Canada -   

1
Hollywood director James Cameron speaks to reporters at a press conference held in Edmonton, Alberta, on Wednesday, September 29, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Hollywood director James Cameron, centre, is lead away by security after speaking to reporters at press conference held in Edmonton, Alberta, on Wednesday, September 29, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Film director James Cameron, centre, tours the Syncrude Canada Bill's Lake mine reclamation site, with industry, provincial officials and reporters, north of Fort McMurray, Alberta, on Tuesday, August 28, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Film director James Cameron speaks at a news conference in Edmonton on Wednesday, Sept. 29, 2010.

Oilsands can be 'a curse' to Canada, Cameron says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Janet Dirks on the tour
Hollywood director James Cameron is calling for stronger federal and provincial regulations on the environmental impact of the Alberta oilsands, after touring the region with aboriginal activists and oil executives.
Power Play: James Cameron, filmmaker
The director of the films 'Avatar' discusses how addiction to fossil fuels was one of the subtexts of the films, and asks who is funding research into making the oilsands more environmentally friendly.
Power Play: Environment Minister Jim Prentice
The environment minister responds to film director James Cameron's comments on the oilsands, and discusses the regulations that are needed to develop them in an environmentally friendly way.
Power Play: Elizabeth May, Green Party Leader
The Leader of the Green Party says James Cameron is helping a lot of Canadians to take a tour of the Alberta oilsands with him.
CTV Edmonton: Scott Roberts on Cameron last day
Hollywood director James Cameron addressed the media Wednesday afternoon in Edmonton saying while he realizes the province's oilsands can be a 'great gift to Canada' he feels it could also be a curse if not managed properly.
CTV Edmonton: Bill Fortier on Cameron's trip
James Cameron's visit has been news in Edmonton all week, but now, the filmmaker's stop to Alberta is creating buzz across Canada and in the U.S.
CTV News Channel: James Cameron, film director
Director James Cameron says the oilsands will be a curse if it's not managed properly, but he also says 'it can be a great gift to Canada and to Alberta if it is managed properly.'
CTV News Channel: Alberta Premier on oilsands
Alberta Premier Ed Stelmach says the media's interest in film director James Cameron's visit has allowed them to tell their story about the oilsands and its benefits. He also says Cameron shares their concern about the environment.
CTV Edmonton: Kevin Armstrong reports
James Cameron began the morning touring Syncrude's facility via helicopter. Cameron then walked the land that was once a mine and has since been turned into a wetland. Syncrude says it did its best to get as much information to Cameron as possible.
CTV Extended: Cameron takes questions
This raw, unedited, video shows a CTV Edmonton correspondent speaking to the Canadian filmmaker behind blockbuster hits Titanic and Avatar moments after he touched down in Fort McMurray on Monday.
CTV National News: Director tours oilsands
Film director and environmentalist James Cameron arrived in Fort McMurray, Alta., tonight to learn more about the oilsands development. Cameron has criticized the industry as a black eye for Canada but now says he will re-evaluate.
CTV Calgary: Ryan Sang on the oilsands
Hollywood movie director James Cameron, who has openly criticized the industry, is touring Alberta's oilsands.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (68) Facebook   

Hollywood director James Cameron speaks to reporters at a press conference held in Edmonton, Alberta, on Wednesday, September 29, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Hollywood director James Cameron, centre, is lead away by security after speaking to reporters at press conference held in Edmonton, Alberta, on Wednesday, September 29, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Film director James Cameron, centre, tours the Syncrude Canada Bill's Lake mine reclamation site, with industry, provincial officials and reporters, north of Fort McMurray, Alberta, on Tuesday, August 28, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS) Film director James Cameron speaks at a news conference in Edmonton on Wednesday, Sept. 29, 2010.

Photos

Hollywood director James Cameron speaks to reporters at a press conference held in Edmonton, Alberta, on Wednesday, September 29, 2010. (John Ulan / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Sep. 29 2010 8:00 PM ET

Director James Cameron warned Canadians Wednesday that Alberta's oilsands "will be a curse" if not enough is done to prevent devastating environmental damage from their development.

Cameron has spent three days in Alberta, touring oilsands projects and meeting with stakeholders, including government and aboriginal leaders, to better understand a system he once called Canada's "black eye."

After a meeting Wednesday morning with Premier Ed Stelmach, Cameron told reporters that the oilsands will yield great benefits for Alberta and Canada, but only if efforts are made to better understand where energy comes from, how it's extracted and the social and environmental costs of its production.

