Canada -   

1
Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the BC Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election. Sept. 1, 2010. (CTV) British Columbia Premier Gordon Campbell, left, and Finance Minister Colin Hansen leave a in Victoria, B.C., on March 2, 2010. Columbia's finance minister is trying to put the brakes on demands his government push ahead on debate over the future of the harmonized sales tax. (CP/Darryl Dyck)

Calls for resignation after HST documents released

Viewer

CTV News Video

St. John Alexander on calls for Hansen to resign
There are new calls for B.C. Finance Minister Colin Hansen to resign over the HST.
Jon Woodward on pre-election HST talks
The B.C. Liberal government was discussing and studying the Harmonized Sales Tax five months before they actually told British Columbians about it.
Correspondents on Liberals' pre-election HST talks
A stack of internal documents appears to show the BC Liberals have been less than forthcoming about the planning behind the HST.
Peter Grainger on HST's damage to Liberals
The HST has led to a loss of trust in the BC Liberals.
CTV News Extended: Pollster on HST's political impact
Angus Reid pollster Mario Canseco talks about how the implementation of the HST has affected the political fortunes of the BC Liberals.
CTV News Extended: Vander Zalm on internal HST documents
Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm talks to Colleen Christie about internal documents showing that the BC Liberals were mulling the HST long before last year's election.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (27) Facebook   

Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the BC Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election. Sept. 1, 2010. (CTV) British Columbia Premier Gordon Campbell, left, and Finance Minister Colin Hansen leave a in Victoria, B.C., on March 2, 2010. Columbia's finance minister is trying to put the brakes on demands his government push ahead on debate over the future of the harmonized sales tax. (CP/Darryl Dyck)

Photos

Fight HST leader Bill Vander Zalm looks through internal government documents showing that the BC Liberals were mulling a harmonized sales tax long before the May 2009 election. Sept. 1, 2010. (CTV)

View Larger Image

Selected Comment

We must be living in a fairy tale with Campbell and Hansen's noses getting longer and longer.

Jennifer

Calls for resignation after HST documents released

talking about
Calls for resignation after HST documents released

Date: Thu. Sep. 2 2010 7:15 PM ET

Less than a day after internal documents revealed that the BC Liberal government was talking about introducing the HST five months before the 2009 election, there are calls for the resignation of Premier Gordon Campbell and Finance Minister Colin Hansen.

Briefing notes, emails and internal correspondence from B.C.'s Ministry of Finance released to media Wednesday showed that BC Liberal bureaucrats were conducting cost-benefit analyses and preparing lengthy briefing notes on the tax for Minister Colin Hansen.

The documents directly contradict statements by both Campbell and Hansen, who repeatedly said the tax "wasn't anywhere on the radar" before the election.

Former B.C. premier Bill Vander Zalm is calling the incident "the biggest lie in the history of the province."

"This document shows the premier and finance minister not only did not tell the truth during the election, but they repeated that deception over and over again afterward. Now they've been caught red-handed, and they must resign," he told CTV News.

Vander Zalm's sentiments were echoed Thursday when the president of a BC Liberal cabinet minister's riding association temporarily called for Colin Hansen's resignation, saying the documents have caused his reputation to be "completely shot."

"Under his ministry, the handling and implementation of the HST has been one blunder after another," Jordan Bateman, who is the president of Housing and Social Development Minister Rich Coleman's Fort Langley-Aldergrove riding association, said in a blog entry.

"The problem for me isn't even that the information went to Colin Hansen, in a memo before the election. It's that Hansen has repeatedly claimed it wasn't on the radar. It was on his desk, but not his radar?"

But Bateman quickly retracted his comments and issued an apology to Hansen, after speaking with the finance minister, whom he described as "gracious" during the telephone conversation.

"I want to apologize to the Minister for my earlier comments (in fact, I apologized to him directly on our phone call). They were spoken out of frustration after reading the volumes of media coverage over the past 24 hours," Bateman wrote.

"We spoke about the documents and I feel you should all know that Minister Hansen gave me his direct assurance that the HST was not being planned prior to the election."

