Canada -
News Sections
Senator offended by Ignatieff's 'cotton-pickin' comment
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Friday Mar. 11, 2011 6:54 PM ET
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff has raised the ire of a Toronto Senator for his use of a phrase that may have originated as an insult referring to slaves, or black people.
Or, as Ignatieff claims, it may be nothing more than a harmless term first used by Bugs Bunny.
Either way, with all federal political parties on-edge over the prospect of a spring election, Ignatieff's use of the phrase "wait a cotton-pickin' minute" quickly generated a response.
Ignatieff uttered the phrase Thursday while accusing Harper of suggesting Canadians "don't care about democracy."
The Liberal leader was responding to Harper's comments that two recent parliamentary violations were just a "distraction" and politics was a game where you win some and lose some.
Ignatieff lashed out.
"If you say democracy is a little distraction, it doesn't matter to you, look out because the ... Canadian people will say now 'wait a cotton-pickin' minute here,'" Ignatieff said.
That prompted a prickly response from Don Meredith, a black, Jamaican-born pastor from Toronto whom Harper recently appointed to the Senate.
He claimed Ignatieff's choice of wording was "at the very least, insensitive, and certainly offensive to many people," and called on Ignatieff to apologize.
"The reference hails back to a time when slavery was acceptable and an entire group of people were held to be lesser than others because of the colour of their skin."
He also slammed Liberal MP Marlene Jennings, who is also black, for not speaking out against the comment.
Ignatieff's office quickly responded, saying the term isn't derogatory, but actually refers to any task that is "finicky, laborious and annoying work."
However the website Wordorigins.org gives an altogether different explanation, saying its first recorded use was by Bugs Bunny in a 1952 Looney Tunes cartoon, when it was used as an adjective of disapproval.
Bugs Bunny said: "Get your cotton-pickin' hooks offa me!"
However, in its noun form -- cotton-picker -- the phrase may in fact be offensive, the website says. It notes that around 1919 it was used as a descriptor for a contemptible person, and since at least 1930 it has been used as a derogatory term with "distinct racist overtones."
The website states: "The adjective cotton-picking does not carry (racist overtones), instead being a reference to the unpleasant nature of the work."
Ignatieff's use of the term isn't the first by a sitting politician.
A search of Hansard, the official record of parliamentary discussion, shows at least four occasions in the 1990s on which a Conservative MP used the phrase.
B.C. MP Jim Abbott and Saskatchewan MP Lee Morrison both used the expression "cotton picking." And Ken Epp, an MP from Alberta, used it on two seperate occasions.
All used the term as an adjective.
User Tools
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Johnn in Kitchener
said
Daniel From Toronto
said
mahanna ali
said
simon in montreal
said
Ken Smith
said
NoContest
said
Pittsky
said
KC-bby
said
Alan
said
James in Calgary
said
Doug
said
Naveed
said
KaRRie19
said
David
said
good news buff
said
B. Kelley, Offended in Ontario
said
Mark
said
Naveed
said
back to work children!
said
Steve's minority needs to resign!
said
Doug ^^^ BC
said
Carl
said
SVCR
said
Dixie from Alberta
said
James T.
said
Dave
said
Mike vdB - Chatham, ON
said
the educated
said
D.F
said
Mark
said
Neal
said
Ed Bain
said
Edgar Helbling
said
Phil
said
MARG MM
said
Will
said
Ben
said
Dubious Duncan
said
Rosie
said
Glenn C
said
PUGFIRE
said
Kasey
said
Peter in MB
said
Fishin Nut
said
Redneck Albertan
said
Cambob in Toronto
said
CMQ
said
Loyalist 1796
said
Michael Breen
said
Peter in MB
said
Anne Marie Halfpenny
said
MIke
said
Pip
said
Donna in NewfoundlandLabrador
said
Al in Orillia
said
Steven
said
Richard
said
Diane (GTA)
said
toon in toon
said
Hugh Mcneill
said
Bernie
said
BMA
said
Conservative Mike
said
Cherry Picker from ON
said
Sick n' Tired
said
Randy
said
Peter
said
Pedro Juan
said
Heather
said
Phil
said
Cdn Politico
said
Alexandria
said
JOHn from ON
said
Art
said
Pete
said
Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said
Jamie, Ottawa
said
Jimmy Stewart
said
George Carter
said
David, Mississauga
said
Bucko
said
Spiltbongwater
said
Andrew
said
john
said
John Lethbridge
said
Matt
said
Matt in NB
said
john
said
April
said
TC in TO
said
john
said
John in Richmond Hill
said
Leanne
said
Steve in Vancouver
said
Inteligent Liberal
said
Frank, Canada
said
dk in nb
said
Richard L. Provencher
said
John
said
Tim
said