Canada -   

1
A sign informs customers of a purchase limit on bags of rice at a Costco store in Mountain View, Calif., Wednesday, April 23, 2008. A Canadian rice expert terms that an over-reaction. (AP / Paul Sakuma) Alex Ly, 4, plays near sacks of rice in back of his family's store, Kim's Oriental Foods, in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania on Thursday, April 24, 2008. (AP / Carolyn Kaster)

No rice supply crisis in Canada, industry says

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV Montreal: Stephane Giroux covers the debate
Food prices are going up and now another important food staple, rice, is also facing a dramatic increase

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (27) Facebook   

Date: Fri. Apr. 25 2008 8:11 PM ET

If you're having trouble finding some specialty rices in Canada, blame flaws in the retail system, says an industry insider.

Ali Bilgen, president of A & BB Rice Inc. in Toronto, told CTV.ca on Friday that rice in general is in good supply in Canada.

Most of this country's rice -- such as the long grain typically served in Chinese restaurants -- comes from the United States, which is producing plenty of rice, he said.

But jasmine rice comes from Thailand, and reports have indicated the Asian country may have problems meeting its export obligations, Bilgen said. "They are having some serious issues."

The country's finance minister has since said Thailand can meet its contract obligations, but the price has still rocketed up to US$1,000 per tonne -- three times its January level.

"That's fuelling the frenzy a bit," Bilgen said, but his firm is having no real problem obtaining rice.

There were reports of U.S. retailers Wal-Mart and Costco limiting rice sales earlier this week, but Bilgen said, "Personally, I think they're over-reacting."

Herman Poon of T and T Supermarkets told CTV Newsnet on Thursday that his chain has no plans to ration rice sales.

If some supermarkets are running out, "to a certain extent, that's their own doing," he said.

Supermarkets require 30 to 60 days notice of a price increase. With prices rising so rapidly, importers are seeing their replacement costs go up just as quickly, Bilgen said.

"We don't have the luxury to continue supplying these supermarkets at well below the market prices for 30 to 60 days. So some of the importers may restrict quantities they are shipping to the supermarkets."

So while some supermarkets might be running out of some types of rice to sell, there is no supply issue at the wholesale level, he said.

David Wilkes, senior vice-president of the Canadian Council of Grocery Distributors, told CTV.ca that his members aren't having any supply problems.

"We are not seeing any changes in consumer shopping patterns with respects to rice at the current time either," he said.

Poon seconded that, saying some customers are stocking up, but most are not.

Difference of opinion

Wilkes disagreed with some of Bilgen's analysis, saying the importers are often buying on the futures market to protect themselves.

"Depending on your point of view, you're always going to claim you're getting squeezed on the way," he said.

Costs do get passed along in any supply chain, and everyone wants it to be orderly, he said.

"But at the same time, if there's an unavoidable change because commodities have gone up, I know that conversations go on between individual trading partners to make sure those adjustments take place in the most reasonable way possible."

The rice situation should also be looked at in the context of the apparent structural shifts going on in the global food market, Wilkes said. He listed some factors:

  • Changing consumption patterns;
  • Food being converted into ethanol;
  • Agricultural land being taken out of production.

Foods based on the commodities being affected are rising in price as a result, he said, citing bread and pasta as two other examples.

On Friday, United Nations Secretary General Ban Ki-moon called the sharp rise in food prices a global crisis and asked for an additional $755 million in funding for the UN's World Food Program.

Bilgen said the high value of the Canadian dollar has protected consumers here. "If we still had currency at $1.30, $1.40, certainly there'd be a lot more concern."

Compared to developing nations, Canadians pay a relatively small proportion of their income on food. A price hike doesn't hurt the average Canadian consumer as much, he said.

But in parts of Asia and Africa, some poor people direct more than half their income to food, he said.

"So when the price of rice doubles, now they have to spend 100 per cent of their income on rice. Or their income is not even enough to cover their daily diet," Bilgen said.