Colin Hansen told CTV News that even though his top bureaucrats were discussing the HST and preparing documents and cost-benefit analyses as early as January 2009, he was not made aware of it.

"At no time did this government ask finance officials to proactively do this work," Hansen said.

"This info gathering, up until the end of May was at their initiative and was not something we asked them to undertake."

One of the documents is an 11-page briefing note given directly to Hansen which outlines the pros and cons of harmonizing the tax. The cover page reads: "There is a strong possibility that the British Columbia government will be asked in the next couple of weeks about its position of harmonization."

Vander Zalm says the "damning" documents, which includes a C.D. Howe report that suggests the tax would have a negative impact on the economy for at least five years, amounts to a great deception on the part of the provincial government.

"The [government] also told us the HST was the best thing they could do for the economy of B.C. It turns out they were not telling the truth about that either, since they were fully aware of a C.D. Howe Institute study showing the exact opposite," he said.

"This is the biggest lie in the history of the province. It's terrible."

Opposition New Democrat Leader Carole James said Wednesday she didn't understand why the Liberals would bring in a tax when it had information that it could damage an already struggling economy for another decade.

James calls the documents "just another betrayal of trust to the public" by the BC Liberals.

"From the start the premier, the finance minster, BC Liberal MLAs have been saying over and over to the public that the HST wasn't on their radar screen before the election. It's very clear from these documents that it was," James said.

"They were looking at options, they were exploring the HST."

Vander Zalm says the revelations will cause British Columbians to question their government leaders. He recommends that the premier calls the B.C. legislature back into session immediately and cancel the controversial tax.

"It's their only hope. Cancel the HST, admit they haven't been truthful with the people and then suffer the consequences."

Comments are now closed for this story

Will
said
0 0

While I certainly do not like the BC Liberals (or their federal, thieving counterparts), I think a little more reason is needed here rather than a knee jerk reaction.Just because the bureaucrats were looking into HST does NOT mean the politcians were. And it not something imposed by the federal government, it was the province that asked for it. By consitutional law, the federal government MUST grant the provincial request for harmonisation. As for the tax applying more widely, again the provinces fault. When it was brought in, my understandign was that the provincial sales tax exemptions would carry over; however they did not because the PROVINCE chose to end those exemptions. Before fetching the torches, pitchforks, and ropes; learn the facts. Then, come election time express how you feel ------just, for gods sake, not NDP again....we barely survived that debacle!


Leah
said
0 0

Any other person caught lying on their resume would be immediately fired. Any other person who stabbed hundreds of thousands of people in the back would be immediately in jail. Yet he's still there for why????


Ayirp
said
0 0

Gordon Campbell-- I would have thought you learned your lesson from your DUI. Do you believe that telling the truth is the 'best policy'?? Obviously not! You are engaging in some pretty destructive behaviour. First, you endanger the 'public' by drving under the influence and now you are blantantly deceptive. What message are you instilling/modelling to British Columbians? If you have a speck of dignity, humilty and intergrity for yourself and the people of British Columbia-- you should resign. The Olympics are over and you recieved the fame and attention craved, so resign!


John
said
0 0

So if Colin Hansen didn't ask for the HST studies to be done ...then who did ? and if the near mention of it was thought to be untimely, then why would someone think of doing the study? - Don't the Public Servants have anything else to do...? I think he better come up with a better line...The ship is sinking and he's gasping for air ...Do the respectable thing admit it and Quit .........


Darlene
said
0 0

My husband and I are not against taxation. If we lived in the US we would be buried alive in debt due to serious health issues. We are against lying to the electorate. Resign for lying, not once, not even twice, but over and over again. How can we believe anything these people say.


Maria
said
0 0

Carole, did you even read the article? They lied to everyone!


