Edmonton or Winnipeg can get money ofr new areans too? seems smart buy votes in one city to loose them in the rest of Canada!


Jonny Ballgame
said

Who is Iggy's strategist? That tactic may have bought him a couple of votes in Quebec, but likely cost him several thousand in the rest of the country. Conservatives are laughing at him right now! HA!


Bob
said

Liberal funding is down so you have to look for alternatives. I guess this is an easy way to increase Liberal funds. Make promises that tax payers cover the cost.


WestofTheRockies
said

Hey Rob Alberta, We are agreed this is stupid policy and we'll be paying for it in the slim chance this idiot gets elected but pleeeease..... get off your soap box. Alberta is not funding everything in Canada. B.C. and Ontario are and have long been net contributors (Sent vs. Rec'd) to Federal coffers as well. B.C. and Ontario longer than Alberta. In terms of equalization payments B.C. & Alberta have received them before but for the first time ever, Ontario will this year. Set up in 1957 B.C. and Ontario were the benchmarks used for the system. The two traditional "Have" provinces at the time and many years after. Quebec has of course managed to be a "have-not province since.


N.O. Fundarena from ON
said

People of Sherbrooke, Drummondville, Montreal, Chicoutimi, speak up. Let's hear from you. You pay federal taxes like the rest of us. Do you want those taxes to go towards an arena in QC that is by and large for the private sector ? If so, I'm sure you wouldn't mind if your taxes also pay for one in Winnipeg and maybe a covered CFL stadium in Halifax. What about you folks in Quebec City, are you buying into this shameless pandering by Iggy?


Mike in Pembroke
said

Michael Ignatieff said he would fund the arena in Quebec which means he is fishing for Liberal votes in Quebec. If and I say if he was elected PM I can see the headlines shortly after the election. SORRY QUEBEC, I was left such a huge deficit that the governmet does not have the money. But thats okay folks because I am the MP now. Did Quebec City not have a NHL team before which the people did not support so they were sold to an American city? What makes Iggy think the people of Quebec city will support an NHL team now? Ignatieff has been bitching about how big the deficit is (even though he and Jack forced the CPC to spend) so I would like to ask him where the money is coming from. What side of the country is he going to take it from, the Eastern or the Western parts of Canada. I do not believe anything Iggy says as he will say anything to get elected. The Liberal Party needs a new believeable leader and I do not mean Bob Rae.


Act of a desperate man
said

"for the Liberal leader to come up with an announcement like this is entirely irresponsible." .....I say it is irresponsible, desperate and foolish to use OUR money this way and foolish for Quebecers to fall for this tactic.


JPC
said

Buying votes WITH OUR MONEY is what Liberals do best. Millionaires don't need handouts.This may buy them a few votes in Quebec but take MANY away in the rest of the country.


Proud Albertan
said

Glad to see that BUYING votes hasn't gone out of style.


A retired westerner
said

Iggy, your party just lost my vote because of your irresponsible proposal. If you promise this what other important country wide needs wiil have to be dropped due to lack of federal funds. You are desperate for votes and your back room advisors are not doing you any favours.


Ed1949
said

He complains constantly about Harper spending money and what does he do promises a new arena for Quebec. Is there no end to this train of thought. No way will I vote Liberal.


TRex in BC
said

Yet another reason to NOT vote Liberal. I'll be damned if Iggy is going to use MY tax dollars to build an arena where another business will profit from me. If Quebec wants an arena, then Quebec can fund the arena with THEIR tax money from provincial coffers.


Namesh (GTA)
said

Oh my goodness gracious, this will never be good. Imagine taking our tax dollars and using them to buy Quebec votes! What will my friends in the GTA think of this one? We will vote Conservative. This is just so outrageous for this man to do this thing to us.


Gullible Quebecois?
said

Ignatieff and his Liberal organizers must think Quebecois lack intelligence to fall for this political bait. How contemptuous towards the Quebecois voter by this Liberal leader and his handlers! You can be sure had the Prime Minister suggested using taxpayer dollars to fund an NHL arena there would be hell to pay. The hypocrisy of this Liberal party is very disturbing and they have been doing this for generations - buying the vote. Are Quebecois really that gullible?


Bob
said

This kind of "vote buying" is a typical Liberal posture. I only hope that Canadians see this for what it truly is. An atempt from the leader of a party deficient in any ability to govern to dupe the peoples of Quebec into supporting his party.


