Canada -
News Sections
Canada to launch protest against seal product ban
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Mon. Jul. 27 2009 8:37 PM ET
Canada will launch a formal protest with the World Trade Organization over a ban on the import of seal products approved by the European Union, International Trade Minister Stockwell Day announced Monday.
The ban, which was approved Monday at a meeting of EU foreign ministers in Brussels, would be implemented in all 27 EU member countries over the next nine months, in time for Canada's next seal hunt.
The ban applies to products and processed goods that come from seals, including their skins, meat, blubber, organs and oil.
At an Ottawa news conference, Day and Fisheries Minister Gail Shea said they were disappointed with Monday's vote, which they said violates WTO guidelines.
"Associations of veterinarians and others have determined that Canada's hunt is indeed humanitarian, scientific and follows environmental rules of sustainability," Day said.
"And it is our view inappropriate that a trade decision is taken which is not based on the science. And for that reason we are announcing that we'll be pursuing an appeal of this vote today. We want it made very clear that there should be a clause which reflects any country that is following the humanitarian, scientific and environmental guidelines established by the EU themselves, should in fact be exempted from this particular ban."
Denmark and Romania abstained from supporting the ban during the vote, as did Austria, which wants even stronger measures against seal products.
David Barry of the Fur Institute of Canada, said the ban's approval was "not unexpected."
"We feel it's certainly irresponsible, completely counter-productive in terms of looking at seal practice and how to do it well, and it's simply a political move on the part of EU decision-makers," Barry said Monday morning on CTV News Channel.
In a statement, the foreign ministers said the ban was a "response to concerns about the animal welfare aspects of seal hunting practices."
Many of the EU's 27 member countries charge that Canada's seal hunt, the largest in the world, is inhumane. The EU objects to the large number of animals killed during the annual hunt, which can be as high as 300,000, and the methods used, such as clubs and rifles.
Both Day and Shea said experts have deemed Canada's seal hunt to be humane, something that animal rights groups say is not true.
Rebecca Aldworth, director of the Humane Society International Canada, said government reports show that 97 per cent of seals killed during the hunt are less than three months of age.
She also said the conditions in which the seal hunt takes place, including bad weather, prevent sealers from quickly and accurately killing seals, which end up suffering.
"I've observed the seal hunt for 11 years and this is a slaughter of defenseless baby seals and it's beneath every Canadian to allow it to continue," Aldworth told CTV News Channel.
Ban will affect 'many Canadian livelihoods'
The federal government has always said that a ban unfairly targets Canada's Northern communities.
"We are particularly concerned that the views of Canada's Inuit have not been considered by the EU," Shea said during the news conference. "They have made themselves quite clear that an exemption will not help them, yet European officials persist in pretending that it will."
The ban does exempt products that stem from traditional seal hunts carried out by the Inuit, as well as traditional hunts in Greenland, Alaska and Russia.
Products from "hunts conducted for the sole purpose of sustainable management of marine resources may only be marketed on a not-for-profit basis," according to a news release.
Last year, Canada exported about $3.5 million worth of seal products to the EU. The federal government estimates the ban could cost some 6,000 sealers in Canada up to 35 per cent of their earnings.
"The sealing industry is crucial to many small coastal communities and to Northern aboriginal people, where few economic opportunities exist," Shea said. "In caving to pressure from NGOs for a seal product ban, European Union has taken short-sighted and irresponsible actions that will affect many Canadian livelihoods."
The ban will not compromise the main seal product markets, according to Barry. Russia and China are developing markets for seal skin and oil, he said, while markets for meat are found in Northern communities and Newfoundland.
But the ban puts a negative label on the 12,000 Canadians who have commercial sealing licenses, Barry said.
"It more so affects them in a labelling sort of way in the sense that we have 27 Western nations who have now arbitrarily decided that a commercial seal hunt is somehow inherently inhumane," Barry said.
Barry also said the ban will affect other industries that rely on wild resources.
