Canada -   

1

Senator offended by Ignatieff's 'cotton-pickin' comment

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff speaks to reporters in the foyer following Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, March 10, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Senator Don Meredith Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff speaks to reporters in the foyer following Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill, in Ottawa on Thursday, March 10, 2011.
Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff speaks to reporters in the foyer following Question Period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Thursday, March 10, 2011. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (100) Facebook   

Date: Friday Mar. 11, 2011 6:54 PM ET

Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff has raised the ire of a Toronto Senator for his use of a phrase that may have originated as an insult referring to slaves, or black people.

Or, as Ignatieff claims, it may be nothing more than a harmless term first used by Bugs Bunny.

Either way, with all federal political parties on-edge over the prospect of a spring election, Ignatieff's use of the phrase "wait a cotton-pickin' minute" quickly generated a response.

Ignatieff uttered the phrase Thursday while accusing Harper of suggesting Canadians "don't care about democracy."

The Liberal leader was responding to Harper's comments that two recent parliamentary violations were just a "distraction" and politics was a game where you win some and lose some.

Ignatieff lashed out.

"If you say democracy is a little distraction, it doesn't matter to you, look out because the ... Canadian people will say now 'wait a cotton-pickin' minute here,'" Ignatieff said.

That prompted a prickly response from Don Meredith, a black, Jamaican-born pastor from Toronto whom Harper recently appointed to the Senate.

He claimed Ignatieff's choice of wording was "at the very least, insensitive, and certainly offensive to many people," and called on Ignatieff to apologize.

"The reference hails back to a time when slavery was acceptable and an entire group of people were held to be lesser than others because of the colour of their skin."

He also slammed Liberal MP Marlene Jennings, who is also black, for not speaking out against the comment.

Ignatieff's office quickly responded, saying the term isn't derogatory, but actually refers to any task that is "finicky, laborious and annoying work."

However the website Wordorigins.org gives an altogether different explanation, saying its first recorded use was by Bugs Bunny in a 1952 Looney Tunes cartoon, when it was used as an adjective of disapproval.

Bugs Bunny said: "Get your cotton-pickin' hooks offa me!"

However, in its noun form -- cotton-picker -- the phrase may in fact be offensive, the website says. It notes that around 1919 it was used as a descriptor for a contemptible person, and since at least 1930 it has been used as a derogatory term with "distinct racist overtones."

The website states: "The adjective cotton-picking does not carry (racist overtones), instead being a reference to the unpleasant nature of the work."

Ignatieff's use of the term isn't the first by a sitting politician.

A search of Hansard, the official record of parliamentary discussion, shows at least four occasions in the 1990s on which a Conservative MP used the phrase.

B.C. MP Jim Abbott and Saskatchewan MP Lee Morrison both used the expression "cotton picking." And Ken Epp, an MP from Alberta, used it on two seperate occasions.

All used the term as an adjective.

Comments are now closed for this story

Johnn in Kitchener
said

How cotton-pickin' picky can you get?I'm no Iggy supporter (not even close), but for Pete's sake (hope that isn't an offensive term) let's not get our jockey's in a knot over such cotton-pickin' insignificant things . . . . . .


Daniel From Toronto
said

Probally should have used a different choice of words but come on people who get offended by this are just silly. All they are doing is recognizing Minorities and isnt that what were suppose to be eliminating? aren't people equal? just ignore it and go on with life sheesh!


mahanna ali
said

MARK - you plum forgot "cotton pickin"....


simon in montreal
said

"Wait a cotton-pickin' minute" is a reference to TIME, a minute, that one would otherwise ignore but should not because of the enormity of the situation. This term has been used in N America for centuries, long before the 1900's when the racial Dixie slur "cotton picker" was used. Cotton Picker refers to a person of color. Cotton-Pickin' Minute has to do with an essential Time Frame that must be respected in order to do a job however tough it may be. Thank you for giving me a cotton-pickin' minute to explain!