Mike vdB - Chatham, ON
said

Slippery slope. I don't think money should go to a professional hockey arena from the public coffers. Simply put, it should be funded by private contributions, the owners, the players, the people who buy the tickets (essentially the people who would use it). Iggy is wrong on this one.


It's what it is
said

@ MargMM... funny comment after the vote buying that Harper's been doing for years, and with your full support in these forums might I add. And yet, he has not delivered on the bulk of them like you accuse Liberals of doing. Someone's hypocritical colours certainly are showing through now aren't they? Give it a rest.


Mike in Lloyd
said

If the Harper gov't had said they would fund an arena in Que, then Iggy would be crying foul over spending tax dollars on a frivolous expenditure. This is nothing but a ploy to garner votes in the upcoming election that's "not happening" anytime soon. If Iggy wants to fund one in Que, then he better be prepared to dole out funds for the stadium in Regina, and any other city that wants a new stadium. I agree with not using tax money for entertainment venues when it could be wisely used in more important areas of the country. This is simply political sandbox play, that is not necessary. Liberal ploys just to make themselves look like the good guy. Give me a break.


Jack Meseyton
said

Well let's look at this.....Iggy said he would fund a new arena in QC. Maybe he meant with HIS own money...seen as how he is so free with the cash. Maybe?HAHHAHAHAHAHHa of course not....I know it is IGGY's promise but our money! IGGY and Liberals.....please come up with something other then this. Pandering at its worst.


Joyce
said

"Anonymous Al"; couldn't have said any better even if you are a Liberal supporter or not . Ignatieff certainly knows how to get his foot in his mouth on very many occasions. Mr. Ignatieff has forgotten about the outcry of Taxpayers about this issue. We do not need to fund the millionaire Hockey Players and have our Troops suffer because of the Lliberal Leader's stance on Arena funding. What part of "not" does Ignatieff not understand .


Sarah P
said

That wooshing sound sound you hear is the votes of everyone east of Ottawa fleeing the Liberals. What a dumb decision by Iggy and co.


mark
said

Hmm...sounds like they're trying to start a program to sponsor the arena. They could even toss in a bunch of Canadian flags on there with this sponsoring. Wonder what they'd call this sponsorship-type program...Ah, the Liberals. They'll spend as much of your money as possible if it buys them votes.


Guelph Observer
said

Very clever politics Iggy and may I suggest that when you are PM that you take the money from Alberta. That gov't out there doesn't know what to do with all that money they are raking in from the tar sands - may as well go to a worthy cause.


Cambob in Toronto
said

"...But he said he has yet to see a business plan for the proposed $400-million arena." So... in addition to buying votes with voters own money, he doesn't even know what the bribe is. Brilliant.


Beadle in Winnipeg
said

Mr. Ignatief, you have made a poor decision. The rest of Canada will not take kindly to even more money larded onto Quebec, in order to buy votes with other provinces taxpayers' money.It seems every time Quebec squawks, the rest of the country must cough up more cash.I say, let Quebec go, and we will see how it does as a French island in an English speaking ocean. If this happens then there will be no more bilingual balony in the rest of Canada. It would be nice to not have to turn labels around in the grocery stores in order to read something other than French.


back and to the left
said

If building an arena in Quebec City gets rid of Stephen Harper, I'm ok with it. I'm tired of having a sneak for a Prime Minister. Stephen Harper is the worst thing to happen to Canadian politics in my lifetime.


rob from ontario
said

iggy always said canada doesnt want an election, well i think i speak for the country WE DONT WANT ONE! and yet he threatens onehe says he knows what canadians want.... he comes up with a new hockey arena and in all places quebec WE DONT WANT IT, this man is so out of touch not just with canadians but the world.liberals never learn their lesson favoring quebec over the rest of the country is political suicide


Scott, BC
said

Wow. I'm glad he made this move - he looks even more like a desparate idiot attempting to buy votes. If he funds this he needs to also fund one in Edmonton, Halifax, maybe something in Saskatchewan - and what about Winnipeg? We need Iggy like we need a hole in the head! GO HOME TO THE US!


Frank Buchan
said

The Liberals are free to fund it any time they wish. Does such a stupid statement constitute a verbal contract? Reminder to all politicians (not that they care), but we -- the public -- are who fund your nonsense.