"The groups who have spearheaded this move in the EU are after animal agriculture," he said. "So this sets the trade precedent that can affect Canada widely in all of our primary resource production, especially when it relies on animals."
With files from The Associated Press
User Tools
Related Stories
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
I fail to see just what a minister could learn by an on site visit that he couldn't get from people who are actual experts in the various fields of work involved. It is doubtful that he is any sort of nuclear engineer or expert in construction. Just another photo op...
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Sal
0
said
0
Marc
0
said
0
Robin
0
said
0
chuck
0
said
0
I wonder if the EU will ban seal products from the U.S.?
SK Freedom Lover
0
said
0
Dave H. Cornwall, Ontario
0
said
0
Merlin..........Surrey BC Canada
0
said
0
The people of the world have been telling you time and time again....You are murdering the seals by using clubs and pointy sticks..You asked for this.
Nunavummiuq in Cape Dorset
0
said
0
Does Greenpeace put food on your table?
Linda in Vancouver
0
said
0
Every poll I've read on line today,while not scientific,is sugge3stiog that the EU DOES NOT have the support of the majority of Canadians.And actually,if you look at the thumbs up and the thumbs down on on the comments psoed here,it would appear that the majority support the seal hunters.Or,at least the concept of having CANADIANS decide how best to manage the harvesting of abundant and renewable resources within it's borders.
PLEASE.We all have the right to an opinion.But don't make excues about phony claims that your position is supported by "the majority of Canadians", unless you can back it up.In this case,I do not believe you can.
I'm with "Doug in BC".Harper should impose enough duties on EU products to finance the lost incomes of these hunters.If they feel strongly enough about the seals,I'm sure they would be willing to pay the hunters wages and even accept job losses there if we ban their products.
Rob NS
0
said
0
Yukon Doug
0
said
0
This has more to do with competition that cruelty.
Doug Rutherford
0
said
0
Instead we will still have to live with the industry based on bilking people out of large sums of money through deceptively advertising for donations to end a hunt for whitecoat seals, which ended 25 years ago, to maintain the high end lifestyles of many of the board members of these groups.
Don't buy European.
KLK
0
said
0
It's not like that can be compared to the seal hunt.
Now if you want to compare the Spanish bullfights to something, how about the Calgary Stampede where animals are tortured and killed each year while people cheer it on.
Bill Steedman
0
said
0
DN
0
said
0
JJ in Waterloo
0
said
0
It's time to end the commercial hunt for good. The fur industry is dying and is a sick and dirty business. Killing animals for vanity and fashion is ridiculous.
We left the caves thousands and thousands of years ago, it's about time we stopped looking like cavepeople too.
Hannah in BC
0
said
0
Jay
0
said
0
Eating off the land is the natives way of life.You may not like it but you can't expect them just to give it up and get a job in the city.This has been there way of life for many many years and we have no right to change that.
Stephy In Ontario
0
said
0
Rick in SK
0
said
0
1.) I will never visit Newfoundland,
2.) I will continue to visit and spend all of my money in Europe and
3.) I will continue to support IFAW as I have for more than thirty years."
I have a few ideas on this too:
1. I annually spend thousands of dollars on trips to Europe. As of next winter I am going to start visiting South America (Chile and Argentina)
2. I am going to spend a lot more time in Newfoundland. Wonderful people.
3. I have no idea what IFWA is but I am sure I don't like them. :-)
4. No more European wine for me, Australia, California and Chile all make good wine. (as well as BC and Ontario)
5. I still think the idea of taxing EU tourists directly is a good idea. $20 per head won't stop them from coming but it will show them that they are paying for their governments folly.
6. I like the idea of taxing imported leather goods from europe as long as they are told why it has been imposed.
Rod
0
said
0
John
0
said
0
"Oh, but our livelihood! Our livelihood!". Sorry to sound harsh, but if people don't want your product anymore get out of that business. Things change, things evolve. Quit trying to force people to stay with the status quo just because you don't want to find another job. Sorry sealers, but your days are numbered. Deal with it.