Ken Smith
said

The famous blues song "Cotton Fields" (in them old cotton fields back home) by black musician Lead Belly has been covered by hundreds of artists over the years, black and white.Johnnie Cash and CCR (Credence Clearwater Revival) in that company.The central lyrics are: "Now when them cotton bolls get rotten you can't pick very much cotton/ In them old cottonfields back home".This implies that not only blacks picked cotton. They were made slaves in the work unfortunately.I wonder if the Jamaican Conservative senator would have been as deeply insulted if Stephen Harper had made the remark.


NoContest
said

This does not matter.


Pittsky
said

For once in my life I agree with Iggy.


KC-bby
said

Interesting thought came to mind - boys and girls don't actually "mature" in the way I assumed we would as we grow older. To my dismay it appears that we just become refined about how we lie, insult and feigned indignation. There is no leadership in this country - there is no man that will inspire us to work together to become a greater nation. All I see in Ottawa are man-childs. Now we get to see this crap on tv commercials - name callings and insults continue - VOTE for me! I'm a better Canadian than the other guy! I vote for NOBODY - sincerely, I'll be having a beer on a sunny Cancun beach free from this shamelessness that permeats what was once a noble institution - government. Shameless, corrupt, lying sacks of you know what!


Alan
said

We all know what would have happened if Harper had said it.Double standard? You bet.


James in Calgary
said

If this is what our elected officials debate in Ottawa? Be nice if we could just get rid of all the idiots and bring in mature adults. I cringe every time I read about these sort of stories. These people are supposed to lead us? What a group of inept fools. Even my kids notice how dumb they can be arguing over such trvial matters...shame.


Doug
said

Not much chance I will vote for Iggy or his forever whining Liberals but there is nothing wrong with Iggys "cotton" comment. All of the people who make a career of being offended should just get a life. They won't of course but they should!.


Naveed
said

As I said in my earlier comment, this is just Harpers government (Conservative senator in collusion with him), trying to distract Canadians from their anti-democratic misdemeanours.But let me argue on their level. Ignatieff used this term 'cotton pickin' in regards to in effect stating that the Canadian people ( by inference of all backgrounds) do not stand for having their democratic rights trampled by the Harper regime.Therefore the comment 'cotton pickin' as used by Iggy is equating freedom and justice (even if through the former black folks) against the dictatorial Harper government. To use their own argument against them, the black slaves of the past are being applauded and put on the same standared as the freedom loving Canadian citizens of today.In actuality though, this is just a silly bit of distraction and Iggy's comment is totally innocent.


KaRRie19
said

WHO CARES!?!?!?!


David
said

Iggy your not back at home! watch you tongue.


good news buff
said

Give me a cotton-pickin break!!!! How ridiculous to be pulling the race card for such a trivial event. I would suggest that the Senator save the race card for an event worthy of it. This vernacular act on the part of the senator does neither him, nor his sponsor, nor the race card any credit. Has he nothing better to do with his time than trying to score brownie points?


B. Kelley, Offended in Ontario
said

The great pandemic of the 21st century will be remembered as the Great Political Correctness Virus. According to the Language Police it's okay to throw around the "F" bomb anytime and anywhere but "cotton picking" is offensive? Absolutely absurd! Our society has totally lost any sense of perspective as we tiptoe around the over-sensitivities of people who are just looking for something, anything to offend them so that they can promote sympathy for the terrible hand that that they think life has dealt them. Respect is earned through making positive and meaningful contributions to society and keeping a sense of humour in the process, not by whining and jumping on the "poor us" train at every opportunity. All they're doing is demonstrating that stupidity and self-pity are primary symptoms of having caught the disease.


Mark
said

I wish ALL of these 'tree cuttin', ''wheat thrashin', 'pencil pushin', 'fish nettin', 'time wastin' politicians would just get to WORK . ALL of them


Naveed
said

The Conservatives can't find anything to justify their contemptible and anti-democratic recent behaviour and corruption, so what do they do? Try to pick alleged faults in the opposition and from Iggy, which are in reality no fault at all.Its called distraction, and Harper government is good at this game.


back to work children!
said

ahh...the nonsense is really picking up steam. i am getting so tired of all these clowns trying to create an issue where there is none. the libs started it, the ndp gets on the bandwagon and now its the conservatives turn. c'mon bloc!! where is your ridiculous rant about nothing? oh yeah, we've already spend 4 years listening to it.


