Canada -   

1
Local activists and farmers attempted to disrupt cattle trucks removing animals from the farm in Kingston, Ont. on Sunday, Aug. 8, 2010. Caroline Yull, left, and Carol Tapp wave to honking cars outside the Correctional Service Canada regional headquarters in Kingston, Ont. on Friday July 23, 2010. (Lars Hagberg / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A protester is arrested outside the Frontenac Institution, a correctional facility in Kingston, Ont. on Sunday, Aug. 8, 2010.

Prison farm supporters losing hope after arrests

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Craig Oliver on the protest
At least 14 people are facing charges of mischief after a confrontation with police in Kingston, Ont., during a protest against Ottawa's decision to close down prison farms to save money.
CTV News Channel: Dianne Dowling, dairy farmer
A dairy farmer who represents Save Our Prison Farms explains why about 150 demonstrators and close to 100 police officers stood outside a federal prison in Kingston, Ont., aimed at preventing the closure of a prison farm.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (11) Facebook   

Local activists and farmers attempted to disrupt cattle trucks removing animals from the farm in Kingston, Ont. on Sunday, Aug. 8, 2010. Caroline Yull, left, and Carol Tapp wave to honking cars outside the Correctional Service Canada regional headquarters in Kingston, Ont. on Friday July 23, 2010. (Lars Hagberg / THE CANADIAN PRESS) A protester is arrested outside the Frontenac Institution, a correctional facility in Kingston, Ont. on Sunday, Aug. 8, 2010.

Photos

Local activists and farmers attempted to disrupt cattle trucks removing animals from the farm in Kingston, Ont. on Sunday, Aug. 8, 2010.

View Larger Image

Date: Mon. Aug. 9 2010 8:49 PM ET

Protesters aiming to save prison farms say they're losing hope after about 15 people were arrested Monday morning during a demonstration at a federal lockup in Kingston, Ont.

"I don't think there's any chance to reverse (the shutdown of prison farms)," Dianne Dowling of Save Our Prison Farms told CTV Ottawa in a phone interview after the protest.

She said much of the livestock from previous closures has already been auctioned off, and the animals taken Monday -- about 8,000 chickens and 300 cows -- are scheduled to be sold at an auction in Waterloo, Ont., on Tuesday.

About 100 people gathered at Frontenac Institution to block seven trucks filled with cattle from leaving the property, one of six prison farms set to close down across the country. Fifteen demonstrators were taken into custody, including group organizer Andrew McCann, when they tried to block the first truck from leaving around 7 a.m.

They have been charged with mischief and were to be released on their own recognizance, said Kingston Police Const. Michael Menor.

By noon, the crowd had dwindled as many headed to the police station and courthouse in a show of support for those arrested on Monday and during a similar protest on Sunday, Dowling told CTV News Channel.

Eight protesters were arrested Sunday during a blockade that kept four trucks from reaching the farm to load up cattle. They were also charged with mischief and four were released. Others were to face bail hearings on Monday.

About 100 police officers were on site for Monday's protest, Dowling said.

Dowling, a dairy farmer, says she originally opposed the closure because it threatens farmland, already at risk from urban sprawl.

"It's completely surrounded by industrial, residential and commercial property at the moment, and I'm sure developers are drooling at the thought of getting some of it," she said.

But in researching the issue, she learned a lot about the prison farms' benefits for inmates, Dowling said.

"I've seen how valuable this program is in rehabilitating and training inmates, and when they're rehabilitated and trained, they don't re-offend," she said.

Public Safety Minister Vic Toews said Monday fewer than one per cent of inmates who work on the farms continue with farming work when they are released from custody.

"My responsibility as public safety minister is to ensure that individuals who are in our facilities receive training that is appropriate, receive skills that are appropriate to the environment they will be returning too," Toews said.

"It's not a productive use of the convicts that are incarcerated for a period of time ... Our responsibility is to provide appropriate training and jobs skills so that they can be reintegrated in a wholesome fashion in society at large."

Supporters also pointed out that eggs produced at the institution were distributed to 18 prisons in Ontario and Quebec. Thousands of eggs were also given to the Kingston food bank every week.

In 2009, the federal government announced its plan to eliminate the farms by March 2011, and has stood firm on the decision despite calls for an independent impact study from the House public safety committee.

An appeal to the federal court argued Correctional Service of Canada did not consult inmates before cutting the program. It was defeated.