Dave
0
said
0
AJ
0
said
0
KLK
0
said
0
Since Canada, otherwise known as "The Land of Can't Make a Tough Decision to Save It's Life", is too scared to put an end to the barbaric seal hunt for fear of offending a handful of people, the EU has to take steps to do it for us.
Randy
0
said
0
Dash
0
said
0
I thought so.
David
0
said
0
erleen
0
said
0
vulpes
0
said
0
pete
0
said
0
oh but I guess marmots and bulls aren't cute eh...
Anyone who lives near the sea and is dependant oh fish stocks for thier livelyhood know that as cute as those little seals are, THEY ARE PESTS!! Just like cute raccoons and cute skunks and rabbits etc... all very cute, but PESTS!
It's time for Canada to take Europe to task and start banning all sorts... let's start with all beef products and see what kind of response that gets....
chris
0
said
0
Pete Mac Neil
0
said
0
http://video.hsus.org/linking/index.jsp?
Jackie Barrett
0
said
0
First of all, the Canadian Government should suspend or cancel any free trade deal discussions. If Stephen Harper still wants to go ahead with a free trade agreement with the European Union, then he's is being a hyppocrit as he is supporting a country that is hurting Canadian livelihoods.
Second, because some European Union member states practice active animal cruelty, especially the Spain and its bullfighting, Canada should ban all beef imports from certain EU countries like Spain.
Thirdly, the European Union should pay a $5 billion restitution to the Canadian, American, Norwegian, Greenlandic, and Russian Governments to cover the costs of the seal ban due to the possible environmental damage these seals can inflict on marine life, especially cod.
Fourthly, Canada should launch a propaganda campaign against the European Union to show the consequences of the seal ban not just on the environment, not just the economic damage on communities who rely on them, but also on Europeans who rely on them. For example, the ban on seal products will result in poorer quality famous Scottish Sporrans, and lower access to high quality health food products like Omega Three Oil.
Finally, all Canadian Restaurants, such as Corner Brook's Gitanos, should boycott all alcoholic beverages from European Union member countries as an act of solidarity against the seal ban.
Do the right thing, stand up for Canada, stop the misinformed European Union Seal Ban.
JF, Moncton
0
said
0
How interesting that we love freedom, unless it is someone else's freedom which causes us personal grief. There is a global shift away from seal products. We can't hold a gun to their heads and say "You must buy our product". I feel for the sealers, but I think our time would be better spent trying to find alternative sources of income for sealers instead of trying to defend a dying industry.
Keith In Brampton
0
said
0
As for the ban: I wonder how big our import market is for leather and other non-food, animal-based goods? How about we ban importation of those products until they lift their ban on seal fur imports? Bye-bye Italian shoes; designer handbags; etc...
JP from MTL
0
said
0
Lisa
0
said
0
Years of hoping that the seal hunt would end have paid off!!!!
Trent
0
said
0
David Coruthers
0
said
0
1.) I will never visit Newfoundland,
2.) I will continue to visit and spend all of my money in Europe and
3.) I will continue to support IFAW as I have for more than thirty years.
Wiggum
0
said
0
problem solved
a maritimer
0
said
0
Ron In Niagara
0
said
0
Time to check those lables when shopping . the only way to fight back is with raw cash.!
This is Canada and our economy is at stake . Last time I checked we don't takes threats from bleeding heart groups.
Time to take a stand
Robin from Ottawa
0
said
0
We have to cull them whether we can sell them or not. If we don’t, the exponential increase in Seal the population will completely decimate the Cod population. So, unless you want to pay lobster prices for your next batch of Highliner fish and chips, I suggest you think about the long term effects of such a decision.
R
Jim in Ottawa
0
said
0
Funny how you both jump to the sweeping generalization that "the majority" of Canadians oppose the seal hunt, only to see about 80% of the people giving the thumbs ratings to your comments disagree with you!
