Canada -   

1

Tough year ahead for RCMP's civilian commissioner

RCMP Commissioner William Elliott speaks with the media during a new conference to comment in changes to the management of the police force in Ottawa, Thursday October 21, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS) William Elliot
RCMP Commissioner William Elliott speaks with the media during a new conference to comment in changes to the management of the police force in Ottawa, Thursday October 21, 2010. (Adrian Wyld / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (13) Facebook   

Date: Thursday Dec. 23, 2010 6:35 AM ET

The RCMP's civilian commissioner will push forward with an agenda of change in the coming year, while his leadership is further tested by an unrelenting conflict with a pack of senior Mounties.

It was in late July when word leaked out that an unspecified group of top Mounties had made formal complaints about the way Commissioner William Elliott went about his work.

They alleged Elliott was abrasive with subordinates, often displaying abusive and bully-like behaviour towards them.

Paul Kennedy, the former RCMP complaints commissioner, told CTV.ca that it was an unprecedented conflict, which involved numerous Mounties -- not a lone individual.

And the officers leading the charge were dedicated career Mounties, the types of people that Kennedy describes as being "the heart and soul" of the RCMP.

The discord inside RCMP headquarters was serious enough that former CSIS director Reid Morden was paid more than $28,000 to complete a "workplace assessment."

To the public watching the drama unfold, it appeared that Elliott's job could be on the line.

In August, Morden reported to Ottawa that there was a high level of tension within the senior ranks regarding the glacial pace of change in the organization.

Elliott emerged from the conflict bruised, but not beaten, and he publicly acknowledged that he is "far from perfect."

After vowing that he and his colleagues would "try and be a more effective team," the Mountie boss went to work reorganizing the people at the top of his organization.

Elliott reduced the number of deputy commissioners in the top brass and he replaced Deputy Commissioner Raf Souccar, who was one of his main critics. Other top Mounties simply retired from the force.

With the turmoil over, Elliott believes "the mood of the senior leadership of the RCMP is very positive" at the end of 2010, according to statements he provided to CTV.ca through his office.

"The new team is united and focused on delivering the highest quality services and continuing our efforts to bring about positive change in the RCMP, to make us more efficient, effective and accountable," he said.

While the commissioner doesn't anticipate any further reorganization of the senior leadership "in the immediate term," Elliott said "further realignments of responsibilities are possible as we continue to work to improve our operations."

Elliott said an additional announcement about a senior appointment is expected before Christmas.

Linda Duxbury, a Carleton University business professor who has done consulting for the Mounties, said the recent changes look like a house-cleaning of the people who made complaints about their boss.

"It seemed that the commissioner punished people who spoke up," Duxbury told CTV.ca in a recent telephone interview from her Ottawa home.

For the RCMP to move forward, "we need to encourage people to speak truth to power," Duxbury said, rather than reinforcing an autocratic culture that handcuffs its critics.

In a phone interview, Liberal public safety critic Mark Holland said that there is "a real cloak of secrecy" around the conflict and the number of Mounties who were involved.

Ottawa's public safety committee is digging into the issue and Holland said that some of Elliott's critics will be among those called to testify. So far, Souccar and former Assistant Commissioner Mike McDonell have been called to appear before the committee in February.

Further challenges

By year's end, Elliott signalled that the force was making progress on more ambitious changes that critics have long said are necessary to building a better RCMP.

During a November speech, Elliot endorsed having the RCMP made into a separate employer, so that it can exercise greater control over its spending and staffing allotments.

Separate employer status would give the RCMP authority to make its own human resources decisions and to manage its budget, as opposed to going to the Treasury Board for approval on these matters.

Elliott also said the RCMP should be overseen by a civilian management board, a change that a federal task force has previously called for.

The commissioner told his audience "the changes we are pursuing are neither simple nor easy. Nor would they be a magic solution or a silver bullet."

Kennedy said these issues are just some of the big-picture problems the RCMP faces, including a wave of baby boomer retirements that has depleted their reserve of experienced officers.

The former RCMP complaints commissioner told CTV.ca that this trend has forced the force to promote its uniformed Mounties sooner than expected, without giving the mentorship they need to grow into their new positions.

"They are going to have to learn their job and how to perform the job on the fly," Kennedy said in a recent telephone interview from his Ottawa home.

Elliott told CTV.ca that the RCMP expects to see turnover in its senior leadership positions "over the coming months and years, including as a result of individuals reaching their retirement dates."

Duxbury said Elliott is "saying all the right things" about the changes he wants to implement in the RCMP.

But she said it is beyond the point where talk will suffice and Elliott will have to produce.

"The commissioner is in an unenviable position, the spotlight is on him," Duxbury said.

With files from The Canadian Press

Comments are now closed for this story

Jim
said

Without specifics of the alleged abuses by the Commissioner it is difficult to determine the root cause. It appears most likely the senior mounties launched their complaints largely due to resentment of a civilian boss being appointed. As the Commissioner moved forward with much needed change in the RCMP this resentment grew towards this "outsider", resulting in a lack of cohesion in the senior ranks. As supposdly disciplined professionals these senior mounties clearly demonstrated why they had to go.