Steve's minority needs to resign!
said

Don Meredith wants us Canadians to focus on an old-school phrase that we've all heard from our fathers and grandfathers a time or two. Yes, let's all forget the $30 BILLION dollar fudget-estimates, let's also forget the outright lies by Oda, and criminal charges being laid on conservative appointees, the integrity-czar scandal...the list goes on - but instead focus on "cotton pickin minute" - yes, let's talk about cotton pickin and whatever the hell that means. Harper, honestly, you think that we are so stupid to turn our attention to "cotton pickin" and ignore the dirt and sleaze that serves as the back drop of the conservative MINORITY govt? OMG! You truly are dellusional.


Doug ^^^ BC
said

OMG!!! How childish can these people be? Or is this just a case of turn around being fair play,? Most of us in BC are still reeling by the comments of Hedy Fry,who told Parliament she saw cross burnings in Prince Gerorge.Now there's a comment I still get angry over.It seems to me that she actually lied when she delivered her racist comment.This one,even though I am no longer a Liberal,looks stupid enough,but not all that racist..But,I concede,I am caucasian.I might feel different if that was not.Thoough I suppose one could argue that anyone who wants to lead a country should be more careful with his words.Especailly if you advertise yourself as being so much more intelligent than everyone else. But hey,you get what you give.The hate and fear mongering from the opposition in the last 5 years makes them a perfect target.While I find the controversy much adieu about nothing,I can see how it has come to this.Especially now that the opposition has painted themselves into an election corner,and has no real issue or policy on which to fight that election.As far as I can see, hating Harper is a poor excuse to call an election that most people think will give a result very similar to the last one. So kiddies,get back to work.There are criminals to deal with.Illegal refugees and immigants.We have a poorly equipped military to fix,men and women serving that military are currently in harms way.We have an economy to build,and a whole host of REAL issues to resolve.I'm sure I'm not the only voter that is growing weary of this sand box spit balling.


Carl
said

Maybe Iggy should not have used the term "cotton-pickin.'" But I find many of his other comments far more offensive. Like when he compared my country's flag to a beer label and said the only thing he missed about Canada was Algonquin Park. And when he advocated the use of torture, assassination and pre-emptive war in the fight against terrorism. Why haven't those comments received as much attention as this relatively benign remark?


SVCR
said

FYI, there is NO such thing as an Intelligent Liberal.As I spelt it right that shows how intelligent an Inteligent Liberal really is!!! LOL


Dixie from Alberta
said

This should not even be in the news. Someone has way too much time on their hands to bother complaining about a phrase such as this one. Stop nitpicking and get on with the country's business.


James T.
said

As an American, you'd think Mr. Ignatieff would be more sympathetic when it comes to suffering his people imposed on the slaves. I guess, like a fine wine, intolerance is timeless...


Dave
said

Harper get all his advice from Bugs Bunny? What's up Doc!


Mike vdB - Chatham, ON
said

Being from out west, my dad would substitute "Cotton-picker" for less savoury language every time he went to swear. I never even realized the word had any history to it until I moved to SW Ontario where there is a closer link to the Black Community (of which I do realize even using the term, "Black," can make some offended). I support Iggy on this one though and think that almost every phrase, at some point, has links to a sordid past (i.e. "For Pete's Sake" for ole saint Peter). I guess I will just have to result to the good old swear words we all hold dear. Then I can be rest assured everyone will be offended.


the educated
said

Must be a Yale man.


D.F
said

We need to get grade 1 students to run goverment -what a bunch of idots,if you can cottin that,No wonder the country gives away money we dont have and our own citizens suffer..Say what you will but Jack Lation is the only one making any sense.


Mark
said

They say it was used by bugs bunny back in the 50's. We all must remember that cartoons made back then used alot of inappropriate words in cartoons. Thats why all those old cartoons with ifie words are no longer aired on public TV.