Cameron in Deux-Montagnes
said

Thanks for now ensuring a Conservative Majority, Mr. Ignatieff - Not!! How much longer will we have to stand for you opening your mouth and in the process destroying the Liberal Party? Time to get back to Academia and leave Canadian politics to those who realize that the majority of Canadians, including those of us in Quebec, DO NOT want our tax dollars going to support professional sports teams nor to help bail out millionaires who will not take the risks involved themselves. The Conservative Party must be jumping with glee at the opportunity you have given them to blow you out of contention for ever governing Canada.


justanothercanadian
said

Liberals are so divisive. This is exactly why the Conservatives didn't give the money for the arena. Now every province that wants an arena is upset because money isn't thrown their way. If the conservatives did this the liberals and NDP would have gone crazy. It's no wonder why so many detest the way Liberals do politics.


Retired in Burlington
said

The Liberals will help fund a hockey arena in Quebec. Every Election the Liberals try to buy votes in Quebec yet the PQ doesn't want anything to do with Canada unless of course they can get money from whatever party is in power. This promising Quebec money or special treatment is an old song the liberals love to sing and Iggy is the new lead singer. I didn't hear any such promises for the rest of Canada. I can hardly wait until election day so we can get rid of Mr. Ignatieff once and for all.


David
said

Is Iggy thinking about trying to get our finances in order or is he just going to be buying your vote to get elected. Don't fall for this liberal bull they love to promise the world until their elected.


James T.
said

What's next, Yankee Doodle Iggy - another NEP to drain two hundred billion more dollars from The West to buy votes in Ontario & Quebec? That is the Liberal way. That's also why your support stops at the Manitoba border.


Payattention
said

No such words came from iggy's mouth.. All made up by Cons.


Mr. Not a Pye Chart
said

@Mitch first,,,,It's not like Harper has done anything as well in the areas you describe but he has wasted MILLIONS campaigning on my dime (26 in the first 3 months this year alone)@Alberta Boy second: Again,,,Your boy Harpy has been spending the purse dry now for 5 years and put us so far in debt I doubt my young kids will live long enough to pay it off. By the way,,,,Iggy WAS born in Canada, just the same as me and you. You know what your problem is,,,,,neither you or your hero Harpy COULD EVER get into Harvard except on the Saturday morning bus tour but keep your eyes on Stevey,,,he loves to throw people under that bus


Peter
said

This man is of the rocker for sure. Complaining that the Harper Government squanders money and look at him promising money for a hockey arena when so many persons are in need of money for medical costs.


DC in AB
said

Fantastic news! This also means that Iggy would have to fund the proposed new domed stadium in Regina too! Hell, he's need to fund a new arena/stadium in EVERY city in Canada! Great news, this makes our new F-35 fighters look cheap! Not sure where Iggy's money tree is, but I'd like to get some seeds and plant my own money tree...


Rob Alberta
said

Its more like he would the new arena with Alberta money! Like everything else the Liberals do


Craig from NS
said

How about an arena in Winnipeg or a stadium in Halifax? Any takers? How about stop giving Quebec everything and start taking care of the rest of the country?


bb
said

I'm from NS and I live in Ontario and I would love to see another Canadian team. I used to love the rivalry between the Habs and the Nordiques.This would be money well spent - much better spent than money given for corporate tax cuts (for already rich corporations) or for money spent on fighter jets (whose cost seems to rise every second day).


e. doerksen
said

here we go spending money he doesn't have. Iggy's been complaining Canada has a huge deficit and he promises money.Will this american not go home? please?


WestofTheRockies
said

Feet firmly planted in La La Land, where pandering to Quebec is the first rule of the Liberals. He thinks that somehow what Quebec asks for, the rest of us will automaticaly shell out for. They don't have a team now and have been told they will not get an NHL team so what's the point? Not to mention that no goverment in Canada has funded an NHL Rink in 25 years. We're sick and tired of watching Quebec get fat at the table while the rest of us have to be satisfied with their table scraps. We're tired of funding their gold plated programmes, some like daycare which we don't have, just because they speak a different language. This is just the primer, imagine what's coming as the election heats up. This guy hasn't come up with a single plan, not one.


mr_cb7
said

What! What are you doing Iggy? No sane public tax payer who doesn't live in the QC City area wants this! Health Care? Education? infrastructure?...Priorities!