The fact is: the majority of Canadians support the seal hunt because it is a humane and moral industry that provides goods and services to the people seeking these products, and puts food on the tables of those who earn their honest livings from this industry.
Raymond
0
said
0
Zig from Ottawa
0
said
0
jmp
0
said
0
--------------------
It's time for us as a species to step up to bat and start living responsibly in our "global ecosystem" and helping species to thrive instead of killing them off. If we don't, well our children and children's children and so on, will be left with literally nothing!
Doug in BC
0
said
0
Canadians should not be paying the hunters for the loss of their incomes.TAXES on imports of products from the EU should pay those people.
That aside,it's not an easy time to impose tariffs.We are currently trying to find other markets for Canadians.Government must be careful to impose tariffs of equal value so they can't be accussed of simple protectionism.
These animals are a renewable resource that will sustain a small industry.There are millions of them in a population that is growing.They are NOT an endangered species.
As was stated by "Pippipandallthat", "if the seals were not white and cute no one would give a damm".And the dofus's from the EU would care even less.They know nothing of wildlife management.NOTHING.
AndyL
0
said
0
Raj
0
said
0
Carmen
0
said
0
Bravo EU! It's about time CANADA stepped into the 21st century, northern territories and all!
Northern dweller
0
said
0
Doug
0
said
0
J.W.
0
said
0
mac
0
said
0
baby seals are NOT harvested, clubbing is very rarely used ...
mis-information about the seal hunt and the lack of the press to support the real story has to change.
the government IS doing all it can and more to get the correct message out there.
bottom line - whether its a seal, a cow, a chicken or a pig.. lets be kinder and gentler and find a more humane method of processing.
Anne
0
said
0
Darlene, NS
0
said
0
So why do you even care whether there is a seal hunt or not? If you eat meat or fish of any kind, the 'cruelty' aspect is a mute point - every other animal/fish you eat has been killed, too, and there is no difference between killing a seal and killing a chicken. For the supporters, this 'way of life' idea is very quaint, but humans evolved through constant creation of new 'way(s) of life', not by trying to live history. Peoples who attempted that ended up extinct, which is exactly what will happen to seal hunters. In short, for the vast majority of Canadians, the continuation or elimination of the seal hunt will have little or no effect on day to day life, so why do you care?
The fact is, if there is no market for the product, there will be no hunt. We are crying about the EU banning seal product yet most Canadians have no access to seal products either. If the industry is sustainable, it will continue whether the EU bans it or not. If the loss of the relatively small market in the EU ends up killing the Canadian seal hunt, I'd say it was a dying industry anyway and we should just let it go.
Keith in Brampton
0
said
0
Sealers don't skin the seals alive; it's a myth perpetuated by animal rights groups - and ought to be considered libel. Occasionally, you may see some involuntary movement from the corpse, but that is along the lines of chickens running around after their heads have been cut off.
And how is rounding up livestock, herding them into a building where they can smell and hear - if not actually see - what is happening to the animals ahead of them any less cruel than hunting the seals in the wild? If anything, as the seals have some chance to eascape, and seldom know what's coming, the hunt is arguably LESS cruel.
Others have commented that seals don't eat cod. Granted, it's not their primary food source, but they will eat them if they have the chance. They also eat the fish cod feed on, and other stocks being scooped up by the EU.
Eventually, if left without any predators (man being the primary one), they will outgrow their food source and there will be mass starvation. That's less cruel than keeping the population under control?
Finally, with this decision the EU prove themselves utter hippocrites. If they want the seals to live, then they should be responsible for ensuring there is enough for them to eat. Canada should tell them that to ensure the seals survival, their fishing boats aren't allowed anywhere on the continental shelf - inside the 200 mile zone or not - and that their presence here will be considered an ecological act of war and acted on accordingly.