Neal
said

It is great to have someone as arrogant and dumb as Mr Ignatieff in opposition . He shoots himself in the foot every day !!!


Ed Bain
said

Let's not get too stupid here about Iggy"s comment. I am a staunch conservative and I don't like Iggy but this is nit picking to the point of absurdatity. Let us all give our heads a shake on this one!


Edgar Helbling
said

How much does this Senator earn of our money to act as stupidly as that.Right in our faces. Phone me Mr. Senator, and I will give you some real reason to whine.


Phil
said

Who cares what the American pro-separatist says. It's all a pack of lies anyway.


MARG MM
said

The only thing to say about this is the fact that if a Conservative had made this remark, the opposition would be calling for a commitee to look into it, and the Liberals would be calling for a resignation. When Marlene Jennings heard the words "tar baby" a while back she was on a tirade along with her fellow Liberals, so they should not expect anything less from someone that is offended by the "cotton pickin" remark. It looks like we are in for lots of mudslinging and derogatory remarks from all parties. At the very least Michael Ignatieff should appologize due to the fact that he has offended people by using this American slang.


Will
said

sauce for the goose. Those complaining about it being pointed out need to grow a little perspective themselves.


Ben
said

I believe that Conservative MP Pierre Poilievre said something that was actually quite racist in the House of Commons back on May 29, 2009 (google it if you want to know what he said, I don't want to type such garbage) so before the good Senator tries to score points on Ignatieff (who said nothing wrong) maybe he should go and educate his fellow-Conservative, Mr. Poilievre, about racial sensitivity and ask his boss Mr. Harper why he saw fit to promote Mr. Poilievre to the position of parliamentary secretary rather than kicking him out of caucus as he should have.


Dubious Duncan
said

Don Meredith, by pulling out the 'race card' over such a statement is an embarrassment to this Conservative. Iggy is an embarrassment to this nation. As such, I do enjoy watching the Liberal leader shoot himself in the foot, but I also believe in fair play. Political correctness used to the extreme is a Liberal game that conservatives need not indulge in.


Rosie
said

There was an earthquake in Japan that killed many people.Lets not sweat the small stuff from now on.


Glenn C
said

I'm not an Iggy fan either (by any stretch), but come on Senator get real, Can't you find something 'public service' to do) What next Iggy for prime minister!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.


PUGFIRE
said

Now let's just hold on here for a ********** minute.I thought we, the people, elected ADULTS from various political parties to go to Ottawa to represent us. The the PM selects more ADULTS to go to the Senate to represent us. If I am correct in my assumptions, how did these children get into the picture? As Bugs Bunny also often said "What a bunch of Maroons"


Kasey
said

Well, there you go! He should be forced to resign as Leader of the Liberal party. We cannot have our Leaders insulting others, everyone in a postion of power must be politically correct all the time and they must never make comments that can be construed as insulting to anyone. Get a life everyone! This is news???!!!


Peter in MB
said

this is a great day!!! IGGY and liberals are finally getting a taste of their own medicine.


Fishin Nut
said

Well, I guess if you have nothing better to do pick, I mean, start a fight. This will definitely change the country! Good job senator.


Redneck Albertan
said

First off, I cannot believe someone would be offended by that. Secondly, if they are, exactly how can such a thin skinned person manage to survive in politics unless their survival is based on calling anyone they disagree with a racist. Pretty pathetic. Third, I am no fan of Mr. Ignatieff, but he did absolutely no wrong with the terminology he used. Don Meredith, on the other hand, is a prime example of what is wrong with political correctness.


Cambob in Toronto
said

As much as I dislike Ignatief, this is a ridiculous slam against him. If he has said "Hold on a minute" would that be a racist comment against receptionists? If he had said "Just a sec" would that have been offensive because it's almost like saying sex? Seriously, the senator should get back into his FIELD of work and stop PICKING fights... I wonder if he Caught On to my slam against his race and comeplete idiocy?


