News Sections
Opposition demands answers on Bernier files
CTV News Video
|
Watch: See all Videos in the Player
CTV.ca News Staff
Date: Tue. May. 27 2008 10:16 PM ET
The opposition is demanding answers about why it took so long for the government to realize the classified documents at the centre of the Maxime Bernier scandal were missing.
"Will the government confirm that the documents that lay around Julie Couillard's room for five weeks were classified briefing notes relating to the Bucharest summit and our mission in Afghanistan?" asked Deputy Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff during Tuesday's question period in the House of Commons.
"Will the government then explain why it took them five weeks to realize the documents were missing?"
And finally, he wondered if Prime Minister Stephen Harper will be able to explain to France's President Nicolas Sarkozy "that Canada can still be trusted with confidential information?"
Couillard is the ex-girlfriend of Bernier, the former foreign minister who resigned Monday after admitting that he left the sensitive documents at her home.
Their relationship made headlines about three weeks ago when reports revealed she had past personal connections with people involved in the biker underworld.
House Leader Peter Van Loan said the report contained a mix of classified and publicly available material.
"I will not, however, discuss classified documents in the House," he said.
Bloc Quebecois MP Serge Menard said he found it incredible the government only found out in the last few days that the documents had been missing for five weeks.
"It's impossible that the Prime Minister's Office was not informed beforehand. Will the government admit that the interview with Julie Couillard forced them to make public the serious mistake by their former minister?" he asked.
Couillard revealed her side of the missing documents story in an interview, which had been pre-taped, but aired Monday on Quebec's TVA network.
"The prime minister acted as soon as he was aware and accepted that resignation," Van Loan said.
Menard asked Van Loan to formally say Harper had no knowledge of the incident before Monday.
"The Prime Minister's Office in fact had no information about the documents before yesterday," Van Loan said.
Liberal Leader Stephane Dion painted the affair as showing an "appalling lack of judgment on Harper's part."
He called for an additional investigation to see if there have been other security breaches and suggested a public inquiry is in order. But Van Loan said the foreign affairs department has been asked to "analyze the situation and ask for assistance as required."
Harper in Europe
Harper wasn't in the House of Commons. He landed in Paris Tuesday to kick off a three-day tour of Europe.
He told reporters this issue is about Bernier's carelessness with classified documents.
"You obviously don't disclose classified materials and you certainly take adequate care to ensure that they are not disclosed and they are not left behind somewhere," he said.
"Unfortunately the minister broke those rules, and that has nothing to do with who he happens to be dating, it's irrelevant in that sense but the rules have to be respected."
The prime minister said he's had no concerns directed to him by NATO allies about the security breach.
Harper has named David Emerson to replace Bernier in the foreign affairs portfolio on an interim basis.
Tasha Kheiriddin, a conservative political commentator in Montreal and a friend of Bernier, told CTV Newsnet that Bernier had no choice but to step down.
The other gaffes that Bernier made as minister, such as publicly calling for the governor of Afghanistan's Kandahar province to be fired, made things worse for him, she said.
"This will certainly damage his political career," she said. "There's always ways back from the depths, but this is a long road, I fear, because this is really a sign of poor judgment."
The Bernier affair could also damage Conservative prospects in Quebec, where the party hopes to make gains," she said.
Bernier had been seen as a rising star. "Having a weaker Quebec cabinet contingent can only hurt the prime minister," Kheiriddin said.
User Tools
Related Stories
CTV Video Player
Mike Duffy Live
The inside story on how Maxime Bernier's resignation came about and what questions still remain about security.
CTV.ca Specials
In her words
Maxime Bernier's ex-girlfriend said her relationship with the minister has left her 'destroyed.'
Most Popular
Most Viewed News Stories
Most Talked about Stories
This short piece illustrates perfectly the problem with the adversarial legal system, where the idea of actual guilt is irrelevant to all participants in the pantomime. I support the vigorous defence of a person's rights, but also grasp why lawyers come across slimy. It's hard to look crystal clear and clean when you provide your services on a foundation of one set of acceptable lies against another.
Email
Comments are now closed for this story
Ian
said
GP
said
Jimbo
said
Bernier....has been blackened in the toaster!
Fred
said
Scott
said
JP
said
Mr Harper and his gang keep bring up the former Liberal governmnet and their mistakes- yet The Conseratives are racking up there share .
MR HArper- I think it is time you call and elections and see what the people think.
Wally
said
Na-na-na-na-na-na-na Hey-ey-ey
Good bye.
Any Tory who claims otherwise is pretty hypocritical.
David Dunlop
said
Paul in BC
said
You only get hit harder when you avoid the true facts and the Prime Minister sure hid the facts. It was only when Julie Couillard went public did the Prime Minister decide to own up to the facts.
Robert Himpfen
said
ronin
said
CONs used to be big on national security weren't they?
