Canada -
News Sections
Some G20 charges dropped, others put over
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
ctvtoronto.ca
Date: Mon. Aug. 23 2010 9:23 PM ET
Some suspects accused of committing G20-related crimes had their charges dropped Monday in exchange for a charitable donation as several hundred people packed into a north Toronto courthouse.
"There's no admission of responsibility with this. It's simply a diversion," Crown attorney Vince Paris said outside the Finch Avenue West courthouse on Monday about the donation.
But protester Josh Berman asked: "If I'm not responsible, why do I have to pay anything?"
The Crown later said only a minority of accused individuals had their charges dropped. The majority will be back for return court dates in September and October.
More than 300 suspects made appearances in three different courtrooms over the day.
Monday's scene was chaotic at times as the suspects, their families, supporters, lawyers and various other protest groups and demonstrators descended on the courthouse. Busloads came from as far away as Quebec, with one person making her way to Toronto from Washington, D.C.
"I came all the way from Washington, D.C. just to have my case withdrawn because of course they don't have a case," Lacy MacAuldy said.
MacAuldy had been charged with assaulting a peace officer at a demonstration outside the Eastern Avenue detention facility during the G20 Summit.
"Today's hearing was completely ridiculous," said Dominic Palladini of the G20 arrestees' network, during a news conference outside the court. Speaking in French, Palladini said the hearing was a waste of time.
"We had to come from Montreal to Toronto for nothing, to learn the Crown wasn't ready to present evidence, to learn some people from the gymnasium are facing additional charges. That's totally ridiculous, and we'll be fighting that injustice."
Others had their charges dropped on Monday, including Robert Gamble, who had faced charges of disturbing the peace. He maintains all he did was yell "Arrest the war criminals. Investigate 9/11" while outside a friend's house in downtown Toronto.
Two news photographers also saw their charges withdrawn.
All of those appearing in court Monday have already been called before a judge in recent months to face their charges, and were told to return for the mass court date.
No trial proceedings were scheduled for Monday.
Instead, those charged will receive disclosure about the allegations against them and information about the next step in their legal proceedings.
Most of those appearing Monday were arrested at a protest at Queen's Park on June 26 when police stormed the area and rounded up dozens of suspects.
Some suspected ringleaders also appeared Monday. They are charged with conspiracy to assault and obstruct police. One, accused ringleader Kelly Rose Pflug-Back, said she wasn't talking to the news media at the moment.
Twenty-three others who were rounded up after police released photos and asked for help from the public, were also to appear Monday. They face a total of 62 charges. Two individuals were re-arrested, and the one accused is a young offender.
Robyn Maynard, of an anti-capitalist group from Montreal, voiced the sentiments of many who believe the police action was heavy-handed during the G20.
"The reason that people came out this day... is that people were moved to protect their communities and those that they care about and denounce a global economy that's based in the massive transfer of wealth and the stripping of resources from the poor to the rich," Maynard said Monday outside the court.
"Being in the streets is not something that's illegal and it's not something that's unethical, it's actually something that many people all over the world think is necessary."
The arrests began in earnest after a relatively small group of vandals using so-called Black Bloc tactics split off from a massive, peaceful, labour-sponsored rally on June 26. By the day's end, six police cars had been torched or otherwise damaged. A number of downtown businesses had their windows smashed.
After the violence broke out, police started cracking down on all demonstrators. More than 1,100 people were arrested, but most were released without being charged in 24 hours.
Civil liberties groups have called the police reaction excessive, particularly a "kettling" incident at Spadina Avenue and Queen Street West on June 27. Police have said they feared another Black Bloc incident was about to start as a group of about 200 walked down Queen Street West.
The Toronto Police Services Board has said it will conduct an independent civilian review of policing operations that day, although Ontario Premier Dalton McGuinty has said there will be no full public inquiry.
With a report from CTV Toronto's Tom Hayes and files from the Canadian Press
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
It is about time - as a grandparent I have watched our kids (who were allowed to fail although I do remember some nagging on our part) learn, I have watched our children now micro-manage their children. A big part of it is the fact that there are predators out there and an extreme reluctance on the parents part to alllow freedom that might result in the children becoming victims.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Highway Dawg
said
Bear witness to the rise of the Security Industrial Complex. A new spin on an old business.
Gregoryd
said
Elizabeth, Ontario
said
University Student
said
We have better things to do with our time, study, work, party, enjoy the summer, etcetera.
Why on earth would I want to spend my weekend (long weekend for our rivals at UofT) protesting when I can chill out at a cottage or work to pay for our expensive (but a worthwhile investment) tuition?
The small group of "students" or "young" people that caused problems are just that, a small group. Their (the violent protesters) beliefs and attitudes don't reflect the general student or young population.
Please don't look down on younger generations.
Thanks!
abrocks
said
Alfonse Brudrorge
said
CYL
said
Robert
said
Cat
said
Bob in DOWNTOWN Toronto
said
With that out of the way...why is it there were 1100 or so people arrested, 300 or so officially charged, and today at least 75 of them dropped? If anyone DOESN'T see a problem with this, you can stop commenting. If there's a murder in the neighbourhood, do you arrest everyone, and sort it out in court?
What if a couple is coming out of a restaurant, or leaving Nathan Philips Square after a concert (promoted by the mayor). What about those stopped and searched on the streets BEFORE any vandalism started (like me). Anyone who thinks that the police did no wrong, and that all those arrested were involved with the vandalism have been drinking the kool-aid. Remember at the beginning of the Robert Djekanski(sp) case, most were behind the police, now, not so much.