"(The oilsands) will be a curse if it's not managed properly, (but) it can also be a great gift to Canada and to Alberta if it is managed properly," Cameron said.

"Personally I believe that this is an incredible resource, and I certainly understand why everybody is stampeding toward it with this desire to exploit it as rapidly as possible, because it's the single largest reserve of potential crude oil next to Saudi Arabia.

"In an energy-starved future, that's going to…put Canada in a different position and help with energy independence in North America."

After arriving in the province Monday, Cameron toured a Syncrude facility, including a reclaimed mine that is now a wetland known as Bill's Lake.

He then travelled to the community of Fort Chipewyan, where he listened to the concerns of people living downstream from the oilsands, including fears over the safety of the drinking water and fish.

Cameron said he was presented with a study during his meeting with Stelmach that refuted the claims of environmental damage by the residents of Fort Chipewyan.

But the Oscar-winning director said residents told him they are afraid to swim in or fish the Athabasca River.

"I think we need to respect the First Nations communities for having their finger on the pulse of what's happening to mother nature," Cameron said. "And if they say the fish taste different and they're being affected and something's going on, I think it would behoove us to listen to that and find out for sure what these causal links are."

Cameron said because the oilsands development is still in its infancy -- only between 2 and 3 per cent of tar sands deposits are being mined -- the true environmental impacts are years away.

Therefore, Cameron said, greater regulatory controls must be placed on the industry, including caps on sulfur and carbon dioxide emissions, and a moratorium on tailings ponds, the dump sites for toxic waste from the oilsands. Cameron said the technology to mine via a so-called dry finds process, which does not require tailings ponds, is only about five years away.

"I think it's impossible to imagine a refining process and an extraction process on this scale that did not have negative environmental impacts. That would have to be some kind of Immaculate Conception," Cameron said. "So it's important for us to embrace the fact that there will be negative impacts, they need to be understood, and they need to be mitigated at the source to the extent possible."

During his own post-meeting press conference Wednesday, Stelmach would not comment on Cameron's suggestion to place a moratorium on tailings ponds.

But he said his meeting with Cameron was worth his time for the healthy discussion about the oilsands' economic and environmental impacts.

Federal Environment Minister Jim Prentice said the oilsands need to be developed for economic and national security reasons, but agreed that it must be done in an environmentally responsible way.

"Let's be clear about what our national objective is," Prentice told CTV's Power Play Wednesday evening. "We intend to produce the oilsands, but we have to do it in an environmentally responsible way. We have to be the most environmentally responsible producer of all forms of energy, and that includes the oilsands."

But Green Party Leader Elizabeth May said the federal government has to do more to develop the oilsands in an environmentally sound manner.

"What James Cameron has done has been to help a lot of Canadians take the tour with him, to see the massive scale, to see the devastation of the environment, to understand more of the science and to see where we really are right now on this planet in terms of our overall imperative to get off fossil fuels," May told Power Play in an interview from Victoria. "And using oilsands crude, tar sands crude in the meantime, but how do you do that responsibly?"

Cameron called for independent research, not funded by industry, into how land can best be reclaimed after the extraction process is over, and on the true environmental impacts of the oilsands industry. He also urged oil executives, government and aboriginal leaders to work together.

"The world is looking at what you here in Alberta do," Cameron said, "and the decisions that are made here are really going to shape the energy policy of the future."

Comments are now closed for this story

Havelock Heavy
said

Unfortunately, Jim Prentice is not behaving in a manner that Canadians should expect from their Environment Minister. He is more like the Minister for Tar Sands promotion. His only response to the serious problems that the tar sands are creating is that he will appoint an expert panel to advise him. Why would he do that when he has very competent scientists who work in his department? Why has he not been listening to what they have been telling him?


Dave-O
said

That's one VIP stating the obvious. Now if only the "little people" could be heard and listened to, that would be worthy of a headline.

Dave in Surrey
said

Not sure if the commentators here actually read the article or not, it would appear they didn't... Cameron said the oilsands "CAN" be a curse "IF" it is not properly managed... How can anyone disagree with that statement? I am for oilsands development, and willing to listen to both sides and mature enough to see the actual truth... Of course some on the pro side and the nay side will just tell us the inverted story the other is telling, both full of lies.