Roy
said
0 0

Gordon and Colin along with the rest of the party do not have to worry because what ever happens they will be heading to the bank every month with a big fat pension cheque


Ken in Vic
said
0 0

When the first MLA is recalled (fired by the people), a statue should be permanently erected at the door of the legislature in the image of that politician as a reminder for decades to come of what will happen to future MLAs if they lie, cheat, steal or fail to represent the will of their constituents. I wonder which Liberal wants the distinction of being the first recalled MLA in Canada? What a legacy!!


Jim In Vancouver
said
0 0

Someone once remarked, "That the truth will set you free". Recall or resign either way the electorate is mad as hell in BC and that is a fact. Bad management, bad policies and corruption and lies to boot!. Who could take over?, The NDP, yea I guess that Carole James will win. Too bad that we don't have a more centralist party. The bigger part of this entire debacle is whomever forms the next government, they have a lot of working to do in restoring leadership and honesty to our government.


sdgreen
said
0 0

There is no question in my mind that both Gordon Campbell and Colin Hansen must resign for lying and for putting the Province of BC in a economic harms way. Equally, the entire Liberal Cabinet needs to be removed for its failure in asking the right questions. Colin Hansen is a total failure, completely incompetent.Time for an immediate change in the governance of the Province. I think the Lieutenant Govenor needs to intervene and force this issue.The Liberals no longer have a mandate from the people, period.


Carole
said
0 0

I am more troubled by the fact citizens ignore the issues at election time, but scream very loudly during the term of the elected body. Someone has to pay taxes for the ever increasing "free" benefits the population demands. Were the names on the petitions, on the elector s list of the last election, and DID THEY VOTE? They do not speak for me.


MikeInBC
said
0 0

If the government is allowing the Bureaucrats to pursue whatever agenda they want it would indicate to me that the government is not in control....another reason the Liberals should resign.How many other agendas are the Bureaucrats pursuing without the government's direction and would this not indicate a waste of taxpayer money???


Dan D
said
0 0

So let me get this straight.Hanson is NOT responsible because he did not know what his staff was doing?Does Hanson not speak to his staff on a regular basis?Are we to believe staff does not report, even in brief, what they are doing on a daily/weekly basis to their elected superiors?Are we to understand that it is the staff/underlings that are running the province without the knowledge of elected officials?If our elected officials do NOT KNOW what their staff is doing, then why do they have that staff?For that matter, if our elected officials are not working with their staff, what exactly are they doing with their time?How do our elected officials know what file(s) to work on if they are not communicating with their staff?Have we not seen other elected officials (the federal CONservatives come to mind) use this same excuse for past wrong doings?After a communications breakdown occurs, isn't it the responsibility of our governments to learn from past mistakes and ensure it doesn't happen again?Seems to me that there have been enough uses of the excuse "Oh, I was unaware of what my underling was doing", for it NOT to be an excuse any longer.It's time to hold these elected official's feet to the fire and demand they answer these and other questions truthfully, fully and without hesitation.Anything less is deceptive, umm, no, fraudulent and they should be formerly charge as per the Canadian Criminal Code.


cherylb
said
0 0

Are you kidding me? Harcourt resigned when one of his MLAs was accused of hanky-panky in Bingogate! Campbell has stayed through being thrown in jail for drunk driving in a FOREIGN country, presiding over the only police raid of our Leg in history, the scandals of various MLAs over the past 9 years and now being caught red-handed lying about the intentions of the government and the HST. Both Huggie and Gordo need to resign NOW if there is any hope in saving the BC Liberal Party.


Chris Ryan
said
0 0

Colin Hansen, Gordon Campbell, Terry Lake, and all the other deceitful MLA's who have voted for, supported and tried to convince people that that this was anything other than a transfer of taxation from the corporate friends of the Liberals to the backs of the people of BC really need to apologize then resign from public office immediately.The Federal Government needs to explain precisely what costs that $1.6 Billion bribe they offered the BC Government to implement the HST was really all about. To me, it looks like they are trying to become the only body that controls taxation in Canada.


