Canada -   

1
In this Dec. 10, 2007 photo, convicted newspaper baron Conrad Black leaves the federal building in Chicago. (AP / Jerry Lai)

U.S. Supreme Court gives Conrad Black partial victory

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV National News: Joy Malbon reports
Conrad Black received a partial break from the U.S. Supreme Court Thursday after it set aside part of his conviction. However, the media baron likely won't get out of his Florida prison cell any time soon.
CTV News Channel: Steven Skurka, legal analyst
CTV's legal analyst explains the implications of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling and says the ruling does not surprise him, while also explaining what Black's lawyers might argue in his appeal.
CTV News Channel: Jacob Frenkel, former prosecutor
A former U.S. prosecutor explains why he doesn't think Conrad Black will be released from prison, even though the U.S. Supreme Court gave the media baron a partial victory on Thursday.

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (23) Facebook   

In this Dec. 10, 2007 photo, convicted newspaper baron Conrad Black leaves the federal building in Chicago. (AP / Jerry Lai)

Photos

In this Dec. 10, 2007 photo, convicted newspaper baron Conrad Black leaves the federal building in Chicago. (AP / Jerry Lai)

View Larger Image

Date: Thu. Jun. 24 2010 6:41 PM ET

Conrad Black won a partial victory Thursday after the U.S. Supreme Court set aside three corporate fraud convictions against the former media baron.

The court has left the ultimate resolution of Black's case to a lower appeals court -- meaning Black has not been exonerated in the case.

In a related ruling, the court ruled that former Enron CEO Jeffrey Skilling could not be convicted of so-called honest services fraud.

According to justices the law which covers fraud schemes to "deprive another of the intangible right to honest services" -- could be applied constitutionally only to cases involving bribery or kickbacks.

"Because Skilling's misconduct entailed no bribe or kickback," Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg said in the ruling, "he did not conspire to commit honest-services fraud under our confined construction" of the law.

The government argues that even with the ruling the charges against Black and Skilling should be sustained.

Lawyers for both men argue that their convictions should be thrown out.

CTV legal analyst Steven Skurka said it seems inevitable that the appeals court should set "honest-services" fraud convictions aside.

"There were no bribes, and there were no kickbacks alleged by the government in the Conrad Black case," he told CTV News Channel.

Black is serving a 6.5-year prison sentence in Florida on mail fraud and obstruction of justice convictions.

Comments are now closed for this story

peter in BC
said

Another great example of a legal system gone into the toilet. It used to be that if you were convicted, you had an appeal. If the appeal was turned down or you lost, well, you served your sentence. Nevermind the $$$$ associated with the never-ending appeals, but at what point do you stop and just tell the guy, "you are found guilty and the conviction stands."?Do you think the same number of appeals would be offered up to some petty thug who stole from innocent citizens over the course of a decade? Do you think he could argue the absolution of a few words in the law? No. Guilty is guilty and if you don't want to be in prison, don't break the law. Most of us can do it, why couldn't he???


Daryl
said

Prosocutors need to be reined in when they resort to laws that could convict any individual just to put another notch on their ... well you know what I mean.


Rosalie
said

Mr. Black thinks he is the next step down from God Himself. And does he ever have any other expression on his face except one of smugness and self-importance? They'd better not restore his Canadian citizenship. If you swear an oath (like I did when I renounced my American citizenship), you cannot get it back, you swore you didn't want it; may he never get what he wants in that regard, Canadian citizenship to him was "an impediment" in his quest for further greatness in the British House of Lords.

Mark in TO
said

This man has fallen and risen so many times in his life, but he was written off to a final downfall upon his conviction. I guess there's only one headline suited to his possible successful legal victory, 'Always bet on black'.


Mike in Ottawa
said

Don't feel sorry for ole Conny Black. He's got millions likely stashed away that Babs is living off of in Florida and he'll be a rich man when he gets out. No to him getting his Canadian citizenship back. He gave it up on his own.....


