News Sections
Texting while driving worse than being high: study
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Wed. Sep. 24 2008 10:57 AM ET
A new British study has found that drivers who write and send off text messages are more impaired than those who've been drinking or are high on pot.
The study, commissioned by the Royal Automobile Club (RAC) Foundation, found that composing text messages while driving had a negative impact on all key measures of driving performance.
Researchers, who released the study this month, watched drivers between the ages of 17 and 24 on a driving simulator and discovered that:
- The reaction times of texting drivers deteriorated by over one-third (35 per cent).
- This was worse than alcohol at the legal limit, which slowed reaction times by 12 per cent.
- Even drivers under the influence of cannabis fared better than texting drivers, with reaction times that were 21 per cent slower than sober drivers.
- Drivers drifted out of their lane more often if they were texting. Steering control was 91 per cent worse, compared to 35 per cent worse when under the influence of cannabis.
In a press release outlining details of the study, the RAC Foundation said that text messaging while driving poses an "unacceptable risk," especially when it involves young drivers.
"Despite the danger, 48 per cent of U.K. drivers aged 18 to 24 admit to using short message services (SMS) whilst driving -- a group already at much higher risk of being involved in a crash," said the media release.
The RAC Foundation is calling for a high-profile education campaign to raise awareness among young people in Britain about the dangers of text messaging and driving.
Prof. Stephen Glaister, director of the RAC Foundation, said that study participants were almost unanimous in their view that drinking and driving was riskier than texting while driving.
"Yet this research clearly shows that a motorist who is texting is significantly more impaired than a motorist at the legal limit for alcohol," Glaister said in the press release.
"No responsible motorist would drink and drive. We need to ensure that text devotees understand that texting is one of the most hazardous things that can be done while in charge of a motor car."
The study's authors said that text messages that normally took about 22 seconds to compose at a desk took almost three times as long when the person texting was behind the wheel.
"Writing a text message had the biggest impact on reaction times, increasing them from 1.2 seconds to 1.6 seconds. At motorway speeds, this would mean travelling an additional three car lengths before beginning to brake. Some participants missed the visual trigger completely," the press release said.
Researchers said that drivers are distracted in three ways if they're writing and sending text messages:
- the work of composing the text takes the mind off the road
- using the phone's keypad means that only one hand is on the wheel, limiting control of the vehicle
- the driver's eyes are on the phone and not on the road ahead
Here in Canada, Quebec, Nova Scotia, and Newfoundland and Labrador have laws limiting text messaging or use of cellphones while driving.
A University of Toronto study that looked at the cellphone records of nearly 700 Toronto drivers who had been in car crashes found that they were four times more likely to get into an accident while on their phones.
User Tools
Related Stories
Related Websites
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
This short piece illustrates perfectly the problem with the adversarial legal system, where the idea of actual guilt is irrelevant to all participants in the pantomime. I support the vigorous defence of a person's rights, but also grasp why lawyers come across slimy. It's hard to look crystal clear and clean when you provide your services on a foundation of one set of acceptable lies against another.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Peter, Vancouver BC
said
What this study shows is that it is MUCH MORE dangerous than drinking (at the limit) or smoking pot while driving. That is the point. Also, it is important to note that the participants (all young drivers) understood the dangers of drinking and driving ... but did not realize the dangers of texting and driving.
Research like this is valuable to provide PROOF of the danger of texting and driving for young drivers.
The other interesting finding, is that this study was undertaken by a driver's lobby group.
CYL
said
John
said
Here's an example. The Conservatives oppose safe injection sites because of "common sense" - we're condoning drug use, crime will increase. Yet, studies show that the opposite is true. The fact that the Conservatives ignore such research only points to their willingness to secure the greatest number of votes, like all politicians. That's on us, people.
Lina
said
I decided not turn right. I waited until he passed ahead of me.
The government of this province refused over and over again to put a stop on people driving while on their cell phone or texting at the same time.
Andy
said
Here is the bottom line, we have become a society of self-centered people who have lost all manners.
People are now so concerned with their own little universe, that we think it is more important to send that text message to a friend than it is to make sure that the guy in car beside you does'nt die because of your carless attitude.
We as tax payer complain of goverment waste, but we force them to make the ridiculous study and change laws because we have no common sense.
By the way before they come out with a study on this, you should also not read while driving, put on make up, have a meal, finish getting dressed or in other words concentrate on your driving. Have some manners and concideration and you will have your life when you get to your destination and hopefully you will not have ended mine.
Maybe now they can do a study on manners at movie theaters and why the person beside you who also paid for admission also has the right to enjoy the movie.
BB in B.C.
said
Ken
said
Related Story
said
"The ER doctors cite rising reports from doctors around the country of injuries involving text-messaging pedestrians, bicyclists, Rollerbladers, even motorists."
From the story -- "Don't walk and text at the same time: ER doctors"
Isn't it obvious that if your doing one thing, odds are, you're not paying anywhere near the same amount of attention to something else.
Sounds pretty simple to me....
Mark
said
I think I have seen some of their test subjects on the road.
What a summer job that must have been, getting high, getting drunk, and texting while driving. It's no wonder I can't find enough employees I can't compete with these job options.
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out texting while driving is stupid.
I guess it's a good thing I didn't send this comment from my Blackberry while driving to town.
Mr. Obvious
said
Jeromy in Edmonton
said
As a driver of a motor vehicle you are in control of a massive amount of power. To be blunt, many people who have an operators licence do not have the proper training to be in control of that vehicle.
Due to that lack of extensive formal practical driver education people will always be a danger to themselves and other motorists while operating a vehicle.
The only answer is set your cell phone to silent while driving and retrive your voice mail messages when you have arrived at your destination.
No matter what you do for a job or how important you think you are; you are NOT that important to jepordize the life and safety of another person nor is your telephone call.
MuskyBuck
said
People actually do this?
I've watched women doing their makeup in the rearview mirror...
I've watched someone eating a full lunch whilst steering with ???
I've seen people toking up and passing the joint..
This is freakin' ridiculous actually and shows just how stupid our society is becoming in general.
Bee
said
A more informative study was the one that showed talking on a cell phone was less distracting than talking to a real passenger because too many drivers feel they have to look at their passenger while talking to them.
Since the Liberals love to ban things, maybe they will ban passengers along with cell phones.
Just because some people can't chew bubblegum and walk at the same time, it should be banned. That's just the Liberal way - not because it's sensible, but because it's popular.
Melissa
said
For those who do it, look at it this way. A text can wait, once your life is over - it's done. You can't go back and re-do it.
What a bonehead thing to do.
Safe Roads For All
said
When you are doing something while driving, you aren't focussing on driving!
Please, put down the cell phone while you are driving.
Silly in NB
said