Comments are now closed for this story

Sask Man
said

I find some of these comments amusing.

We need to understand that capitalism is what feeds the world.
The Soviet union was a huge Agricultural mess until capitalism took hold and the farming practices changed. Now they can feed themselves and others.
The reason there are food shortages at the moment,is because of poor yields in many countries due to high fuel & fertilizer costs and cylical droughts. These droughts are due to increased sun spot activity and energy. It happens as part of longer term cycles.
As these weather patterns start to change again, farmers around the world will start producing more and prices will lower.

For now, all the best to the clean fuel initiatives of ethanol, made from grains...
But remember we need to look after those less fortunate. Consider sponsoring a hungry child.
Support the plans of our government to give more toward food aid.



Robin da Hood
said

Does anyone here have anything useful to say? I'm talking about informed opinion. Fact is 95% of the World's economy - yes even China's - is capitalistic and mostly unregulated. Now things are starting to fall apart (at least it's at a faster pace now). Hence, if you put 1 plus 1 together what's to blame?.. thats right!.. since there is nothing else it must be capitalism. Wooh!
Unfortunately the short term gains offered by capitalism are starting to give way to long term costs and I can see many who are accustomed to their lavish lifestyles will have great difficulty facing that new reality. Ofcourse they will always try to blame others - the "commies" - for their own excesses and loss.



Steve
said

These last few days are just the panic icing on the shortage cake. I have been watching this develop for six months.

If there was an excess of supply everyone would settle down. Supplies are pretty tight. When people started seeing they couldn't depend on getting all the rice they wanted at a cheap price, they acted like any rational being would...they panicked.

I talk to my friends at various retailers. Rice deliveries were becoming sporadic before the public panicked.


Dr. Singval
said

The third world needs to limit their reproduction rate, or else they will all starve. China was wise to implement the "one child per family" policy. The rest of the third world should do the same. Instead of sending charity food to these countries, we should be sending them more means of sterilization. A true work of mercy.


tony
said

Have we not learned from the mad cow fiasco? Feed an herbivore meat and it goes mad; the cattle is slaughtered and that industry takes years to recover. We feed our automobiles our food and the world becomes starved! Stop these people from proposing such risks.


Roch
said

Anti-capitalists should see how much food they can buy at the grocery store with no money.

Go live in your communes and munch away at your home-made canned preserves all year if you wish, but I intend to continue to order a pizza from a corporation if I feel like it.




David #1
said

I'm beginning to wonder if I should withdraw my financial investments with the way the world is going these days. Just in case the state decides to seize our assets and nationalize it all. Revolution on the horizons?

Oil pricing rising, food shortages, China stealing our jobs and killing the middle-class in North America.

Sounds like a fabulous recipe for a new world order with China/India becoming the capitalists North America once was and North Americans turning ever more to socialism/communism.


Kevin L
said

It's soon going to be awfully more expensive to live in a large city. Living in a rural area I just go outside with my shotgun to get food for dinner.


Doug
said

The vast majority of Canadians have not experienced food issues since the depression of the 1930s.As a result we think we are immune to these problems.And with our resources,we should be.
Sadly,mired in debt and with a crumbling infrastructure,we are at the mercy of global economics.
Producing food in Canada is now so expensive that even we will have trouble paying for it.It has to do with a lack of productivity here,and debt that has to be paid off.If we weren't spending $40 billion dollars per year in servicing the debt,we could use the money to move affordable,clean energy to places it is needed.We would be refining Alberta oil to use where it was needed,at prices that people could afford.And BC would be making wood products,instead of selling raw logs,so we can then buy it back after it has been made into something.
Canada has all the resources we need to keep us living well.We just choose to sell the raw product,instead of using it as a competetive advantage.
Like Rome,it appears Canada could "burn" while our so-called leadership fiddles.


