Top Stories -   

1

Scrabble knockoff returns to Facebook with changes

A A |  Email ThisEmail  | PrintComments (14) Facebook   

Date: Thursday Jul. 31, 2008 2:55 PM ET

NEW YORK — A popular Scrabble knockoff is back on Facebook -- with changes that could help it skirt legal trouble.

The return came less than two days after the creators of Scrabulous blocked their version of the word game from U.S. and Canadian users of Facebook, the online hangout. The Indian brothers behind Scrabulous had pulled it Tuesday after being sued in federal court by Hasbro Inc., the owner of Scrabble's North American rights.

Now, the game has reappeared with the name Wordscraper. The change could help it avoid any brand confusion with Scrabble, a key point in trademark disputes.

The game itself has also changed. Instead of Scrabble-like square tiles, for instance, Wordscraper has circles. The tiles earning double and triple points have been rearranged, and tiles for quadruple points have been added.

Whether those design changes will protect the creators from claims of copyright infringement remains to be seen.

Ideas cannot be copyrighted, but expressions of ideas can. The case could turn on whether Wordscraper feels more like Scrabble or a generic board game based on words.

"It's going to come down to the little things like squares and circles and double, triple and so on," said Ethan Horwitz, an intellectual-property lawyer at King and Spalding in New York. "What they've done is taking a step in the right direction, but I don't think it's a big enough step."

In a statement, Hasbro said it "will evaluate every situation individually and take actions as appropriate."

Word of the rechristened game started spreading through blogs late Wednesday, and by Thursday afternoon thousands of Facebook users already had added the application. Still, that's nowhere near the half-million or so daily users that Scrabulous had been enjoying.

Last week, Hasbro sued Scrabulous creators Rajat and Jayant Agarwalla of Calcutta, India, in U.S. District Court in New York, claiming copyright and trademark infringement.

The lawsuit followed video game maker Electronic Arts Inc.'s release of an official version of Scrabble for American and Canadian Facebook users under a broad licensing deal with Hasbro. That official Scrabble, still in a "beta" test mode, hasn't been as popular.

Separately, Hasbro asked Facebook to block Scrabulous, something the site resisted despite risks of losing immunity protection from copyright lawsuits. The Agarwallas agreed to suspend Scrabulous on Facebook in the United States and Canada in deference to the online hangout, though it has remained available at Scrabulous.com.

Comments are now closed for this story

Sam Crawford
said

Few things make me laugh as hard as when people take time to click on a link and read a news item, then take time to post a comment about how un-newsworthy it was!

Mark M... Hasbro was already suing the game makers and Facebook; by changing the look of the board I believe they WILL be able to put an end to the lawsuit.

Ideas cannot be copyrighted, only the realisation of the idea.


Joyce
said

I hope we can have something like scrabulous. The beta is harder to play on.



MDM
said

Just to add to the comments about those not considering this newsworthy. It is, and not just here on CTV. Take a quick glance at some international news sites, including in the U.S., UK and Australia, and you'll find the story on those as well. News is whatever people make it. The fact that you read it, and millions of others did too, proves that it newsworthy.


MJ Overby
said

Amazing...glad it will be back in ANY FORM....Hasbro should be happy someone is immitating the game...makes new users want to try the game and want buy it from the store. I'm off to play now....I was NEVER defeated in Scrabulous...and I will NOT be beaten in Wordscraper!
MJ


Weiss
said

To those who comment that this story should not be considered "news"

Why did you click on the story and read it? Why comment? Many seem to think only certain stories are important enough to be considered newsworthy, but the reality is, anything that catches the public's interest is news. If millions play this game, that makes it important enough to write about. If you disagree, only read and comment on the stories you want to see more of.


Mark M
said

Good luck to the creators of Scrabulous. But just because they created an online version of a popular game doesn't mean they own the idea. I don't think you can skirt copyright and trademark laws by changing the name, changing the tiles to round from square and leaving everything else the same.

That's sort of like changing the name of Monopoly to Real Estate Grab, changing the board from square to round and expecting that you are not going to get sued.

This issue goes to the heart of our economic system. People must have the expectation that if they invent or design a new product, someone else can't steal their idea.

I predict a monster lawsuit coming from the owners of Scrabble that will sue these brothers and facebook too.


Maureen Gerken
said

Now all I have to do is find it so I can reconnect to my Canadian friends. I'm locked out of the "official scrabble" because there are two versions - one for North America and one for the rest of the world. Isolationist? You bet.



Kaba
said

Echo, its because like 21 Million Canadians are on Facebook. Facebook is important to Canadians.


Mikie
said

Slow news day?


Kelly
said

To Echo.

I am not typically in the habit of commenting on other people's posts.. But, yours made me angry. My first reaction was to write, "Aw, whatsamatter, not enough news stories about disasters, murder - either personal or environmental, crooked politicians for your liking?". I happen to consider myself a very responsbile, caring and concerned citizen. I also enjoy(ed) playing Scrabulous online with friends - near and far. Reality check - this is 2008. The Internet, Facebook and online gaming are here to stay.

john
said

We don;t need another type Scrabble game Do;nt try to fix something that is not broken.


Echo
said

And this is a top story? Good grief.


Kelly
said

Started playing it last night and really, really like it. Long live the Agarwalla brothers. You guys rock!


KMD
said

Thank god....


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

Most Talked about Stories

If there weren't so many people who hide their faces when committing violent acts then we wouldn't need a law forbidding masks. Unfortunately this is our society now. No one can hide their faces... we aren't special over here, violence has arrived and it is here to stay. Let's not kid ourselves. Violence just escalates to new levels. We've let this "hiding the faces" scenario go on far too long.

KC

Montreal bylaw could offer preview of federal mask ban