TP
said

Cameron should take his cause to Venezuala and see if Chavez affords him the same courtesies as Stelmach when he attacks their Orinoco tar sands project.

Maggy
said

In order to develop responsibly we need to be open to views other than those 'dictated' by industry and government. I hope we can listen and take into account concerns and issues from all communities that connect to the environment and economy. James Cameron does not have all the answers, no one does.


JB in Ontario
said

Yes, listening to the Aboriginal people of Alberta who keep a close eye on Mother Nature is sound advice I think. I agree with Elizabeth May in that we have to extract the crude oil in a way that least affects the environment and think of ways to rehabilitate the land after the oil is extracted. I wouldn't swim in the Athabasca river and I would also be very concrened about the quality of fish the Aboriginals use as their staple food.I am glad Mr. Cameron went to see the site and disucssed it with Ed Stelmach and Jim Prentice.


MBA1995
said

The oilsands development's effect on the earth are nowhere near the environmental damage done daily from frivilous city driving , long daily commutes, driving to and from the gym to exercise for 45 minutes, and jet trips to sunspots every winter. The distruction of this world, polluting the air, and destroying the soil by building 4- 6- 10-lane freeways, roads, parking lots, airports, is far worse. The roads etc. are never restored. The construction of houses and shopping centres on top-quality farm land around major cities is unforgivable.

LDL in ONT
said

Now I know what inspired James Cameron to put that line in the Titanic movie...." I'm King of the World"....because he believes he is !


Lz in Edmonton
said

Interesting. The posters here think he spoke BADLY about the whole thing. Though I don't think he is qualified to speak technically about anything, he has a right to an opinion. What I get from him is that in the next 20 years, his concern is that development might go so crazy that we begin to disregard our present policies and allow for the potential for an environmental disaster. We need sustainable and responsible development of the oilsands. We do have a jewel in Alberta and Saskatchewan regarding resources that the world will be in short supply of in the next 20 years. So we best get our house and rules in order now and stick to them. The resource in this area is a 200 year project. It takes decades to extract an area and decades to reclaim it. We can't get in over our heads and develop everything at once. But until they discover a means of fueling our world without fossil fuels, we need to be good stewards of our resource and I feel that the next 50 years, we will be very financially successful.


David
said

When was the last time Cameron has looked into any of the true U.S. environmental disasters. I've been to Ft. Mac Murry; I can breath just fine there. I've been to most all major cities in the U.S.; try and breath there. The air and polution, in the U.S. is so bad people don't open their windows anymore.


Wayne
said

James Cameron probably has plenty of relevant advice and opinions for the film industry, he should stick to that. Why CTV continues to present his 'crusade' as relevant news to Canadians is beyond me.WHO CARES WHAT JAMES CAMERON THINKS


B. Kelley, Ontario
said

Cameron should go back to doing what he does very well - making movies. Why is it that as soon as people such as he gain some fame in Hollywood they automatically become experts on every subject imaginable. Cameron left Canada to make his fortune so he should stay there and spend it. My 8 year old Grandson's opinion on the Tar Sands holds about as much credibility as his does, maybe more.


chris
said

Whoa, getting testy now, are we, about the "Hollywood Elitist" coming here and opening his mouth. Last I heard it's a free country and people from anywhere can come and speak their minds. Why not? What I heard him say, and agree with, is that the oilsands have the potential to be environmentally devastating in many ways, and if we're going to develop them we better make sure we do it in a way that is relatively benign, otherwise it would be folly to proceed. Sacrificing the future for profits is not only short-sighted but criminal.

steve in wildrose country
said

"Oilsands can be a curse to Canada." Of course so can Cameron.


Charlie Cahill
said

Why did this network and the 'other' as well bother giving air time to a Hollywood film-maker?Must have been a very slow news day when our networks vie with each other to make a national spokesman out of a man who has no experience in this field at all.


JEFFDW
said

Why is anyone even listening to what an entertainer thinks ? Why does the media even report on this? As an entertainer his main motivation is to do or say anything that will garner attention to himself . This is a person whose movies consume hundreds of millions of dollars of resources in their production and provide nothing of value back to society, it is not like he is providing food or housing, entertainment is the most trivial of needs, he is the ultimate environmental hypocrite.

Carlos
said

He's Canadian for crying out loud and he was invited by the Alberta government to tour the oil patch.