Overfed in Calgary
said

An indictment of capitalism? Wait, WE don't have any shortage or food. The Western captalist countries produces a surplus of food. It's the basketcase countries that are net food importers. Countries that have the state meddling in every layer of production. China and the former Soviet Union have only approached self-sufficiency since they adopted more free marketfarm economies.


Rene
said

To Matt:

You claim that prominent capitalist countries are doing well? Are you talking about the fact that these countries are not willing to sacrifice economic growth in order to save the environment? Without the environment there will be no economy left to save. Or are you talking about an economy partly based on yearly trends where last year's stuff is no longer cool and advertising tells you to buy new things when you clearly don't need them? Overconsumption is remorselessly at the cost of our natural resources.

Now they want to use our precious crop space to grow biofuel instead of food. People are starving in many different parts of the world, but that doesn't matter to capitalism because cars need to be driven. What a shame!


Trent
said

Having been to both communist USSR and Cuba I would beg to differ how the communist system provided bountiful food for its people. Shelves were/are more often bare or if there were any food available most westerners would refuse to eat it or contained little or no real food value.
This is another example that the Earth is not able to sustain the current human population size based on our desires (moving from more simple foods such as grains to more meat based meals).
In the not too distant future, this whole ethanol project is going to be looked upon as a great failure. But under the current US administration which seems to have strong economic ties with the Saudi oil, ethanol production which takes a larger quantity of oil then the ethanol it produces will continue on


TGB
said

"Everyone is so focused on money these days they forget that it's food and water and such that actually sustains us, not corporate profits and bonds"

That does pretty much sum it up doesn't it?


Linda BC
said

Duh!! Higher food prices in the wake of higher energy prices.
What a shock.If the cost of producing and transporting food goes up,we all pay more.
It means nothing to wealthier people.But the lower your income,the greater the impact.And the less likely you will be able to feed your family a healthy diet,or get them decent educations.
I have no ideological issue with capitalism.I think we have done well by it.On the other hand I see the socialists as wanting to impose maore taxes as a solution to every problem.
So,I guess I wonder how higher taxes and energy costs actually help with the fight against poverty.It actually looks like they make the job of producing "affordable" food almost impossible.
And,it also looks like the environmental extremists will finally get their way.We can all live in tents and freeze in the dark while we nourish ourselves on local roots and berries.And,of course we won't have excess wheat to send to starving people in other parts of the world either.
Nice going,eh.


Robin the Hood
said

If you look at it deep down it is evident that capitalism is incompatible with nature because it's growth is unsustainable and is based on greed which leads to a few in power being allowed to over-exploit nature at the expense of everyone else. Things are really coming to a head now where decades of unrestricted growth, non-renewable energy use, over-population, pollution, over exploitation of the environment, etc. are all resulting in climate change and food shortages. Now the "steady state" economic model needs to be seriously considered assuming its not already too late. However, such a model, along with the life style changes, requires extensive regulation if only because the greedy will oppose such regulation and try to cheat the rules. Thus to make it work they must be stopped by whatever means necessary. Essentially, as difficult as it is to say, we have to move towards more socialism because it is the rights of the individual that has allowed the greedy and cheaters to do whatever they wanted at our expense! Perhaps Karl Marx was right after all?!




Dale in Calgary
said

Kudos to the reporter who put together this story. It's not easy report the facts and get a "there is no crisis" story past editors.

WetCoastGuy
said

Capitalism isn't the cause of rising oil prices, food prices and shortages, it's increasing consumerism!!! The Western affluent lifestyle cannot be sustained. If everyone wants the North American dream of a house, a car, and all the electronics to fill it, plus food readily available there isn't enough resources in the world to sustain it. It's Economics 101: Demand exceeds Supply = Higher prices. It's going to be a huge change in lifestyle as days of cheap energy and disposable products are over. Unless you are one of the super-rich the party is over.