Dino
0
said
0
I’m sure it can be done. Or do we want the work to think of Canada
As and Asian country where they kill and eat anything./
JFC
0
said
0
d in Regina
0
said
0
Jay
0
said
0
If your going to tell the natives they can't hunt.Your going to have to give millions of daollars each year to make up for it.
sandini
0
said
0
Take the prime breeding stock of seals and put them in pools. Eradicate all the rest and then they can selectively slaughter the "pool raised" seals in warehouses. Thats the "European Way" of being humane.
James
0
said
0
Kiruna
0
said
0
Jayme
0
said
0
The probleam is alot of those groups are misleading the public.NO longer is the hunt for baby seals yes alot of these groups say they do hunt them.
THE Fatman
0
said
0
As for the seal hunt, it's time it became a part of history and we moved on......
MAL of TO
0
said
0
Joe King pickering
0
said
0
Robert J in Calgary
0
said
0
darren
0
said
0
VIVE LA CANADA
bevvy
0
said
0
Gern
0
said
0
MoiMeme
0
said
0
Look, there is no way we are ever going to get the world to support the seal hunt, which as an industry is of no economic consequence whatsoever.
(It is worth about $10 million total revenue a year, which wouldn't even cover the PR costs associated with trying to justify the hunt.)
So if we want to behave like adults, we should just stop the hunt, pay compensation to the handful of people still involved with the hunt, and we just move on.
- Mm
PBW
0
said
0
And how, exactly, is this supposed to help the aboriginal hunters, who rely in part on the PROFITS of the seal hunt to earn a living? That clause is simply there to appease, as it is just another means of preventing the hunt.
Europeans raped Canada's north for centuries; now they not only fail to accept responsibility for that, but seem to cast the blame on tose who came to Canada at their behest to carry out that rape.
Forget the WTO: just impose a unilateral ban on a some EU product that would hurt one of their minorities.
Matt
0
said
0
As rediculous as the situation is, you're not going to get the EU to change their mind, no use wasting time and money over something so insignificant, move on.
Frank Buchan (Vauxhall, Alberta by way of Ontario)
0
said
0
I don't seal hunt, and this really isn't likely to affect most of us...at least not directly. The fact is the EU has the right to do whatever they please, and there is no story here.
As for the idea killing them is any less humane than shooting a cow in the skull, it isn't. Having said that, the seal hunters must be awfully dumb as a group not to realize the perception issue they have.
Chris
0
said
0
Mike Ottawa
0
said
0
Stop all imports from the countries who believe that Canada is a backward county who the UE can dictate.
Pippipandallthat
0
said
0
Cindy
0
said
0
Perhaps it is better to be monitoring the actions of these vessels to aid in fish stock protection. Fisherman also need to wake up and take responsibility for their destructive methods of fishing. They leave nets suspended in the oceans that drown untold numbers of whales, turtles, seabirds, seals, etc. When allowed, Nature keeps balance, which is something that the human race is incapable of doing. As human beings we are capable of positive change and we can create eco-tourism instead - a win for the wildlife and a win for the people. Hopefully, Canada can move out of its cruel practices and be innovative as I know we can be without destroying other life forms in the process.
Michael, Cambridge ON
0
said
0
Well, we should warn the EU that any ships caught fishing illegally in Canadian waters (which happens all the time, because Europe has no fish left)will have their vessels impounded and their crews charged with illegal fishing and entering Canadian territory without the proper documentation.
Where is Mr Tobin when you need him?
I would like to point out in your comment that EU has no fish left. Maybe we should learn lesson from EU because this will happen to Canada too....
Let nature take care of itself as it has been without human for millions years...
It is 'we' who destoryed cod population or any else.
Also Mr. Tobin is not here as any MP from Harper's loop are never here for anybody.
Tom Turek
0
said
0
Take a look at how Canadians are voting on the comments in this atricle. You state that the majority of Canadian oppose the seal hunt, but the votes show otherwise. Why's dont all of you hippies move to the EU if you think they are so ahead of the times and leave hardworking people and tax payers alone. Complete hypocrites!!, most of you probably eat all kinds of meat that is raised and processed in more questionable ways than the seal hunt.
