Canada -
News Sections
Pacioretty opposes criminal investigation into Chara hit
ctvmontreal.ca
Date: Thursday Mar. 10, 2011 9:03 PM ET
MONTREAL Canadiens' forward Max Pacioretty was released from the Montreal General Hospital late Thursday afternoon and sent home to start his healing, which he hopes does not involve having to think about criminal litigation.
Late Thursday the injured forward tweeted a message that read:
"I sincerely appreciate all of the support that I have received since my injury. I was disappointed that the NHL did not suspend Zdeno Chara. However, I have no desire for him to be prosecuted legally. I feel that the incident, as ugly as it was, was part of a hockey game."
"I understand that this is not my decision. I have respect and admiration for the authorities in Quebec. I simply wanted to make my opinion clear."
Pacioretty was referring to a report that Montreal police was launching a criminal investigation into Tuesday night's bodycheck by Zdeno Chara that left him the young Canadien with a broken neck and a severe concussion.
Montreal Canadiens' owner Geoff Molson called on his 29 fellow owners to join him in a group to analyze safety in the NHL.
"I am willing to play a leadership role in coordinating this group effort," wrote Molson.
Montreal police confirmed on Thursday that they have opened a criminal investigation at the behest of Quebec's director of criminal and penal prosecutions, Louis Dionne.
"The police investigation will be held. Like all police investigations, evidence will be gathered and an investigation report will be submitted (to the DCPP)," Dionne's spokesperson Martine Berube said Thursday.
"(The DCPP) will then evaluate to see whether there's grounds for prosecution."
When asked what kind of punishment might result from the case, Berube said it was too soon to say.
"That would depend on what charges are laid. That's a little difficult to predict at this point."
Pacioretty is recovering from a severe concussion and a non-displaced fractured vertebra he suffered in a hit by Boston bruins captain Zdeno Chara on Tuesday evening.
In recent years, Quebec police have charged at least three hockey players from the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League with assault.
On Wednesday, Montreal police asked Canadiens fans to stop calling them to file complaints against Chara.
Police said they were inundated with calls from people seeking to file a criminal complaint against the six-foot-nine defenceman.
The calls demanding criminal charges began Wednesday afternoon, shortly after the NHL announced it would neither suspend nor fine Chara.
Police say their emergency call centre started getting flooded around 4 p.m. – after the NHL announced its decision.
A spokesman says police suspect the calls were inspired by a local media outlet that suggested the idea.
The police spokesman described the gesture as irresponsible – and he urged Montrealers to keep the emergency line free for actual life-and-death matters.
He would not speculate, however, when asked whether police might actually investigate the Chara incident.
The incident not only tied up police lines but also landed in the political arena: in the House of Commons, the federal minister responsible for sport called on the NHL to act.
Hockey players charged in Quebec include Jonathan Roy who played for the Quebec Remparts. Roy was given an unconditional discharge by the judge in October 2009.
Patrice Cormier, now a member of the Atlanta Thrashers, also plead guilty for an assault following a vicious elbow to an opponent's head in January 2010. A third Quebec junior player was also charged in another incident but cannot be named upon orders of the court.
Charges unlikely: experts
Legal and law-enforcement experts expressed doubt the police investigation would result in criminal charges.
"This would be the type of case that would be very tough to prosecute,'' said John Galianos, a former major crimes investigator with Quebec's provincial police.
He added that the difficulty facing prosecutors would be establishing Chara's intent to injure.
"I don't think a Crown attorney would prosecute based on the video,'' Galianos said.
The prosecution would also have to argue that the violence of the hit went above and beyond the normal level of violence in professional hockey, said a Montreal criminal lawyer.
"When you get involved in a sport, there is a concept of acceptance of risk,'' said Steven Slimovitch.
"The question is did Pacioretty agree to be hit in that kind of fashion by Zdeno Chara? Was the hit so outside the norm of what is found in the sport of hockey . . . that it's not hockey anymore.
Slimovitch pointed out that while criminal charges have been brought against NHL players in the past for on-ice violence, they have generally involved stick-swinging incidents.
There is little precedent for a bodycheck leading to legal action.
Following the Bruins' pre-game skate in Boston on Thursday, Chara reiterated his claim that he didn't set out to hurt Pacioretty.
"You feel bad when a fellow player gets severely hurt,'' he said. "I know, deep down, I did not do it intentionally.''