Tim
said

I live in the Fraser Valley where applications for land to be removed from the Agricultural Land Reserve (ALR) is going up. Abbotsford's excuse;we need to expand our industrial tax base. What about food? Can't eat tax money. Everyone is so focused on money these days they forget that it's food and water and such that actually sustains us, not corporate profits and bonds. And what did they do with the land that was removed from the ALR? Paved it over and put up about 500 RVs for sale! Bye bye farmland hello gas guzzling RVs!


Matt
said

If capitalism is killing us, why are prominent capitalist countries doing so well?

The alternative to a free market is a government controlled economy.

Our competative capitalist system in North America is still generating more food than we consume, and because it has made us rich we can afford the massive food hikes that are occuring.

Sure there are people richer than you, but even the poorest in Canada are rich by global standards. People who are anti capitalist really need to open their eyes and look at the miserable situation in countries that reject capitalism.


Joe
said

The 'media' more than ever is the 'message'. with 24/7 news networks needing to fill space, hysteria can feed upon itself.

Everything becomes a 'crisis' or an 'outrage' from the price of a bag of rice to some bully beating up a kid in Nowheresville, USA.. Everyone is 'shocked'. The media interviews itself and then interviews the interviewers and the cycle feeds on itself.
It's almost like a bad skit out of Monty Python: 'We interupt this 693rd interview on the Obama-Clinton race to bring the latest update on the search in Seattle, Washington where lttle Sally has just been reunited with her lost kitty cat.


Munro - Brampton
said

Costco in the US just created a problem. What they did will create a shortage of rice. People will think something is wrong and buy more to stock up, and cause a shortage. Why they can't see that is beyond me. Dumb.


We need to Do Something fast!!!
said

I agree with "Capitalism is killing us". But to be honest, I can't stand socialism and communism as well. As I said before, its now a world of survival of the fittest!!!

Doesn't matter. All over the world, revolution is coming and we have to prepare for a third world war over food, shelter, clothing, and the ridiculous pricing of oil.

You capitalist dictators watch out, history has taught us this and history has an uncanny way of repeating itself. We in Canada maybe well off, but in the Unites States, I can easily see revolt from the masses over food, oil, religion, etc.

My point is that the world is in a supreme hurt locker if we don't stop all this capitalist madness!!!


David in the West
said

Agree with the first post.
Example, look at the Fraser Valley in BC. Some of Canada's most precious soil, being developed by cookie cutter houses at a record pace! This soil is too important to pave over!!


DG
said

I'm going to eat more potatoes.
No to biofuel.


T.O. Capitalist
said

RE: Capitalism is killing us.

I couldn't agree more. Everyone knows that the collective farms used in the Soviet Union made it so EVERYONE had more food then the knew what to do with. Collectivization and the subsequent famines are just capitalist propaganda. You really hit the nail on the head there buddy.


JoeNorthAmerican
said

Mmmmm rising oil prices, food and rice shortages??? Sounds like revolution coming to the shores of North America. Are we going to become the "new" communist China???


Captialism is killing us
said

Don't matter whether we have stock of rices but this is a wake up call for everybody to stop being a such wasteful with everything we have. We must control foods and price that ensure that every humans are being fed. I doubt that going to happen. Captialism really killing us with massive production concept do not work along with mother natural. We must control population by control city's growth so that there are enough room for FARMING. We must take action now to ensure a propresity future but if we do not then we will have a doomday future.


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Today's Canada Stories

Abby Maryk, Dominic Maryk

Missing Winnipeg siblings found in Mexico

More  1 Video(s) 1

Residents survey the damage caused by a force one tornado in Saint Benoit, Que., Saturday, May 26, 2012. (Ryan Remiorz / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Tornadoes cause millions in damage in Quebec

More  1 Video(s) 1

Vincent Massey Park, Ottawa, Ontario, lightning

Ottawa man struck by lightning dies in hospital

More

Most Talked about Stories

I fail to see just what a minister could learn by an on site visit that he couldn't get from people who are actual experts in the various fields of work involved. It is doubtful that he is any sort of nuclear engineer or expert in construction. Just another photo op...

Pugfire

Environment minister visits stricken Fukushima plant