Canada -   

1

NWT, Nunavut in dog house for lax animal rights laws

The B.C. SPCA says it is recommending charges against the owner of a golden retriever that was found starving by the side of the road in Maple Ridge. March 9, 2010. (SPCA)
The B.C. SPCA says it is recommending charges against the owner of a golden retriever that was found starving by the side of the road in Maple Ridge. March 9, 2010. (SPCA)

View Larger Image

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (24) Facebook   

Date: Thursday Jun. 10, 2010 10:20 AM ET

The Northwest Territories and Nunavut have the worst animal protection laws in Canada, a California-based animal-rights group says in a new report card.

The Animal Legal Defense Fund's says the two territories are the "best places" to be if you're an animal abuser, because convictions for animal abuse there carry minimal fines, and the territories have weak laws when it comes to seizing abused animals.

Animals in Alberta and Quebec also have rotten legal protection, the group alleges in its report card.

Animals in Ontario, meanwhile, enjoy the best protection in Canada, the ALDF says, which ranked the province in the top spot. It applauded, in particular, Ontario's mandatory restrictions on future ownership of animals for those convicted of animal cruelty.

Here's the full ranking list:

Top Tier:

  • 1. Ontario
  • 2. Nova Scotia
  • 3. Manitoba
  • 4. New Brunswick

Middle Tier:

  • 5. Yukon
  • 6. British Columbia
  • 7. Saskatchewan
  • 8. Prince Edward Island
  • 9. Newfoundland and Labrador

Bottom Tier:

  • 10. Alberta
  • 11. Quebec
  • 12. Northwest Territories, Nunavut (tie)

To create the reports card, the ALDF says it conducted a detailed comparative analysis of the animal protection laws of each province and territory, ranking them on the relative strength and general comprehensiveness of their animal protection laws.

The group says New Brunswick showed the most significant improvement overall, moving from the bottom tier last year to fourth best in the country this year.

New Brunswick moved up after enacting some of Canada's stiffest penalties for cruelty offences.

Abusers there now face fines of up to $100,000 and imprisonment for up to 18 months. By comparison, animal abusers in Alberta – which the ALDF ranked in the bottom tier -- can be fined only up to $20,000, and abusers can't be incarcerated under provincial law.

Nova Scotia overtook Manitoba as the second best province due to a host of new laws including better standards of care for animals, stronger penalties and requiring veterinarians to report suspected offences.

Stephan Otto, ALDF director of legislative affairs and report author, said Alberta ranked sixth in 2008, ninth last year, and now 10th, because the province is simply not keeping up with other provinces in strengthening its laws.

He called for all provinces to update their animal protection laws and enforcement abilities.

"We continue to see significant disparity across the provinces and territories," Otto said in a news release.

"Animals do not vote, but those who love and care about them do. It is our hope that these ongoing reviews continue to garner support for both the strengthening and enforcement of animal protection laws throughout Canada."

ALDF was founded in 1979 with the unique mission of protecting the lives of animals through the legal system.

Comments are now closed for this story

bc grrl
said

i agree with matt...i love my animals and i will care for them but they are animals and they do come with a pricetag...$107 to start from the bcspca (spayed female) plus upkeep for at least 10 years! it is people who ruin animals, indulging your pet with too many treats is abuse, those people with fat pets should be charged as well as those with starving animals. to give animals a whole set of rights is sick considering that for every new animals right, there is one less human right! i own house pets and lives stock, i protect my animals. if my neighbour's dog goes after my chickens i will 'abuse' that animals alright...why is their mongrel poo eating dog who is never on leash or in a fenced yard or allowed in their house be more important than my chickens in their 8 foot high elk fenced and concreted pillared area that provide food for my family? someone needs to rethink this whole animals rights thingy???


John In Edmonton
said

" Animal Protection Laws" are a must. Those who mistreat animals for their own thrill should always be punished. Those who abuse animals because they are mentally ill should be helped. Those that do not know how to care for any animals should be taught. Those are the right things to do. However, animals do not have rights, they are in fact, and in many cases, food.


Dan
said

Your discussion/article is flawed in one major way....animal rights is not the same as animal welfare or animal protection. Do I think animal welfare/protection laws should be put in place and strengthened in Canada, YES, do I think animal rights laws should be put in place in Canada, NO. Please understand the difference before writing these articles and commenting on such issues.


ian
said

Apparently there are several States in the US that have pitiful animal protection laws so these guys should clean up their own back yard first.


Suezie
said

Dear Bill - working or not makes no difference in whether it deserves to be treated humanely or not.And in fact - there is not one dog in the community that I lived in, to my knowledge, that was used for work... and calling them pets would be a far cry as well.If nothing else - unleash and uncollar the dog so at least it has a chance (instead of leaving chained with no choice but to starve/freeze etc).Containing an animal should be a privilege with policy and not a right.


SK Weim Nut
said

Anyone who's travelled in the north knows the abuse that is inflicted on domestic animals there - it's inexcusable...


kimmie
said

The Golden Retriever is not only doing wonderful in his new home, but criminal charges were laid by the bc spca and accepted by crown counsel!


Kevin
said

People, wise up - the picture is an old one of a dog that was rescued and is back to normal, the owner was charged and fined. The story is not about that dog, it is about the NWT having poor regulations against cruelty to animals. The picture is only being used to get your attention, but it is an old case.