With files from The Canadian Press
User Tools
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
brad
0
said
0
Isabelle
0
said
0
Bettman is INCOMPETENT!
0
said
0
J
0
said
0
You have the power and if you do not wield it, then ultimately it is you who will have failed us. Of course the employer (the league) won't do anything. Employers are for making money. We elect governing bodies just for the purpose of enforcing workplace safety. And you are not acting. Please let us all know where you stand on unsafe workplace safety and why 'normal' employers are treated differently than the rich and famous employers .... Yes, these players give implicit consent to fighting and athletic injuries, but I don't think anyone gives implicit consent to being run into a poll through negligent workplace conditions. Remember the luge incident? These things will occur again and our athletes need our protection just like any other worker ...
ralph Morton
0
said
0
If I were to do the same thing to someone in the stands I would not have the luxury of saying ask the other guy if he wants charges pressed or not.
No Max this should go beyond what you want , we were subjected to witnessing that and trying to answer very hard questions from our children.
Kym
0
said
0
Dennis
0
said
0
Stephan
0
said
0
Flair
0
said
0
get rid of that stupid piece of glass and post or make the whole rink glass so there is no abuttment. it will also prevent too many men on the ice penalties as well .
welcome to the BIG leagues lotto Max .next time keep ur head up fella !
now centre bell fans really have a reason to boo mr.Big Z
(it is going to be a wild and heavy banging playoffs..just like olde time hockey !!
cha cha ching $$$$$
John Hogan
0
said
0
AGuyFromBoston
0
said
0
Second, it's hockey. Hits happen. What should they do, ban checking? Make sure it's only allowed in the middle of the ice where there is no possibility of someone hitting a board (or stanchion pole)?
Thrid, Max had a nice dirty hit on
the Rangers's Mark Eaton. Where's the outcry over that hit?
In any event, no one wanted to see him get hurt, least of all Chara. Hopefully he heals up and gets back to hockey.
AHMED
0
said
0
Gus
0
said
0
Tjay Caine
0
said
0
hockey but at some point it should be moderated if the NHL leaders are too blind to see the aggression taken by chara to pacioretty the other night then u better be prepared for a fight because nobodys going to sit back and watch i agree with every action being taken and hope it doesn't stop not until we get what we deserve which is a proper suspension i mean come on he broke the guys neck
fan 4 life
0
said
0
i have much love for the game and only a real canadien can appreciate speed and skill but when only 5 teams are Here and the rest down below it just makes financial sense...........
Maxp hope you get better soon kid....need you back on the ice we down 2-1...maybe a fight will get OUR TROOPS RATELLED UP.........NOT
Heather Perry
0
said
0
Hockey fan Ed
0
said
0
Raoul Noel
0
said
0
Catherine Cherry
0
said
0
Last year my ten year old grandson from Ottawa got hit in the first minute of an intercity tournament that was taking place in Syracuse, New York. His femur was broken. He could have bled out and died if the bone had even nicked the main artery which passes through the center of the femur. Fortunately three of the parents present were Doctors and they jumped on the ice to help. He received wonderful treatment in the local hospital, but contacted C-difficile shortly after surgery, thus extending their stay for a week. My daughter, who was pregnant at the time, and my son-in-law slept on the floor beside him. It took almost a year for him to recover.
The boy who hit him did not receive a penalty for his devastating and life-threatening action. He continued his aggressive behavior and went on to receive five of the fifteen penalties his team amassed in that one game.
My grandson is well and back playing hockey, but in a league without checking.
I almost lost my grandson.
I stand with those opposed to violence in hockey.
Yours truly,
Catherine Cherry M.Ed. M.A.
Terry Birch
0
said
0
Harold Faigan
0
said
0
Harold Faigan
0
said
0
Danny P
0
said
0
Please do us all a favor and stick to figure skating or what ever else requires no use of a brain.
If you think this an unfortunate accident you have obviously lost your mind and I hope to god you don't have children.
David Jordan
0
said
0
My thoughts are with Max and his family for a speedy recovery!
Henry Krul
0
said
0
Why was there a steel post exposed where it could hurt a player?
Why isn’t the whole rink surrounded by plexiglass?
Why has no one paid any attention to this, the real key factor in this matter?
Is there any question at all that this tragedy could have been averted if the Bell Center had properly protected the unpadded steel post?
I’d love to hear your views.