Amber M
said

At least some people know wha they are talking about. Apparently, James T Murphy hasn't got a clue. Black is a crook through and through and deserves all he's getting and more. I am certain he will be let out before he has completed his sentence, but I relish each day he spends behind bars.


Jack Chit says Book'em Dano
said

I say we give Black back his Citizenship, so we can put him in jail here, for forgetting our Canadian Values of Honour, Honesty, Trust, Truth, Ethics, Integrity, and Doing the RIght Thing.It's time that all of our business leaders learned that you have to be good, to be Canadian. Until then, we don't owe these guys Jack Chit.


Sam
said

Uhm, James, fact check time: Chretien didn't strip anyone of citizenship. Prime Minister's don't have that power. Conrad Black renounced his citizenship because he was more interested in being a British Lord than a Canadian. Please get your facts right.


Willi
said

Looks like MONEY will still try to buy entry to Canada.....Hope Mr. Black stays a CONVICTED FELON, and is DENIED entry to our great country!!!!!!!!!!Did not realize that the US Supreme Court could be bought.....


Pat from GTA
said

I am reminded of something I once heard:"The slimier the snake, the slipperier it is"


JFJ
said

Superb! Congratulations me Lord!


Tom
said

Chretien did strip Black of his citizenship - as was made clear when he said he would not allow Black to get the Lordship in England...Chretien should be in jail instead of Black


Chris
said

Pity. Had he been prosecuted for being pompous, smug, arrogant, self-involved and having a lovely daughter, he'd surely be serving 30 years...


Dean in Abby
said

@James T Murphy, He willingly gave up his Canadian citizenship to become a British Lord. Canada should not be involved with this criminal at all. Let him rot in prison or let Britain help him. I am quite sure he doesn't give a rip about anyone but himself and certainly, given his behaviour in the past, wouldn't lift a finger to help anyone else. Leave him in jail to do his time, then send him off to Britain. Canada doesn't need to accept criminals into our country.


jackfromreddeer
said

C'mon already.... How many times do people get to appeal their sentence? This is why the courts are so tied up. That's like asking mommy for a treat... being told no... so you run to daddy in another room... then to grandma.... grandpa... etc! Eventually you will get what you want.


Mil in Ottawa
said

Mr. Chretien did not strip Mr. Black on his Canadian Citizenship. Mr. Black renounced his Canadian Citizenship so he could take a seat in the British House of Lords.


BCDarr
said

FINALLY! It's about time rich people got a break.


CK
said

His citizenship was not stripped, Black renounced his citizenship himself to become a lord in the UK - the Nicol Resolution, which was uphelp bt Canadian courts, does not permit any Canadian to accept a peerage. Black made his case, the law was upheld, and he choose to become a Lord over being a Canadian.


colwiz
said

Your history is off. Black gave up his citzenship to become a lord in England. He then wanted it back. This had nothing to do with Chretien. Everything is not about politics."Excellent! Now Harper needs to restore his Canadian citizenship that was stripped by Chretien."


Craig from AB
said

The Beatles sang that "Money Can't Buy You Love". Considering the case of our poor friend Rahim, and now our beleaguered ex-pat Conrad, money, influence and power can certainly skew, and hence buy justice.


Donaldbain
said

Gee, what a surprise. The Supreme Court letting a robber baron off the hook but referring it to a lower court so they don't have to do the actual dirty work. "White collar crime" is what separates CB from real prison time, another 2 tier system in action! Somehow, as an executive, crimes are more excusable, as if the behavior is almost acceptable for one of your "status". I understand a criminal record is a requirement for long term survival in the House of Lords.


Get Real
said

I don't really care about those rich useless people!!! Show other news!!!


James T Murphy
said

Excellent! Now Harper needs to restore his Canadian citizenship that was stripped by Chretien.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Edgar Sulla-Puma, 26, is seen in this undated image. Sulla-Puma was injured in the crash and remains in hospital.

Crash survivors eligible for health care coverage

More   25 Comments 25    12 Video(s) 12

The Manulife Financial offices are seen on Water Street in Kitchener, Ont. on Friday, June 17, 2011.

Manulife Financial books $69M loss in 4th quarter

More