AGM
said
Follow the Financial Trail ...
said
It doesn't seem incredibly likely that anyone in Canada is at elevated direct risk of terrorism because of this affair. However, it would clearly be in the interests of underground markets that all steps within reach be taken to ensure supply lines remain efficient. It is pure common sense that information about NATO operations in Afghanistan, along with a role in security at an airport in North America, could help "organizations" smoothly run their "businesses". If there is a LOT of profit to be made, why should we be surprised to see sophistication?
Some Canadians may think it is cool to bury this affair, but let's not forget that our neighbors to the south probably won't like that very much.
We have an obligation to take appropriate measures to reassure our friends ... and it would probably be quite naive to think that a simple resignation clears this slate. Financial motivations need to be considered.
M. Cameron
said
If you believe issues of national security are fit for the National Enquirer then you seriously need to be schooled in what it takes to run an effective government.
David #1
said
brenda
said
The Liberals, on the other hand, who have had the power and responsibility for more of my 50 + years, really should know better (as in when they are stealing from the publics tax purse, etc..)
This was a sad mistake on Bernier's part, but it's over, he's gone, lets move on.
As for PM Harper, I feel sorry that he has to always either deal with his own peoples incompetence, or the nincompoop Liberals, which you know won't let this sorry story go for at least another two weeks!
DT
said
Earl Robert
said
Dave
said
Time to pull the plug on this sorry excuse for a government.
Facts or Innuendo?
said
Lots of speculation and VERY little facts other than a minister left papers where he should not have done so. Not the first time a minister has done so. Bernier has now paid with his resignation.
Unless the opposition has any FACTS let them be quiet and stop trying to fabricate news based on innuendo's from disparate politicians aided by their friends in the media.
Trudy
said
ranjan
said
Dave
said
DOUGB
said
Ian
said
Trent
said
Arguing "What ifs" are a huge waste of time and money. Get on with the important things that actually mean something to the people that voted you into office!
Jeff
said
This is not an issue to him but Bill C-10 is? Please.
Can you imagine this country with a Conservative majority? Lord help us all.
Edward in Vancouver
said
Graham Henderson
said
I say out with the Tories, and in with the humble, sincere, intelligent, and respectful Stephane Dion and the Liberal Party of Canada!!
DWB
said
Apart from that, the British have a term for people that treat women the way Bernier has treated Ms. Couillard - a cad.
Allan Eizinas
said
Julie Couillard says that her box spring under her mattress had had a listening device implanted for a time. PM Harper does not believe her and dismisses the allegation.
Is Julie Couillard an honest person, a liar, a part time liar and part time honest person or what?
Shannon
said
I also think Julie Couillard has given us every reason to be suspicious of her and her motives. In her interview it says "Couillard said she contacted a lawyer after finding the document and was told that it was the property of the Canadian government.
"The document was given back,'' she said."
Who contacts a lawyer when she finds out her boyfriend (or ex) left something at her place???? Most people would call him up and say "hey, you left something here. Do you want me to drop it off or will you pick it up?" Suspicious, suspicious, suspicious...
Dan from Toronto
said
I actually feel bad for Bernier. You have to wonder what was going on in Harper's mind when he gave the top job to Bernier.
Then again, Bernier was likely poster boy for Foreign Affairs while Harper micro-managed it. We all know that Harper has a vice grip on his cabinet ministers.
Stu
said
Dick Varley
said
Bonnie
said
FD
said
yarml
said
Gentleman Joe
said
Mark
said
Ravinder
said
WW
said
sb
said
steve I. C.
said
Dana
said
They appear to have no concern whatever that sensitive and confidential information about NATO allies and the mission in Afghanistan has been floating around untethered.
They appear to care more about how it looks for the demagogue of their idolatry that they do about cabinet confidentiality, NATO security or the safety of the Canadian men and women serving in Afghanistan.
But answer me this o grand and glorious journalists: Why was Bernier wandering around with these documents in his possession a good few weeks after the Romania NATO conference? Did he just happen to wander by Ms Couillard's house wit them? Did he deliberately go there with them? Is that all he had with him?
Who is the lawyer? Who else is this lawyer known to represent?
Who are the "security experts"? What's their track record?
If our allies are left with too many unanswered questions it could be hard sailing ahead.
We already know Harper won't answer any.
Do citizens still have the right to know? Does the news media have any role to play?
No and no as far as I can see in our brave neo world.
DCR-Sask
said
Karen Cao
said
Byron Beauchene
said
John Wells
said
IT Manager
said
No.. having weak judgment, weak policy, weak competence, and the complete inability to tell the truth is what will hurt the Prime Minister.
How many more lies, gaffes, and scandals will the right wing tolerate before they realize that Harper has cost this country FAR more than adscam EVER did. He is costing us credibility and respect on the International stage.
By all means, CON supporters, keep spinning the story. We get a kick out of it.
raj
said
Gary Keigan
said
M.T.A.
said
PVT
said
Doug
said