Andrew in NB
said

LOL.... what a nut!! Of course.. he can promis anything as he will not win in any Canadian election!! Go back to the US


paul
said

of course he would. READ THIS CAREFULLY ENGLISH SPEAKING CANADA.... He is offering your money for more votes.


David in Dartmouth
said

I agree with JC....the rest of us will be handed the bill and our defence department will be summarily chopped in Liberal fashion..to pay for Ignatieffs promises..!!


Steve from Edmonton Alberta
said

Hey Iggy!! over here in Edmonton!!! do we get an arena??? or I guess you know no one here supports you so you wont bother.


MARG MM
said

Here we go, the Liberals already pandering to Quebec for votes. I doubt this will bode well in the rest of the country. Oh well, we all know that the Liberals only make promises to get votes, and once in office do not deliver.


vj
said

I detest Harper and his right wing agenda. His lackey Baird makes me ill. And now this ... political nincompoop, Ignatief, promises Federal money for the Quebec Arena. With that one promise, he has committed the feds to at least 3 arenas, Quebec, Regina, and Edmonton. Total cost of about 1.2 billion. No, you idiot, no! We do not have the money for the next multiple years. Come back in 5 years and maybe the numbers will be better, but not today with a 50 billion deficit.


firstMickey
said

Iggy, We taxpayers don't need or want an arena in Quebec City for an imaginary team. Don't you get it? Butt out. :You cannot buy our vote with nonsense.


Greg Boudreau
said

I agree with J.C, it is easy to say these things just to win votes. If the Government gives money to a city for an arena, than you have to give to everyone, and that could cost lots of money.


Daniel From Toronto
said

another reason not to vote Liberal. THANKS!


David
said

Well it's our tax dollars, harper wasted enough on the G8 & G20 to build many arenas and what did we get for it?Put it on the ballot, do you want your tax dollars going to another county or spent within your own country? I vote for spending it for the people of Canada and before a dime goes to another country we take care of our own needs and funding! When will Canada wake up, people protest every day for the right to vore so use your vote!


Joanne
said

If this is the only way the Ig can get votes we are in SERIOUS TROUBLE. Quebec has held this country hostage to its every whim for decades, now this moron wants to add to it!!! Time for the Ig to go back to wherever he came from U.S. or Britain, who cares, just GO!!!


John MacPriest
said

I'm sure that if he were to raise the GST back up to where it ought to be, he'll have lots of money for what is sure to be a string of stupid campaign promises.


Gomtor
said

Sure they will. How many votes will that bring in? Strategy for the election is coming together. Who's going to pay for that again?


Tom in Ontario
said

Seems to learning from the Tory play book. This is a great political move, one the Tories would be praising if they had done it. Well done! Next move, Tories.... Don't you just love that our Prime Minister has turned this into a game. It is so much more fun.


Craig in BC
said

FIberals buying votes in quebec once again? I wonder how many brown paper bags of cash will change hands if he got in...


Anonymous Al
said

I'm a Liberal supporter, but congratulations, Mr. Ignatieff, you just shot yourself in the foot.


J.C.
said

There he goes already promising money for something that the rest of Canada does not necessarily agree to just to buy votes from the province of Quebec. He must be desparate to be in power.If a province wants an arena then they should pay for it with their own taxes and not with the taxes of all other provinces! If this is what Ignatief refers to as fiscally responsible then he sure won't get my vote. Quebec already gets more money transferred to it than all the other provinces as it is. He wants to give them their cake and help them eat it too.


Paul de T.O.
said

Ignatieff has intercepted the ball, and now has to run with it. If he is fleet footed, he could score an important touchdown.


mitch
said

Pure genius. It's not like health care or education needs that money.


Alberta Boy
said

Will this American stop at nothing to spend my tax dollars to gain votes? It will be a sad day if this hack ever gets into office on the ruling side.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Double lung transplant recipient Helene Campbell appears on 'Ellen,' on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Campbell celebrates recovery with 'Ellen' appearance

More   15 Comments 15    10 Video(s) 10

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  1 Video(s) 1

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada has confirmed that a small plane has  crashed near Cochrane, Ont. on Friday, May 25, 2012.

2 dead in northern Ontario plane crash

More

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?