Canada -   

1
Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the B.C. Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election on Sept. 1, 2010.

Documents show B.C. negotiated HST pre-election

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV British Columbia: St. John Alexander reports
There are new calls for B.C. Finance Minister Colin Hansen to resign over the HST.
CTV British Columbia: Peter Grainger explains
As Hansen faces questions about HST, the premier is nowhere to be found.
CTV British Columbia: Leah Hendry reports
Internal documents cast doubts on whether HST is good for consumers.
CTV British Columbia: Jon Woodward reports
The B.C. Liberal government was discussing and studying the Harmonized Sales Tax five months before they actually told British Columbians about it.
CTV News Extended: Vander Zalm on docs
Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm talks to Colleen Christie about internal documents showing that the BC Liberals were mulling the HST long before last year's election.
CTV News Extended: Pollster on the impact
Angus Reid pollster Mario Canseco talks about how the implementation of the HST has affected the political fortunes of the BC Liberals.
CTV British Columbia: Correspondents report
A stack of internal documents appears to show the BC Liberals have been less than forthcoming about the planning behind the HST.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (8) Facebook   

Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the B.C. Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election on Sept. 1, 2010.

Photos

Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the B.C. Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election on Sept. 1, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Sep. 2 2010 10:33 AM ET

VANCOUVER — The man behind a petition to kill the harmonized sales tax in B.C. is calling for the resignations of Premier Gordon Campbell and Finance Minister Colin Hansen after the release of new documents about the tax.

Former Premier Bill Vander Zalm says the documents, released under a freedom of information request, show the government was talking to Ottawa about the HST months before the provincial election in 2009, despite denials from the provincial Liberals.

"This document shows the premier and finance minister not only did not tell the truth during the election, but they repeated that deception over and over again afterward," Vander Zalm said in a news release. "Now they've been caught red-handed, and they must resign."

However, Hansen said government bureaucrats were just doing their jobs examining the HST and were not taking any political direction from the Liberals.

"They were doing what they normally do, and that's to collect information about tax policy issues," he said. "And when Ontario made their decision to go the HST, they did their due diligence and gathered information."

Hansen confirmed Wednesday he briefly examined an HST briefing document in March 2009, but did not seriously consider adopting the tax until after the provincial election that May.

Vander Zalm also said a report included in the documents warned that the HST would have a negative impact on the B.C. economy but the Liberals told the public the HST was the best thing they could do for the economy.

"It turns out they were not telling the truth about that either, since they were fully aware of a C.D. Howe Institute study showing the exact opposite," he said.

Opposition New Democrat leader Carole James said she can't believe the government went ahead with the HST when it had information the tax could hurt the economy for years.

"When you're in a difficult economic time, when you're in a recession, when we haven't seen the tentative signs of recovery, a tax that's going to going to discourage consumer confidence, going to slow down our economy, slow down our growth -- why would you bring in that tax?" she said.

Comments are now closed for this story

Anphil, Ottawa
said

I think many commentors in this thread dont understand that this has nothing to do with Harper and the Conservatives. Maybe if you all took a lesson in constitutional law, you would understand that the federal goverment is REQUIRED, UNDER THE LAW, to offer the same programs and services (i.e., HST) to ALL Canadian provinces - they can't cherry pick. As for Campbell, its evident he wanted this and so he should go!


jjaycee
said

I fail to see just what the heck the problem is. Everyone knows we are in for an increase in Taxes. Better HST than an increase in Payroll taxes. We have to work. There are very few things HST taxable that were not GST-5% and PST-7% taxable. Has anyone actually looked up the list on the BC Government site? The Government could have just extended PST to Restaurant meals and books and magazines and various services. So then you would still pay the 12% and it would continue to be 2 separate calculations for businesses.


Steve
said

Please, don't tell me it isn't for a viable 3rd party . One that speaks for the people and takes responsibility for their actions. MPs and MPPs have to represent their constituents at all times and not follow in goose step to the party line. Until we get an overhaul of our political system , nothing will change. The deception will remain


Island Man
said

Campbell and Hansen should immediately resign and the lgislation should be recalled to deal with ths crisis. We can no longer believe one word uttered by this government. And let's get those documents without all the black ink. What were the options presented to the Minister and what did the department recommend as a course of action. The people deserve all the facts on the table. It may very well be we should have another election this fall.


Greg in Cambridge
said

No wonder the Conservative's polling numbers are down. Many believe that they are the reason for Provinces approving the hated hst tax grab and not just the liberals themselves.As much as I "dislike" liberals, I can't condone Federal Conservatives screwing Canadians this way while trying to just blame liberals.Shame on Ottawa! Get rid of the hated hst,now or wait for the next election to see who goes and who stays.


Wendy
said

I hate the government we have in BC & can't wait to see it gone. The BC liberals are made up of social credit, progressive conservative & reform alliance, they are in no way connected to the federal liberals. The BC liberals are has been conservatives, hiding behind the liberal name. This mornings poll shows Harper & Ignatieff tied at 29%. Next election we'll probably get a liberal majority, Canadians don't want Harper or Campbell. I noticed the highest increase in bankruptcies is in Alberta, maybe their starting to wake up to the fact Harper has destroyed our economy.


Tom in BC
said

Ok Hugh. We throw the liberals out and then what? In go the NDP? Oh wouldn't that be freaking wonderful. I'm still trying to recover how Glen Clark screwed over this province! I agree however the liberals have to go. Perhaps, if we must. the NDP are the lesser of the two evils at this juncture.....:-(


Hugh pei
said

Slimey Slimey Slimey and that go,s for the Feds too. For both to be negociating this and neither one to say this is the wrong way of doing things but what the heck ,its only the public we are screwing.Throw the Libs out of BC and the Cons out of Ottawa


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

RCMP looking for Sawyer Clarke Robison, 27, considered a person of interest in shootings of two of RCMP members.

Person of interest sought in Alberta RCMP shooting

More  3 Video(s) 3

Census data says the population of the Saskatoon metropolitan area was 260,600 in 2011, compared with 233,923 in 2006. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick)

Canadians heading west in droves, 2011 census shows

More   57 Comments 57    2 Video(s) 2