ErinL
said

@Reality-Don.... Photoshop'd? Seriously. Do you have a heart? Didn't think so.Animals can't fend for themselves. It breaks my heart seeing pictures like that. That person should abolutely be charged. I personally think we need stricted laws regarding animal cruelty.


Bill in BC
said

Before people start freaking out, remember that animals are NOT humans and most are working animals NOT pets. step back, take a breath and think!


lucie
said

Where is the golden retriever at this point? Has he been saved.... Is he being cared for?


Stu from London
said

Sorry, I'll always be more sad to see animals dying and being mistreated than hearing about human deaths. Deal with it. Humans can only blame themselves and each other, animals can only blame humans.


Mac
said

Man's inhumanity - period anyone who abuses anyone or animals MUST be made to pay for their actions -For the bureaucracy - and council(s) - there is NO excuse or justification to delay bringing in STRICT punishable rules for ANY abuse - Abuse means failing to provide basic care and treatment of any animal - domestic - farm - wild or other .... period If you and I dont speak up - who will ??


Suezie
said

The NWT government is stalling on pushing forward new laws for too long. The suffering up North is incredible. Dogs are starving at the end of short chains, freezing to death in the winter, collars ingrown around their necks, no water, no shelter, injured with no care. I lived up North for 1 year, and it would appall you to know how bad it really is, and what the volume of cases like this really are. Please send a letter, make a phone call.. anything. We need to put the pressure on government. Mr. Robert McLeod, Minister, Municipal and Community Affairs (867) 669-2366 Mr Jackson Lafferty, Minister of Justice (867) 669-2399 Government of the Northwest Territories Legilsative Assembly Building Yellowknife, NT X1A 2L9


Pitti Lover
said

What kind of sick depraved individual would do that kind of horrendous thing to any animal? The mere act of simply slapping a financial fine on someone who can't be bothered to foot the bill to feed their animals is just useless. Come on now, let's get some punishment to fit the crime. Once again, I call upon the media to start publishing pictures of these people front and center for all to see.


elena
said

jim McB: wow, you've completely missed the point of this article. public outrage about animal cruelty and abuse is a sensitive topic so please leave your conspiracy theory out of this discussion. YES, WE CARE about what animal rights activists think because usually they are dead on. Lax laws are lax laws and it hardly makes a difference what organization points out the flaws of our legal system. While i do not disagree with you on the point you made about PETA being extreme in its methods of "getting the point across" i also think that if they dont say it like it is NO ONE will. the bottom line is that animals all over the world need protection and countless innocent lives are lost every day because people do not think they are important. Who gave humans the right to feel superior over any other being on this planet? I think it is the responsibility of humankind to protect the silent victims.


Matt
said

At the risk of sounding heartless I just want to say that I truly believe people like chris (sask) are off their rocker. Now I have two cats, and I like to think they’re well taken care of and, my girlfriend and I like to have them around and we keep them full and happy, however, if one ever got sick and the price tag came out to “everything I own” I’m sorry but its goodbye kitty time, I guess I’m keeping the house and the car over a cat. I’ve got nothing against animals, but it has always urked me when people have more respect for their pets than towards other human beings.


Reality-Don
said

Wow…. Fascinating Posts so far. We humans ‘butcher’ each other like Hogs and you all go tsk, tsk, and move on. But some ‘Fruit Loop’ special interest group puts a ‘PhotoShop’d’ picture on a story and you all are ready to bring back the lash and death penalty. Lets get it in perspective people.


Ben, Edmonton
said

I'm all for animal rights but I could care less about what a group of americans says, especially given what they just did to the gulf of mexico.


Jim McB
said

Do we really care about what a group of special interest Americans think about our laws?These guy are as crazy as PETA but see the value in earning money via legal battles. US lawyers will do anything to get work!


Tracy
said

Agree completely with the 2 comments above... the 'owner/abuser' of this animal should absolutely be charged and his/her name printed in the news... this poor dog has suffered so much already....these provinces and territories need to upgrade their protection laws for animals... what a gorgeous animal this was and still can be... whipping and starving the owner is what I would personally like to do!


chris (sask)
said

first of all about time Ont. did something right. I have 2 dogs and 2 cat and there is nothing that i wouldn't do for them. If something happened to them (medical wise) I would sell everything that I own to take care of them. Pets love you no matter what, you have a bad day and they are there for you, so why is it that there are people out there that have try to prove their worth in this would by harming animals.


bellesque
said

Starving that dog is a despicable act and the owner should go to jail. I live in Quebec and here we have terrible animal protection. How many July 1 (moving day) cats have I rescued because the callous owners didn't want them anymore and didn't want to bother finding them a home, just put them out on the street. July is warm, January is -20C and there are plenty of strays out in -20C. Some people are both stupid and cruel towards animals and only laws will protect these creatures that deserve protection from their biggest predator, man..


Pugfire
said

They are CONSIDERING (????) charges against the inhuman entity who did this to such a loving animal??If no charges are laid, charges against the SPCA should be laid!!!!


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Related Websites

Today's Canada Stories

Prime Minister Stephen Harper delivers his speech in Guangzhou, China, Friday, Feb. 10, 2012. (AP / Kin Cheung)

Harper mixes oil and human rights in China speech

More   3 Comments 3    6 Video(s) 6