Sincerely,
Henry Krul
Rosemary Turpin
0
said
0
Well, I don't know if you call the regular Montreal CTV station the "CTV News Channel"
or not, but that is where I saw it! As you can tell, I was HORRIFIED! There have been
plenty of worse things to be horrified about in this world lately, but your headline was
the only one to inspire me enough to write a note! By the way, the time I gave might have been
a few minutes early -- it may have been closer to 5:00 p.m. -- whenever you do those
news teasers.
Sincerely,
Rosemary
Nance
0
said
0
Nance
0
said
0
Richard Waite
0
said
0
Jon
0
said
0
If something happens on a construction site the employer is immediately under review and huge fines are levied almost certainly to employers for not paying attention to dangerous conditions ....
The stanchion was a very dangerous accident waiting to happen ... the employer, the LEAGUE, should be heavily fined and forced to compensate in this kind of situation .... that is not asking too much as it certainly won't bring back the guy's spine ....
People in Quebec, do some good for your injured player ... redirect your calls to the "Ministry of Labour" not the police!
Jaun
0
said
0
I am a South African living in Montreal and got to know the game of Hockey over the last year and a half. I love it. Speed, Skill and timing its all there just like my in my favorite sport Rugby which is as physical or even a bit more. We have phased out violence in the game as far back as the 1990's. Players who does do so gets hefty Fines and are suspended for many games depending on the severity of the offense. Rugby has now evolved into one of the most spectacular sports on the planet. Hockey is beautiful but i dont understand why organizers allow such foul play in this awesome game.
Regards
linda
0
said
0
The NHL is f***ing blind if they can not see that Chara intentionally pushed Max purposely into the pole. They have to clean up the violence in the game and deal with players who continue to defy the rules. I wish Max the best and I really hope this does not end his career.
Frankie
0
said
0
This kind of injury should not be overlooked. Suspensions and fines aren't working so a team should be made to forfeit a goal and give it to the other team for their player causing injuries. It will make the player think twice before going after a player.
tanyabanana
0
said
0
Instead, they sent the message that if you insult another player's girlfriend, as Sean Avery did a few years back by calling Elisha Cuthbert—who was then dating Dion... Phaneuf—"sloppy seconds," you get a six-game suspension. (Taken fro Kamal Panesar's blog)
Moe
0
said
0
WHAT ARE WE TEACHING OUR FUTURE YOUNG HOCKEY PLAYERS...
I DON'T WANT MY GRANDCHILDREN
THINKING IT IS OKAY TO HURT SOMEONE WHILE PLAYING HOCKEY AND NOTHING WILL HAPPEN BECAUSE OF THEIR ACTIONS...THIS IS WRONG !!!
Carol-Ann
0
said
0
David - Sherbrooke
0
said
0
Common sense should prevail.
maxx
0
said
0
Ross Wilkins
0
said
0
If any person dies as a result of the 911 operators being diverted from real emergencies by you selfish people, I trust the authorities will charge you with endangering life by wasting police and 911 time.
All sports have referees/umpires and administrators whose job is to penalise all incidents appropriately. The Chara hit has been judged and no penalty laid. If you don't like the decision flood the NHL with calls not 911.
Now - on with the game.
Ken
0
said
0
He had the puck, didn't he? That's the point. I also didn't see an arm guiding anyone's head.
You can't tell the difference? Neither can the NHL.
@ Chris
I agree, calling 911 was a bad idea. They should have filed a complaint directly at the police station if they wanted.
People were waiting to see what the NHL would do, because we had faith in the existing system.
Will
0
said
0
shavedone
0
said
0
IMAGINE IF IT WAS OVECHKIN OR CROSBY -- NO SUSPENSION --
YEAH... RIGHT??!
TDH
0
said
0
Ryan White and Jack Johnson - no penalty on this one....looks the same to me also.
Dwayne Bowman
0
said
0
hockey lover's from now, Until next week. I'm trying to stop people from watching NHL hockey for the sake of Max Pacioretty. its pretty clear that the people who are running the NHL do not care about the well being of they're hockey player's. the less we watch the games of the NHL on tv. maybe there will be some kind of sign. we as the people who make this game what it is. can change the leagues opinion about how they're treating there player's. you can make the difference!!stop watching until next weekend.
TDH
0
said
0
What's good for the goose is good for the gander. Check out Max on You Tube.