William
said

My son as a member of the RCMP puts his life on the line each day in undercover work. I strongly recommend Paul Palango' s book "Dispersing The Fog, inside the secret world of Ottawa and the RCMP". What needs to be done is to cut the umbilical cord between the politicians (cabinet, PMO, MP's) and the RCMP. Then, they need to get rid of this political appointee William Elliott and replace him with a cop who was not a "yes man" to Giuliano Zaccardelli who himself was a Chretien Liberal puppet who "took care of business" for Chretien. It is not morally right that our men and women in of the RCMP risk their lives while others play power politics in the echelons of political power using the RCMP for their own cover ups and questionable political purposes. Read the book.


Cam
said

This position should always be held by a civilian educated in law, the police have a reputation of abusing the powers and hiding their wrong doings.


Will
said

While Ian in Ottawa has a very good point, I don't believe putting in a Military leader is the way ahead, he would lack the cachet of legitimacy for both the RCMP members and the public - though Ian's point about leadership by example is exactly on the mark. What the RCMP need is to promote internally a new commissioner, one who is senior enough to deserve the appointment but is also untainted. Don't ask me who that will be as I don't know their leadership at all, but is has to be internal and the present unqualified civilian HAS TO GO.


Anne M
said

The thought that a General should take over the force is a good one, but I doubt that a General in his right mind would want to lead that pack of freeloaders, as they are like mad dogs and bite at every opportunity. The RCMP need to become a modern day police force, improve their forensics, investigative procedures, and make them worthy of the respect they have lost under previous management.


Charles Tailor
said

If you speak to RCMP constables they are unhappy because of the lack of change, the lacking behind municipal forces in equipment and benefits. Being the National Police force (the FBI of Canada) I was shocked that police officers in Toronto make significantly more. More over they have no one to represent them. This force will see more dark days before the light under this guy.


Tony
said

A head of a police service does not need to be a police officer. The head of a police service is the person who is accountable for the mistakes made by that particlular service. In the case of the RCMP, the previous commisionaires were incapable of admitting that they were ineffective. A shake up in the RCMP was long overdue.


JDs
said

When Elliott took over, I was skeptical. A Civie running a policing organization...c'mon. I have seen the changes over the last couple years and grow more and more impressed of his work. He's certainly ruffled some feathers in the upper-brass but they needed it! This Service has been failing for a few years now with internal politics and corruption. I have a growing respect for the Mounties now, since Elliott's appointment. Good on him for sticking it out! I'm sure it's lonely at the top and is not easy but he's doing some great work! Keep it up, Sir.Oh, and putting a CF General in charge of policing isn't a bright idea. Policing and military mandates are completely different. The police service should not report to the CF and by putting a Gen (regardless of BGen, MGen or LtGen) would suggest that the RCMP is lower than the CF. They're equals as far as I'm concerned. I understand the need for having a respectable person at the top but that has to be earned, not commanded. Elliott has earned mine, and a lot of RCMP members'.


George V.
said

From the day William Elliott was appointed commissioner of the RCMP the force especially the senior staff worked against him,because he was a civilian, the feeling was he didn't work his way to the top through the ranks and file, he wasn't one of "us". He was bad mouthed even before he was installed as a commissioner. We saw how the previous commissioner ran the RCMP, money was spent lavishly for personal gain, problem after problem occurred, the force was on a downward spiral. Let's give this commissioner a chance, he can't fix in a few years that took years and years to break down.


Earthwatcher
said

Fire him, hire a qualified senior RCMP officer (one determined by an outside review panel) and move on. This guy is causing more trouble and discord than he is effecting any kind of positive change.


Garry W
said

It was more than necessary that we installed civilian oversight in the RCMP. Proof has been undeniable that they are incapable of objectively governing themselves. Too many secrets, too many lies, too many scandals, too many abuses.Problem is, you need a committee of civilians, not one Czar.

Sam
said

I'm not understanding why we have a civilian in this role. There are complexities specific to the RCMP that one would think requires a career RCMP officer in that role.


Ian Ottawa
said

Solution!Get rid of the Civilian and put in a Canadian Forces General who can show Leadership by example until the time that the rCMP can take over the top job again.A Government Appointed Talking Head is NOT what he RCMP want or need at this time or any time.The RCMP system had a problem and a poorly thought out solution was put in place. At least a Military General would respect the RCMP and visa versa.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Double lung transplant recipient Helene Campbell appears on 'Ellen,' on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Campbell celebrates recovery with 'Ellen' appearance

More   13 Comments 13    10 Video(s) 10

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Estranged husband charged in Gatineau, Que., murders

More  1 Video(s) 1

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty holds a press conference in Toronto on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Federal deficit falling despite $9B spike in March

More  1 Video(s) 1

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?