DGRose
said

Well, I guess even a mega-bucks movie producer needs some free press from time to time. I like the claim that the oilsands will only be good for us "if efforts are made to better understand where energy comes from, how it's extracted and the social and environmental costs of its production." Uhh... I'm gonna take a wild stab in the dark on this one and say the research was not only done but it's ongoing, especially considering that said research is vital to the continued viability of the oilsands to begin with. I think Bill Maher said it best when he said "Get over yourself!" Remind me to watch more of your movies in the future, Mr Cameron.


Sue
said

Those of you who dispute any claim other than from the oil industry or government as being correct are the same people who would scream if you found one bag of garbage thrown on your lawn from a passerby. Mr. Cameron is echoing the frustrations of Canadians; not all, but a few whose voices seem to be ignored. Just because he resides in the USA doesn't mean he isn't allowed to speak. After all we certainly voice our own opinions on the US military practices whether on a soapbox or in our own homes.


Bloke
said

The Oilsands development north of Fort McMurray has nothing to do with cancer in Fort Chip. Cancer has been an issue there for many decades and the cause is directly related to the Uranium in the area and the closed mine. The barges from Uranium City to Fort McMurray polluted Lake Athabasca and the river for years.This guy from Hollywood is pretty naive and doesn't have a clue, he is on a publicity trip in all the wrong places.


Chris
said

The headline for this article could have just as easily read: "Oilsands can be 'a great gift' to Canada, Cameron says". The media seems to put a negative spin on every article dealing with the oilsands. What I don't understand is what environmental groups (and the media) think is a viable alternative to fossil fuels at this time.


CraigW
said

I would think we are better off with the oilsands in Canada than James Cameron.


Jasper
said

The Canadian oilsands are an easy target for the environmentalist groups. It is safe to protest and the Canadian media gives them attention. Mr. Cameron should go to and inspect an oilfield in Russia, Libya, Syria, Jordan, etc. He may never be seen alive again.


Jenn
said

I totally agree with the comments here (well, minus one). There is nothing more annoying than Mr. Cameron travelling to another country to be critical when there are enough glaring issues in his own backyard that he could turn his attention to. And why does the media pay attention to people who are only famous because of Hollywood? Why do they suddenly acquire some sort of credibility just because they are famous?


Loretta
said

It is all good fun until there is no gas for your car and your house is cold and dark, right Mr. Cameron.


Mike
said

"(The oilsands) will be a curse if it's not managed properly, (but) it can also be a great gift to Canada and to Alberta if it is managed properly." I have absolutely no idea why everyone is so uptight about this obvious statement. I take it that all these dissenters would still complain even if Cameron only said... "it is a great gift to Canada and to Alberta." Makes one wonder????


Amy
said

Mr. Cameron is putting a famous face to the possible dangers of oilsands refining. I support that. From the get-go this venture has made me nervous for my country, my environment. All he has maintained is that people's concerns need to be addressed and respected. And that all parties involved need to be open and honest. The oilsands development is a scary thing. The 'pro-oil-sands' ads that I've seen on the TV already make me nervous. As does the big money being offered to grunt workers with little to no training to uproot and move there. I fear for the land and the people in that area. I can see the bureaucracy totally taking over and leaving everyone else with a devastated environment, poor health, no jobs and no money.


Scott ON
said

Amazing how critical you guys can get when someone says something you disagree with, yet are all super quick to bash the U.S. And for the record, Cameron is CANADIAN. The oil sands are dirty, anybody who thinks they are any more environmentally friendly than drilling offshore is delusional. Day to day operations reek as much havoc as the oil spill did. I've been there. I've worked there, and I've seen it first hand. But it's essential and I believe can be made safer. Everything he's stated is true and I applaud his realistic approach to dealing with it.


b. emms
said

hmmm...interesting to see the media choose to put the word "curse" in the headlines and not use the "gift" sentiment from Cameron in the same sentence. Let the Alberta bashing continue.


Ralph Eddy
said

where did the fuel he used to come up here come from?another planet! how can he be against oil when he uses it also. why doesn't he invent something else we can use? if he is so smart.

Ron
said

He is a smart man and we should be glad he is shining some light on these issues. Good for you Mr Camron. We can have jobs and a clean environment too. As far as him being a Hollywood elite, I give him credit for at least caring and lending his support to this cause. He could have just not cared and stayed at home spending his millions like most Hollywood stars.