CMQ
said

Honestly, this is what politics becomes when you have nothing more to do than sling mud back and forth. Again CTV, how about going after the Libeal's platform and their costs, holding them accountable in the press about what they would do if they decided to go against their choice of plan, yes their choice, the program they began on the jets!!!! Let's hear about that and why they have changed thier minds on this and corporate tax cuts. You have done well to go after the conservatives, how about some good journalism where you begin to ask the tough questions of all parties and ask Iggy what he would actually do. Anyone can talk generalities, we want specifics, a plan, the cost, what it means to Canadians. Obama got elected by feel good speeches because the press didn't ask him how he would do what he said he would do and the cost and because of that they are still fighting over health care and the budget!!!!


Loyalist 1796
said

The good Senator has just got to get a life and a grip on reality.


Michael Breen
said

Can we recall senators ?....This man is an idiot...


Peter in MB
said

@ intelligent liberal... said "cotten picking" is commonly used in America in normal conversation... for once I agree with Intelligent liberal... Why Because I guess this means that Iggy is a true American.... AKA caption U.S.A... So maybe now the liberals will stop with their “American style this: and American that” smear against Steven Harper. Because Iggy is the real American.


Anne Marie Halfpenny
said

"Wait a cotton-pickin second!!" Come on....it isn't a racist comment!! If I'm not mistaken...Canadians didn't have slaves here and if I'm not mistaken didn't the Underground Railroad come all the way to Canada so slaves could be free!!! People need to chill out....nothing was meant derogatory from the comment. There are MORE things in life that are important than getting upset about some stupid wording that wasn't even projected towards Senator Meredith!!Enough already!!!


MIke
said

I can't get over the fact that people are more concerned with a term used by Iggy than the fact our PM doesn't think we care about democracy.


Pip
said

To John, who writes "To all the Canadians that judge Ignatieff I say you don't even know what he stands for", you are SO right! Maybe that's why he has such a low rating in opinion polls!


Donna in NewfoundlandLabrador
said

This world is gone cotton-pickin mad! If anyone gets offended by this phrase Bugs Bunny should ring their ears!


Al in Orillia
said

@Tim: You hit the nail on the head! (hope I'm not offending any carpenters)


Steven
said

At my sons last hockey game, I heard a parent yell to his son...."atta boy, great goal". That parent should be arrested for his use of the word "boy" as it negatively portrays african americans. Somebody do something!


Richard
said

Atta boy Mr. Senator...(oops can I even say that?), you really earned your pay on this one.


Diane (GTA)
said

@Leanne "I should type "gosh" as to not offend those who believe in god"... ...that would show some respect but when people use God's name inappropriately they insult Him and that is the greater issue. As for Iggy's statement, well the offense is in the eye of the offended I suppose.


toon in toon
said

This is what happens when the high and mighty Liberals and NDP pick apart everything the Gov't does. Sooner or later it will come back to bite you in the ass. Just deal with issues that concern Canadian citizens, because if Ignatieuf is so bound and determined to have an election he is going to get it then he is going to be one of those on the unemployment line, probably down in the States.


Hugh Mcneill
said

Finally a left-wing Liberal makes a pollitically incorrect statement.Or at least is being brought to account for making insensitive comments, but wait what he said isn't what he meant. He is insulting the intelligence of the average Canadian with the feeble explaination that his office is putting out. Just apologize for being insensitive, fire his staff and fall on his sword. He would demand no less of a conservitave!


Bernie
said

When Bugs Bunny uttered his famous..."whats up doc?"...not many knew then or now, that he was actually pledging his allegiance to former Haitian dictator "Baby Doc Duvalier"...


BMA
said

Speaking as a Conservative voter, I'd say the Conservative Senator needs to lighten up a bit. I don't care for Mr. Ignatieff, or his policies, but in this case I don't think Mr. Ignatieff has said anything hurtful to any particular group. The next thing you know, someone's gonna get bent out of shape because another Member of Parliament used a comment that Foghorn Leghorn, or Yosemite Sam said. I thought you needed to have thick skin to be a politician.


