Canada -   

1
Correctional Investigator of Canada and Federal Ombudsman for Prisons, Howard Sapers, right, is joined by Dr. Ivan Zinger, Executive Director and General Counsel as they hold a news conference in Ottawa on Wednesday Sept. 8, 2010. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)  An undated family handout photo of Ashley Smith, who took her own life in a federal institution on October 19, 2007. The photo was taken before she was incarcerated. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Tom Hanson) Howard Sapers, the Correctional Investigator of Canada, speaks with CTV News Channel from Ottawa, on Friday, Sept. 11, 2009.

End long isolation of mentally ill inmates: watchdog

Viewer

CTV News Video

Canada AM: Kim Pate, Elizabeth Fry Societies
A representative of an organization that is devoted to prison reform reacts to a prison probe in to Canada's progress in preventing deaths in custody.
CTV News: Roger Smith on the prison review
Canada's prison watchdog is reviewing the response to death in federal institutes by correctional service employees. Howard Sapers, the Correctional Investigator of Canada is calling for 'better monitoring of prisoners and suicidal behaviour'.
Power Play: Panel of MPs on the review
Tory MP Rick Dykstra says the issues Howard Sapers pointed out are ones that need close attention. Liberal MP Ralph Goodale says the report that Sapers released is serious as major deficiencies and risks are occurring in the prison system.
Power Play: Howard Sapers on the report
The correctional investigator of Canada says the death of Ashley Smith in 2007 is now seen as a milestone since her death brought many changes. Although there is still frustration since the changes that were made have not lowered the amount of deaths in custody.
CTV News Channel: Ombudsman Howard Sapers
Correctional Investigator of Canada says it's troubling that where there are deaths in federal penitentiaries there seems to be recurring patterns of the same failures in emergency response and security patrols.
CTV News Channel: Howard Sapers in Ottawa
The Correctional Investigator of Canada discusses a report on a series of inmate deaths and says staff doesn't always know what to look for in potential victims and don't always have time to spot the signs.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (7) Facebook   

Correctional Investigator of Canada and Federal Ombudsman for Prisons, Howard Sapers, right, is joined by Dr. Ivan Zinger, Executive Director and General Counsel as they hold a news conference in Ottawa on Wednesday Sept. 8, 2010. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)  An undated family handout photo of Ashley Smith, who took her own life in a federal institution on October 19, 2007. The photo was taken before she was incarcerated. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Tom Hanson) Howard Sapers, the Correctional Investigator of Canada, speaks with CTV News Channel from Ottawa, on Friday, Sept. 11, 2009.

Photos

Correctional Investigator of Canada and Federal Ombudsman for Prisons, Howard Sapers, right, is joined by Dr. Ivan Zinger, Executive Director and General Counsel as they hold a news conference in Ottawa on Wednesday Sept. 8, 2010. (Sean Kilpatrick / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

View Larger Image

Date: Wed. Sep. 8 2010 8:29 PM ET

Ottawa's prison watchdog says the Correctional Service of Canada should ban the practice of isolating mentally ill inmates for long periods of time, to prevent them from putting their own lives at risk.

In a new report, Howard Sapers, the Correctional Investigator of Canada, says the CSC must use its experience from past deaths-in-custody to improve its practices and safety record moving forward.

After reviewing the cases of nine inmates who died over a two-year period ending in April 2010, Sapers found six common problems in the deaths:

  • Inappropriate or inadequate responses to medical emergencies
  • A lack of effective information sharing between frontline and clinical staff
  • A recurring pattern of deficiencies in monitoring suicide pre-indicators
  • Compliance issues related to the quality and frequency of security patrols and head-counts
  • Mentally-ill inmates are managed according to the security concerns they pose, not the health-care they need
  • The quality of internal reports and processes must be improved

At a news conference in Ottawa, Sapers said the CSC has made some strides in preventing deaths in custody, though "many of the same concerns continue to arise because there has been no movement on key accountability and governance issues."

This is particularly concerning after the tragic death of Ashley Smith, a teenage inmate who took her own life in a Kitchener, Ont., prison three years ago.

Since Smith's death there has been a push for changes in the way that prison staff handle mentally-ill inmates. And last December, Sapers asked the CSC to spell out what it is doing to help those inmates out.

Yet, "the frustration is is that those measures have not translated into a decrease in numbers of death in custody or in fact sustained progress on some very common-sense things like security measures," Sapers told CTV's Power Play Wednesday evening.

In his report, Sapers noted that there have been 130 deaths in custody since 2007.