GHW
said

I want to see Canada develop the oilsands and make some good coin. Canada has it made in the shade! Yahoo! I also see no reason why big oil can’t pay to extract the oil with ZERO environmental impact given a bit of time to get up to speed. I trust big business with my family's future about as far as I can throw them. I would rather see an appropriate portion of oil profits go toward a clean environment than in some fat-cat oil executives bank account. In this case I see the criticism and pressure put on this industry to clean its act up as a necessary annoyance.

Vickie
said

No disrespect to Mr Cameron but he is a film director not a mining engineer or a scientist. His opinions are of his own and why is it he, a high profile Canadian is jumping on the "beat up the oilsands" band wagon in 2010 when the oilsands have been around long before he won his first oscar.It is time that the all knowing, all being actors, actresses and those in the entertainment field quit trying to play in everyone else's field. When he has his masters in engineering along with a thesis on the study of the oilsands then maybe, just maybe he has the right to make statements that the oilsands could be a great gift to Canada...what is he talking about, we already have the oilsands, we don't need it to be a gift. What we need is people to stay out of our oil and it's business.


Pau West Coast
said

Makes sense to me; slow down extraction and wait for technology to catch up so there can be environmentally dry extraction. In the meantime weight all the consequences of our actions. Governments must campaign and target much lower emissions if this planet is to sustain itself.


morvin
said

Cameron is bending over backwards trying to give the Canada's governments and oilsands industry a break - a chance to correct their ways. However, if the industry, the Government of Canada, the Government of Alberta and those who selfishly proclaim that the industry is environmentally friendly, don't change their ways, a barrel of Alberta oil-sands-crude will be worth less than a seal skin a few years from now. And, if you don't like Cameron, wait until Michael Moore shows up, film crew in hand, without notice, to make another one of his global blockbusters about the industry.


Donaldbain
said

What is with these actors and directors and musicians coming to our country and trying to tell us how we must live and who to vote for? Making movies or records does not qualify you to meddle in our internal affairs. James Cameron, Bono, and company take note. (especially Bono)


Kate Jensen
said

I am glad that someone like James Cameron, who is well known, has taken an interest, and I feel he is right by stating the world will be looking at Alberta closely, so how we handle this is important.. He is right in stating all parties need to work together. This is a valuable resource that is much needed, but so is our environment (mother earth)...


steve in wildrose country
said

We care what Cameron says why?


Amar
said

This guy is weak for attacking Canada. I dare him to go to Iran or Saudi Arabi and "voice" concerns about their oil production. Coward!


Irritable Canadian
said

Why the he** is James Cameron's opinion on the oil sands relevant? If we shut the oilsands down is he singlehandedly going to provide salaries to all the people who would be unemployed as well ensure the financial stability of Alberta and indeed all of Canada due to the loss of this industry? Give me a break. As for the First Nations in Fort Chip, I used to live in Fort McMurray for about 20 years and let me tell you that the First Nations in Fort MacKay, Chip, Anzac, Conklin, Janvier, are wellserved by the oilsands and are EXTREMELY well paid. The oilsands companies have gone out of their way to work with First Nations communities there and a vast majority appreciate the oilsands for the great jobs they provide and the higher quality of life they are giving to many citizens. And for those of you tempted to blast the oilsands because you get your news from stooges like James Cameron or Greenpeace, get you butt on a plane and take a look at it for yourself -- you'll find that in many respects the oilsands companies have done and are doing more for improving the environment than any jerk from Greenpeace who spends his/her time scaling buildings and yelling obscenities. Stick to directing movies James, you pompous dope.


Ken Durham
said

Cameron has an opinion, wow. People provided him with information! Double wow-wow. I hate to think where this will end up, perhaps another boring movie like Titanic. It ran for over 3 hours and was soooo boring I fell asleep. Get over yourself Cameron, you are even more boring than your movies and your opinions are meaningless.


Adam
said

MYOB James Cameron! Who dost thou think thou are?Alberta is not anti-environment so stop demonizing the province, Did you use fuel to come to Canada by the way?

PG Pete
said

Just curious, but what makes Mr. Cameron an expert in oil recovery or environmental issues? ie. why should we pay any attention to what he has to say? Yes, he is an underwater exploration expert, but I'm not too sure how that gives him any credibility towards the oilsands.

mtl
said

Toxic Alberta parts 1, 2, and 3 sum it all up quite nicely. Please look this documentary up.


