Canada -
News Sections
Liberals unveil bill to reinstate long-form census
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Thu. Aug. 26 2010 10:15 PM ET
The Liberals introduced a new bill Thursday to bring back the mandatory long-form census, which the Conservative government intends to replace with a volunteer option.
Liberal finance critic John McCallum said the bill is an attempt to undo the damage that will be done if the Conservatives go through with their plan. The move comes after months of sparring with the Conservatives over the controversial decision.
"Liberals believe that sound information helps make sound decisions," McCallum said in a release.
"That's why we will fix the mess Stephen Harper created by reinstating the mandatory long-form census and ensuring the threat of jail time is removed in the Act."
The Conservatives have argued that the census is invasive to Canadians and that the threat of jail time for those who refuse to comply, is heavy handed.
McCallum said the Liberal legislation, which will be tabled on Sept. 20 when Parliament resumes, will remove the threat of prison time.
The Bill specifies that 20 per cent of Canadians will receive a mandatory long-form questionnaire at census time. While jail time will not be a factor, Canadians would be legally required to complete it.
McCallum dismissed the Conservatives' concerns about privacy, saying that argument is a smoke screen hiding the party's true goal: hamstringing government's ability to deliver progressive social programs.
He called the census vital to Canada's interests, saying: "As one business person put it recently, the first rule of business is 'you can't manage what you can't measure.'"
The Conservatives and Prime Minister Stephen Harper have faced months of opposition to the decision, which was widely panned by academics and organizations, including Munir Sheikh, the former head of Statistics Canada, which relies heavily on the data from the long-form census.
One of the main criticisms of the Tories' move is that data collected under a new, voluntary system will not be comparable to decades of data already collected in past decades, rendering it virtually obsolete.
McCallum said the move would also provide an inaccurate picture of Canada, because lower income, minority groups would be less likely to participate in a voluntary survey.
Dimitri Soudas, Prime Minister Stephen Harper's director of communications, quickly shot back, telling The Globe and Mail that the statement shows Liberals' tendency to "constantly look down on working class people."
He said it is wrong to assume that minorities and the poor need to be threatened with jail time in order to participate in the census.
"We believe that freedom is an essential Canadian value, and we don't think that it is right to try to frighten or intimidate people into surrendering huge amounts of private information to the government," Soudas said.
Recently the Conservatives said they would add language questions to the short-form version of the census, which were previously only included on the long-form census.
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Dan Laurin Windsor
said
Dan laurin Windsor
said
Dan Laurin Windsor
said
Captain Canada
said
Dan Laurin Windsor
said
Pat - Ottawa
said
Gerry
said
B. Kelley, Private in Ontario
said
P. Desmarais
said
Wendy
said
Naveed
said
Keith in Brampton
said
diolbat
said
kim
said
Wayne (Waterloo)
said
5th Generation Canadian
said
Myrna Ellis
said
Spence in Ontario
said
charlie
said
Luc from Carp
said
Norm in London
said
Tomko
said
LIBERALS LIE
said
Mark - Fort Erie
said
Mark
said
Steph
said
Richard in Ontario
said
Ryan
said
Yvon W. Madore
said
Can you just imagine how Mr.Harper's party would govern if he held a majority? A scary thought and not one that I would ever have previously considered in Canada.
thetruth1028
said
tony
said
DaveB
said
chris [london]
said
Nolan Moore
said
vancouver girl
said
Acroyear
said
Doug On
said
Chris [london]
said
Doug # BC
said
Damon
said
LP Markham
said
MARG MM
said
Will
said
Pedro
said
crittle
said
aysopn
said
Brian
said
Andrew
said
Paul Vancouver Island
said
Brenda
said
Ken - Calgary
said
mike
said
M.M.B. Ont
said
Frank Buchan
said
Paul
said
Chris
said
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Barb Bull Lake NB
said
lc
said
Tom (Calgary)
said
Redneck Albertan
said
bikerborz
said
Peter in MB
said
Alexandria
said
charlie
said
JS Toronto
said
The PM and the Conservatives have certainly done the right thing in making the census voluntary. Government can pay for information if it wants it that bad like any other focus group, polling company, or research firm.
David
said
Irritable Canadian
said