Fantasm
said
-------------------------
Try looking online at the videos of the people surrounded by the police. The police were laughing and telling them to leave ( a requirement before they can arrest them), but refusing to let them out of the perimeter. People are shouting at them "how can we leave if you won' let us?"
There's one particular video that shows a young girl of about 14, in the crowd, crying on her boyfriends shoulder in the rain, surrounded by 200lb plus riot cops in body armour.... She certainly doesn't look like a black clad Blac Blo member...
Victorian Kate (85 years strong)
said
Mike
said
Now all of you people that weren't there are gonna find out that the cops actually do go around arresting people at random. I would not have believed it either until it happened to me.
Richard in Ontario
said
I don't care if the G20 cost was a gazillion dollars, this still doesn't give the hooligans, thugs, jerks, cowards, that are disguised as protesters the right to destroy other people's property. I don't care what their cause is all about. Oh, they were so hard done by. Yah Right!!! For those others that were "peaceful protesters", some of these folks were arrested because they disobeyed orders from the Police. Too bad on them. Maybe at the next protest they will do as there asked.
Linda in Vancouver
said
Yea.Blame Harper.If he made a mistake it was in assuming that Canadians in Toronto were grown up enough to host an international event.Chretien made that same mistake on the west coast many years ago.His band just pepper srayed the crowd.What kind of an idiot PM places faith in the people?
If you were there,you had a right to protest.We all know that.But if you support the rowdies and the destruction of property you are on my hit list.If you failed to get out of the way when things got nasty,you gave the rowdies the cover they needed to do the damage.That makes you either a idiot,or an accomplice.It's wake up time Janie.
No one has a right to set fires on the street,or give cover to those who do.The people who did the damage must pay for the damage.Not law abiding citzens.
Helen Jean
said
What happened to law and order???
A Real Canadian Speaks.
said
dawn
said
i'm willing to bet most of the posters here are not what they seem; rather cops and gov't employees. i can't believe this many people believe the "authorities" about what happened at the G-20
Colin Hanshaw
said
mike
said
Down with Harper.
Down with the UN.
Before you reply ask yourself what HAS the UN done for Canada.
Colin
said
Craig
said
I wonder if the man who had his artificial leg stolen by police before his arrest was one of the ones who had his charges dropped, or if he was told to come back later.
Dean in Abby
said
Stu from London
said
Marc
said
Greg
said
Mark
said
Pip
said
Art
said
Janie
said
Paul ~ Kitchener
said
The only mistake the police made was not "Reading the Riot Act" and then going about the powers they have by law and stop this act of violence in its track.
Police brutallity ~ Hogwash ~ Civil Rights ignored ~ Hogwash.
These criminals have "No Rights" they give them up when they broke the law.
Isn't it also so tragic, that out of the woowork comes all these "Candy Ass Lawyers", to what, defend their lawlessness, (money drives these leeches).
Let Justice ring from the court, and to the guilty "JAIL + A CRIMINAL RECORD" !!!!!
Anne
said
Richard in Ontartop
said
And Mr Dominic Palladini from Montreal, says "Today's hearing was completely ridiculous and the hearing was a waste of time" My suggestion to this person is, it would be better if he told his group to stay in Quebec instead of trashing Ontario and deal with the justice system there. I will defend proests anytime, but when it involves hooligans, thugs and yes, cowards, then I just hope the Ontario justice system throws the book at them. If it takws months to do this then who cares?
Paul
said
Rodney
said
Gord
said
Any mambly pambly bleeding heart defence of all their confusion started with their potty training and is all their parents fault should also be discounted. Shove accounability for their destructive actions down their collective throats and make 'em pay bigtime.
Mark
said
As for intentionally misleading people, where is the hue and cry for McGuinty's government to come clean on their 'illegal' or quasi-illegal abuse of the justice system by implementing the 'law' prohibiting gathering within 15 metres of the fence? McGuinty's government continues in its lie and deceive policies-now tried and true and years long.
Don't just blame it on the Toronto Police. This fish...stinks from the head.
Rick in NB, Ste Marie
said
Robert Drew
said
that they will suffer consequences for their actions. However, there was misinformation given about the
unusual "police powers" and innocent
people were charged. Rubber bullets
etc. were used and the police over-
reacted in some cases. The public was intentionally mislead by some politicians and Toronto Chief of
Police. Apologies came late.
Will
said
Gord. Robson, Nova Scotia
said
police cars and destroying/damaging businesses should not and will not be tolerated.
We the tax payers are footing the bill and we want to see these criminals held responsible and face jail time. We have had enough, this type of "protest" has to stop...NOW !
Arnie Williamson
said
Now that individuals are being held one at a time to account for their actions, I wonder if we'll see a whole bunch of suddenly very remorseful people.
I suppose when the criminal part of the process is concluded the banks businesses and insurance companies will begin the civil process fo monetary restitution from those convicted.
Prof. Pye Chartt
said
Alex (Toronto)
said
Mark
said
No doubt we'll hear all sorts of namby-pamby excuses but the sum total of this is that a civilized society has laws in place for the mutual protection of the people and it's government. You want to protest? Go to Queen's Park, write a petition and vote your conscience.
This "radical" and "anarachist" crap is exactly that-crap. Throw the book at that bunch.
manner
said