Government figures indicate the farms produced revenues of about $7.5 million against $11.6 million in expenses, resulting in a $4.1 million loss.

With files from The Canadian Press and CTV Ottawa's Joanne Schnurr

Comments are now closed for this story

jjrsuperstar
said

"Government figures indicate the farms produced revenues of about $7.5 million against $11.6 million in expenses, resulting in a $4.1 million loss" - rather than what - $11.6 milion in losses.


Matt
said

Yeah. Farming skills are really going to help the 95% of prisoners who return to cities after their release. Why aren't they taught usefull things like trades: plumbing, carpentry, welding, ect. Skills that will actually help them get a job after release.


Brian in calgary
said

If the prisoners want to have a prison farm program, I suggest 5 man chain gangs. They could pick bales, pick rocks, even pick garbage on the ditch side of the fence lines.You could have them brought out to farms to work. have the chains long enough for some to milk the cows while others pick eggs. They could learn their skills at the same time saving the tax payer 4 million or so a yr, and give a farmer cheap labour. Yes get rid of the farms and bring back the chain gangs. A good hard days work in the fields instead of sitting in your cells.


Don in Fredericton
said

Prison farms could be run as a profit making business (some farmers do) and teach inmates skills that could help them secure employment once they have completed their sentence. Too bad the government doesn't see it that way.


Meredith
said

I wonder if prison farms are the best way to rehabilitate and train inmates anyway - There are fewer and fewer smaller farms (a tragedy for sure), and the work on a small farm differs from a large farm, so would the skills learned by inmates actually be used upon release? Should we be spending tax dollars on teaching skills in which the inmates will actually find work (unemployed ex-cons reoffend much more). I am genuinely curious, these have been my initial questions on this issue - maybe I am wrong and am happy to be educated on the matter!


Russ
said

Farm aid is good aid, for everybody, We give and give and give to those in need and so are these farmers, the only reason they don't get any is they live here. Time to give something back to them


oddie
said

now what in the world is wrong with a prison farm--can the prisoners not do any work for their keep --maybe more gym rooms and plasma tv's in their rooms more tax payers money ---they are criminals quit babying them now they are getting wheel chairs canada Pension --more they get more they want


James
said

I love the "Tough on Crime" garbage this government tries to shove down our throats. They want to warehouse people without any hope of improving their perspective, gauranteeing that its a self-perpetuating cycle. They want to ensure that it none of the prisons are self-sufficent, thereby draining the government's financial resources, precluding those tax dollars from doing anything truly useful. The sad thing is that 1 in 3 Canadians are buying it.


bill in ottawa
said

Crime isn't perpetrated by evil people who have succomed to the Devil. The woman in the article has it right when she says "I've seen how valuable this program is in rehabilitating and training inmates, and when they're rehabilitated and trained, they don't re-offend". Unfortunately this enlightened attitude is lost in a society that would rather create desperation and the circumstances that lead to it, than reduce it.


Miro Kwasnica, B. Ed.
said

I find it disgusting that 9 people arrested at a demonstration against the shutdown of prison farms in our country. Why not keep them operating to give inmates a chance to learn a wholesome work ethic and basic life skills? So sad to see another blow to prison inmates perpetrated by our P.M. and our justice system. Another of the many examples of the lack of understanding and petty narrow principles continually being forced upon Canadians by Conservative dogma.


Kestral
said

i wonder how long it will be before this food producing land will be paved for yet another wal-mart, urban sprawl subdivision, or industrial place to park a truck.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Prime Minister Stephen Harper delivers his speech in Guangzhou, China, Friday, Feb. 10, 2012. (AP / Kin Cheung)

Harper mixes oil and human rights in China speech

More   3 Comments 3    6 Video(s) 6

Most Talked about Stories

I think he was pushed to take matters into his own hands. I have a teenage son and if he was involved with a drug dealer I would be furious and try anything to save him like this father did for his daughter. Why do police often say they can't do anything until it's too late? Whether it be a drug dealer or an abusive spouse, the police can't seem to do anything until something really bad happens. In this case they could have raided the drug dealers home and arrested him. The whole town knew what was going on in that house but yet the police chose to do nothing. Release this man and give him a medal for doing the right thing by his daughter. I can't wait to see the episode on W5, I will certainly be watching this one.

Shelley

W5: How far would you go to save your child?