Liz in Montreal
0
said
0
Our tax dollars hard at work investigating an obvious Hockey accident.How can anyone truly believe that Chara wanted Max to end up in the hospital with a fractured neck.....really? This is so ridiculous. It's just an extremely unfortunate accident.Instead why not ban all violence from the games from now on. I'm not a big hockey fan but I sure will be watching the next Habs games to see how many people cheer those vicious fights....and how many will be calling 911. What's next for the Montreal police......perhaps investigating a boxer being injured in a professional boxing match?
Chris
0
said
0
Obviously people should call 911 when they are witnessing violence WHEN IT IS taking place. Not the day after when the player was in the hospital.
Christine
0
said
0
alan smithee
0
said
0
Today Pavel Kubina was suspended 3 games for a high elbow against a Blackhawk player.
Check out the video..It was really ugly.
To those unfamiliar with sarcasm,this is extremely tongue in cheek.
bruinsfan94
0
said
0
Stavroula
0
said
0
Chris
0
said
0
You hockey fans should make up your minds - clips were shown from the beginning of the same game where there were two players fighting and the crowd was cheering!!! Maybe it does depend who is winning the fight! Violence is considered too acceptable in our society now and you can't pick and choose when you agree with it or not. We already don't have enough police to take care of public safety in the streets what with murders, home invasions, etc. - let the Hockey Association take care of this.
William
0
said
0
I love the physical Hockey game, it's great, it adds another dimension to every players decisions. You won't go as hard for the puck if you know as soon as you get there you're up for grabs, it's that moment of hesitation that makes hockey so unpredictable.
What is predictable for a player is that when he does not have the puck he is not required to protect himself for these bone crushing hits. As soon as the player is not in possession of the puck he quickly changes his priorities, Max hit the puck away 1 or 2 feet from inside the Canadiens zone, the hit and last minute shove by Chara. Max was a couple of feet before the red line as Max was accelerating passed him. This was a race for the finish line as one car steered the other into a brick wall.
Max had no reason to expect such a late and deliberate hit from Chara. I have no idea why it matters whether or not the 6' 9" player had his skates off the ice of not. Also saying that if Max and just gotten up it would be a different story, right but the reason he didn't just get up it because of the intent.
William
0
said
0
I don't care if it was Chara's ego or just the adrenaline pumping I’m sure a lot of real life assaults are motivated by the same thing, but don't credit the guy for athletic ability and coordination and tell me that he was just clumsy on this one. Either you're a professional athlete that makes calculated moves and plays or you're not in control of what you’re doing.
From now on I will reffer to all of Chara's good plays and goals as accidents.
Niko Laval
0
said
0
IvaB
0
said
0
A from Montreal
0
said
0
2. Kids will be pulled out of the sport moving forward.
3. If Campbell's son was on the ice out cold, would the judgment be the same? Would Bettman still insist it is part of the game and it was a clean hit?
Kimberly
0
said
0
john
0
said
0
Cam
0
said
0
J C
0
said
0
Jake the snake
0
said
0
Parker
0
said
0
steven
0
said
0
scott stevens crushed players centre ice no team or city called the police on him.
Brian
0
said
0
G
0
said
0
1- ur not from MTL
2 - don't care about the safety of our players
3- don't care about the message it's giving to our kids and of course to those players who think ya it's ok to be so agressive, i won't be penalized for it
Althoguh perhaps calling the cops was pushing it, it's probably becasue this was their worst case senario seeing as the big heads of NHL allowed for this to happen and allowed for Chara to get away with it. Good job Heads of NHL - Good freaken job!
To those who thin MTL pushed ti too far for calling the cops, I'd like to see if one of your players for whatever team you cheer for gets a hit like this and absolutey NOTHING happens. How would you feel and what would you do?
Max - I'm sorry this happend to you and you didn't get justice out of this. WE the MTL'ers hope you can get out of this in a healthy state. We're all pulling for you and we got your back.
steven
0
said
0
William
0
said
0
---
You obviously don't understand what happened. I could easily make the case that people are just complaining and are stupid for seeing it like that. Unfortunately that's the basic response when you want to deny the severity of something, you followed it textbook.
---
None of what Chara did could have been better, he did everything perfectly from hitting him so long after he touched the puck (which was at the blue line) to skating beside him for a few strides and then all of a sudden it was the right time to shove and then guide Max's face into the glass with the left arm. It couldn't have been more perfect or illegal.