Becca
0
said
0
max
0
said
0
Mike Johnson
0
said
0
First of the EU is not a country.
And foremost people tend to forget other inhumane treatments of animals.
I like the "ban all beef products from the European Union because of the treatment of bulls by member state Spain." Statement the best, as should be Canada's first step in dealing with the EU.
Chris China
0
said
0
Mama Mumujabubufellafelnijad from Pickering, Ont
0
said
0
Nic
0
said
0
That's what happens when you mess with ecosystems.
The seal hunt isn't a solution to the overpopulation. You have to look at the root of the problem.
Geoffrey
0
said
0
Suck it up Canada.
Martin
0
said
0
Then Canada gets all offended when the EU does something to show that they are displeased. That's all that this really is: It has not much to do with how cute seals are; it has lots to do with how ugly our government looks.
Michael, Cambridge Ontario
0
said
0
I fully support ban on seals. This doesn't mean I am any less Canadian in fact I am more Canadian this way because I cared about earth and human. That is Canadian way.
I am donating my money to Sea Shepherd, Greenpeaces and many more groups that are against hunt on seal or whales.
I applaud their efforts in having EU banned seals hunts... Finally!
Canadian seal hunter need to stop whine... their industry was dying for past 10 years...... Get over it already!
Marc
0
said
0
Are they joking? Sealers do this as an off-fishing-season thing, and 35% of perhaps 5% or less of a east coast commercial sealers' yearly earnings (this isn't even a Northern Canadian inuit sealing issue, really), from an industry that is worth less than a small fraction of one percent of the Newfoundland GDP - this is clearly an industry that doesn't have the demand the Canadian government claims it does.
People don't need seals killed, and the majority don't want seals killed. It costs more via tax-payers to keep it alive than it returns. The east coast commercial seal hunt has no real sustainable basis to exist, and certainly quite obviously, no moral basis to exist. How about Canadians elect non-redneck political parties, enough with the Conservatives and DFO mismanagement!
Tono
0
said
0
Dd
0
said
0
Do you think bull fights are not barbaric? How about the marmot cull in Germany? Or the continued practice of hunting foxes in Britain (on private land)?
How about the Norwegian seal hunt?
This is hypocrisy at its worse. And if one wants to truly believe that an increase in the seal population from a stable 1 million to an out of control 7+ million doesn't affect cod stocks, then ban the Europeans from fishing on the Grand Banks where the obvious answer is the overfishing which is depleting the stocks.
Roanald Meaghan
0
said
0
Steve, alb
0
said
0
Dave in Ottawa
0
said
0
Dean
0
said
0
Vince
0
said
0
Rick in SK
0
said
0
Joanna in Kingston
0
said
0
People Power
0
said
0
Andrea
0
said
0
Shamaro
0
said
0
Where is Mr Tobin when you need him?
Remarkable
0
said
0
Europe as far as I am concerned, is and probably always will be a continent of nations that feel that they are self-righteous. Believe me, Europe needs Canada more than Canada needs Europe, with all of our minerals and resources.
Ron
0
said
0
Stevie, give these people some money and tell them to move on. Thousands of auto worker are being laid off (which effects millions), causing a recession. Then we have a couple hundred hunters making the entire country look like savages because they can't travel onto the ice of the north Atlantic during the spring, so they can club some seals.
IT'S TIME TO EVOLVE
Dorward
0
said
0
Greg
0
said
0
willowb
0
said
0
Jim
0
said
0
Silva
0
said
0
How difficult would it be, as one time only solution, to round up a significant amount of seals and relocate them by the coast of the european countries that so object to the hunt. How long do you think it would take for those same countries to engage in seal hunting to protect their fisheries?
Duck
0
said
0
A REAL Canadian
0
said
0
meerkat
0
said
0