Who?
said

Make a name for yourself in Hollywood and it makes you an authority on everything, especially politics.I really wish people in the film industry would stick to making movies and leave the rest to people who know what they are talking about


Captain Kirk
said

All you guys out there are being so hateful. This guy is Canadian and you're telling him to go back over the border cause he's American, and should worry about the States. You know, if everyone (regardless of their financial situation) stood up and said something, (worth saying) then I wouldn't be worried about bringing a child into this world. We have to think about the future NOW! Enough of the ravishing already. This is the same as any vice, and the opposite of vice is virtue...Wake up oilsands workers, there are other ways to make a living.


Scott
said

Shouldn't he be directing movies? Do we really need to take advice from a movie director? What a joke.


Prof Dis Gusted
said

Cameron is absolutely right for speaking out. Good for him. I hope the Alberta and federal governments will finally take note of the legitimate public concerns about this activity and get serious about ensuring that the problems at the tar sands get fixed before worse things happen.


Jay Spark
said

Although I respect that you feel this is newsworthy, I don't think James Cameron's opinion on this subject really deserves this amount of coverage. The words could have come from the mouths of many ordinary people, some of whom with more basis to express an opinion on the subject. This seems like celebrity worship, not news. Expect better from CTV.


Frank Buchan
said

I'm no fan of the man, but the fact is he's entitled to his opinion, and he's not entirely wrong. We really have no certainties. But then it is a process of extraction driven by consumers, so maybe he should focus on helping those consumers (us) reduce our dependence. As to all the shrill voices here lambasting him, that kind of response is unnecessary and pointless. he can use his voice as he sees fit; let him talk. And to those who trot out tired arguments beginning along the lines, "we're better than...": Being the best is always better than being better. To suggest we can't do better is false, and to suggest we shouldn't aggressively lead the world in making this process better every day is degrading our potential. In other words, let us rise to the challenge rather than rely upon tired excuses.


Jalal Karim
said

does someone actually want to discuss the environmental issues of the oilsands? or just slam a person using their celebrity to get the word out?


George V.
said

Mr Cameron should realize that the U.S.A. are the lion's share recipients of the tar sands oil. If it weren't for their dollars we wouldn't be digging and transforming that land into a moon scape.


D. Jason Walters
said

Cameron should be supporting the oil sands, not condemning it. I can't remember the last time the oil sands spilled 25 million gallons of crude into the Gulf of Mexico.As for the First Nations, if they are so concerned about the environmental effects, then I take it that they are totally petroleum-independent. Otherwise all they are saying is "not in my backyard." Other countries can pollute their land and we will reap the benefits.


Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said

Who is being hysterical now? Cameron is saying we should be careful and think before we destroy things we can't fix. Meanwhile you posters are trying to discredit him for being cautious. I would rather listen to somebody talking sense than irrational ranting.


Dylan
said

It's sad that the media only pays attention to this environmental disaster after a celebrity intervenes. Oil companies should not be allowed to regulate themselves, in the interest of public safety and health. And yes, there is a lot of money to be made in the oilsands, but once that's depleted Alberta will just be a septic field of toxic chemicals. Step up and make your voices heard while we can still make a difference.


Dave Hills
said

I see a lot of comments that can't see past the fact that this is a famous person saying what is obvious. We know there are negative effects on the environment! If his comments sour the taste of your Alberta-economy enhanced Grande Latte then too bad. Dave


PJ
said

Wow, I am astonished at the backlash and the venom in the responses I see from other commenters. I, for one, amd happy that Cameron took the time to go and visit the oilsands and see of his own eyes what devastation we humans can dish out, all in the name of economic progress and propserity. Simply put, oil gas = BAD. We are destroying the Earth and we have no idea how long it will take to clean-up the mess we are making. It doesn't take a doctorate to see destruction or take a position against what we know causes CO2 emissions and impacts the climate. Shape up people!


pilgrimomega
said

James Cameron said: "My appeal really is to the public to learn the issues, connect with these issues."but all the commentators here think that, as a film maker he's not allowed an opinion. Truth is, anyone who reads, and can research can talk about what they find. So go ahead, keep on jumping him without reading. Pointing out pictures of mutated and tumor ridden fish isn't a lie, it's exposing truth. This isn't on the same level as Paul McCartney flying to seal country and telling people to stop killing the cute little pups without concern for people's ability to make a living. Cameron is there to expand his research and help formulate his opinions. Even suggesting possible ways to avoid further pollution. Stop sucking the oil tit people. We need to get past it. While I don't think Cameron is untouchable, or a prophet on this topic, he is most definitely trying to get more attention brought to the topic. It's working. I still take what he says with a grain of salt, but that grain is where I do some research on my own to find out if he's bullcrapping or on the level.


