Canada -
News Sections
Oilsands can be 'a curse' to Canada, Cameron says
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Sep. 29 2010 8:00 PM ET
Director James Cameron warned Canadians Wednesday that Alberta's oilsands "will be a curse" if not enough is done to prevent devastating environmental damage from their development.
Cameron has spent three days in Alberta, touring oilsands projects and meeting with stakeholders, including government and aboriginal leaders, to better understand a system he once called Canada's "black eye."
After a meeting Wednesday morning with Premier Ed Stelmach, Cameron told reporters that the oilsands will yield great benefits for Alberta and Canada, but only if efforts are made to better understand where energy comes from, how it's extracted and the social and environmental costs of its production.
"(The oilsands) will be a curse if it's not managed properly, (but) it can also be a great gift to Canada and to Alberta if it is managed properly," Cameron said.
"Personally I believe that this is an incredible resource, and I certainly understand why everybody is stampeding toward it with this desire to exploit it as rapidly as possible, because it's the single largest reserve of potential crude oil next to Saudi Arabia.
"In an energy-starved future, that's going to…put Canada in a different position and help with energy independence in North America."
After arriving in the province Monday, Cameron toured a Syncrude facility, including a reclaimed mine that is now a wetland known as Bill's Lake.
He then travelled to the community of Fort Chipewyan, where he listened to the concerns of people living downstream from the oilsands, including fears over the safety of the drinking water and fish.
Cameron said he was presented with a study during his meeting with Stelmach that refuted the claims of environmental damage by the residents of Fort Chipewyan.
But the Oscar-winning director said residents told him they are afraid to swim in or fish the Athabasca River.
"I think we need to respect the First Nations communities for having their finger on the pulse of what's happening to mother nature," Cameron said. "And if they say the fish taste different and they're being affected and something's going on, I think it would behoove us to listen to that and find out for sure what these causal links are."
Cameron said because the oilsands development is still in its infancy -- only between 2 and 3 per cent of tar sands deposits are being mined -- the true environmental impacts are years away.
Therefore, Cameron said, greater regulatory controls must be placed on the industry, including caps on sulfur and carbon dioxide emissions, and a moratorium on tailings ponds, the dump sites for toxic waste from the oilsands. Cameron said the technology to mine via a so-called dry finds process, which does not require tailings ponds, is only about five years away.
"I think it's impossible to imagine a refining process and an extraction process on this scale that did not have negative environmental impacts. That would have to be some kind of Immaculate Conception," Cameron said. "So it's important for us to embrace the fact that there will be negative impacts, they need to be understood, and they need to be mitigated at the source to the extent possible."
During his own post-meeting press conference Wednesday, Stelmach would not comment on Cameron's suggestion to place a moratorium on tailings ponds.
But he said his meeting with Cameron was worth his time for the healthy discussion about the oilsands' economic and environmental impacts.
Federal Environment Minister Jim Prentice said the oilsands need to be developed for economic and national security reasons, but agreed that it must be done in an environmentally responsible way.
"Let's be clear about what our national objective is," Prentice told CTV's Power Play Wednesday evening. "We intend to produce the oilsands, but we have to do it in an environmentally responsible way. We have to be the most environmentally responsible producer of all forms of energy, and that includes the oilsands."
But Green Party Leader Elizabeth May said the federal government has to do more to develop the oilsands in an environmentally sound manner.
"What James Cameron has done has been to help a lot of Canadians take the tour with him, to see the massive scale, to see the devastation of the environment, to understand more of the science and to see where we really are right now on this planet in terms of our overall imperative to get off fossil fuels," May told Power Play in an interview from Victoria. "And using oilsands crude, tar sands crude in the meantime, but how do you do that responsibly?"
Cameron called for independent research, not funded by industry, into how land can best be reclaimed after the extraction process is over, and on the true environmental impacts of the oilsands industry. He also urged oil executives, government and aboriginal leaders to work together.
"The world is looking at what you here in Alberta do," Cameron said, "and the decisions that are made here are really going to shape the energy policy of the future."
User Tools
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I feel that if certain organs were in demand, less effort would be made to revive people. Am I being silly? Not really. I had a bad experience in hospital when my heart stopped, the doctors tried to revive me and failed. They stopped and said I was gone. I came around on my own when the nurse was giving a final BP reading of 'zero'. I heard her declare me dead! It was all I could do to shake my head but they never caught on til I was able to open my eyes. You should have seen them scramble then! I thought the nurse was going to faint. The thing is, I think we may write people off too soon when there is something of value to be gained from them.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Havelock Heavy
said
Dave-O
said
Dave in Surrey
said
TP
said
Maggy
said
JB in Ontario
said
MBA1995
said
LDL in ONT
said
Lz in Edmonton
said
David
said
Wayne
said
B. Kelley, Ontario
said
chris
said
steve in wildrose country
said
Charlie Cahill
said
JEFFDW
said
Carlos
said
DGRose
said
Sue
said
Bloke
said
Chris
said
CraigW
said
Jasper
said
Jenn
said
Loretta
said
Mike
said
Amy
said
Scott ON
said
b. emms
said
Ralph Eddy
said
Ron
said
GHW
said
Vickie
said
Pau West Coast
said
morvin
said
Donaldbain
said
Kate Jensen
said
steve in wildrose country
said
Amar
said
Irritable Canadian
said
Ken Durham
said
Adam
said
PG Pete
said
mtl
said
Who?
said
Captain Kirk
said
Scott
said
Prof Dis Gusted
said
Jay Spark
said
Frank Buchan
said
Jalal Karim
said
George V.
said
D. Jason Walters
said
Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said
Dylan
said
Dave Hills
said
PJ
said
pilgrimomega
said
CSK
said
Lorraine, Boyle,AB.
said
Dan
said
Kinikinik
said
Duncan Druhl
said
Marlyn
said
Joe
said
uber
said
Mark
said
raj
said