Following his investigation, Sapers outlined specific corrective measures that the CSC should implement immediately.

On the management side, Sapers said the CSC must develop a better system for public accountability and monitoring staff performance in its prisons, as well as an improved process for internal investigations. He recommends that the CSC create a senior management position that promotes and monitors safe-custody practices.

In the prisons themselves, Sapers wants to end the practice of putting mentally ill inmates, or those at risk of suicide or serious self-injury, into prolonged segregation. Additionally, the federal ombudsman says inmates must have 24-hour access to health-care within the prison.

He also wants to improve the quality of security patrols within prisons, while ensuring that frontline staff have the training they need to supervise inmates at risk of self-injury.

Sapers told Power Play he knows the CSC is recruiting health-care workers, primary workers and correctional officers, among other staff, in the hopes of better meeting its mandate to house and care for prisoners.

Meanwhile, the CSC has a duty to respond to his concerns, he said.

"It is a fairness issue, but it's more than a fairness issue, it's also a legal issue. There is a duty of care," Sapers told Power Play.

"When an offender is sent to a federal penitentiary, the Correctional Service of Canada is 100 per cent responsible for their wellbeing. That's the law. So that includes meeting their safety needs, and if those safety needs include mental health or physical health care, they have to be met. It's also a human rights issue. There are minimum standards that are recognized internationally in terms of providing health care for people who are in places of custody."

Comments are now closed for this story

jackfromreddeer
said

So you would rather see these fragile individuals be put into a population that thrives on the hurt of others. We can watch as they get further harassed by the jail bullies, who know just what kind of buttons to push. And those that have to fend for themselves and go against the bullies, find themselves in a whole new world of hurt.


Earthwatcher
said

To simply put a mentally ill prisoner convicted of a crime into isolation "for his own safety" is barbaric. First off, if he is mentally ill, why would he be convicted of a criminal offense that would no doubt have been directly connected to his mental illness? Should not they be put into a secure mental health institution to not only "serve the time" but to have access to clinical assistance to deal with their mental illness. If it not curable (and it often is not even with medication) then the state should be prepared to put them up. For as long as it takes....Oh, wait. All of those facilities were closed about twenty years ago, too expensive. Let's just lock up the mentally ill like dangerous animals instead, put them in isolation while we're at it "for their own safety" Right. It isn't about their own safety it is about government not wanting to do the right thing, spend the money and take care of that small portion of our citizens. Citizens, just like you and I deserving of the chance for some dignity.


Cambob in Toronto
said

It's a no win situation. Do nothing and these folks end up hurting themselves or others. Taking preventative action violates thier human rights. The logical choice is to take preventative action, but who is brave enough to suffer the wrath when our society condemns them as heartless?


JB in Ontario
said

We have Canadians living on the street because of a lack of affordable housing, mental illness which is a barrier to getting employment, especially now with just getting over a recession. We need to have a better social safety net if we are to improve the lives of those people suffering from mental illness. Most probably feel very isolated to begin with due to lack of understanding and knowledge of mental illness by others.


JB in Ontario
said

1 in three people in Canada will suffer some kind of mental illness during their lifetime. Are we not a tolerant and caring country? We need to help people who suffer from depression, bipolar, schizophrenia and mood disorders etc. Otherwise we are not supporting a large portion of the population. Being isolated for long periods of time is not healthy, afterall, we are human and need interaction and rehabilitation from Healthcare workers to lead productive lives for those with less serious crimes. This also provides jobs. Locking people up in isolation for long periods of time is not helpful.


Brian Fr Langley
said

I find it staggeringly irritating that security concerns in a Canadian institution should override basic humanity. By definition the mentally ill are not responsible for their actions and while they pose a hazard to safety, steps can and should be taken. But to ease your work load by simply locking them in isolation cells is both despicable and unjust.


Pam
said

Does this mean that the mentally ill who are turned out to live on the streets need to commit a crime to get HELP!!! There has been this terrible idea in the political field that the mentally ill are capable of looking after themselves in the real world. Probaly the majority of homeless people have mental illness and other disablilities that are ignored by our self-centred poiiticians. Large institutions were closed and nothing replaced them, just live on the streets. Attitude of politicians: You will grow out of it. You will get better with time.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital.

Crash survivors eligible for health care coverage

More   33 Comments 33    13 Video(s) 13

Shown is a warning sign outside of the nuclear reactor at the Atomic Energy Canada Limited plant in Chalk River, Ontario, Wednesday, December 19 2007. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Fred Chartrand)

Feds looking to put AECL nuclear labs on the block

More