CSK
said

He comes across such as that Alberta is doing nothing about the concerns he has brought up. Independent review of the affects, good idea. Hey, guess what, Stelmach ordered that a few weeks ago. Again, sir, you open your mouth only to jamb your foot down your throat as far as it goes. James, did you not realize you were standing in the only reclaimed tailings pond in the world? As for the scale of the projects, maybe you ought to go visit the James Bay hydro project in Quebec where 130,000 sqkm of forest have been disturbed never to be reclaimed? How green is that?Due to the amount of GHG created to make the Avatar movie, screen it twice and put it to DVDBlue ray twice, I still have no interest in purchasing your products. I've done my part in reducing GHG's. Cameron, contact me as to where to send your carbon credit cheque, thank you.ps...Don't fly home, walk home. By the way, how are the oil sand projects in California doing?


Lorraine, Boyle,AB.
said

I agree with former comments made....I believe you look at your own doorstep before you interfere in other people's and countries affairs. Perhaps Mr.Cameron should have walked from Edmonton to Fort Mac that would be the really environmentally friendly thing to do, in the mean time, he could have enjoyed our beautiful country.


Dan
said

When the US has perfected its environmental policies and practices then they can come up to Canada and criticize, until then stay home and shut up. It is also ironic that one of the world's largest oil consumers and the number one consumer of oil from the oil sands is the one being the most critical of our practices. This is the same country who wouldn't even maintain a moratorium on offshore oil projects even though the disasterous environmental impact of these has been demonstrated over and over again.


Kinikinik
said

Stelmach doesn't care if the land is rendered useless.......as long as the grassland he needs to feed cattle remains the same.


Duncan Druhl
said

At least he is a bit less hysterical than the usual Hollywood-hype expert. One does wonder where his petroleum engineering and finance credentials arise, though. Everyone's "concerns" give them an instant measure of credibility? I'm worried about Canada's foreign trade imbalance with the US, but that concern, per se, does not make me an expert.Besides, that he has five baby goats is not our concern - it is the children that matter.


Marlyn
said

Cameron should also understand that there are long-term negative effects from making anti-America or anti-Western nations films supporting the 3rd world dictatorships and terrorists nations to chip away at democracy and destroy our way of life. Does he understand along with his irresponsible Hollywood elites that as well?

Joe
said

Oh really? Well Mr. Cameron with all his mega bucks (why doesn't he help Americans who are facing foreclosure keep their homes with his money?) has a lot of extra time on his hands like most "Hollywood elitists" who don't live in the real world anymore. When is the last time he went to a grocery store? The tar-sands are a vital part of Canada's economy and the people of Canada need it to fund our socialist lunacy gone amok thanks to Quebec demanding 60% of federal equalization payments funding their $7 daycare and free invitro treatments of 30 grand per Quebec couple demanding genetically produced kids instead of adoption.


uber
said

He has 5 kids? Well that's kind of environmentally unfriendly I thought. Oh wait, he's rich, so that's five more eugenicists he's raising then, I see. THEY'LL be the ones determining who gets to live or die...oh ok then. Continue on most worshipful master.


Mark
said

...and James Cameron makes movies. He is not a geologist, geophysicist, scientist, anthropologist or otherwise.He makes movies about fairy tales and the Titanic. Why does anyone care what he thinks?


raj
said

I wont listen to him , his mind was made up before his private helicopter landed. His movies are the Pitts! Ciao! Made in Canada, is way better than made is Saudi! perhaps he needs to think about that one


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Double lung transplant recipient Helene Campbell appears on 'Ellen,' on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Campbell celebrates recovery with 'Ellen' appearance

More   9 Comments 9    10 Video(s) 10

Gatineau Quebec Police investigate an abandoned van that may be connected to a major crime scene that happened kilometer away were multiple bodies were found on Thursday May 24,2012 in Gatineau, Que. across the river from Ottawa. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand

Police confirm triple-murder in Gatineau, Que.

More  1 Video(s) 1

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty holds a press conference in Toronto on Friday, May 25, 2012.

Federal deficit falling despite $9B spike in March

More  1 Video(s) 1

Most Talked about Stories

I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.

me

Should all Canadians be automatically considered organ donors?