Conservative Mike
said

I'm actually going to defend Iggy on this one, as much as it pains me to do so... He did NOT use the term in a racial context. He was clearly not even referring to African Americans, or any aspect of American History. The phrase is an expression, and any criticism of Mr. Ignatieff's comment is a threat to free speech. If I was Iggy, perhaps the best strategy would be to say "I'm sorry if I offended anyone, that was certainly not my intent," and leave it at that...


Cherry Picker from ON
said

I'm as Conservative as they come and I have every intention of voting that way at the next election, plus I really don't care for Iggy, but come on ( I resisted the urge to use the phrase in question right there.) This is rediculous.


Sick n' Tired
said

ugggggggg when are we going to put ADULTS in charge of this Country!!!!!!!!!!!!


Randy
said

Darn that "wascawee wiberwol" Ignatieff.


Peter
said

Wait a cotton pickin minute - demigogues are demigogues regardless of phraseology.


Pedro Juan
said

This is simple American slang. We should not be surprised to hear such from Mr.Iggy. He is trying to connect with the common folk but has forgotten he's back in Canada.


Heather
said

We are becoming so damn spineless that it's disgusting.I'm not an Iggy fan but c'mon people, let's get real here...


Phil
said

What he meant to say to Sephen Harper (on behalf of 60-some-odd per cent of Canadians) was "fuddle duddle"...


Cdn Politico
said

Excuse me John, you want Ignatieff to apologize for the term "cotton-pickin'"? Okay, sure, right after CPC MP Jim Abbott and ex-CPC MPs Ken Epp and Lee Morrison apologize for using the term too... not to mention Yosemite Sam and Porky Pig.


Alexandria
said

Who says Iggie is really SMART?I don't think so or he would not yell and holler as he does. A smart person uses reason in a calm way to get their thought across.I wonder how many students graduating from Harvard act like he does? Too bad if they do.


JOHn from ON
said

Instead of judging the issue by skin colour, why doesn't the pastor grow some skin and shrug this one off! i highly doubt Iggy was making a racist slur. But rather using the term to emphasize his point. Context is more important than words!


Art
said

They talk about Iggy having a strong American background? Well that comment certainly sounds like it. Not too many Canadians use tthat term , I'd suggest it is more American slang. What's next , " Howdy Folks " ?


Pete
said

Who cares! I wouldn't vote for the guy anyway.


Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said

Ignatieff is all over the Conservatives on "little " things... Well if our Prime Minister had used those words we would never hear the end of it.......There is a real double standard at work here the Liberals and media making big deals out of what most Canadians are getting tired of hearing about... this witch hunt has to stop before it bites the power hungery Liberals where they do not want to be bitten ! ......................................We care about the economy and the seniors on G.I.S.


Jamie, Ottawa
said

*This* is the caliber of individual we're appointing to the Senate nowadays? People who get offended by phrases originated by Bugs Bunny? Wait until she hears what Porky Pig has been saying.


Jimmy Stewart
said

They don't actually pick cotton. It's done with harvesting equipment, like tractors. I do say however it was no more that Iggy doing a little JImmy Stewart impersonation.Now wait just a minute....


George Carter
said

Oh for "sassa-frassin, mickrashin, gol-tootin, rip-rooting rip-rashin!!!!"I DEFY THE GOOD SENATOR TO FIND FAUILT IN THIS OTHER SIMILARILY POPULAR YOSEMITE SAM TIRADE. "Oh goodness, I want an apology since 'sassa-frass' is a durogatory from an ancient dialect of jibberish".....


David, Mississauga
said

Conservatives playing the 'gotcha!' game. Weak.


Bucko
said

MY,my aren't we touchy.


Spiltbongwater
said

Are you kinding me? If he called Mr. Harper a cotton picker, I could vaguely see the concern, but to say cotton picken minute is racist? Get a real job senator, and a real concern.


Andrew
said

If the shoe was on the other foot... And it was the Conservatives who made such a comment, you know all the opposition parties would be demanded a resignation...


john
said

Jim Abbott and other conservatives used it, the article even mentions it.I think the Conservatives just want to create an issue about nothing!


John Lethbridge
said

Ha, ha, well there's no putting the toothpaste back in the tube on that one... Pretty tough when you can't talk about the economy.