We deal with accidents and accept them, Richard Zednik anyone? (Another Boston cheapshot) But this is unacceptable.
I'm don't know if you think the hockey arena is a separate country, or is this was all sanctioned by the Quebec Boxing Commission, because it's not and it wasn't. If those who profit from the NHL are going to be the ones who decide what's acceptable when it comes to these hits they have to take action. If they don't it will go up the chain, I'm shocked to hear that you think a private for profit company can make the final decision on violence or culpability for serious injury. Tell me why this can't be investigated by the police? Have the laws changed? Is the Bell Center a foreign country?
I remind you that Max Pacioretty is from the USA and Chara is from Slovakia so we're not defending a Canadian, we are defending the game and the safety of players.
It's in all of our best interest to get that out of the game. Not having done it before is not an excuse, we learn that as kids.
RCawz
0
said
0
steve
0
said
0
Herbert
0
said
0
Mister
0
said
0
lINA
0
said
0
Concerned hockey mom
christina
0
said
0
come on this was about time! You hit a guy, ruin his career and then think you will walk away just like that? SPVM better put this SOB behind bars for that. The NHL isnt about violence its about playing good friendly hockey and if they NHL couldnt take disciplinary action then the police will!
superannoyed
0
said
0
J C
0
said
0
theo
0
said
0
david
0
said
0
Ken
0
said
0
Lula
0
said
0
squirrelly
0
said
0
Mr. GI
0
said
0
When the Police department needs to contact the media to tell citizens to stop calling 911 because they want Chara arrested???!!??!!??
...something is wrong with you people. Do you not realize how dumb you come off to the rest of the world?
Attack my comments all you want, it won't make them any less true.
Ali
0
said
0
Simple and Sweet
Big Brother interferrence?
0
said
0
EB
0
said
0
Chris H
0
said
0
Mike
0
said
0
Get over it. Now, if they really want a police investigation because a hit ended up with a dreadful result, OK; but know this -- to do so would fundamentally change the game.
Every incidental high stick that results in a broken orbital bone or every garden-variety trip that results in a concussion or bruised knee would have to be judged and investigated by the same standards. Want that? The players don't. The GMs don't. The fans, unless they're Montreal fans Tuesday, by and large, don't.
Francois
0
said
0
Pretty simple but how effective.
Now some people will tell me, what about real accidents? Listen, if players can score top net while skating at 30 mph, pass the puck around like mad mans, I am sure they can elevate their game to care for each other a bit more too.
Christine
0
said
0
alan smithee
0
said
0
Let me re phrase what I said.
If Chara BROKE Kessel's or Grabovski's NECK,all of TSN's talking heads and Toronto's biggest cheerleader,Don Cherry,would be crying murder about this despicable ruling.
And if you doubt that,then you're the fool.
aj
0
said
0
The time has come for Hockey to live up to its reputation and be responisble in stopping violent plays like this.
ronnie from montreal
0
said
0
AHMED
0
said
0
Nick
0
said
0
Vinnie
0
said
0
Mr John.
0
said
0
space taken up for something that only 30% of the population are interested in.Things are way out of proportion.!!!!!!
I am always glad when the season is over here. It is only then that we can have our downtown back to enjoy. The double Hs are gone(Hockey Hicks)
it will never stop..the violence... even if someone dies.
Careers have already been lost because of it..some have died early deaths as well.
I have the feeling Crosbys career will be a short on due to the hits he taken...
And once again ...to those who called the police... get a life.
Would you call that many times for a suspected rapist or known child molester... No you would not...
firstMickey
0
said
0
Eric
0
said
0
alan smithee
0
said
0
People should be flooding Bettman's office to vent their disgust with this pathetic ruling.
What's more troubling for me is the silence from Canadiens management and ownership.
They should be ripping apart the league's decision.
And if management and Geoff Molson want to be silent,you'd think there'd be ONE GM in the league that would voice some sort of concern.
I'm sick and tired of reporting,notably from the Toronto Sports Network who slammed Hab fans for wanting blood,defended Chara's hit and reputation,downplayed Pacioretty's injury and were united in believing Zdero didn't deserve a suspension..
I wonder how they'd react if Chara laid out Kessel or Grabovski.
Michel Bergeron wrote a good piece at the RDS site and he came up with an excellent idea.
If Pacioretty's career is done,he should SUE Bettman and the NHL.
Maybe accountability would change the NHL's despicable schizophrenic disciplinary rulings.