Chris Ryan
said
0 0

Colin Hansen, Gordon Campbell, Terry Lake, and all the other deceitful MLA's who have voted for, supported and tried to convince people that that this was anything other than a transfer of taxation from the corporate friends of the Liberals to the backs of the people of BC really need to apologize then resign from public office immediately.The Federal Government needs to explain precisely what costs that $1.6 Billion bribe they offered the BC Government to implement the HST was really all about. To me, it looks like they are trying to become the only body that controls taxation in Canada.


Frank
said
0 0

I hate to see that smiling face of Colin Hansen. I don't think it is funny to lie. It is disgusting.


Ethan
said
0 0

So this government is just letting the bureaucrats make all the policy decisions for them? Either way, they are incompetent, or liars, as their entire tenure has already shown. NO INTEGRITY!!! RESIGN!!!!!!!!!


MikeInBC
said
0 0

As a former BC Liberal supporter I demand that they both resign as should every Liberal in BC. If the Liberals want to form a government in the next election there are a number of things they have to do. Kicking these guys out of their positions and the party is first.


Brian Fr Langley
said
0 0

I guess if all's fair in love and war and The Zalm is clearly at war with the Libs this might make some sense. But for folks to actually believe the Libs planned this HST prior to the election based on the documents released is cod swallop. Who has ever heard of a beaurocrat not interested in exploring how to get their hands on your tax dollars. As for the Libs not knowing they may have had some awareness in an off hand way but that does NOT prove they were making plans before or during the election. My guess they totally blew their budget forecasts and rather than admit their "budget" was going to look like a "fudge it", the Premier knee jerked into the HST. Now thats believable.


A Out West
said
0 0

Please remind me... Did Vander Zalm tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth when he was in office? Do any politicians?They lie. It's how they get elected, and re-elected.Big deal. I'd still take a lying Liberal leader over any of the others. The lesser of the evils, per se. The tax is here. It would be a fiscal nightmare to scrap it. In a year or two, everyone will appreciate what it does for the social programs we all want and love.


Maira
said
0 0

I don't know how these two can think they can continue on running this province. Resign already!


Jennifer
said
0 0

We must be living in a fairy tale with Campbell and Hansen's noses getting longer and longer.


Besna Victoria BC
said
0 0

The only people that believe that the Liberals had no prior knowledge, before the election, about bringing in the HST are those that don't even know where British Columbia is in the world. Not for one second does any half educated person believes that the Liberals were not talking about the HST, BEFORE, the election. They have to go, end of story.


Patrck
said
0 0

The whole bc liberal cabinet should go a bunch of crooks. We still don't know the truth about the raid on the bc legislature nor do we know what happened with the sale of BC Rail. Remember the carbon tax everybody... That money was to support carbon mitigation instead where is that money going? Resign resign resign crooks crooks crooks


I Wonder
said
0 0

Now given this new information it is too bad there isn't a law to allow us to fire then without waiting for a RECALL. Misrepresentation and mishandling of public funds should be a criminal offense and they should be put in jail and not allowed to hold public office ever again!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


bob turcott
said
0 0

You watch,He's made some Ambasador deal for himself later,the slimeball !!!!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

In Depth

Harmonized Sales Tax in B.C.

Harmonized Sales Tax in B.C.

CTV News explains the opposition, the support, the politics, and how the HST impacts you.

Have Your Say

Should B.C. Finance Minister Colin Hansen resign?

Should B.C. Finance Minister Colin Hansen resign?

What do you think: Should Colin Hansen resign? Should Premier Gordon Campbell resign?

Today's Canada Stories

Air Canada planes land at Pierre Elliott Trudeau Airport

Air Canada reaches tentative deal with machinists

More

Rev. Raymond-Marie Lavoie walks outside for a lunch break at his trial in Quebec City, Monday, July 11, 2011 followed by his defence lawyer Serge Goulet. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Jacques Boissinot)

Quebec priest gets prison term for sexual abuse

More

Players compete in a game of Ultimate Taser Ball, in which players try to score goals, while avoiding tackles and Tasers.

Ultimate Tazer Ball set to shock Toronto

More

Most Talked about Stories

I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.

Shelley

W5: How far would you go to save your child?