Matt
said

Look, I'm a Conservative supporter, but REALLY? Reminds me of a few years ago when a Conservative MP used the term "tar baby" when refering to Dion's Green Shift plan sticking to Ignatieff. Liberal MP Marlene Jennings (who is black) went on a tirade about the comment being racist.


Matt in NB
said

The CON's will really use any excuse to side step their actions in the last few weeks. TTTThat's all Folks!


john
said

To all the Canadians that judge Ignatieff I say you don't even know what he stands for and everyone makes mistakes and I say it is a small matter but the truth the Prime Minister said you win some, you lose some on the Speaker's rulings. That is a lot more significant. He can brush aside serious rulings that are a contempt of parliament.


April
said

Well, it's more polite to say 'cotton-pickin' minute' than God-damn minute which is what he should have said. Everyone here claims they're "offended" everytime someone else says something. It's ridiculous. Grow thicker skin people!


TC in TO
said

This is nothing more than a distraction from the very serious issue of the erosion of democracy in my country. The phrase in question has nothing to do with racism.


john
said

I think the worse thing is Harper lied about not appointing senators. I think we need either elections now or just abolish the Senate!


John in Richmond Hill
said

This is just a non issue people should let it go. I think Ignatieff was making a good point about democracy and the fact that the Conservatives have had a bad week and need to face up to the Speaker's rulings.


Leanne
said

ARE YOU KIDDING?My god...sorry, I should type "gosh" as to not offend those wo believe in god, but has Canada become so uptight and "faux-PC" that the use of a term such as cotton-picking is seen as racist?The worst part is that it was a conversation between two white men and the "fear" of political incorrectness and offending some black people (who probably don't even give a damn about it), has now made this into a national issue and further enlightened people to what is "racist" and what isn't.Why can't people realize that it isn't the word that is meant to hurt, but the intention and meaning behind it.Come on, are we trying to be Americans or do we, as Canadians, want to maintain our public perception (well, not after the G20, but...), of fairness, congeniality and equality?Be good people.Be good to people.


Steve in Vancouver
said

This is just simply Iggy trying to sound like a down to earth ah shucks Canadjan eh. Iggy wants to sound like one of us regular Canadjans up here in the northern hemisphere. But of course he is more Amurican than Canadjan. Cotton picker is an American derogatory term. But hey ya know when ya are a phony its easy to screw up. Dug gun it anyways.


Inteligent Liberal
said

What these overly sensitive MP's from Toronto have to realize is the term "cotten picking" is commonly used in America in normal conversation. Although it may not be used as much in Canada, MP's need to give credit to the fact that PM - Elect Iggy spent time at elite American universities who provided different dialect and better social context.


Frank, Canada
said

that phrase is an american colloquialism - so perhaps it makes sense that ignatieff would use it.but do Canadians use that term - definitely not - no Canadians that I know use it - just more examples that ignatieff doesn't know Canada or Canadians- he should go home


dk in nb
said

You must remember that Iggy is an elitist. Be careful Canada, he believes in social status. He is of the upper class, just ask him.


Richard L. Provencher
said

Now if PM Harper had used these same words, you can bet your booties, the media and all Liberals would be ranting up and down Toronto's Yonge Street, with bonfires roasting caricatures of our PM late into the night. It looks like Mr. Ignatieff gets a pass.


John
said

For a guy who's really smart, he seems prone to foot in mouth syndrome. Just apologize and move on...


Tim
said

Ahaha. Oh the irony. Ignatieff gets hit with an absolutely ridiculous complaint while MAKING an absolutely ridiculous complaint. Maybe if he spent less time putting words in other people's mouths, people would be less inclined to put them in his.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Double lung transplant recipient Helene Campbell appears on 'Ellen,' on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Campbell celebrates recovery with 'Ellen' appearance

More   15 Comments 15    10 Video(s) 10

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  1 Video(s) 1

The Transportation Safety Board of Canada has confirmed that a small plane has  crashed near Cochrane, Ont. on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Small plane crashes in northern Ontario

More

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?